WHY DO WE WANT TO MODEL THE COLLISIONAL EVOLUTION OF MBPs? SOLAR SYSTEM FORMATION : what was the primordial distribution of the minor body population.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Spitzer IRS Spectroscopy of IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks Christine H. Chen (NOAO) IRS Disks Team astro-ph/
Advertisements

Origins of Regular and Irregular Satellites ASTR5830 March 19, :30-1:45 pm.
Mars/moon impact rate ratio: 2000/2012 comparison Impact craters as a link to other terrestrial planets, satellites and asteroids Interplanetary comparisons.
Origins of Regular and Irregular Satellites ASTR5830 March 21, :30-1:45 pm.
Interplanetary bodies: asteroids asteroid-- rocky object in orbit around the sun includes: Main Belt asteroid Hilda and Thule asteroid near-Earth asteroid.
Some Short Topics AS3141 Benda Kecil dalam Tata Surya Prodi Astronomi 2007/2008 B. Dermawan.
Alberto Cellino – CD VI, Cannes, June 2003 INAF --Osservatorio Astronomico di Torino Asteroid Families Families What can we learn from them?
Formation of our Moon: The Giant Impact Hypothesis Michelle Kirchoff Southwest Research Institute Center for Lunar Origin and Evolution.
Depletion and excitation of the asteroid belt by migrating planets Kevin J. Walsh, Alessandro Morbidelli (SwRI,OCA-Nice) Sean N. Raymond (Obs. Bordeaux),
The Late Veneer: constraints on composition, mass, and mixing timescales “Post-AGU” Divya Allupeddinti Beth-Ann Bell Lea Bello Ana Cernok Nilotpal Ghosh.
Surface Chronology of Phobos – The Age of Phobos and its Largest Crater Stickney 1 N. Schmedemann 1, G. Michael 1, B. A. Ivanov 2, J. Murray 3 and G. Neukum.
Derek C. Richardson (U Maryland) Rubble Piles & Monoliths CD-VI Cannes PreshatteredRubble This online version does not include the movies. Please .
Investigating the Near-Earth Object Population William Bottke Southwest Research Institute William Bottke Southwest Research Institute.
Asteroid Rotations and Binaries
Dynamics of the young Solar system Kleomenis Tsiganis Dept. of Physics - A.U.Th. Collaborators: Alessandro Morbidelli (OCA) Hal Levison (SwRI) Rodney Gomes.
MINOR MEMBERS OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM: Asteroids. Images of three asteroids, taken during spacecraft flybys, shown to scale (Mathilde is 59 km wide and 47.
Coupling the dynamical and collisional evolution of the Kuiper Belt, the Scattered Disk & the Oort Cloud S. Charnoz A. Morbidelli Equipe AIM Université.
10Nov2006 Ge/Ay133 More on Jupiter, Neptune, the Kuiper belt, and the early solar system.
Binaries in the Vesta Family of Asteroids William H. Ryan (NM Tech/MRO) Eileen V. Ryan (NM Tech/MRO) Carlos Martinez (UNM)
Observations and models of size distribution of KBOs (summarize several articles) Yeh, Lun-Wen
Clues to the origin of Jupiter’s Trojans: the libration amplitude distribution F. Marzari, P. Tricarico, and H. Scholl Katie McGleam TERPS conference Dec.
CATASTROPHIC DISRUPTION 2007 CD Workshops: Why??.
« Debris » discs A crash course in numerical methods Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
COMETS, KUIPER BELT AND SOLAR SYSTEM DYNAMICS Silvia Protopapa & Elias Roussos Lectures on “Origins of Solar Systems” February 13-15, 2006 Part I: Solar.
29 NOVEMBER 2007 CLASS #25 Astronomy 340 Fall 2007.
A coherent and comprehensive model of the evolution of the outer solar system Alessandro Morbidelli (OCA, Nice) Collaborators: R. Gomes, H. Levison, K.
THE LATE HEAVY BOMBARDMENT AND THE FORMATION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM
Chapter 9a Remnants of Rock and Ice Asteroids, Comets, and Pluto.
The Solar System at ~10 mas perspectives for a Fresnel imager Paolo Tanga Marco Delbò Laboratoire Cassiopée, OCA.
Spins and Satellites: Probes of Asteroid Interiors Alan W. Harris and Petr Pravec Sixth Catastrophic Disruption Workshop Cannes, 9-11 June 2003.
Vagabonds of the Solar System Chapter 17. Guiding Questions 1.How and why were the asteroids first discovered? 2.Why didn’t the asteroids coalesce to.
Planets in Debris Disks Renu Malhotra University of Arizona Planet-Debris co-evolution Where can debris exist? Cases: Solar system, upsilon Andromedae,
FORMATION OF PLANETESIMALS BY GRAVITATIONAL INSTABILITIES IN TURBULENT STRUCTURES: EVIDENCE FROM ASTEROID BELT CONSTRAINTS A.Morbidelli (OCA, Nice) D.
Space Asteroids Raynaldo 6B.
16 th Dec 2009 Hilke Schlichting (CITA) Planetesimal Accretion & Collisions in the Kuiper Belt KIAA 16 th December 2009 Hilke E. Schlichting Canadian Institute.
: The Golden Age of Solar System Exploration TNOs: Four decades of observations. F. Merlin M.A. Barucci S. Fornasier D. Perna.
Modeling Planetary Systems Around Sun-like Stars Paper: Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems: Cold Outer Disks Associated with Sun-like Stars,
EART 160: Planetary Science Itokawa Enhydra lutris Image copyright Fred Hsu Image courtesy ISAS/JAXA.
Cratering on Nix and Hydra William Bottke (SwRI).
ASTRONOMY 340 FALL 2007 Lecture # 23 October 2007.
Primary Rotations of Asteroid Pairs P. Pravec, D. Vokrouhlický, D. Polishook, A. Harris, A. Galád, O. Vaduvescu, F. Pozo, A. Barr, P. Longa, F. Colas,
Europlanet 2007, Potsdam, Highlights
Expected Coalescence Rate of NS/NS Binaries for Ground Based Interferometers Tania Regimbau OCA/ARTEMIS on the behalf of J.A. de Freitas Pacheco, T. Regimbau,
Lecture 32: The Origin of the Solar System Astronomy 161 – Winter 2004.
The PSI Planet-building Code: Multi-zone, Multi-use S. J. Weidenschilling PSI Retreat August 20, 2007.
PI: Hal Levison DPI: Cathy Olkin SwRI Project Manager: John Andrews S/C Provider: LM Management: GSFC.
OBLIQUE IMPACT AND ITS EJECTA – NUMERICAL MODELING Natasha Artemieva and Betty Pierazzo Houston 2003.
From Planetesimals to Planets Pre-Galactic Black Holes and ALMA.
Astronomy 340 Fall October 2005 Class #???
Astronomy 340 Fall December 2007 Class #29.
DYNAMICAL EVOLUTION OF THE SEINAJOKI ASTEROID FAMILY Vladimir Đošović Bojan Novaković The sixth Symposium "Mathematics and Applications" 17. October2015.
ORIGIN OF THE LATE HEAVY BOMBARDMENT OF THE TERRESTRIAL PLANETS
New Views on the Lunar Late Heavy Bombardment
Cratering in the Solar System William Bottke Southwest Research Institute Boulder, Colorado.
Asteriods “Minor planets”, ranging in size from several hundred km to boulders (most less than 10 km) 10 4 to 10 5 objects (with 10 6 to 10 7 km average.
Collision Enhancement due to Planetesimal Binary Formation Planetesimal Binary Formation Junko Kominami Jun Makino (Earth-Life-Science Institute, Tokyo.
Theoretical difficulties with standard models Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge.
David Jewitt University of Hawaii Water Ice in Comets and Asteroids.
Dynamical constraints on the nature of the Late Heavy Bombardment and models of its origin A.Morbidelli Observatoire de la Cote d’Azur, Nice, France.
Title. Jedicke Nature Paper Nesvorny Icarus Paper.
Circumstellar Disks at 5-20 Myr: Observations of the Sco-Cen OB Association Marty Bitner.
Figure 4. Same as Fig. 3 but for x = 5.5.
Asteroids.
Takashi Ito (CfCA/NAOJ, Tokyo) Renu Malhotra (LPL/U.Arizona)
Crater models and possible scaling law
Daniel D. Durda, William F. Bottke, and Brian L. Enke
Remnants of Rock and Ice
Population Control of Martian Trojans by the Yarkovsky & YORP effects
Daniel D. Durda (Southwest Research Institute)
Stochastic Late Accretion on the Earth, Moon and Mars
Presentation transcript:

WHY DO WE WANT TO MODEL THE COLLISIONAL EVOLUTION OF MBPs? SOLAR SYSTEM FORMATION : what was the primordial distribution of the minor body population before the collisional evolution begins? Constraints on the planetesimal accretion process. COLLISIONAL PHYSICS: to understand the formation of families and family erosion. Statistical testing of scaling laws on many events. INTRA-POPULATION FLUXES: interrelation among different populations in the solar system (MBAs – NEOs, Trojans – SPC, TNOs – Centaurus….) LIFETIME OF BINARIES, LIMITS ON FAMILY YARKO-EXPANSION.

GUESS Initial population of Minor Bodies. GUESS Fragmentation models (Q * D, Q * S, .) Dynamics (V imp,, Yarkowsky, PR drag…) Observational constraints The MODEL MBAs, Trojans, Hildas, KBOs

Size and velocity distribution of escaping fragments, c f, s f D p ρ p, c p, s p D t ρ t, c t, s t V imp c = structure: porosity, rubble pile, monoliths.. s = spin rate Simple analytic equations FRAGMENTATION MODEL -1 THE DREAM Benz-Aspahug, 1999: Q * D (D), f l (Q * D, E). N f (D f, Q * D, E) ??

FRAGMENTATION MODEL -2: THE SINERGY Impact experiments Scaling laws Hydrocodes Asteroid families Size distribution of minor bodies Craters on planets and asteroids Binary asteroids Meteorites

DYNAMICAL EFFECTS: 2) Resonances cause outflow from the belt 3) Dissipative forces (Yarkowsky, PR drag) ( O’Brien & Greenberg, 2001 ): the small body tail problem. Penco, Dell’Oro, La Spina, Paolicchi, Cellino, Campo Bagatin., in press. 1) V i, (Farinella, Davis, Dahlgren, Bottke, Marzari, Dell’Oro, Paolicchi, Greenberg, Vedder, Gil-Hutton…….)

Initial population guess Time (yr) Planetesimal accretion ( about 1 Myr) Giant impacts – Mass depletion, stirring of orbital elements ( about Myr) Collisional evolution models (about 4.5 Gyr) MBAs Trojans Resonance sweeping, Endogenic dynamical excitation

THE ‘CLASSICAL’ NUMERICAL MODEL: 1) Bodies distributed in size-bins 2) v imp input from the dynamics of the population 3) Montecarlo method: computation of representative collisions and distribution of new generated fragments in the bins (the fragmentation model is used here). 4) Time evolution controlled by relative changes in each bin. 6) Tail control with interpolation (???) 5) Families are treated as sub-populations

PREDICTIONS OF THE MODEL THAT CAN BE COMPARED TO OBSERVATIONS (The Main Belt case) 1) Size distribution of Main Belt Asteroids 2) Number of families and their slope (Marzari and Davis, 1999) 3) Basaltic crust of Vesta (Davis et al. 1984) 4) Rotation rates (difficult to implement, physics not yet clear) 5) CRE ages of stony meteorites (O’Brien and Grenberg, 2001) 6) Fraction of rubble-piles among asteroids (Bagatin et al. 2001)

N(>D) = K D -b Gaspra Ida SDSS Durda SDSS PLS SIZE DISTRIBUTION

Bumps, waves…. what is the origin? 1)Transition regimes in scaling laws or dishomogeneity 3) Different populations  S = 2.7 g cm -3 por: 30%  C = 1.4 g cm -3 por: 40% (from Britt et al. 2002: Ast III) 2) Small size cutoff (non-gravitational forces) ?? Maybe. too gradual to produce waves.

D l (km)ModelObservedN. asteroids ? ? ? Number of families vs. completeness limit. Marzari et al Number of bodies Diameter 1) COLLISIONAL EROSION 2) NO DYNAMICAL EROSION

VESTA: basaltic crust almost intact. The body was not disrupted over the solar system age.

Different populations and families Yarkovsky effect, PR drag CPU time MODEL

FUTURE DIRECTIONS: Include all dynamical effects and handle the problem of the small body tail Derive strong constraints on the primordial populations of minor bodies, study the history of families Testing different fragmentation models and scaling laws while waiting for the dream to come true (The perfect fragmentation model)

–High shot repetition rate (1 shot / 25 min) –Velocity km/s (200 m/s step) –Projectiles mm –Target temperature control K –4 shadowgraphs up to 1 MHz –Shock accelerometers up to g. Resonant freq. 1.2 MHz 1) Guns: FRAGMENTATION MODEL -3: LABORATORY EXPERIMENTS 2) Explosives Review: Holsapple et al (Ast. III)