Download presentation
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byDenis David Webb Modified over 7 years ago
1
Class II - 2013 Charles University – Law Faculty October 2013 © Peter Kolker 2013
2
How does the dispute begin: Contract between U.S. and Czech Company for Czech Tech to produce and send to U.S. high tech automotive radios: What are the contract terms? What’s “the deal” Class II - 20132
3
Before there can be a Breach of Contract, there must be a Contract. What does it take to prove there is a contract? “Offer” - the request to the other side to buy or sell something. “Acceptance” – the agreement to the offer; that is to, buy or sell something. Must match exactly the offer. This results in: “Meeting of the Minds” on what is being bought or sold. Class II - 20133
4
A description of the product or service that is clear. Time for the sale to take place or service to be provided. Quantity – how many? – Can be a variable number – “requirements contract”. Price and delivery terms. Warranty or other post-sale agreements. Often, an agreement on how and where to resolve disputes. Is there “consideration” to each side? A benefit each side receives? Class II - 20134
5
In writing or otherwise clearly agreed? By people who are legally capable of agreeing. Not a child or someone who is not able to agree. Breach of the Contract: violation of its terms. A “substantial” violation, not a minor error Remedy: Damages – money to correct the breach. Sometimes, an injunction may be granted; An injunction prevents a party to the contract from doing something, or requires the performance of something. Example: sale of a house or other unique property Class II - 20135
6
An injunction is often given before the case is decided finally – it is a “preliminary” remedy. What if it should not have been given? The party who obtained the injunction must post a bond to repay the other party, if the injunction should not have been given. So, there is a danger in seeking an injunction. But it is an important opportunity. Apple’s injunction against Samsung; $95 Million bond Class II - 2013 6
7
Not all disputes are worth fighting about: Costs of the dispute may be too high Damage to the relationship by bringing the suit: even if it is right, it is not getting any new orders from a customer it just sued; Damage to its reputation if it is known to fight with its customers – who wants to do business with such a company But, if it is worth fighting about – a lot of money or an important principle, then how is a law suit handled in the U.S.? We will later consider if there is another way: A lternative Dispute Resolution Class II - 20137
8
U.S. Company: “we’re going to Court in the U.S.“ Very expensive for Czech Company. Why? What is the process in U. S.? Class II - 20138
9
How will this work: First, the Complaint (claim) is filed. Then, the defense to the claim is filed. Now, both sides know what the case is about. But what is the evidence ? What is the proof? How is it obtained? Class II - 20139
10
Unlike cases in the Czech Republic, or in the E.U. generally (except for the U.K.), cases in the U.S. allow extensive and expensive “discovery”. What is that ? Pre-trial testimony from anyone with information about the case (“depositions”). Document Production: all of your documents, including all of your private emails (except for those with your attorney). This includes the email that you thought you had deleted. These can be very damaging – to either side. Obtaining emails from your opponent may help you prove your case. Expensive, but could be a big help. Class II - 201310
11
How are documents obtained? A “document” is a piece of paper BUT it is also an electronic record: “Electronically Stored Information” A lot of volume Think about the emails or SMS sent between you and your friend to arrange a meeting How many people receive the same email? The emails requested will go back for years. Problems of collecting and producing them. Problems of reviewing them when produced A very expensive process. Class II - 201311
12
Class II - 201312
13
Now you have the documents: but what will the witness say about them? In U.S. litigation, you can take a “deposition” A deposition is the sworn testimony of a witness as if given in a court room, but it is taken privately, recorded and with a transcript. It is a “preview” of how the witness will testify at trial. It is a record that will limit the witness afterwards Class II - 201313
14
The Trial U.S. courts allow jury trial, or trial without juries. - 6 or 12 persons decide the facts; the judge instructs the jury on what the law is: What each side must prove to win. - Juries are difficult to predict and can reach a result based on emotional responses. - This is dangerous for both sides, but juries often favor the “home team” – the person or company from that area. - Jury trials take longer and are more expensive. Class II - 201314
15
Or, cases in the U.S. can be decided by a judge alone, without a jury. If tried by a judge, he or she then decides the facts and applies the law. Attorney’s fees are usually paid by each side, regardless of who wins. If the loser pays legal fees for both sides, it raises the cost of bringing suit. Good cases might be eliminated Also, bad cases might be eliminated Appeals after trial: not a second trial, but an opportunity to correct a legal error: did the trial judge make a mistake? Class II - 201315
16
Selection of Judges in the U.S.: is it fair? Almost all have practiced law privately or with the government before becoming a judge Not specially trained to be a judge – they learn “on the job” Federal judges are appointed by the U.S. President They serve for life State judges may be elected for 5 years, or more; or State judges may be appointed by the governor Either way, they are subject to influence But they may be more democratic Class II -201316
17
Judges in the Czech Republic are in career positions Not having served as lawyers first, they may not see the case in the same way as the lawyers do. If the judge is not good, or does not work hard, can he be replaced? There is no (or limited) pre-trail discovery: you will hear the positions for the first time during the trial, limiting your ability to prepare for it. You will not have access to the documents from the other side, so you may not know the full story. Attorney’s fees will be paid by the losing side. Class II -201317
18
Cost and uncertainty of Litigation cause parties to look for other methods of resolving disputes: what are they and how do they work? A. Arbitration Agreement to resolve disputes through a private, but binding method of resolving a dispute Provided for by the contract: specific provision instead of litigation. How is a disputed arbitrated in the U.S. ? (International arbitrations are somewhat different and will be discussed later). Class II - 201318
19
Arbitration resolves a dispute outside of court, but in a binding way. Both sides must agree to arbitration instead of litigation. Can be done in the initial contract, before there is a dispute, or can be agreed after the dispute arises. If there is an agreement to arbitrate, the US Courts will enforce that and will decline to litigate the case, so the arbitration will decide the case, not the court. Usually, the parties agree on an organization to conduct the arbitration and to be bound by their rules For example, the American Arbitration Association Class II - 201319
20
Class II - 201320 Different Rules for different types of disputes: Complex cases vs. simple cases. Some discovery allowed, but not as much as in litigation, with agreed rules of procedure. Arbitrator(s) is selected from a panel, and agreed to by both sides. Arbitrators are typically lawyers, but may also be non- lawyer specialists with expertise in their fields: Engineers, Doctors, Architects, Construction specialists In arbitration, a party may be able to compel witnesses to attend, but not as much authority to do so as in federal court.
21
Arbitrator(s) will set a schedule for case, allow time for limited discovery and then schedule a “hearing”, similar to a trial Witnesses will appear, documents will be considered, and hearing will proceed more quickly than trial in court Arbitrators are required to apply the law; they cannot substitute their own views. Written decision (“award”) is issued quickly after the evidence is admitted – often 30 days Can be a “reasoned decision” or just the result. Class II21
22
Arbitrator can order payment of winner’s attorney’s fees to be paid by losing party. Contrast with litigation in US where normally loser does not pay winner’s attorney’s fees Some exceptions to that rule This makes the cost of arbitration potentially much greater. Selection of Arbitrator is controlled by the parties. Contrast with litigation where judge is selected at random and usually cannot be changed. Class II22
23
U.S. Courts enforce agreements to arbitrate and do not interfere with the arbitration Once an arbitration award is issued, in the U.S., it must be confirmed by the Court so that enforcement can occur. Intended to be a simple process, but often is an invitation to overturn the award by claiming improper actions of the arbitrators. If arbitration award is confirmed, then judgment can be enforced anywhere in the U.S. Class II23
24
Limited Right of Review: An Award can not be appealed in the same way as a judgment in a trial court can be appealed. The only basis for resisting an arbitration Award after it has been entered in the U.S. are: If the arbitrator(s) did not reveal a relationship with the parties when requested to do so at the beginning; or If the arbitrator(s) exceeded their authority by entering an award that went beyond the request; or If there was improper conduct during the arbitration (for example: an arbitrator met with one of the lawyers in private during the arbitration). If no basis to challenge, the Award will be entered as a judgment, and then collection can proceed in the US. Class II -201324
25
Some types of disputes may still be presented to Court if they are described in the agreement to arbitrate: Example: where urgent remedy is needed – someone is taking your intellectual property and is about to put it on the internet. One of your former employees has taken customer files, copied them and is about to give them to a competitor. Arbitration, while usually fast, does not have the same immediate remedy measures as litigation in court has available. So contracts to arbitrate provide for exceptions for court filing for some situations. Class II - 201325
Similar presentations
© 2024 SlidePlayer.com Inc.
All rights reserved.