Source sizes and energy partition from RHESSI imaging and spectroscopy Alexander Warmuth Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
RHESSI Investigations of the Neupert Effect in Solar Flares Brian R. Dennis AAS/SPD Meeting 6 June 2002.
Advertisements

Masuda Flare: Remaining Problems on the Looptop Impulsive Hard X-ray Source in Solar Flares Satoshi Masuda (STEL, Nagoya Univ.)
RHESSI observations of LDE flares – extremely long persisting HXR sources Mrozek, T., Kołomański, S., Bąk-Stęślicka, U. Astronomical Institute University.
Thick Target Coronal HXR Sources Astrid M. Veronig Institute of Physics/IGAM, University of Graz, Austria.
Energy Release and Particle Acceleration in Flares Siming Liu University of Glasgow 9 th RHESSI Workshop, Genova, Italy, Sep
R. P. Lin Physics Dept & Space Sciences Laboratory University of California, Berkeley The Solar System: A Laboratory for the Study of the Physics of Particle.
Solar flares and accelerated particles
M1.0 flare of 22 Oct 2002 RHESSI observations of the M 1.0 solar flare on 22 October 2002 A. Berlicki 1,2, B. Schmieder 1, N. Vilmer 1, G. Aulanier 1 1)
Low-Energy Coronal Sources Observed with RHESSI Linhui Sui (CUA / NASA GSFC)
Super-Hot Thermal Plasmas in Solar Flares
Relations between concurrent hard X-ray sources in solar flares M. Battaglia and A. O. Benz Presented by Jeongwoo Lee NJIT/CSTR Journal Club 2007 October.
Imaging with subcollimator 1. Dec 6, 2006 white light flare Hinode/SOT image during the main HXR peak! SOT resolution.
24 Oct 2001 A Cool, Dense Flare T. S. Bastian 1, G. Fleishman 1,2, D. E. Gary 3 1 National Radio Astronomy Observatory 2 Ioffe Institute for Physics and.
+ Hard X-Ray Footpoint Motion and Progressive Hardening in Solar Flares Margot Robinson Mentor: Dr. Angela DesJardins MSU Solar Physics Summer REU, 2010.
MSU Solar Physics REU Jennifer O’Hara Heating of Flare Loops With Observationally Constrained Heating Functions Advisors Jiong Qiu, Wenjuan Liu.
X-Ray Observation and Analysis of a M1.7 Class Flare Courtney Peck Advisors: Jiong Qiu and Wenjuan Liu.
Characterizing Thermal and Non- Thermal Electron Populations in Solar Flares Using RHESSI Amir Caspi 1,2, Säm Krucker 2, Robert P. Lin 1,2 1 Department.
Hard X-ray footpoint statistics: spectral indices, fluxes, and positions Pascal Saint-Hilaire 1, Marina Battaglia 2, Jana Kasparova 3, Astrid Veronig 4,
RHESSI/GOES Xray Analysis using Multitemeprature plus Power law Spectra. J.McTiernan (SSL/UCB)
Measuring the Temperature of Hot Solar Flare Plasma with RHESSI Amir Caspi 1,2, Sam Krucker 2, Robert P. Lin 1,2 1 Department of Physics, University of.
Statistical Properties of Hot Thermal Plasmas in M/X Flares Using RHESSI Fe & Fe/Ni Line * and Continuum Observations Amir Caspi †1,2, Sam Krucker 2, Robert.
Modeling the Neupert Effect in Flares: Connecting Theory and Observation Andrea Egan Advisors: Dr. Trae Winter and Dr. Kathy Reeves.
FLARE ENERGETICS:TRACE WHITE LIGHT AND RHESSI HARD X-RAYS* L. Fletcher (U. Glasgow), J. C. Allred (GSFC), I. G. Hannah (UCB), H. S. Hudson (UCB), T. R.
RHESSI/GOES Xray Analysis using Multitemeprature plus Power law Spectra. J.McTiernan (SSL/UCB) ABSTRACT: We present spectral fits for RHESSI and GOES solar.
RHESSI observations of LDE flares – extremely long persisting HXR sources Mrozek, T., Kołomański, S., Bąk-Stęślicka, U. Astronomical Institute University.
“Refinements to flare energy estimates…” Emslie et al., et Hugh too, JGR 110, 2005 Particles Flows Waves Corona B 2 /8  EM radiation Mechanical energy.
RHESSI OBSERVATIONS OF FLARE FOOTPOINTS AND RIBBONS H. Hudson and M. Fivian (SSL/UCB)
The hard X-ray spectral structure of flare ribbons H. Hudson, L. Fletcher, S. Krucker, J. Pollock.
Distinguishing Between Thermal and Non-Thermal Electron Populations in Solar Flares Using RHESSI Amir Caspi 1,2, Robert P. Lin 1,2 1 Department of Physics,
Inversions of Flaring Radio Emissions. Gregory D. Fleishman.
WG1: Techniques and Applications Wed AM: imaging comparison Wed PM1: source positions Wed PM2: source sizes Thu AM1: new algorithms Thu AM2: source fluxes.
GLOBAL ENERGETICS OF FLARES Gordon Emslie (for a large group of people)
Mon AM: opening plenary session Mon PM – Tue AM & Wed: working groups 1-6 Thu AM: concluding panel discussion Thu PM – Fri.
4 November 2003 Kaufmann et al Two questions raised by submm- observations presented by Kaufmann et al. 2004: By what mechanism(s) is the emission.
White-Light Flares via TRACE and RHESSI: Death to the thick target? H. Hudson, plus collaboration with J. Allred, I. Hannah, L. Fletcher, T. Metcalf, J.
RHESSI and global models of flares and CMEs: What is the status of the implosion conjecture? H.S. Hudson Space Sciences Lab, UC Berkeley.
WG 1 Summary Techniques and Applications. WG1 sessions New algorithms: UV smooth, electron maps Source locations Source sizes Source fluxes (imaging spectroscopy)
Sizes of Hard X-ray Footpoints Brian Dennis Rick Pernak (CUA) NASA GSFC.
Co-spatial White Light and Hard X-ray Flare Footpoints seen above the Solar Limb: RHESSI and HMI observations Säm Krucker Space Sciences Laboratory, UC.
Flare Thermal Energy Brian Dennis NASA GSFC Solar Physics Laboratory 12/6/20081Solar Cycle 24, Napa, 8-12 December 2008.
Thermal, Nonthermal, and Total Flare Energies Brian R. Dennis RHESSI Workshop Locarno, Switzerland 8 – 11 June, 2005.
Multiwavelength observations of a partially occulted solar flare Laura Bone, John C.Brown, Lyndsay Fletcher.
Compelling Theoretical Issues Driven by Observations / Theoretical Wish List of Observations WG5 Hamish Reid.
Locarno, 8 June 2005Peter Gallagher (UCD) Chromospheric Evaporation Peter Gallagher University College Dublin Ryan Milligan Queens University Belfast.
Evidence of Chromospheric Evaporation in a Neupert-type Flare NING Zongjun Purple Mountain Observatory, China.
Lyndsay Fletcher, University of Glasgow Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager Fast Particles in Solar Flares The view from RHESSI (and TRACE) MRT.
RHESSI and Radio Imaging Observations of Microflares M.R. Kundu, Dept. of Astronomy, University of Maryland, College Park, MD G. Trottet, Observatoire.
Simultaneous monitoring observations of solar active regions at millimeter wavelengths at radio telescopes RT-7.5 BMSTU (Russia) and RT-14 Metsahovi radio.
Measurement of the Reconnection Rate in Solar Flares H. Isobe 2004/12/6 Taiyo-Zasshikai.
Studies on the 2002 July 23 Flare with RHESSI Ayumi ASAI Solar Seminar, 2003 June 2.
Energetic electrons acceleration: combined radio and X-ray diagnostics
H α and hard X-ray observations of solar white-light flares M. D. Ding Department of Astronomy, Nanjing University.
A Local Reacceleration Thick Target Model (LRTTM) (a modification of the Collisional Thick Target Model CTTM -Brown 1971) Brown, Turkmani, Kontar, MacKinnon.
Joint session WG4/5 Points for discussion: - Soft-hard-soft spectral behaviour – again - Non-thermal pre-impulsive coronal sources - Very dense coronal.
Spectral Breaks in Flare HXR Spectra A Test of Thick-Target Nonuniform Ionization as an Explanation Yang Su NASA,CUA,PMO Gordon D. Holman.
Today’s Papers 1. Flare-Related Magnetic Anomaly with a Sign Reversal Jiong Qiu and Dale E. Gary, 2003, ApJ, 599, Impulsive and Gradual Nonthermal.
Probing Electron Acceleration with X-ray Lightcurves Siming Liu University of Glasgow 9 th RHESSI Workshop, Genova, Italy, Sep
Energy Budgets of Flare/CME Events John Raymond, J.-Y. Li, A. Ciaravella, G. Holman, J. Lin Jiong Qiu will discuss the Magnetic Field Fundamental, but.
Characterizing Thermal and Non- Thermal Electron Populations in Solar Flares Using RHESSI Amir Caspi 1,2, Säm Krucker 2, Robert P. Lin 1,2 1 Department.
Some EOVSA Science Issues Gregory Fleishman 26 April 2011.
Cycle 24 Meeting, Napa December 2008 Ryan Milligan NASA/GSFC Microflare Heating From RHESSI and Hinode Observations Ryan Milligan NASA-GSFC.
Coronal X-ray Emissions in Partly Occulted Flares Paula Balciunaite, Steven Christe, Sam Krucker & R.P. Lin Space Sciences Lab, UC Berkeley limb thermal.
Statistical Properties of Super-Hot Solar Flares Amir Caspi †1*, Säm Krucker 2,3, Robert P. Lin 2,4,5 †
Physics of Solar Flares
Two Years of NoRH and RHESSI Observations: What Have We Learned
RHESSI and H study of the X4 Flare of 3 Nov 2003
Gottfried Mann and Rositsa Miteva
Chromospheric and Transition Region Dynamics
Understanding solar flares from optical observations Heinzel, P
Nonthermal Electrons in an Ejecta Associated with a Solar Flare
Presentation transcript:

Source sizes and energy partition from RHESSI imaging and spectroscopy Alexander Warmuth Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam

Thermal vs. nonthermal energy content What is the energy partition (thermal vs. nonthermal) in solar flares? How do these quantities change with flare importance? Consequences of energy partition: is it consistent with the standard picture (heating by nonthermal electron beams driving evaporation)?

Parameters from HXR spectral fits: - emission measure - temperature Parameters from HXR imaging: - thermal source area  thermal volume (direct) - footpoint area - footpoint separation  thermal energy: Thermal component: thermal volume (indirect) Parameters from HXR spectral fits: - total injected electron flux above low-energy cutoff  nonthermal energy Nonthermal component:

18 flares (from C5.5 to X17.2) Time series of HXR spectral fits: - VTH + THICK - corrected for decimation, albedo & pile-up  physical parameters Time series of HXR images: - images at thermal energies: thermal areas - images at nonthermal energies: footpoint areas & sep.  geometric parameters Method

HXR spectroscopy: Spectral time series

Area measurements Imaging algorithms used: CLEAN uniform weighting CLEAN natural weighting MEM_NJIT VIS_FWD Area measurements: CLEAN: gaussian fit to sources, FWHM, quadratic subtraction of CLEAN beam MEM_NJIT: area inside 50% contour VIS_FWD: area directly obtained from fit Volumes: direct: V dir = 4  /3 A th 3/2 indirect: V ind = A FP * l

Time series of an M-class flare: FWHM, area & volume CLEAN uniformVIS_FWD CLEAN naturalMEM_NJIT

Thermal volumes – direct & indirect method (cotemporal)

Thermal and nonthermal total energies

Radiative losses: after Cox & Tucker (1969) Conductive losses: approximation by Veronig et al. (2005) Losses from the thermal plasma

Radiative & conductive losses vs. nontherm. energy

Losses Conductive losses on the order of 1E32 erg in large flares But: simple model may be not applicable However: from SORCE observations: total radiative energy in 2003 Oct 28 flare: 4E32 erg (Kopp et al. (2004), Woods et al. (2004), Emslie et al. (2005)) are high conductive losses real after all?

Conclusions using several imaging algorithms gives error estimation on source areas & volumes good correlation between thermal & nonthermal energies strong radiative and conductive losses consistent with total radiated energy conduction could heat dense lower atmosphere which radiates in UV & WL Consequence: either low cutoff energy of nonthermal electrons or additional heating mechanisms