NAESB WHOLESALE ELECTRIC QUADRANT BUSINESS PRACTICES SUBCOMMITTEE ACTIVITIES UPDATE TO JOINT ELECTRIC SCHEDULING SUBCOMMITTEE JANUARY 5, 2012 BY ED SKIBA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Market Flow Threshold Field Test NERC ORS Meeting November 14 th and 15 th.
Advertisements

Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements NERC ORS Meeting Toronto, Ontario September 23-24, 2009 Jim.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2013.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
First to Curtail – Last to Curtail Examples December 1 – 2, 2010 (Revised based on Requests/Suggestions During Review) 1.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair May 17 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 23, 2012 DRAFT.
Parallel Flow Visualization/Mitigation Proposal
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair November 9 th, 2011.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update IDCWG October 12 th, 2011.
1 Credit for Redispatch Small Group Review of Unconstrained MFs NAESB BPS Meeting December 14-15, 2011.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair September 13 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 26, 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair April 4 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 2, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 1, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2012.
North American Energy Standards Board Upadate Presented by Bob Harshbarger.
FEBRUARY 27, 2013 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS Parallel Flow Visualization Overview 1.
1 Free Template from Some Industry Updates ISAS Meeting August 20 & 21,
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, August 26, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, January 19, :00 to 4:00 p.m. EST 4 th Quarter
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, September 15, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT 3 rd Quarter
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
NERC Congestion Management Congestion Management Option 3 Vendor Meeting Julie Pierce – NERC IDCWG Chair.
Business Practices Subcommittee
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, December 2, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 13th, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update May 4, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 18, 2014.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 19, :00 to 4:00 p.m. EDT 2 nd Quarter 2011.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Tuesday, April 21, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 24, 2015.
Flowgate Allocation Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Parallel Flow Visualization Project NERC ORS Meeting May 4, 2011.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update April 29, 2014.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting October 20, 2015.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update February 18, 2014.
WEQ Executive Committee Contract Path Task Force Additional Issues Related To Contract Path Management ( WEQ and WEQ )
Generator Prioritization Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update Yasser Bahbaz IDCWG Chair BPS Update September 13 th, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting April 29, 2014.
Joint BPS and ESS/ITS ATC/AFC Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008.
NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz– IDCWG Chair January 5 th, 2016.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 27, 2009.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting August 18, 2015.
Parking Lot Item 19. BPS Bert Bressers 10/31/2011 Firm rights of resources that have a Firm priority to what load (Sink area granularity)
WEQ Executive Committee Contract Path Task Force Additional Issues Related To Contract Path Management ( WEQ and WEQ )
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 16, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 23, 2016.
North America Energy Standards Board Craig L. Williams, Specialist Ld./Sr. MIC Meeting March 23, 2016 La Jolla, CA W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING.
NAESB BPS UPDATE TO EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AUGUST 21, 2012 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION PROJECT 1.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 18, 2015 Chair Rebecca Berdahl, BPA.
1 Parallel Flow Visualization Goals NAESB BPS Meeting September 15-16, 2010.
RELIABILITY COORDINATOR TOPICS 2006 FRCC SYSTEM OPERATOR SEMINAR.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Pseudo-tie business procedure
Standard Review Subcommittee Update
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting
North America Energy Standards Board
Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Overview
NERC Congestion Management
Pseudo-tie business procedure
Presentation transcript:

NAESB WHOLESALE ELECTRIC QUADRANT BUSINESS PRACTICES SUBCOMMITTEE ACTIVITIES UPDATE TO JOINT ELECTRIC SCHEDULING SUBCOMMITTEE JANUARY 5, 2012 BY ED SKIBA WEQ BPS CO-CHAIR PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION PROJECT

OVERVIEW PROPOSED SOLUTION REQUIREMENTS  COMMON REQUIREMENTS  IDC REQUIREMENTS  TAG ALL NON-FIRM REQUIREMENTS  GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION REQUIREMENTS OUTSTANDING ITEMS MILESTONES 2012 MEETING SCHEDULE

PROPOSED SOLUTION PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION APPROACH CONSISTS OF TWO COMPONENTS  TAG ALL NON-FIRM COMPONENT  GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION COMPONENT BALANCING AUTHORITY TO SELECT ONE COMPONENT BUT NOT BOTH TRANSACTIONS OR GENERATION TO LOAD (GTL) HAVING 5% OR GREATER IMPACT WILL BE CONSIDERED WHEN DETERMINING RELIEF OBLIGATIONS COMPONENTS HAVE COMMON REQUIREMENTS AND UNIQUE REQUIREMENTS

PROPOSED SOLUTION TAG ALL NON-FIRM COMPONENT  WITHIN A BALANCING AUTHORITY AREA ALL NON-FIRM TRANSACTIONS ARE REQUIRED TO BE TAGGED INCLUDING NATIVE AND NETWORK SERVICE. GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION COMPONENT  WITHIN A BALANCING AUTHORITY GENERATOR PRIORITIES WILL BE SUBMITTED TO THE IDC VIA THE SDX (IN EITHER MW OR PERCENTAGE) BUILDS ON IDC CHANGE ORDER 283 WHICH UPLOADS GENERATOR OUTPUTS BASED ON GENERATOR OUTPUTS AND DATA PROVIDED UNDER EITHER COMPONENT, THE IDC CAN DETERMINE FIRM GENERATION IN ORDER TO ASSIGN CURTAILMENT OBLIGATIONS UNDER TLR LEVELS 3 & 5 ASSUMPTIONS  INT STANDARDS WILL BE MODIFIED TO REQUIRE TAGGING ON ALL INTRA BALANCING AUTHORITY AREA POINT-TO-POINT TRANSACTIONS (DIRECTIVE UNDER FERC ORDER NO. 693)  IRO-006-EAST WILL BE MODIFIED TO ALLOW AN RELIABILITY COORDINATOR TO REQUEST CURTAILMENTS ON INTRA-BA POINT-TO-POINT TAGS.

COMMON REQUIREMENTS COORDINATION AGREEMENTS  AGREEMENT BETWEEN TWO OR MORE TRANSMISSION SERVICE PROVIDERS FOR COORDINATION OF GRANTING TRANSMISSION SERVICE BY HONORING THE FLOWGATE LIMITS OF EACH COUNTERPARTY AND MANAGING REAL-TIME CONGESTION THROUGH PROCEDURES, LIKE THE TLR PROCESS. UNILATERAL AGREEMENTS ALLOWED IF TRANSMISSION SERVICE PROVIDERS CANNOT AGREE JURISDICTIONAL ENTITIES REQUIRED TO FILE AGREEMENTS WITH FERC RECIPROCITY  EXTENDS COORDINATION OF GRANTING TRANSMISSION SERVICE BY HONORING THE FLOWGATE LIMITS AND MANAGING CONGESTION BETWEEN TRANSMISSION SERVICE PROVIDERS VIA INDIRECT AGREEMENTS SWITCHING BETWEEN COMPONENTS  SEVEN DAY NOTIFICATION  COINCIDE WITH MONTHLY IDC MODEL UPDATE

COMMON REQUIREMENTS (cont.) RELIEF OBLIGATION UNDER TLR LEVEL 5 FOR FIRM TWO-TIER FIRM CURTAILMENT  FIRST-TO-CURTAIL  THE FIRM CURTAILMENT PRIORITY ASSIGNED TO OFF-PATH TRANSACTIONS AND GTL DUE TO A LACK OF COORDINATION AGREEMENT, RECIPROCITY, OR UNILATERAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE TRANSMISSION SERVICE PROVIDER EXPERIENCING CONGESTION AND THE TRANSMISSION SERVICE PROVIDER WHOSE TRANSMISSION SERVICE IS CONTRIBUTING TO THE CONGESTION.  LAST-TO-CURTAIL  THE FIRM CURTAILMENT PRIORITY ASSIGNED TO TRANSACTIONS AND GTL THAT ARE NOT ASSIGNED FIRST-TO- CURTAIL PRIORITY.

COMMON REQUIREMENTS (cont.) ALTERNATIVES FOR MEETING RELIEF OBLIGATIONS  CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH FOR TAGS  CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH FOR GENERATOR PRIORITIES  ALTERNATIVE 1 (WITHOUT CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH) THE BA WILL CURTAIL GENERATION IN THOSE PRIORITY BUCKETS ASSIGNED PROPORTIONAL CURTAILMENTS BY THE IDC IN THIS ALTERNATIVE, THE NEXT HOUR TLR WILL RECOGNIZE CURTAILMENTS MADE IN THE PREVIOUS HOURS.

COMMON REQUIREMENTS (cont.)  CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH FOR GENERATOR PRIORITIES  ALTERNATIVE 2 (CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH) THE BA WILL MEET ITS RELIEF OBLIGATION USING GENERATORS IN PRIORITY BUCKETS NOT ASSIGNED PROPORTIONAL CURTAILMENTS BY THE IDC. THE NET GTL IMPACTS (NET OF FORWARD AND REVERSE IMPACTS) WILL BE COMPUTED BY THE BA PRIOR TO STARTING REDISPATCH (NOTE: THE IDC WILL ALSO CALCULATE THE FORWARD GTL IMPACTS TO ESTABLISH THE RELIEF OBLIGATION FOR THE BA AND THE NET GTL IMPACTS) A TARGET GTL FLOW WILL BE DETERMINED BY THE BA BY TAKING THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE NET GTL FLOW AND THE RELIEF OBLIGATION FROM THE BA. THE BA WILL REDISPATCH ITS SYSTEM TO MEET THE TARGET GTL FLOW. THIS CAN BE ACCOMPLISHED BY EITHER REDUCING FORWARD FLOWS OR INCREASING REVERSE FLOWS. THE IDC WILL DETERMINE IF THE RELIEF OBLIGATION HAS BEEN MET.

COMMON REQUIREMENTS (cont.) COORDINATION AGREEMENTS  MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS  WHEN PROVIDING TRANSMISSION SERVICE OR GTL – RESPECT CONSTRAINTS OF OTHER PARTIES WITH COORDINATING AGREEMENT  MUTUALLY AGREED CONGESTION MANAGEMENT PROVISIONS  HONOR RECIPROCITY PROVISIONS OF OTHER ENTITIES OF THE COORDINATING AGREEMENT BOTH INVOLVED PARTIES SHOULD AGREE FOR HONORING RECIPROCITY WITHOUT HAVING DIRECT COORDINATION AGREEMENT  UNILATERAL AGREEMENT ALLOWED IF PARTIES CAN NOT AGREE  AGREEMENTS TO BE FILED WITH FERC, IF JURISDICTIONAL

IDC REQUIREMENTS MAKE PROVISION FOR ENTERING INFORMATION RELATED TO EXISTENCE OF COORDINATION AGREEMENT DETERMINE IMPACTED TRANSACTIONS AND GTL WITH 5% OR GREATER IMPACT DETERMINE RELIEF OBLIGATION USING EXISTENCE OF COORDINATION AGREEMENTS IDC TO PROVIDE LATEST MATRIX OF COORDINATION AGREEMENTS TO CUSTOMERS IMPACT CALCULATION – USE TWO APPROACHES IN PLACE TODAY  GENERATION TO LOAD DISTRIBUTION FACTOR WITHIN A BALANCING AUTHORITY AREA (BAA)  NATIVE/TRANSFER FOR MARKETS/BAAS WITH MULTIPLE LOCAL BALANCING AUTHORITIES (LBAS)

TAG ALL NON-FIRM REQUIREMENTS TAG ALL NON-FIRM COMPONENT REQUIREMENTS TAG ALL NON-FIRM REQUIRES TAGGING INTRA-BA TRANSACTIONS PSE/LSE TO SUBMIT TAGS GENERATORS ELECTRICALLY RESIDENT IN BUT PHYSICALLY LOCATED OUTSIDE OF A BA THROUGH THE USE OF PSEUDO-TIE(S) WILL UTILIZE INTRA- BA TAGS FOR EACH NON-FIRM TRANSACTION ASCRIBABLE TO THOSE GENERATORS SOURCE GENERATION MAY BE ASSIGNED TO A GENERATOR (UNIT, PLANT OR SYSTEM FLEET) VIA MAPPING IN THE TSIN REGISTRY/WEBREGISTRY

GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION REQUIREMENTS GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION COMPONENT REQUIREMENTS  TSP TO IDENTIFY FIRM AND NON-FIRM USAGE OF GENERATORS  POST METHODOLOGY USED TO IDENTIFY USAGE (TRANSPARENCY)  MW OR PERCENT FIRM OR NON-FIRM GENERATION OUTPUT CAN BE ASSIGNED  PRIORITIZATION CAN BE ASSIGNED TO GENERATING UNITS OR PLANTS AS MODELLED IN IDC AND TSIN REGISTRY  PRIORITIZATION VALUES  UNIT-DEFAULT PRIORITY SCHEDULES FOR PERIODS 6 MONTHS OR GREATER  SHORT-TERM PRIORITY SCHEDULES - CAN CHANGE AS FREQUENTLY AS 15 MINUTES

OUTSTANDING ITEMS CREDIT FOR REDISPATCH  TAG ALL NON-FIRM  GENERATOR PRIORITIZATION DISPUTES ON EFFECTIVE/TERMINATION DATES FOR COORDINATION AGREEMENTS IMPACT ON NERC STANDARDS  INTERCHANGE SCHEDULING AND COORDINATION (INTRA BA POINT-TO-POINT)  INTERCONNECTION RELIABILITY OPERATIONS AND COORDINATION (IRO-006-EAST) IMPACT ON NAESB STANDARDS  TRANSMISSION LOADING RELIEF (TLR)  OASIS (POSTING REQUIREMENTS)  COORDINATE INTERCHANGE (INTRA BA TAGS/INTERCHANGE)  ELECTRONIC TAGGING FUNCTIONAL SPECIFICATION  PSEUDO TIES (LEVEL OF SERVICE ACROSS MULTIPLE BAS)

MILESTONES BPS IDENTIFY CATEGORIES OF SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERS REVIEWING TEST DATA IN DECEMBER BPS COMPLETE PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION WHITE PAPER IN JANUARY BPS FINALIZE STANDARDS AND POST FOR 30-DAY FORMAL COMMENT PERIOD SECOND QUARTER 2012 NAESB EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE TAKE ACTION ON STANDARDS IN THE SECOND/THIRD QUARTER OF 2012 STANDARDS SUBMITTED FOR 30 DAY MEMBERSHIP RATIFICATION BPS WILL ESTABLISH COMMERCIAL EVALUATION CRITERIA IN SECOND/THIRD QUARTER 2012

2012 MEETING SCHEDULE January – Houston, TX (hosted by NAESB) February – Redwood Shores, CA (hosted by OATI) March 6-7 – Little Rock, AR (hosted by Entergy) April 3-4 – Carmel, IN (hosted by MISO) May – Atlanta, GA (hosted by NERC, includes Joint Session with IDCWG) June – Valley Forge (hosted by PJM) July – Minneapolis, MN (hosted by OATI) August – Carmel, IN (hosted by MISO) Sept – Houston, TX (hosted by NAESB) October November December 11-12

Questions ?