Travel Time Measurements Markus Roth 1, Laurent Gizon 1, John G. Beck 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung 2 Stanford University HELAS Workshop.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning
Advertisements

Use of Kalman filters in time and frequency analysis John Davis 1st May 2011.
CHAPTER ONE FINDING YOUR WAY.
Variance and covariance M contains the mean Sums of squares General additive models.
280 SYSTEM IDENTIFICATION The System Identification Problem is to estimate a model of a system based on input-output data. Basic Configuration continuous.
TIME-DISTANCE ANALYSIS OF REALISTIC SIMULATIONS OF SOLAR CONVECTION Dali Georgobiani, Junwei Zhao 1, David Benson 2, Robert Stein 2, Alexander Kosovichev.
HMI – Synoptic Data Sets HMI Team Meeting Jan. 26, 2005 Stanford, CA.
Solar Polar Field Observed by SOHO/MDI and Hinode Yang Liu Stanford University 10/01/ Hinode Workshop.
Time-distance Helioseismology Technique Issues T. L. Duvall Jr. (NASA/GSFC)
Local Helioseismology Laurent Gizon (Stanford). Outline Some background Time-distance helioseismology: Solar-cycle variations of large-scale flows Near.
Inversion of rotation profile for solar-like stars Jérémie Lochard IAS 19/11/04.
CoRA, NWRA, Inc. 7/18/2005 Time-Distance Inversions and Kernels for Ring Diagrams Aaron Birch Outline: A.TD Inversions B.Kernels for Ring Diagrams.
Detection of Emerging Sunspot Regions in the Solar Interior Stathis Ilonidis, Junwei Zhao, and Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University LoHCo Workshop.
RLSELE Adaptive Signal Processing 1 Recursive Least-Squares (RLS) Adaptive Filters.
Principles of the Global Positioning System Lecture 11 Prof. Thomas Herring Room A;
Measuring Center-to-Limb Effect and A New Strategy to Measure Deep Meridional Flow Junwei Zhao 1 & Ruizhu Chen 2,1 1.W. W. Hansen Experimental Physics.
Colorado Center for Astrodynamics Research The University of Colorado STATISTICAL ORBIT DETERMINATION Project Report Unscented kalman Filter Information.
Geo479/579: Geostatistics Ch13. Block Kriging. Block Estimate  Requirements An estimate of the average value of a variable within a prescribed local.
1 Status of Ring-diagram Analysis of MOTH Data Kiran Jain Collaborators: F. Hill, C. Toner.
An Introduction to Helioseismology (Local) 2008 Solar Physics Summer School June 16-20, Sacramento Peak Observatory, Sunspot, NM.
Characterizing Photospheric Flows David Hathaway (NASA/MSFC) with John Beck & Rick Bogart (Stanford/CSSA) Kurt Bachmann, Gaurav Khatri, & Joshua Petitto.
Inversions from one of Konstantin’s Simulations Birch, Braun, & Crouch Data from Parchevsky & Kosovichev.
Sensitivity Kernels for Local Helioseismology Aaron Birch NWRA, CoRA Division.
P MODE TRAVEL TIME IN ACTIVE REGIONS USING TIME-DISTANCE METHOD CRAAG, Observatory of Algiers, BP 63 Bouzareah 16340, Algiers, Algeria. (1)
Supergranulation Waves in the Subsurface Shear Layer Cristina Green Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University.
Axial Flip Invariance and Fast Exhaustive Searching with Wavelets Matthew Bolitho.
PATTERN RECOGNITION AND MACHINE LEARNING CHAPTER 3: LINEAR MODELS FOR REGRESSION.
Wolfgang finsterle, September 26, 2006 Seismology of the Solar atmosphere Seismology of the Solar Atmosphere HELAS Roadmap Workshop, OCA Nice Wolfgang.
Summary of introduced statistical terms and concepts mean Variance & standard deviation covariance & correlation Describes/measures average conditions.
Imaging Solar Tachocline Using Numerical Simulations and SOHO/MDI Data Junwei Zhao 1, Thomas Hartlep 2, Alexander G. Kosovichev 1, Nagi N. Mansour 2 1.W.W.Hansen.
Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Scherrer (2013): Comparison of a quiet tile with a nearby active region (5 o to 8 o away) with a quiet tile with no nearby.
The “ ” Paige in Kalman Filtering K. E. Schubert.
Estimation of Sound Source Direction Using Parabolic Reflection Board 2008 RISP International Workshop on Nonlinear Circuits and Signal Processing (NCSP’08)
TO THE POSSIBILITY OF STUDY OF THE EXTERNAL SOLAR WIND THIN STRUCTURE IN DECAMETER RADIO WAVES Marina Olyak Institute of Radio Astronomy, 4 Chervonopraporna,
Xianwu Ling Russell Keanini Harish Cherukuri Department of Mechanical Engineering University of North Carolina at Charlotte Presented at the 2003 IPES.
Artificial ‘Physics-light’ Ring Data Rachel Howe, Irene Gonzalez-Hernandez, and Frank Hill.
Using Realistic MHD Simulations for Modeling and Interpretation of Quiet Sun Observations with HMI/SDO I. Kitiashvili 1,2, S. Couvidat 2 1 NASA Ames Research.
Comparison of time- distance and holography Junwei Zhao and Alexander G. Kosovichev W. W. Hansen Experimental Physics Laboratory, Stanford University,
 Prevailing winds are major wind patterns that cover large geographical areas  In Ontario the prevailing wind direction is from the West  Prevailing.
台灣清華大學, 物理系 Helioseismology (II) Global and Local Helioseismology ( , 北京 ) 周定一 Dean-Yi Chou.
Local Helioseismology LPL/NSO Summer School June 11-15, 2007.
Tests of the Ring-Diagram Inversions A. Kosovichev.
1 Mei Zhang ( National Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences ) Solar cycle variation of kinetic helicity Collaborators: Junwei Zhao (Stanford,
Linear Filters. denote a bivariate time series with zero mean. Let.
LIGO- G Z August 17, 2005August LSC Meeting – ASIS Session 1 Recovering Hardware Injection Waveforms with Maximum Entropy Tiffany Summerscales.
Horizontal Flows in Active Regions from Multi-Spectral Observations of SDO Sushant Tripathy 1 Collaborators K. Jain 1, B. Ravindra 2, & F. Hill 1 1 National.
Systematic Center-to-limb Variations in Time-Distance Measurements and Meridional Flows Junwei Zhao & collaborators.
Time-distance measurements of meridional circulation using pairs of points at equal center-to- limb angle Tom Duvall Deep Chakraborty Tim Larsen.
Geo479/579: Geostatistics Ch12. Ordinary Kriging (2)
ESTIMATION METHODS We know how to calculate confidence intervals for estimates of  and  2 Now, we need procedures to calculate  and  2, themselves.
GONG Time distance pipeline status Shukur Kholikov.
Estimating emissions from observed atmospheric concentrations: A primer on top-down inverse methods Daniel J. Jacob.
Helioseismology for HMI Science objectives and tasks* Data analysis plan* Helioseismology working groups and meetings *HMI Concept Study Report, Appendix.
Planning for Helioseismology with SO/PHI Birch, Gizon, & Hirzberger Max Planck Institute for Solar System Physics.
Estimation of acoustic travel-time systematic variations due to observational height difference across the solar disk. Shukur Kholikov 1 and Aleksander.
Susan L. Beck George Zandt Kevin M. Ward Jonathan R. Delph.
Computation of Eigen-Emittances (and Optics Functions!)
Vincent Böning, Shukur Kholikov, Jason Jackiewicz, and Markus Roth
Velocity Estimation from noisy Measurements
…Don’t be afraid of others, because they are bigger than you
HMI Data Analysis Pipeline
HMI Data Analysis Pipeline
Forward Modeling for Time-Distance Helioseismology
Principles of the Global Positioning System Lecture 11
Time Distance Study of Isolated Sunspots
Recovering Hardware Injection Waveforms with Maximum Entropy
Geology 491 Spectral Analysis
LoHCo Meeting – Tucson, December 13, 2005
Time-distance: methods and results
Probabilistic Surrogate Models
Presentation transcript:

Travel Time Measurements Markus Roth 1, Laurent Gizon 1, John G. Beck 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung 2 Stanford University HELAS Workshop „Roadmap for Local Helioseismology“, September 25, 2006 Markus Roth 1, Laurent Gizon 1, John G. Beck 2 1 Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung 2 Stanford University HELAS Workshop „Roadmap for Local Helioseismology“, September 25, 2006

Travel Time Measurements Time-Distance Helioseismology IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Δ Source Observer Calculation of the Cross Correlation of the observed signals as function of travel-distance and time lag: Observation of oscillation signal at two locations on the Sun  16.5° Duvall et al (1993)

Travel Time Measurements Cross-Correlation as function of distance  and time lag  Positive time-lag: outgoing-wave Negative time-lag: incoming wave Difference allows to conclude on flows, mean sound speed, etc... 1st ridge: one bounce 2nd ridge: two bounces 3rd ridge: three bounces... IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Observation at the equator, 90 day average Time-Distance Diagram

Travel Time Measurements Measuring Travel Times Used Methods: 1)Fitting Garbor Wavelet (five parameters) ! phase travel time t ph 2)Extra Cross-Correlation (Zhao & Jordan 1998, Gizon & Birch 2004 for stochastic sources), minimization of “badness of fit”: yields travel-time measurement Reference cross-correlation: symmetrized long-term average Correlation coefficient: 0.76 IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions

Travel Time Measurements Measured Travel Times IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Measuring the travel time difference between waves travelling East – West ! sensitive to differential rotation North – South ! sensitive to meridional flow

Travel Time Measurements Wavelet Fits Measuring travel times for 1st & 2nd bounce IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions 1st bounce measurements are smooth 2nd bound measurements need more averaging clear due to signal/noise

Travel Time Measurements Minimization Method IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Advantages: Works on noisy data, too. Fast computation Stable results

Travel Time Measurements Comparison of Performance IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Measured signal in the order of 1 sec (peak near 0 sec) Wavelet fit: often no convergence outliers not Gaussian Extra Cross-Correlation: No outliers Gaussian distribution --- Garbor --- Extra CC

Travel Time Measurements Variance Garbor Wavelets IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Garbor Wavelets: Small errors at distances ¼ 10-20° & at latitutdes ¼ 0° Observational errors are largest for short and long distances, and for high latitudes (consistent with P. Giles 1999, 90 day average) North-South East-West

Travel Time Measurements Variance Extra Cross-Correl. IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions North-South East-West Extra Cross-Correlation: As function of distance: dip at 10°, but more flat than with the Garbor wavelets As function of latitude: minimal error at the equator, appears more flat

Travel Time Measurements Noise Sources IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Main Source: stochastic nature of solar oscillations (excitation, damping) Additional sources (actually the main sources!): systematic noise sources (important for long averages, e.g. for precisions to measure meridional circulation, P-Angle, foreshortening, focus position of telescope) Understanding of noise necessary for: correct understanding of measurements solving the inverse problem, kernels (speed-up calculations)

Travel Time Measurements Estimating the Covariance Matrix IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions Time-distance helioseismology: Information on noise is given by the covariance matrix of the travel time measurements x1x1 x2x2 x1´x1´x2´x2´ Estimation: directly by averaging over many samples ´´ 

Travel Time Measurements Covariance Matrix Wavelet Fit IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions

Travel Time Measurements Covariance Matrix Extra Cross-Correlation IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions

Travel Time Measurements Covariance Matrix Wavelet Fit IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions

Travel Time Measurements Covariance Matrix Extra Cross-Correlation IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions

Travel Time Measurements Conclusions IntroductionMethodsNoiseResultsConclusions The two methods are somehow different in their noise behaviour (1st & 2nd bounce) ! needs to be worked out in detail ! information gained about solar interior Common: Covariance matrix is confined to a few degrees around the target distance confined to a few degrees around the target latitude (+ few oscillations) Differences: between East-West and North-South measurments due to used points for averaging ! data dependence in covariance matrix