Public Forum Debate: Revised Slide Show 2008 champions recognized by Dr. Feeley and School Board, 4/15/2008

Public Forum Debate The Rules in Brief

Pre-Debate Two people debate two people. One team flips a coin and the opposing team calls heads or tails. Whoever wins can choose from two options: -To debate the pro or con side -To speak first or second The losers of the coin flip choose from the remaining option.

Debate Setup Team A: First Speaker: Opening Statement4 minutes Team B: First Speaker: Opening Statement4 minutes Crossfire (A1 vs. B1)3 minutes Team A: Second Speaker: Rebuttal4 minutes Team B: Second Speaker: Rebuttal4 minutes Crossfire (A2 vs. B2)3 minutes Team A: First Speaker: Summary (Rebuttal)2 minutes Team B: First Speaker: Summary (Rebuttal)2 minutes Grand Crossfire (A1 and A2 vs. B1 and B2)3 minutes Team A: Second Speaker: Closing Statement1 minute Team B: Second Speaker: Closing Statement1 minute

More in Depth The Opening Statements (“Constructive Speeches”): Team A- since they go first it consists of the main arguments for their side. Team B- since they already heard Team A’s argument, their opening statement should consist of their team’s main arguments and rebuttals as well. But it should still be mostly B’s arguments, because:

More in Depth First Crossfire: Now the two first speakers from Teams A and Team B begin their 3 minute crossfire. In theory, A1 asks the first question. In practice, B1 may do this, and if A1 answers, OK. They ask questions back and forth, revealing weaknesses in each others arguments.

More in Depth The Rebuttal (for debaters A2 and B2): Team A- Second speaker gives a 4 minute speech which presents new arguments but also rebuts arguments made by the other team. Team B- Second speaker does the same as above. Following this is the 3 minute Crossfire between the two second speakers. A2 and B2 question each other and try to expose weaknesses and point out inaccuracies.

More in Depth Summary Speech: Team A- First speaker (A1) gives a two minute summary speech of the debate with “nothing too crazy”: this is mostly re-statement and a chance to add facts and examples, as well as to rebut. Technically, though, A1 can still introduce a “new” argument. Team B- First speaker (B1) does the same as above for two minutes.

More in Depth Grand Crossfire!! This is the source of Public Forum’s surging popularity among debate formats. It’s very similar to the other crossfires but this one includes all 4 team members together. The speaker that gave the first summary begins the grand crossfire by asking the first question (again, in actuality, this is flexible). Grand Crossfire lasts the same amount of time as the other crossfires, three minutes. Avoid the urge to have one partner or the other dominate: try to present a balanced attack.

More in Depth The Final Focus: The second speakers of each team give a one minute persuasive speech to explain why his or her team should win the round (their strengths or the other side’s weaknesses). A2 goes first, then B2. No new arguments are allowed in the Final Focus!

Prep Time/ Preparedness Each team gets a total of two minutes’ preparation time, which they can use before any rebuttal or crossfire round, if needed, in increments as small as 30 seconds. When it’s a debater’s turn, though, he/she must be ready. Debaters may take notes during their opponents’ arguments, as long as they are listening to them. Debaters may not interrupt or heckle, nor should they make silly or dismissive faces/ gestures…ever! Politeness is rewarded in scoring, and the line between aggressiveness and rudeness varies from judge to judge.

Judging Any adult or student in the community can judge SPDL, except in the playoffs. NFL requires judges to be 18 and h.s. grads. Leagues use an official scoring ballot, which is similar from one league to the next. They score you by giving up to 30 points: = Outstanding27-28 = Above Average = Average20-23 = Below Average What’s rough about SPDL is that each competing Public Forum pair must show up with a judge, or they can’t compete. That’s why novice debaters must be judges first. They chose a winner simply on the points you make and how strong your rebuttals are. They may or may not no anything on your topic and may or may not bias.They chose a winner simply on the points you make and how strong your rebuttals are. They may or may not no anything on your topic and may or may not bias.

Mandatory Workshops No one should judge SPDL who has not attended the judging workshop on October 14 th or participated in multiple SPDL tournaments. Fortunately, some LM debaters went to SPDL in as observers, and I doubt league personnel know the difference. So they have the option of going to the novice workshop on October 21 st. As for those who were not part of SPDL last year, they must attend on October 14 th and on October 21 st. The experience is vital.

Parents/Guardians Thanks to a handful of lawsuit-lovers, no student may ride with another student, or another student’s parent, or a teacher, to a school function, ever! Nor may you drive yourself. We ride in the big yellow bus, just like sports teams. If you want or need to be picked up at a tournament by your own parent/guardian, I must speak to them beforehand. That would be 3:30 on debate day at the latest, since I turn my cell off when I judge. I also must see you leave with that parent, so it can’t be before the last round of the evening is over. Parents/guardians can be incredibly helpful, though, if they are willing to judge. A parent who judges enables another team of two to debate, gaining them valuable experience.