Anthony W. Thomas Nuclei in the Laboratory and in the Cosmos 36 th Course - Erice : Sept 17 th 2014 Hyperons & the EoS of Dense Matter.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Eta production Resonances, meson couplings Humberto Garcilazo, IPN Mexico Dan-Olof Riska, Helsinki … exotic hadronic matter?
Advertisements

Questions and Probems. Matter inside protoneutron stars Hydrostatic equilibrium in the protoneutron star: Rough estimate of the central pressure is: Note.
HL-3 May 2006Kernfysica: quarks, nucleonen en kernen1 Outline lecture (HL-3) Structure of nuclei NN potential exchange force Terra incognita in nuclear.
Delta-hole effects on the shell evolution of neutron-rich exotic nuclei Takaharu Otsuka University of Tokyo / RIKEN / MSU Chiral07 Osaka November 12 -
Possible existence of neutral hyper-nucleus with strangeness -2 and its production SPN 2014, Changsha, Dec , 2014 Institute of High Energy Physics.
Hyperon Suppression in Hadron- Quark Mixed Phase T. Maruyama (JAEA), S. Chiba (JAEA), H.-J. Schhulze (INFN-Catania), T. Tatsumi (Kyoto U.) 1 Property of.
Hyperon-Quark Mixed Phase in Compact Stars T. Maruyama* (JAEA), T. Tatsumi (Kyoto U), H.-J. Schulze (INFN), S. Chiba (JAEA)‏ *supported by Tsukuba Univ.
Nuclear Physics from the sky Vikram Soni CTP. Strongly Interacting density (> than saturation density) Extra Terrestrial From the Sky No.
12 June, 2006Istanbul, part I1 Mean Field Methods for Nuclear Structure Part 1: Ground State Properties: Hartree-Fock and Hartree-Fock- Bogoliubov Approaches.
1 Nuclear Binding and QCD ( with G. Chanfray) Magda Ericson, IPNL, Lyon SCADRON70 Lisbon February 2008.
Equation of State of Neutron-Rich Matter in the Relativistic Mean-Field Approach Farrukh J. Fattoyev My TAMUC collaborators: B.-A. Li, W. G. Newton My.
The structure of neutron star by using the quark-meson coupling model Heavy Ion Meeting ( ) C. Y. Ryu Soongsil University, Korea.
Relativistic chiral mean field model for nuclear physics (II) Hiroshi Toki Research Center for Nuclear Physics Osaka University.
Isospin effect in asymmetric nuclear matter (with QHD II model) Kie sang JEONG.
横田 朗A 、 肥山 詠美子B 、 岡 眞A 東工大理工A、理研仁科セB
In-medium hadrons and chiral symmetry G. Chanfray, IPN Lyon, IN2P3/CNRS, Université Lyon I The Physics of High Baryon Density IPHC Strasbourg, september.
L. R. Dai (Department of Physics, Liaoning Normal University) Z.Y. Zhang, Y.W. Yu (Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing, China) Nucleon-nucleon interaction.
Effects of self-consistence violations in HF based RPA calculations for giant resonances Shalom Shlomo Texas A&M University.
LBL 5/21/2007J.W. Holt1 Medium-modified NN interactions Jeremy W. Holt* Nuclear Theory Group State University of New York * with G.E. Brown, J.D. Holt,
Exotic Nuclei in Relativistic and Non-Relativistic Models Exotic Nuclei large isospin asymmetry - nuclei close to the drip lines - superheavy nuclei non-relativistic.
0 Yoko Ogawa (RCNP/Osaka) Hiroshi Toki (RCNP/Osaka) Setsuo Tamenaga (RCNP/Osaka) Hong Shen (Nankai/China) Atsushi Hosaka (RCNP/Osaka) Satoru Sugimoto (RIKEN)
Hypernucleus In A Two Frequency Model Yiharn Tzeng, S.Y.Tsay Tzeng, T.T.S.Kuo.
Hadron to Quark Phase Transition in the Global Color Symmetry Model of QCD Yu-xin Liu Department of Physics, Peking University Collaborators: Guo H., Gao.
Study of the QCD Phase Structure through High Energy Heavy Ion Collisions Bedanga Mohanty National Institute of Science Education and Research (NISER)
Scalar response of the nucleon, Chiral symmetry and nuclear matter properties G. Chanfray, IPN Lyon, IN2P3/CNRS, Université Lyon 1 M. Ericson, IPN Lyon,
Probing the isospin dependence of nucleon effective mass with heavy-ion reactions Momentum dependence of mean field/ –Origins and expectations for the.
F. Sammarruca, University of Idaho Supported in part by the US Department of Energy. From Neutron Skins to Neutron Stars to Nuclear.
Study of light kaonic nuclei with a Chiral SU(3)-based KN potential A. Dote (KEK) W. Weise (TU Munich)  Introduction  ppK - studied with a simple model.
Limits of applicability of the currently available EoS at high density matter in neutron stars and core-collapse supernovae: Discussion comments Workshop.
Trento, Giessen-BUU: recent progress T. Gaitanos (JLU-Giessen) Model outline Relativistic transport (GiBUU) (briefly) The transport Eq. in relativistic.
Relativistic Description of the Ground State of Atomic Nuclei Including Deformation and Superfluidity Jean-Paul EBRAN 24/11/2010 CEA/DAM/DIF.
Chiral phase transition and chemical freeze out Chiral phase transition and chemical freeze out.
Hyperon mixing in neutron star matter and universal many-body repulsion 2014/12/1 JPARC Y. Yamamoto Collaborators: T. Furumoto N. Yasutake Th.A. Rijken.
Role of vacuum in relativistic nuclear model A. Haga 1, H. Toki 2, S. Tamenaga 2 and Y. Horikawa 3 1. Nagoya Institute of Technology, Japan 2. RCNP Osaka.
Interplay of antikaons with hyperons in nuclei and in neutron stars Interplay of antikaons with hyperons in nuclei and in neutron stars 13th International.
Many-body theory of Nuclear Matter and the Hyperon matter puzzle M. Baldo, INFN Catania.
Extended Brueckner-Hartree-Fock theory in many body system - Importance of pion in nuclei - Hiroshi Toki (RCNP, KEK) In collaboration.
R. Machleidt, University of Idaho Recent advances in the theory of nuclear forces and its relevance for the microscopic approach to dense matter.
Three-body force effect on the properties of asymmetric nuclear matter Wei Zuo Institute of Modern Physics, Lanzhou, China.
Furong Xu (许甫荣) Many-body calculations with realistic and phenomenological nuclear forces Outline I. Nuclear forces II. N 3 LO (LQCD): MBPT, BHF, GSM (resonance.
Time Dependent Quark Masses and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Myung-Ki Cheoun, G. Mathews, T. Kajino, M. Kusagabe Soongsil University, Korea Asian Pacific Few.
1 Longitudinal and transverse helicity amplitudes of nucleon resonances in a constituent quark model - bare vs dressed resonance couplings Introduction.
Operated by Jefferson Science Association for the U.S. Department of Energy Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility Page 1 Check directly vs data.
F. C HAPPERT N. P ILLET, M. G IROD AND J.-F. B ERGER CEA, DAM, DIF THE D2 GOGNY INTERACTION F. C HAPPERT ET AL., P HYS. R EV. C 91, (2015)
And Mesons in Strange Hadronic Medium at Finite Temperature and Density Rahul Chhabra (Ph.D student) Department Of Physics NIT Jalandhar India In cooperation.
PKU-CUSTIPEN 2015 Dirac Brueckner Hartree Fock and beyond Herbert Müther Institute of Theoretical Physics.
Helmholtz International Summer School, Dubna, 24 July 2008 Pion decay constant in Dense Skyrmion Matter Hee-Jung Lee ( Chungbuk Nat’l Univ.) Collaborators.
Furong Xu (许甫荣) Nuclear forces and applications to nuclear structure calculations Outline I. Nuclear forces II. N 3 LO (LQCD): MBPT, BHF, GSM (resonance.
Recent Research on the Thomas Fermi Quark Model Work with Andy Liu and Nate Larson!
Clustered Quark Model Calculation of Strange Quark Matter Xuesen Na Department of Astronomy, School of Physics, PKU CSQCD II.
Proton Mass and EoS for Compressed Baryonic Matter ATHIC 14/11/12 Mannque Rho (Saclay and Hanyang)
1 11/20/13 21/11/2015 Jinniu Hu School of Physics, Nankai University Workshop on “Chiral forces and ab initio calculations” Nov. 20- Nov. 22,
Nuclear Matter Density Dependence of Nucleon Radius and Mass and Quark Condensates in the GCM of QCD Yu-xin Liu Department of Physics, Peking University.
Furong Xu (许甫荣) Many-body correlations in ab-initio methods Outline I. Nuclear forces, Renormalizations (induced correlations) II. N 3 LO (LQCD) MBPT,
Department of Physics, Sungkyunkwan University C. Y. Ryu, C. H. Hyun, and S. W. Hong Application of the Quark-meson coupling model to dense nuclear matter.
A closer look to the H dibaryon Teresa Fernández Caramés (U. Salamanca) poster2.jpg [T.F.C and A. Valcarce, Physical Review C 85, (2012)]
Su Houng Lee 1. Few words on a recent sum rule result 2. A simple constituent quark model for D meson 3. Consequences 4. Summary D meson in nuclear medium:
Relativistic EOS for Supernova Simulations
Structure and dynamics from the time-dependent Hartree-Fock model
mesons as probes to explore the chiral symmetry in nuclear matter
EOS discussion.
Role of Pions in Nuclei and Experimental Characteristics
Relativistic extended chiral mean field model for finite nuclei
Check directly vs data That is, apply new effective force directly to calculate nuclear properties using Hartree-Fock (as for usual well known force)
Kernfysica: quarks, nucleonen en kernen
Pions in nuclei and tensor force
Parametrisation of Binding Energies
Hyun Kyu Lee Hanyang University
Current understanding of the nuclear force
Effects of the φ-meson on the hyperon production in the hyperon star
Presentation transcript:

Anthony W. Thomas Nuclei in the Laboratory and in the Cosmos 36 th Course - Erice : Sept 17 th 2014 Hyperons & the EoS of Dense Matter

Page 2 The Issues There are dozens of equations of state (EoS) − Global approach: try them all − Filter : select by general properties What properties? n-p matter: ρ 0, E/A, symmetry energy, compressibility etc. What else? − Relativistic − Hyperons included − Satisfactory description of hypernuclear systems

Page 3 Relativity In n-star core densities > 2-3 ρ 0 : must have a relativistic EoS − p F n ~ m * n − e.g. velocity of sound:

Page 4 Hyperons Baryons in medium are not complicated E H (p) – E N (p) ~ constant (not Σ-N ) − Λ – N ~ 170 MeV − Ξ – N ~ 380 MeV but μ e/muon ~ 230 – 250 MeV max. which means Ξ - competes with Λ Clearly, as p F n increases Λ or Ξ - must enter − typically around 3 ρ 0 Effect is obviously to soften EoS

Page 5 Summary: We need a relativistic EoS including hyperons

Page 6 Where to get the interactions? Familiar approach: − Fit NN interaction to NN data – typically parameters to fit 1000’s of data points − BUT to fit nuclear data also need 3-body force: typically 4 parameters fit to energy levels light nuclei ΛN : very limited data plus systematic Λ-hypernuclei − cannot determine parameters of a “realistic” potential and certainly no 3-body force!

Page 7 Interactions (cont.) Σ N : no elastic data. Few dozen data on ΛN −> ΣN − Contrary to first results in early 80’s there are no Σ – hypernuclei (one exceptional, very light case) − Phenomenologically : Σ – nucleus interaction is somewhat repulsive Ξ N : No elastic data. Nothing known about Ξ – hypernuclei BUT at J-PARC experimental study just beginning H H : Nothing known empirically

Page 8 Suggests a different approach Start with quark model (MIT bag/NJL) of all baryons Introduce a relativistic Lagrangian with σ, ω and ρ mesons coupling to non-strange quarks − no coupling to strange quarks (Zweig rule) Hence only 3 parameters − determine by fitting to saturation properties of nuclear matter (ρ 0, E/A and symmetry energy) Must solve self-consistently for the internal structure of baryons in-medium

Page 9 ∞ nuclear matter QCD & hadron structure  , , D, J/  …… in nuclear matter quark matter n star Density dependent effective NN (and N , N  …) forces Structure of finite nuclei & hypernuclei

Page 10 Quark-Meson Coupling Model (QMC): Role of the Scalar Polarizability of the Nucleon The response of the nucleon internal structure to the scalar field is of great interest… and importance Non-linear dependence through the scalar polarizability d ~ 0.22 R in original QMC (MIT bag) Indeed, in nuclear matter at mean-field level (e.g. QMC), this is the ONLY place the response of the internal structure of the nucleon enters.

Page 11 Summary : Scalar Polarizability Can always rewrite non-linear coupling as linear coupling plus non-linear scalar self-coupling – likely physical origin of some non-linear versions of QHD Consequence of polarizability in atomic physics is many-body forces: − same is true in nuclear physics V = V 12 + V 23 + V 13 + V 123

Page 12 Summary so far..... QMC looks superficially like QHD but it’s fundamentally different from all other approaches Self-consistent adjustment of hadron structure opposes applied scalar field (“scalar polarizability”) Naturally leads to saturation of nuclear matter − effectively because of natural 3- and 4-body forces Only 3- 4 parameters: σ, ω and ρ couplings to light quarks (4 th because m σ ambiguous under quantisation) Fit to nuclear matter properties and then predict the interaction of any hadrons in-medium

Page 13 Observation stunned and electrified the HEP and Nuclear communities 20 years ago Nearly 1,000 papers have been generated….. What is it that alters the quark momentum in the nucleus? Classic I llustration: The EMC effect J. Ashman et al., Z. Phys. C57, 211 (1993) J. Gomez et al., Phys. Rev. D49, 4348 (1994) The EMC Effect: Nuclear PDFs

Page 14 Calculations for Finite Nuclei Cloët, Bentz &Thomas, Phys. Lett. B642 (2006) 210 (nucl-th/ ) (Spin dependent EMC effect TWICE as large as unpolarized)

Page 15 Linking QMC to Familiar Nuclear Theory Since early 70’s tremendous amount of work in nuclear theory is based upon effective forces Used for everything from nuclear astrophysics to collective excitations of nuclei Skyrme Force: Vautherin and Brink In Paper I: Guichon and Thomas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, (2004) explicitly obtained effective force, 2- plus 3- body, of Skyrme type - density-dependent forces now used more widely

Page 16 Where analytic form of (e.g. H 0 + H 3 ) piece of energy functional derived from QMC is: highlights scalar polarizability ~ 4% ~ 1% Paper II: N P A772 (2006) 1 (nucl-th/ )

Page 17 Very recently: global search on Skyrme forces These authors tested 233 widely used Skyrme forces against 12 standard nuclear properties: only 17 survived including two QMC potentials Truly remarkable – force derived from quark level does a better job of fitting nuclear structure constraints than phenomenological fits with many times # parameters! Phys. Rev. C85 (2012)

Page 18 Constraints from Heavy Ion Reactions − from Dutra et al. (2010) [24] Danielewicz, Nucl Phys A727 (2003) 233

Page 19 Symmetry Energy in β-Equilibrium (n,p,e,μ only) Rikovska-Stone et al., NP A792 (2007) 341

Page 20 Hyperons Derive  N,  N,   … effective forces in-medium with no additional free parameters Attractive and repulsive forces (σ and ω mean fields) both decrease as # light quarks decreases NO Σ hypernuclei are bound! Λ bound by about 30 MeV in nuclear matter (~Pb) Nothing known about Ξ hypernuclei – JPARC!

Page 21 Λ- and Ξ-Hypernuclei in QMC Predicts Ξ – hypernuclei bound by MeV − to be tested soon at J-PARC

Page 22 Σ – hypernuclei  -hypernuclei unbound : because of increase of hyperfine interaction with density – e.g. for Σ 0 in 40 Ca: central potential +30 MeV and few MeV attraction in surface (-10MeV at 4fm) Guichon et al., Nucl. Phys. A814 (2008) 66

Consequences for Neutron Star Rikovska-Stone et al., NP A792 (2007) 341

Page 24 Report a very accurate pulsar mass much larger than seen before : 1.97 ± 0.04 solar mass Claim it rules out hyperons (particles with strange quarks - ignored published work!) J

Page 25 Most Recent Development (Whittenbury, Carroll, Stone & Tsushima) Include in Fock terms the effect of the Pauli coupling (i.e. F 2 σ μλ q λ term) in ρ and ω exchanges between all baryons This introduces more parameters − because of short-distance suppression of relative wave function and possible form factors In line with recent work of Stone, Stone and Moszkowski, require compressibility at ρ 0 in the range MeV see : Whittenbury et al., arXiv: (PRC 89 (2014) ) (related work: Miyatsu et al., Phys.Lett. B709 (2012) 242 and Long et al., Phys. Rev. C85 (2012) )

Page 26

Page 27 Pure Neutron Matter (PNM) c.f. EFT Whittenbury et al., PRC 89 (2014) Details EFT Tews et al., PRL 110 (2103)

Page 28 Heavy Ion Constraints Danielewicz et al., Nucl Phys A727 (2003) 233 and Dutra et al (2010)

Page 29 Equation of State

Page 30 Particle content Standard Hypernuclei corrected Whittenbury et al., PRC 89 (2014)

Page 31 Mass vs Radius Whittenbury et al., PRC 89 (2014)

Page 32 Summary Relativity is essential Intermediate attraction in NN force is STRONG scalar This modifies the intrinsic structure of the bound nucleon − profound change in shell model : what occupies shell model states are NOT free nucleons Scalar polarizability is a natural source of three-body force/ density dependence of effective forces − clear physical interpretation Derived, density-dependent effective force gives results better than most phenomenological Skyrme forces

Page 33 Summary Same model also yields realistic, density dependent  N,  N,  N forces (not yet published) − with NO additional parameters Availability of realistic, density dependent H N and H H forces is essential for  > 3  0 Already important results for n stars : mass as large as 2.1 solar masses possible with hyperons Inclusion of Pauli terms in Fock calculation presents new challenges: Λ hypernuclei no longer bound Can modify couplings to bind Λ hypernuclei and still get massive n-stars – but many open questions - not least, transition to quark matter?

Page 34 Special Mentions…… Guichon Whittenbury Stone Tsushima Bentz Cloët

Page 35 Key papers on QMC Two major, recent papers: 1. Guichon, Matevosyan, Sandulescu, Thomas, Nucl. Phys. A772 (2006) Guichon and Thomas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) Built on earlier work on QMC: e.g. 3. Guichon, Phys. Lett. B200 (1988) Guichon, Saito, Rodionov, Thomas, Nucl. Phys. A601 (1996) 349 Major review of applications of QMC to many nuclear systems: 5. Saito, Tsushima, Thomas, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 58 (2007) (hep-ph/ )

Page 36 References to: Covariant Version of QMC Basic Model: (Covariant, chiral, confining version of NJL) Bentz & Thomas, Nucl. Phys. A696 (2001) 138 Bentz, Horikawa, Ishii, Thomas, Nucl. Phys. A720 (2003) 95 Applications to DIS: Cloet, Bentz, Thomas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95 (2005) Cloet, Bentz, Thomas, Phys. Lett. B642 (2006) 210 Applications to neutron stars – including SQM: Lawley, Bentz, Thomas, Phys. Lett. B632 (2006) 495 Lawley, Bentz, Thomas, J. Phys. G32 (2006) 667

Page 37

Page 38 ORIGIN …. in QMC Model Source of  changes: and hence mean scalar field changes… and hence quark wave function changes…. SELF-CONSISTENCY THIS PROVIDES A NATURAL SATURATION MECHANISM (VERY EFFICIENT BECAUSE QUARKS ARE ALMOST MASSLESS) source is suppressed as mean scalar field increases (i.e. as density increases)

Page 39 Can we Measure Scalar Polarizability in Lattice QCD ? 18 th Nishinomiya Symposium: nucl-th/ − published in Prog. Theor. Phys. IF we can, then in a real sense we would be linking nuclear structure to QCD itself, because scalar polarizability is sufficient in simplest, relativistic mean field theory to produce saturation Initial ideas on this published : the trick is to apply a chiral invariant scalar field − do indeed find polarizability opposing applied σ field

Page 40 Nuclear Densities from QMC-Skyrme Calculation of Furong Xu (2010)

Page 41 Spin-Orbit Splitting Neutrons (Expt) Neutrons (QMC) Protons (Expt) Protons (QMC) 16 O 1p 1/2 -1p 3/ Ca 1d 3/2 -1d 5/ Ca 1d 3/2 -1d 5/ (Sly4) (Sly4) Pb 2d 3/2 -2d 5/ (Sly4) (Sly4) 1.74 Agreement generally very satisfactory – NO parameter adjusted to fit

Page 42 Shell Structure Away from Stability Use Hartree – Fock – Bogoliubov calculation Calculated variation of two-neutron removal energy at N = 28 as Z varies from Z = 32 (proton drip-line region) to Z = 18 (neutron drip-line region) S 2n changes by 8 MeV at Z=32 S 2n changes by 2–3 MeV at Z = 18 This strong shell quenching is very similar to Skyrme – HFB calculations of Chabanat et al., Nucl. Phys. A635 (1998) 231 2n drip lines appear at about N = 60 for Ni and N = 82 for Zr (/// to predictions for Sly4 – c.f. Chabanat et al.)

Page 43 Comparison with other EoS for PNM

Page 44