1. March 2011
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: LB67 Channelization Comment Resolution
Date Submitted: 16 March, 2011
Source: Matt Boytim
Company: Sensus
Address []
Re: []
Abstract: []
Purpose: []
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

2. Comments To be Resolved
March 2011
Comments To be Resolved
CID 17, 545
Accept
Change Khurram’s spreadsheet DCN : GL=0.3 GH=0.2 for MHz band OFDM Option 1
Update Table 67a with commenters’ proposed resolution consistent with Khurram’s updated spreadsheet
Change page 31 line 25 ChanCenterFreq0 from to 917.9
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

3. Comments To be Resolved
March 2011
Comments To be Resolved
CID 18, 546
Reject
Commenters should provide technical justification for consideration of the requested change.
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

4. Comments To be Resolved
March 2011
Comments To be Resolved
CID 332, 334, 338, 330, 331, 333, 335, 339
(Note: CID’s 330, 331, 333, 335, 339 are classified Editorial because they correct errors in the draft they do not change the technical intent)
Accept in Principle
Change Khurram’s spreadsheet DCN : GL=GH=0 for 10kbps, 20kbps, 40kbps in MHz, MHz, MHz, and MHz bands (CID 339 (editorial))
Change Khurram’s spreadsheet DCN : ChanSpacing=0.0125MHz for 10kbps, 20kbps, 40kbps in MHz, MHz, MHz, and MHz bands (CID 332, 334, 338 (technical))
Update Table 67a from Khurram’s updated spreadsheet
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

5. Continued March 2011 Table 67a 896-901 MHz Band ChanSpacing
TotalNumChan
ChanCenterFreq0
page 30 line 52
Filtered 2FSK
0.0125
399
page 30 line 53
397
page 30 line 54
393
896.05
Table 67a MHz Band
ChanSpacing
TotalNumChan
ChanCenterFreq0
page 31 line 7
Filtered 2FSK
0.0125 79
page 31 line 8 77
page 31 line 9 73
901.05
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

6. Continued March 2011 Table 67a 928-960 MHz Band ChanSpacing
TotalNumChan
ChanCenterFreq0
page 31 line 32
Filtered 2FSK
0.0125
2559
page 31 line 33
2557
page 31 line 34
2553
928.05
Table 67a MHz Band
ChanSpacing
TotalNumChan
ChanCenterFreq0
page 32 line 7
Filtered 2FSK
0.0125
7279
page 32 line 8
7277
page 32 line 9
7273
Matt Boytim (Sensus)

7. Continued - Update Table 7c accordingly: March 2011 Bit position
Narrowband FSK PHY mode
4.8 kbps; Filtered 2FSK; mod index = 1.0; channel spacing = 12.5 kHz 1
9.6 kbps; Filtered 4FSK; mod index = 0.33; channel spacing = 12.5 kHz 2
10 kbps; Filtered 2FSK; mod index = 0.5; channel spacing = 12.5 kHz 3
20 kbps; Filtered 2FSK; mod index = 0.5; channel spacing = 12.5 kHz 4
40 kbps; Filtered 2FSK; mod index = 0.5; channel spacing = 12.5 kHz
5-10
Reserved
- addresses
CID 330
addresses
CID 331
- supersedes
CID 333
- supersedes
CID 335
Matt Boytim (Sensus)