26/05/11, Zadar Shallow & deep integrations with the MWA Gianni Bernardi Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (cooperative effort with D. Mitchell,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Crash Course in Radio Astronomy and Interferometry: 4
Advertisements

Jeroen Stil Department of Physics & Astronomy University of Calgary Stacking of Radio Surveys.
PAPER’s Sweet Sixteen: Imaging the Low Frequency Sky with a Sixteen Element Array Nicole Gugliucci for the PAPER Team* USNC/URSI National Radio Science.
Probing Magnetic Reconnection with Active Region Transient Brightenings Martin Donachie Advisors: Adam Kobelski & Roger Scott.
S-PASS, a new view of the polarized sky Gianni Bernardi SKA SA On behalf of the S-PASS team CMB2013, Okinawa, June th 2013.
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope Very Long Baseline Array Whoever North American.
Soobash Daiboo Arvind Nayak N Udaya Shankar Girish Kumar Beeharry Mauritius Radio Telescope Raman Research Institute The Southern Sky at MHz: Latest.
EOR Detection Strategies Somnath Bharadwaj IIT Kharagpur.
MWA Bangalore Meeting EoR using Drift Scan Strategy N. Udaya Shankar 8-December-2009.
Indo – SA Joint Astronomy Workshop, August 2012 / 22 Study of Foregrounds and Limitations to EoR Detection Nithyanandan Thyagarajan N. Udaya Shankar Ravi.
Interferometric Spectral Line Imaging Martin Zwaan (Chapters of synthesis imaging book)
Radio `source’ Goals of telescope: maximize collection of energy (sensitivity or gain) isolate source emission from other sources… (directional gain… dynamic.
Performance of station array configurations Sparse vs. Dense, Regular vs Random Jaap D. Bregman AAVP Workshop,Cambridge,
1 Synthesis Imaging Workshop Error recognition R. D. Ekers Narrabri, 14 May 2003.
Array Design David Woody Owens Valley Radio Observatory presented at NRAO summer school 2002.
Low frequency sky surveys with the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) Gianni Bernardi Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics SKA SA project/MeerKAT observatory.
Point Source Subtraction Bart Pindor University of Melbourne.
Sensitivity Mark Wieringa Australia Telescope CSIRO Astronomy and Space Science.
J.M. Wrobel - 25 June 2002 PROPOSALS 1 PROPOSAL WRITING TUTORIAL Outline 30 minutes: Lecture on Generic Issues 60 minutes: Small Groups Write Proposals.
Multiwavelength Continuum Survey of Protostellar Disks in Ophiuchus Left: Submillimeter Array (SMA) aperture synthesis images of 870 μm (350 GHz) continuum.
Advanced Calibration Techniques Michael Bietenholz Based on a lecture by Mark Claussen (NRAO) at the NRAO Synthesis Imaging Workshop.
Ninth Synthesis Imaging Summer School Socorro, June 15-22, 2004 Mosaicing Tim Cornwell.
Slide 1 25-Jan-10Huib Intema Recent low-frequency developments at NRAO Charlottesville and some other USA institutes.
Wideband Imaging and Measurements ASTRONOMY AND SPACE SCIENCE Jamie Stevens | ATCA Senior Systems Scientist / ATCA Lead Scientist 2 October 2014.
Survey Quality Jim Condon NRAO, Charlottesville. Survey Qualities Leiden 2011 Feb 25 Point-source detection limit S lim Resolution Ω s Brightness sensitivity.
Twelfth Synthesis Imaging Workshop 2010 June 8-15 Advanced Calibration Techniques Mark Claussen NRAO/Socorro (based on earlier self-calibration lectures)
Molecular Gas and Dust in SMGs in COSMOS Left panel is the COSMOS field with overlays of single-dish mm surveys. Right panel is a 0.3 sq degree map at.
J. Hibbard Spectral Line II: Calibration & Analysis 1 Spectral Line II: Calibration and Analysis Bandpass Calibration Flagging Continuum Subtraction Imaging.
Array Configuration Divya Oberoi MIT Haystack Observatory.
The Murchison Wide Field Array Murchison, ~300 km from Geraldton.
Daniel Mitchell (SAO / CfA) For the MWA Consortium.
Which dipoles to use to optimize survey speed? –What tapering? –Trade-off between sensitivity, FOV and low side-lobe levels –Station beam stability, pointing.
Monitoring the Galactic Center with the Long Wavelength Array Greg Taylor (UNM) on behalf of the Long Wavelength Array Collaboration
 PLATO PLAnetary Transits & Oscillations of stars Data onboard treatment PPLC study February 2009 on behalf of Reza Samadi for the PLATO data treatment.
Ninth Synthesis Imaging Summer School Socorro, June 15-22, 2004 Spectral Line II John Hibbard.
Fundamental limits of radio interferometers: Source parameter estimation Cathryn Trott Randall Wayth Steven Tingay Curtin University International Centre.
Conference Summary Ue-Li Pen
Мulti-frequency VLA observations of M87. Observations’ parameters Test VLA observations (configuration D) of M87 (RA=12:28, Dec=12:40) took place on November.
Phase Referencing Using More Than One Calibrator Ed Fomalont (NRAO)
Non-coplanar arrays Wide field imaging Non-copalanar arrays Kumar Golap Tim Cornwell.
Imaging Molecular Gas in a Nearby Starburst Galaxy NGC 3256, a nearby luminous infrared galaxy, as imaged by the SMA. (Left) Integrated CO(2-1) intensity.
Centre of Excellence for All-sky Astrophysics MWA Project: Centre of Excellence for All-sky Astrophysics Centre of Excellence for All-sky.
Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) : Design and Status Divya Oberoi, Lenoid Benkevitch MIT Haystack Observatory doberoi, On behalf.
Large Aperture Experiment to Detect the Dark Ages (LEDA) Jonathon Kocz CfA LWA Users Meeting 26th-27th July 2012.
Observing Strategies at cm wavelengths Making good decisions Jessica Chapman Synthesis Workshop May 2003.
NASSP Masters 5003F - Computational Astronomy Lecture 14 Reprise: dirty beam, dirty image. Sensitivity Wide-band imaging Weighting –Uniform vs Natural.
ASKAP: Setting the scene Max Voronkov ASKAP Computing 23 rd August 2010.
Pulsar luminosity distribution in 47-Tuc Tim Connors, Vacation student University of Sydney.
Recent progress in EVLA-specific algorithms EVLA Advisory Committee Meeting, March 19-20, 2009 S. Bhatnagar and U. Rau.
The Allen Telescope Array Douglas Bock Radio Astronomy Laboratory University of California, Berkeley Socorro, August 23, 2001.
Observations, Database, and Pipeline for EoR Jacqueline N. Hewitt MIT Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research Text.
Foreground Contamination and the EoR Window Nithyanandan Thyagarajan N. Udaya Shankar Ravi Subrahmanyan (Raman Research Institute, Bangalore)
Observed and Simulated Foregrounds for Reionization Studies with the Murchison Widefield Array Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, Daniel Jacobs, Judd Bowman + MWA.
First Exploration of MWA Deep Field Point Source Population C. Williams - PhD Thesis J. Hewitt – reporting some analysis.
Imaging The EoR MWA Project Meeting EoR Session 5 June 2011 N. Udaya Shankar Raman Research Institute.
WIDE-FIELD IMAGING IN CLASSIC AIPS Eric W. Greisen National Radio Astronomy Observatory Socorro, NM, USA.
In conclusion the intensity level of the CCD is linear up to the saturation limit, but there is a spilling of charges well before the saturation if.
Imaging issues Full beam, full bandwidth, full Stokes noise limited imaging Algorithmic Requirements: –PB corrections: Rotation, Freq. & Poln. dependence,
MWA imaging and calibration – early science results
EoR power spectrum systematics
Constraining the redshift of reionization using a “modest” array
AAVS1 Calibration Aperture Array Design & Construction Consortium
Observing Strategies for the Compact Array
Imaging and Calibration Challenges
Data Taking Plans for 32T and 128T
Data Reduction and Analysis Techniques
Wide field imaging Non-copalanar arrays
HERA Imaging and Closure
Image Error Analysis Fourier-domain analysis of errors.
Basic theory Some choices Example Closing remarks
Presentation transcript:

26/05/11, Zadar Shallow & deep integrations with the MWA Gianni Bernardi Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics (cooperative effort with D. Mitchell, L. Greenhill, S. Ord, N. Shravan, R. Wayth & the whole MWA collaboration)

26/05/11, Zadar The bigger… the better!!!

26/05/11, Zadar MWA is (will be) the largest N- array (128 elements, 512?) 800m u,v plane filled inside 1.1km 150 MHz < k < 0.4 Mpc -1 filling suppresses artifacts in continuum fg subtraction dipole layout areal fillingantenna spacings 5x5m tiles

26/05/11, Zadar MWA is (will be) the largest N- array (128 elements, 512?) 800m u,v plane filled inside 1.1km 150 MHz < k < 0.4 Mpc -1 filling suppresses artifacts in continuum fg subtraction dipole layout areal fillingantenna spacings 5x5m tiles

26/05/11, Zadar The Real-Time calibration and imaging System (RTS) (Mitchell et al., 2008, IEEE, 2, 707) (Ord et al., 2010, PASP, ) (GB et al., 2011, MNRAS, 413, 411)

26/05/11, Zadar Deconvolution/source subtraction via forward modeling (or further development on image based deconvolution) (Bowman, Morales & Hewitt, ApJ, 695, 183) (Geil, Gaensler & Whyithe, 2010, 2010arXiv G) (Pindor et al., 2011, PASA, 28, 46) (GB et al., 2011, MNRAS, 413, 411) in the MWA case, visibility data are not stored – causing a possible limitation in the deconvolution accuracy; once the uv plane includes time and position dependent primary beam and ionospheric correction the synthesized beam is position dependent and there is no standard deconvolution method applicable (no Clean, no Cotton-Schwab method); it is a valuable method to evaluate the statistics of the residual visibilities (in the light of EoR detection);

26/05/11, Zadar Flow chart Select a subset of visible sources from image data Generate the FM (the synthesized beam) for each source using current best parameter estimate (position, flux) Simultaneous fit for all the source parameters through a non linear minimization Convergence? Subtract sources from sky model Are there unmodeled sources? No Yes Add to sky model Yes No Done

26/05/11, Zadar Deconvolution can actually be represented by matrix algebra: for M sources and N image pixels, the following system of linearized equations is solved at each iteration: get a new parameter estimate x i: 3M vector of parameter estimates Jacobian matrixweight matrix N vector of data points

26/05/11, Zadar A 512T application: initial image (101 sources + thermal noise) Peak: 87 Jy rms: 105 mJy/beam DNR (apparent) ~ 800

26/05/11, Zadar Non linear minimization for the 15 brightest sources (5 iterations)

26/05/11, Zadar Non linear minimization for the 50 brightest sources (5 iterations)

26/05/11, Zadar Non linear minimization for all the 101 sources (5 iterations) rms ~ 25 mJy/beam final DNR ~ 3400 (Source subtraction for the EoR: ~1200 sources down 1 mJy in a 20° FoV - MWA will be confusion limited before that)

26/05/11, Zadar 400m …5% prototype for MHz MWA 32 tiles (32T)

26/05/11, Zadar 32T Pipeline First Light 20°x 20° Zenith 103 MHz 134 MHz 180 MHz Observations from January x 7hr tracks with real-time calibration, peeling, imaging, resampling and averaging. HEALPIX projection of Pic A field. Pic A peeled to reveal many secondary sources. Several simplifying assumptions relative to the 512T version, but all of the pieces are in place.

26/05/11, Zadar Essential features of calibration and imaging are in place… What does it still need? sky models beam measurements/characterization imaging improvements

26/05/11, Zadar Sky survey: observing specs & strategy Coverage of the whole southern MHz MHz Meridian survey: 136 fields + 34 calibrators Each field is observed close to meridian (within a few minutes of transit) for ~5 min  observations of similar HA -> similar primary beam for each scan  -> similar synthesized beam and sidelobe structure MHz bandwidth & ~ 30’ angular resolution

26/05/11, Zadar Calibration and imaging calibration and imaging performed through the Real Time System running on CPU/GPU in an off-line mode; choice of a few calibrators per pointing direction to determine passband and gain solutions (both direction independent). Gains are computed over ~ 8 MHz bandwidth (after bandpass fitting). The converged solutions are transferred to fields where there is not enough signal-to noise-ratio for selfcalibration. A few calibrators are sufficient to cover the whole sky for δ > -70°:  CenA ( MHz)  PicA ( MHz)  HydA ( MHz)  HerA ( MHz)  VirA ( MHz)  TauA ( MHz)

26/05/11, Zadar Calibration and imaging (cont’d) each 8 sec-0.6 MHz snapshot is re-sampled into the Healpix frame and weighted by the (model) tile primary beam. The short baselines are down weighted using a Gaussian taper with σ = 15 u; snapshot images are co-added up to 5 min; mosaicking is performed in the traditional way, by combining the various pointings weighted by their primary beam (the tile beams are considered to be all the same); dirty images need (offline) deconvolution (both point sources and diffuse emission). We have been doing work in this direction (deconvolution through forward modeling);

26/05/11, Zadar Sky coverage

26/05/11, Zadar Selected areas (undeconvolved images)

26/05/11, Zadar

Zoom in (1) Galactic centre CenA CenB PKS

26/05/11, Zadar Zoom in (1.1) SNR: G GRS & GRS SgrA star

26/05/11, Zadar Zoom in (2) Vela + Puppis FornaxA PicA HydA

26/05/11, Zadar Zoom in (3) PKS

26/05/11, Zadar Moving up north… HydA

26/05/11, Zadar (cont’d) HerA 3C253 SNR W44

26/05/11, Zadar (cont’d) HerA VirA

26/05/11, Zadar Deconvolving real data: an example Source J is modeled in the same way that the pointing is processed via the RTS (beams, cadence, frequency) Convergence after 2 iterations. Positional error ~ 15’, flux error ~ 10%

26/05/11, Zadar Primary beam measurements the sky drifts overhead while the tiles point at zenith; ~30 bandwidth 185 MHz; snapshot images (one every 5 min) are used to measure the beam response towards the J (which is ~ MHz);

26/05/11, Zadar Primary beam measurements J

26/05/11, Zadar Fitting a simple primary beam model The beam is accurate at a 5% level

26/05/11, Zadar Extending the beam work: zooming in to HydA field HydA Observations span slightly more than 5 hours (total) over MHz: 21 tiles available HydA provides the direction independent calibration of the array Snapshot images co-added Multi-frequency synthesis (but in the image plane)

26/05/11, Zadar

Conclusions: o the MWA calibration and imaging pipeline has been tested. It is working well, it will be refined – significant choices will have to be made; o real science data will be ready to come out in the next months; o a first all sky survey (catalogue of point sources brighter than 10 Jy, images of the A-team source) will be available in the next months; o MWA will expand to 128 tiles in the next year, expanding its science targets; Thank you!