FLAT ROOF THIN-FILM PV COMPARED TO TILTED THIN FILM AND CRYSTALLINE PV Ron Swenson SolarQuest ® P O Box 7080 Santa Cruz, CA
Experimental Setup: Three Types of PV Arrays.
Horizontal Amorphous Arrays a
Thin Film Panels Glued to Foam Roofing.
Foam Roofing Handles Penetrations No leaks
Electricity Generated First Full Day of Operation Note late afternoon internal shading near solstice
Cosine Loss Horizontal Amorphous Array Significant losses in Winter
Cosine Loss Horizontal vs. Tilted Arrays Note horizontal performance approaches tilted on cloudy days
Comparing over Time Amorphous vs. Crystalline and Horizontal vs. Tilted Note similarity on cloudy days, increase towards summer
Comparing Amorphous with Crystalline Array Sunny vs. Cloudy Days Note Amorphous outperforms crystalline
Comparing Amorphous with Crystalline over Temperature Range Outcome Inconclusive
It Seemed Okay in March … Inverter losses
Inverter Losses.
Flat top haircut
Inverter Losses Flat top haircut
Monthly Energy Totals Horizontal ArrayTilted Array
See for yourself!