Determinants of Nursing Home Regulatory Activity in the 50 States: An Analysis from the Political Economy Perspective Christopher M. Kelly, Phoebe S. Liebig,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Public Opinion and Political Socialization: Shaping the People’s Voice

Advertisements

A workshop introducing doubly robust estimation of treatment effects

Linear Equations Review. Find the slope and y intercept: y + x = -1.

Statistical Analysis Overview I Session 2 Peg Burchinal Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill.

Quantitative Methods.

Overview of Health Care Coverage and Cost Trends in Minnesota Presentation to the State Budget Trends Study Commission April 22, 2008 Julie Sonier Director,

1 Regulation of Nursing Homes and Assisted Living Facilities Legislative Audit Bureau February 2003.

APHA-2006: Session Choice of denominator to measure disparities in motor vehicle crash deaths of teens and young adults Christopher J. Mansfield,

10-3 Inferences.

Dr. Spencer M. Cowan The Center for Urban and Regional Studies The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill prepared for NARUC Webcast September 15,

Overview of Health Human Resource Planning: A Canadian Perspective 2006 Trilateral Conference Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Dr. Nick Busing President.

Studying hospital quality using mixed methods Elizabeth H. Bradley, PhD Yale University School of Medicine.

PPA 501 – Analytical Methods in Administration Lecture 8 – Linear Regression and Correlation.

Health Disparities and Indian Health: Will the New Health Reform Bill Make a Difference Ralph Forquera, MPH Juaneño Band of California Mission Indians.

Western States Energy & Environment Symposium October 27, 2009.

The Adoption of Constitutional Home Rule: A test of endogenous policy decentralization Jessica Hennessey PhD Candidate University of Maryland.

Knowledge for Equity Conference November 13, 2012 U.S. Department of Education Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services National Institute.

DUAL SENSORY IMPAIRMENT AND CHANGE IN ADL ABILITY AMONG ELDERLY OVER TIME: A SEM LATENT GROWTH CURVE APPROACH Ya-ping Su, PhD, The Peer Review Organization.

Swedish Research Council Formas The Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning Kristina LaurellKTH, March 24.

Work based assessment Challenges and opportunities.

+ Preconception Health and Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Birth Weight: A National Study Kelly L. Strutz, MPH Liana J. Richardson, PhD, MPH Jon M. Hussey,

Hawes - Texas A&M University System Health Science Center 1 Assuring Nursing Home Quality: Divining Effective Models of Regulation Catherine Hawes, Ph.D.

Expanded Capacity of African American Family Caregivers: Project C.A.R.E. in North Carolina Ishan C. Williams, Ph.D. 1,3 & Christopher M. Kelly, Ph.D.

MFMA ASSET MANAGEMENT WORKSHOP ZANELE MNCWANGO National Treasury 24 November 2010 Infrastructure Maintenance.

Balancing Incentive Program and Community First Choice Eric Saber Health Policy Analyst Maryland Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.

1 An Autoregressive latent Trajectory Model of Resident Outcome Improvement in Nursing Homes Thomas T.H. Wan, Ph.D., M.H.S. Professor and Director Public.

Levels and Predictors of LHDs' Engagement in Community Health Assessment, Gulzar Shah, PhD, MS Associate Dean for Research Associate Professor,

. Intellectual and Developmental Disability Psychology: A Unique Approach to Graduate Training Often the psychology of intellectual and developmental disabilities.

Director of CCAWI Centre for Clinical and Academic Workforce Innovation, University of Lincoln, UK Culture and capacity in nursing research England/UK.

Health Insurance Coverage Among US Worker Groups: The National Health Interview Survey ABSTRACT Arheart KL, McCollister KE, Lee DJ, Chung-Bridges K, Fleming.

Mental Healthcare Utilization as Adolescents Become Young Adults Jennifer W. Yu, Sc.D. Sally H. Adams, Ph.D. Claire Brindis, Dr.P.H. Charles E. Irwin,

Acknowledgments We thank members of Nutrition and Chronic Disease of the GBD Study expert panel (D. Mozzaffarin, M. Ezzati, R. Micha, G. Danaie), and the.

Top Management Stability’s Impact on Turnover and Deficiencies Christopher E. Johnson, Ph.D. Associate Professor Director, MHA Program Department of Health.

Introducing NC NOVA: New Organizational Vision Award A Voluntary Special Licensing Award for Home Care Agencies, Adult Care Homes & Nursing Facilities.

Corporate Governance Norms for SME Dr. Indrajit Dube Dean, RG School of IP Law Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur.

Thomas C. Ricketts, Ph.D The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill HSRs of the Future.

The UNC Board of Governors and UNC-Chapel Hill Board of Trustees AMST94, November 21, 2005 Nelson Schwab.

Regression. Population Covariance and Correlation.

HEALTH CARE AND HUMAN SERVICES POLICY, RESEARCH, AND CONSULTING - WITH REAL-WORLD PERSPECTIVE. Administration on Aging’s Community Living Program: Experiences.

Simple Linear Regression. The term linear regression implies that  Y|x is linearly related to x by the population regression equation  Y|x =  +  x.

Workshop on Demographic Analysis and Evaluation. Fertility: Indirect Estimation Based on Age Structure. Rele’s Method.

CORRELATION: Correlation analysis Correlation analysis is used to measure the strength of association (linear relationship) between two quantitative variables.

Predictors of Asthma in Young Children Does Reporting Source Affect Our Conclusions? Jane E. Miller Jane E. Miller, Ph.D. Institute for Health, Health.

Budget Workshop: Fiscal Policies, Process, and Budget Guidelines Board of Governors April 21, 2005.

Screening the US Workforce for Skin Cancer: The National Health Interview Survey 1997 to 2003 Caban-Martinez AJ 1, Lee DJ 1,3, Fleming LE 1, LeBlanc WG.

Polling Public Opinion v. political culture Unbiased Random Sample Stratified Sample Sampling Error/Margin of Error.

Forecasting School Districts’ Revenues and Expenditures Nick Warner November 5, 2015.

Factors Influencing Nursing Home Response to Quality Measure Publication Jacqueline Zinn, Ph.D. Temple University Dana Mukamel, Ph.D. University of California,

THE URBAN INSTITUTE Impacts of Managed Care on SSI Medicaid Beneficiaries: Preliminary Results From A National Study Terri Coughlin Sharon K. Long The.

Defining and Achieving Quality Michigan’s Long-Term Care Conference Troy Hilton March 23, 2006 Alison Hirschel, Esq., Michigan Poverty Law Program Pam.

Introduction to political parties and ideology Civics/geography.

COMPARING HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED CARE MODELS FOR MEDICARE/MEDICAID DUAL ELIGIBLE INDIVIDUALS JANET H. VAN CLEAVE JANETVC ) BRIAN EGLESTON, SARAH.

Presenter: Susan L. Williams, Ph.D., LPC, ACS, NCC State University of New York – Plattsburgh Counselor Education Department AASCB Annual Conference Charleston,

Improving Nursing Home Compare for Consumers Five-Star Quality Rating System.

Democracy and Public Opinion  Core beliefs are shared  Political attitudes differ  What is public opinion?  Public opinion is critical to democracy.

Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.

Structure of Local Governments. Types of Local Government 1. The County 2. The Township 3. The Municipality 4. The Special District.

Introduction Many problems in Engineering, Management, Health Sciences and other Sciences involve exploring the relationships between two or more variables.

Chapter 10 Inference on Two Samples 10.3 Inference About Two Population Proportions.

Institute of Behavioral Science University of Colorado Boulder

EUI The European University Institute.

Evidencing the Contributions of Nurses and Healthcare Teams

Sisters of the Precious Blood Dayton, OH

2007 APHA Presentation Anthony Goudie, MSPH

The National Academies University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill

Algebra 1 Section 6.4.

Siân Curtis, PhD OVC Evaluation Dissemination Meeting,

Robert A. Berenson, M.D. Institute Fellow, Urban Institute

Longitudinal Data & Mixed Effects Models

I can determine the different sampling techniques used in real life.

Presentation transcript:

Determinants of Nursing Home Regulatory Activity in the 50 States: An Analysis from the Political Economy Perspective Christopher M. Kelly, Phoebe S. Liebig, and Lloyd J. Edwards SAMSI Transition Workshop November 10, 2005

Acknowledgments Dr. Kelly was supported in part by a postdoctoral fellowship 1 in the Carolina Program in Health and Aging Research (CPHAR) at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 1 Grant ST32AG00272 from the National Institute on Aging

Nursing Home Regulation in the United States Under OBRA 87, states survey nursing homes, CMS oversees State surveyors rate nursing home deficiencies according to scope and severity Information is available to consumers on CMS’s Nursing Home Compare website

Research Questions What is the extent of nursing home regulatory activity in the 50 states? How did extent change over a three- year period? What factors predict citation volume & severity in the 50 states?

Political Economy Perspective State Citizen/Public Sex/Gender Capital Ideology Race Age Class Estes (2001)

Linear Mixed Model Used to identify predictors of the volume and severity of state citations Provides estimation and hypothesis testing for modeling population and random effects Can accommodate data missing completely at random

Linear Mixed Model is Useful for Studying State Regulatory Activity Longitudinal data (i.e. nursing home quality over several years) Population data - 50 U.S. states. Large sample techniques are challenged. Parsimonious model needed (N =50) Random intercept and slope. Within-subject errors assumed i.i.d.

Nursing Home Deficiencies Stable, but Less Severe Number of deficiencies has remained level (about 6 per nursing home) Percentage of severe deficiencies has declined (about 7% of all deficiencies cause actual harm) States vary widely in volume & severity of deficiency citations

Possible Predictors of the Extent of State Regulatory Activity External Determinants Urbanization Education Age Political Culture Internal Determinants Nursing Home State Surveying Agency Legislature Interest Groups Governor

Linear Mixed Model Predicting State Citation Volume Variableβ Intercept10.3 Time.180 Education-.260 **** Urbanization-.063 ** Total Nursing Home Staffing1.29 ** Total Agency Funding.006 ** Legislative Professionalism-40.2 **** Democratic Governor.669 Time X Democratic Governor-.565 *** Urbanization X Legislative Professionalism.505 *** * p<.1; ** p<.05; *** p<.01; **** p<.005

Linear Mixed Model Predicting State Citation Severity Variableβ Intercept.446 Time-1.87 **** Education.482 **** Legislative Professionalism-7.35 ** Democratic Governor6.71 * Education X Democratic Governor-.300 * * p<.1; ** p<.05; *** p<.01; **** p<.005

Citation Volume: Effect of Governor’s Political Party

Citation Severity: Effect of Governor’s Political Party

Future Use of the Linear Mixed Model 1. Repetitive Scheduling of Annual Inspections: States are to avoid inspecting a nursing home during the same month in consecutive years 2. Deficiency Resolution: States are to resolve non-actual harm deficiencies within 60 days and actual harm deficiencies within 30 days

Contact Information Christopher M. Kelly, Ph.D. CPHAR Post Doctoral Fellow Institute on Aging University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Tel