Business in Medicine and its Effect on Resident Education Jennifer Litwin D.O. HO4, Randy Wobser M.D. Creighton University Medical Center Omaha, NE Introduction.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Challenge and Importance of Evaluating Residents and Fellows Debra Weinstein, M.D. PHS GME Coordinators Retreat March 25, 2011.
Advertisements

Resident Duty Hours UB Office of Graduate Medical Education Donna M. Cummiskey Director, GME Resource Management May 20, 2008.
Basic Statistics: The Three Things You Need to Know In Order to Complete Your Project.
Comparing Two Proportions (p1 vs. p2)
Next Accreditation System Safe Care for Current and Future Patients.
VANDERBILT SURGERY Impact of Initiation of a Pediatric Surgery Fellowship on General Surgery Resident Operative Volume ♦ ♦ ♦ Rebecca A. Snyder, MD Sharon.
Two Sample Hypothesis Testing for Proportions
Impact of the 80 Hour WorkweekImpact of the 80 Hour Workweek  The role and training of the general surgical resident has perpetually evolved since its.
Economic Impact of Medical Education Expansion in Nevada & Recommended Approach FUTURE 1.
CASE LOGS & CLINICAL PROCEDURE TRACKING M. Njoku, MD UMMC DIO, Chair GMEC GMEC Meeting June 25, 2015.
Rural Medical Education Premedical Student Conference Thanks to Scott Owings, MD Associate Director – Smoky Hill Family Medicine Residency 2/18/12.
1 Medina Healthcare System: Centralized Scheduling Center.
Evidence-Based Medicine 4 More Knowledge and Skills for Critical Reading Karen E. Schetzina, MD, MPH.
Outpatient Surgery Centers Draw Cases Away from Hospitals, Impact Resident Training Volume Kyle Dunning, MD* Eric Liedtke DO* Lori Toedter, PhD† Chand.
TEMPLATE DESIGN © Patient’s Attitude and Perception Toward Medical Students Nadin A. Alghanaim, N. Anfinan, K. Sait, A.
Advanced Laparoscopic Fellowship and General Surgery Residency can Co-exist without Detracting from Surgical Resident Operative Experience Shanu N. Kothari,
A rich history of commitment to Medical Education in Northwest Ohio.
Boarding Times and Patient Safety: A quantifiable and generalizable model David Wein, MD MBA Associate Facility Medical Director Tampa General Hospital.
Elizabeth A. Martinez, MD, MHS Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions September 10, 2008 Organization of Care and Outcomes in Cardiac Surgery AHRQ grant 1K08HS A1.
AMU DoQuP FINAL REPORT MD, PhD, Associate Professor G.Ahmadov Azerbaijan Medical University Bishkek, April 22, 2015.
III. Affect of the 2011 duty hour regulations on the source of admission Harborview Medical Center primary team
In Duval County Florida, there are approximately 2, 360 persons living with HIV. Between an estimated 25.6% of persons aged 25 or older living.
Biostatistics Class 6 Hypothesis Testing: One-Sample Inference 2/29/2000.
Disclosure of Financial Conflicts of Interest in Continuing Medical Education Michael D. Jibson, MD, PhD and Jennifer Seibert, MD University of Michigan.
Statistics - methodology for collecting, analyzing, interpreting and drawing conclusions from collected data Anastasia Kadina GM presentation 6/15/2015.
1 ERCOT LRS Precision Analysis PWG Presentation February 27, 2007.
VACCINE STORAGE AND ADMINISTRATION AMONG PRIMARY HEALTH CARE WORKERS IN SOUTH-EAST NIGERIA: EFFECT OF EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION UZOCHUKWU BSC, ONWUJEKWE.
In order to improve the Family Medicine obstetrics (OB) rotation orientation and to encourage resident- resident teaching, we developed an orientation.
Design and Assessment of the Toronto Area Computerized Household Activity Scheduling Survey Sean T. Doherty, Erika Nemeth, Matthew Roorda, Eric J. Miller.
Preparing Future Teachers for 21 st Century Learning Partnerships that enhance the capacity of pre-service education 2008 Deakin University Faculty of.
Healthcare Workforce and Regionalization of Services: Lung Cancer Resections Stephen C. Yang, M.D. Chief of Thoracic Surgery The Arthur B. and Patricia.
Operative Volume in the New Era: A Comparison of Total Resident Operative Volume Pre vs. Post 80-Hour Work Week Restriction Implementation Pamela J. Bruce,
A short introduction to epidemiology Chapter 9: Data analysis Neil Pearce Centre for Public Health Research Massey University Wellington, New Zealand.
2 sample interval proportions sample Shown with two examples.
Local and national trends in general surgery residents’ operative experience: Do work hour limitations negatively affect case volume in small community-based.
© Copyright McGraw-Hill 2004
STACEY T. GRAY, MD PROGRAM DIRECTOR, HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL.
High Quality Residency Education and Patient Safety are Directly Related David T. Harrington, MD Program Director, General Surgical Residency Program Associate.
Comparing Performance on the Virtual Laparoscopic and Robotic Simulators Among Medical Students Pursuing Surgical versus Non-surgical Residencies Amanda.
Gender Differences in Medical Student Performance of Simulated Vaginal Deliveries and Cervical Exams Nitsche J, Shumard K, Fino N, Denney J, Quinn K, Bailey.
LMMHC Medicine Research rotation B Kanna MD, MPH, FACP Associate Program Director of Internal Medicine Associate Director of Graduate Medical Education.
Factors Affecting Resident Participation in Surgical Cases Jesse Loeffler, MD; Jennifer Griffin, MD, MPH; Harlan Sayles, MS Department of Obstetrics and.
Number of Simulation Sessions and Vaginal Delivery Performance in Medical Students Joshua F. Nitsche, MD, PhD, Timberly Butler, Alison Witkowski, Sha Jin,
A survey of our OB/GYN residents identified fellows as a source of valued and effective teaching more often than either senior residents or faculty members.
In 2014, U.S. Residency Programs including Ob-Gyn fully implemented the Next Accreditation System with the use of Milestone evaluation and reporting. Residency.
Chapter 9: Introduction to the t statistic. The t Statistic The t statistic allows researchers to use sample data to test hypotheses about an unknown.
Meeting the ACGME Milestones through Group Prenatal Care INTRODUCTION Mila D'Cunha MD. MSc., Anastasia Kolasa-Lenarz MD. MPH., Karolina Lis MD., Kimberly.
TEMPLATE AND PRINTING BY: GRMERC Consortium Members: Grand Valley State University, Michigan State University, Saint Mary’s.
Improving the Quality of Prenatal Care at the WMed FM Residency Clinic Susan Jevert, DO Homer Stryker MD School of Medicine Department of Family and Community.
360 DEGREE FEEDBACK: A NOVEL FORMAT FOR A PROGRAM EVALUATION COMMITTEE IN AN ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE RESIDENCY PROGRAM Holly Caretta-Weyer, MD; Morgan.
Introduction Methods Objectives Results Conclusions Figures/Graphs Implementation of clinical innovations are often evaluated at the operational and patient.
APHA 135 th Annual Meeting – Scientific Session Disparity in Access to Perinatal Tertiary Care in a Regionalized System Gary L. Loy, MD, MPH, Maternal-Fetal.
Developing a PCMH Team Block Rotation: Practical Considerations for FM Residency Training Rabin Chandran, MD; Arnold Goldberg, MD; David Ashley, MD; Christopher.
Introduction References Objectives Conclusions Results Faculty provision of performance feedback is critical for residents to improve their clinical skills.
Trends at the ACGME (where we are going
Clinical Learning Environment Review GMEC January 8, 2013
Ambulatory Neonatal Circumcision Clinic in a Family Medicine Residency
Identifying patients that drop out of bariatric surgery programs David Mahony, Ph.D., Henry Alder, M.S., M.B.A. & Jeff Eha Introduction Bariatric surgery.
Crucial Statistical Caveats for Percutaneous Valve Trials
Stats Tools for Analyzing Data
Semiannual Report, March 2015
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU Material & Methods (Click)
Oversight of Underperforming Programs Through Special Reviews
Christopher S. Kiefer MD, Erica B. Shaver MD,
Advanced Nurse Practioners Physician Assistants
Conclusions/ Future Directions
Souheil W. Adra, MD Amber W. Trickey, MS Moira E. Crosby, MPH
Effects of Financial and Human Resource Management Controls
Souheil W. Adra, MD Amber W. Trickey, MS Moira E. Crosby, MPH
Presentation transcript:

Business in Medicine and its Effect on Resident Education Jennifer Litwin D.O. HO4, Randy Wobser M.D. Creighton University Medical Center Omaha, NE Introduction On September 1, 2014, in-network participation with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Nebraska and the primary resident teachings hospitals, Alegent Creighton and Bergan Mercy Hospital, ended. The result was a loss of patients with this carrier from the resident case load. While these two big institutions work to resolve their differences, many - - including patients and residents, were caught in the middle. Traditionally, high volume and long hours during residency were considered necessary to ensure both competency and patient safety in training. With the shift in patient coverage at these training institutions concern has been raised on adequate volume to produce competent doctors. Surgical volume is important for evaluating resident experience, skill, and to ensure adequate clinical resources. Our study analyzes the effects and potential effects of financial driven business decisions on the quantity and quality of resident teaching at Creighton's two main resident training hospitals. Reviewing procedures/case logs for all residents to ensure adequate clinical resources. By analyzing the volume we are able to: –Make adjustments that may be needed to maintain resident education and experience –Ensure that the program has adequate numbers to meet procedure requirements Study Design: Retrospective observational study The Null hypothesis is that procedural volume pre and post-loss of insurance contract will be the same.. Methods Results Discussion References 1.[ACGME] Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. ACGME common program requirements. dutyHours dh_dutyhoursCommonPR pdf. Accessed June 6, [ACGME] Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. ACGME institutional requirements. irc_IRCpr pdf. Accessed June 6, Simpson D, Lypson ML. The year is over, now what? the annual program evaluation. J Grad Med Educ. 2011;3(3):435–437. In addition, there was no detectable difference in the proportion of deliveries that were attended by residents between 2013 and 2014;The odds ratio (2013 to 2014) is 1.04, p-value = ; 95% confidence interval (0.96, 1.14). In light of the immediate decrease in both surgical and clinical volume, residents at Creighton were provided the opportunity to seek out surgery at additional affiliated facilities in the greater Omaha metro area. Starting in September residents began working more extensively with contributed faculty at all CHI facilities in the metro area as well as at the outpatient surgical centers. With these new opportunities resident case volume remained steady. Furthermore, this shows the personal motivation and drive the residents at Creighton have to maintain a robust surgical experience. One of the limitations of our study is that it is biased by resident reporting. Resident procedure numbers were collected from ACGME, a self reporting site. We attempted to eliminate that bias by looking at the proportion of cases where residents were primary surgeon vs the total number of cases. We were able to preform this with deliveries; however, due to the inability to tract total surgical opportunities across 9 locations we were unable to eliminate that bias for gynecological cases. Data on gynecological and obstetric volume was collected from the ACGME database as well as hospital scheduling from two major teaching hospitals for 2012, 2013, and To eliminate any seasonal variation the same quarters were compared with each other. Initial preliminary data indicated that surgical volume was affected (decreased). However, affiliations with contributing faculty allowed for experiences at outside facilities that added to resident cases. These additional numbers were also taken into account in our analysis. The chi-square goodness of fit test for your data indicates that there is a difference amongst the years (p = ). Rather than go through each of the independent 2x2 tables to determine where the difference lies, I calculated the 95% confidence interval for the proportion of each type of procedure. The line centered on each bar above represents the confidence interval. The area where there is a difference is in the proportion of other cases across years; specifically, the lower bound for 2014 does not overlap the upper bound for Initial results did show a difference of approximately 28% in overall gynecologic volume as shown below; however, when separated out into type of case there was not a statistical difference. Despite an estimated global decrease of approximately 30% for surgical and clinical volume interventions implemented during this time of transition made for a minimal impact on resident surgical experience. Another consideration to the surgical volume at Creighton is effect of robotic surgery. In an era where attendings are transitioning their preferred mode of hysterectomy and comfort with new technology it can leave resident out of the primary surgeon role when they may have been previously. Table 1: Minimum Resident Case Numbers Conclusions In regards to deliveries, with the p values being and thus not statistically significant we can accept the null hypothesis. In terms of gynecological volume, there was a significant difference with a P value of Further analysis needs to be done on route of surgical, specifically hysterectomy and vaginal vault suspensions and its influence on resident participation. At this time we can thus conclude that the interventions to improve resident surgical experience in the light of decreased volume at our primary hospitals has augmented the anticipated effect on resident education while maintaining and optimizing resident training. With that being said, it is important for training institutions to be cognizant of changes in the educational environment and be adaptable to insure that they produce competent doctors. Number of cases preformed by 3 rd year OB/GYN residents September to October Resident AttendedNo ResidentTotal Total Table 2: Delivery numbers for 2014 and 2015