A Presentation to the SHINE ’02 Workshop by J.G. Luhmann (August 19, 2002) CME initiation: A zoo not an animal (Images from the on-line CDAW CME catalogue.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

CME/Flare Mechanisms Solar “minimum” event this January For use to VSE must be able to predict CME/flare Spiro K. Antiochos Naval Research Laboratory.

Advertisements

Interaction of coronal mass ejections with large-scale structures N. Gopalswamy, S. Yashiro, H. Xie, S. Akiyama, and P. Mäkelä IHY – ISWI Regional meeting.

The Hemispheric Pattern of Filaments and Consequences for Filament Formation Duncan H Mackay Solar Physics Group University of St. Andrews.

Active Region Evolution and the Removal of Magnetic Helicity by CMEs Len Culhane Mullard Space Science Laboratory University College London.

Reviewing the Summer School Solar Labs Nicholas Gross.

Global Distribution of Slow Solar Wind N. U. Crooker, S. W. Antiochos, X. Zhao, Yi-M. Wang, and M. Neugebauer.

The Relation between Filament Skew Angle and Magnetic Helicity of Active Regions Masaoki HAGINO, Y.J. MOON (Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute)

Using Potential Field Models to Learn About CME Coronal Context and Consequences J.G. Luhmann and Yan Li (Space Sciences Lab, UCB) C.N. Arge (CIRES, U.

“Insights” on Coronal Hole Magnetic Fields From a High-Order PFSS Model D.J. Bercik and J.G. Luhmann Space Sciences Lab, UC Berkeley 1 FEW 2011, Aug 24.

SHINE Campaign Event: 1-2 May 1998 Brian Welsch (& Yan Li) Space Sciences Laboratory, UC Berkeley Introduction: Data, Context, etc. Work: Completed & Ongoing.

Comparing the Large-Scale Magnetic Field During the Last Three Solar Cycles Todd Hoeksema.

Jonathan A. Constable University of St Andrews Solar REU Presentation 2009 A flux rope model for CME initiation over solar cycle 23 Jonathan Constable.

Heliospheric MHD Modeling of the May 12, 1997 Event MURI Meeting, UCB/SSL, Berkeley, CA, March 1-3, 2004 Dusan Odstrcil University of Colorado/CIRES &

Evolution of the Large-Scale Magnetic Field Over Three Solar Cycles Todd Hoeksema.

AGU – Fall 2006 The Solar Polar Field – Cycles 21 – 23 The Solar Polar Field During Solar Cycles J. Todd Hoeksema, Yang Liu, XuePu Zhao & Elena Benevolenskaya.

High-latitude activity and its relationship to the mid-latitude solar activity. Elena E. Benevolenskaya & J. Todd Hoeksema Stanford University Abstract.

A General Cone Model Approach to Heliospheric CMEs and SEP Modeling Magnetogram-based quiet corona and solar wind model The SEPs are modeled as a passive.

A particularly obvious example of daily changing background noise level Constructing the BEST High-Resolution Synoptic Maps from MDI J.T. Hoeksema, Y.

3-D Pre-Eruption Magnetic Field Configuration Involved in 28 Oct 2003 Fast Halo CMEs Xuepu Zhao Stanford University 36 Th COSPAR Assembly Beijing, China,

The Hunt for a Link : Quantitative Connections Between Magnetic Fields and EIT Coronal Wave/CME Properties Prepared by James R. Robertson J.R. In conjunction.

Synoptic maps and applications Yan Li Space Sciences Laboratory University of California, Berkeley, CA HMI team meeting, Jan 27, 2005, Stanford.

Tucson MURI SEP Workshop March 2003 Janet Luhmann and the Solar CISM Modeling Team Solar and Interplanetary Modeling.

Understanding Magnetic Eruptions on the Sun and their Interplanetary Consequences A Solar and Heliospheric Research grant funded by the DoD MURI program.

Prediction of Central Axis Direction of Magnetic Clouds Xuepu Zhao and Yang Liu Stanford University The West Pacific Geophysics Meeting, Beijing, China.

1 Synoptic Maps of Magnetic Field from MDI Magnetograms: polar field interpolation. Y. Liu, J. T. Hoeksema, X. P. Zhao, R. M. Larson – Stanford University.

Relationship between the High and mid latitude Solar Magnetic Field Elena E. Benevolenskaya J. Todd Hoeksema Stanford University.

Ward Manchester University of Michigan Coupling of the Coronal and Subphotospheric Magnetic Field in Active Regions by Shear Flows Driven by The Lorentz.

Working Group E: The Pre-CME Sun - Pre-eruption structure, evolution & energy release - Global issues: helicity, homologous CMEs - Inputs to CME initiation.

Accurate Polar and small scale observations during the solar cycle Elena E. Benevolenskaya Yang Liu J. Todd Hoeksema Stanford University HMI/AIA meeting,

1 July 31, 2007 SHINE 2007 – Heliospheric Plasma Sheet The Unusual Heliospheric Current Sheet at the End of Cycle 23 A Comparison of Cycles 21,22,& 23.

Helicity as a Component of Filament Formation D.H. Mackay University of St. Andrews Solar Theory Group.

February 26, 2007 KIPAC Workshop on Magnetism Modeling/Inferring Coronal And Heliospheric Field From Photospheric Magnetic Field Yang Liu – Stanford University.

Space Weather Forecast With HMI Magnetograms: Proposed data products Yang Liu, J. T. Hoeksema, and HMI Team.

The nature of impulsive solar energetic particle events N. V. Nitta a, H. S. Hudson b, M. L. Derosa a a Lockheed Martin Solar and Astrophysics Laboratory.

A particularly obvious example of daily changing background noise level Constructing the BEST High-Resolution Synoptic Maps from MDI J.T. Hoeksema, Y.

Session 6 Key Questions for Understanding This Unusual Solar Minimum Alan Gabriel Todd Hoeksema Janet Luhmann Bill Matthaeus Neil Sheeley.

SPD – June 2006 Solar Polar Flux – MDI The Sun’s Polar Magnetic Flux Observed with SOHO/MDI J. Todd Hoeksema E.E. Benevolenskaya,

Sung-Hong Park Space Weather Research Laboratory New Jersey Institute of Technology Study of Magnetic Helicity and Its Relationship with Solar Activities:

Photospheric Sources of Very Fast (>1100km/s) Coronal Mass Ejections Recent studies show that only very fast CMEs (> 1100 km/s) are capable of producing.

Coronal and Heliospheric Modeling of the May 12, 1997 MURI Event MURI Project Review, NASA/GSFC, MD, August 5-6, 2003 Dusan Odstrcil University of Colorado/CIRES.

The “cone model” was originally developed by Zhao et al. ~10 (?) years ago in order to interpret the times of arrival of ICME ejecta following SOHO LASCO.

Coronal holes as seen in soft X-rays H. S. Hudson (UCB and SPRC) SOHO-11, Davos, March 13, 2002.

Luhmann1 An NSF Science and Technology Center led by Boston University, involving solar partners at SAIC, U of Colorado, BU, HAO, Stanford, NRL, AFRL,

RT Modelling of CMEs Using WSA- ENLIL Cone Model

Thomas Zurbuchen University of Michigan The Structure and Sources of the Solar Wind during the Solar Cycle.

A topological view of 3D global magnetic field reversal in the solar corona Rhona Maclean Armagh Observatory 5 th December 2006.

The Asymmetric Polar Field Reversal – Long-Term Observations from WSO J. Todd Hoeksema, Solar Observatories H.E.P.L., Stanford University SH13C-2278.

1 C. “Nick” Arge Space Vehicles Directorate/Air Force Research Laboratory SHINE Workshop Aug. 2, 2007 Comparing the Observed and Modeled Global Heliospheric.

The Sun’s Global Photospheric and Coronal Magnetic Fields Duncan H Mackay Solar Physics Group University of St. Andrews.

Proxies of the Entire Surface Distribution of the Photospheric Magnetic Field Xuepu Zhao NAOC, Oct. 18, 2011.

Coronal Mass Ejection As a Result of Magnetic Helicity Accumulation

1Yang Liu/Magnetic FieldHMI Science – 1 May 2003 Magnetic Field Goals – magnetic field & eruptive events Yang Liu Stanford University.

1 THE RELATION BETWEEN CORONAL EIT WAVE AND MAGNETIC CONFIGURATION Speakers: Xin Chen

SHINE SEP Campaign Events: Long-term development of solar corona in build-up to the SEP events of 21 April 2002 and 24 August 2002 A. J. Coyner, D. Alexander,

SOHO-20 “Transient events on the Sun and In the Heliosphere” – August 28, 2008, Ghent SOHO-20 “Transient events on the Sun and In the Heliosphere” – August.

The Rise of Solar Cycle 24: Magnetic Fields from the Dynamo through the Photosphere and Corona and Connecting to the Heliosphere Part 2: Corona & Heliophere.

Polar Magnetic Field Elena E. Benevolenskaya Stanford University SDO Team Meeting 2009.

ORIGIN OF THE SLOW SOLAR WIND K. Fujiki ， T. Ohmi, M. Kojima, M. Tokumaru Solar-Terrestrial Environment Laboratory, Nagoya University and K. Hakamada Department.

Modeling 3-D Solar Wind Structure Lecture 13. Why is a Heliospheric Model Needed? Space weather forecasts require us to know the solar wind that is interacting.

Anemone Structure of AR NOAA and Related Geo-Effective Flares and CMEs A. Asai 1 ( 浅井歩 ), T.T. Ishii 2, K. Shibata 2, N. Gopalswamy 3 1: Nobeyama.

Heliospheric Simulations of the SHINE Campaign Events SHINE Workshop, Big Sky, MT, June 27 – July 2, 2004 Dusan Odstrcil 1,2 1 University of Colorado/CIRES,

State of NOAA-SEC/CIRES STEREO Heliospheric Models STEREO SWG Meeting, NOAA/SEC, Boulder, CO, March 22, 2004 Dusan Odstrcil University of Colorado/CIRES.

Long-term measurements of the Sun’s poles show that reversal of the dominant magnetic polarity generally occurs within a year of solar maximum. Current.

Large-Scale Solar Magnetic Fields – How is Solar Cycle 24 Different?

Anemone Structure and Geo-Effective Flares/CMEs

Introduction to Space Weather

Anemone Structure of AR NOAA and Related Geo-Effective Flares and CMEs

Solar and Heliospheric Physics

Ron Moore and Alphonse Sterling

A Presentation to the SHINE ’02 Workshop by J.G. Luhmann

Presentation transcript:

A Presentation to the SHINE ’02 Workshop by J.G. Luhmann (August 19, 2002) CME initiation: A zoo not an animal (Images from the on-line CDAW CME catalogue by Seiji Yashiro)

Collaborators Yan Li UCB, Space Sciences Laboratory Xuepu Zhao Stanford University Also special thanks to: Seiji Yashiro Chris St. Cyr Spiro Antiochos Jon Linker for some of their graphics used in this presentation.

Several current CME models “in competition” include “Breakout” and flux emergence/cancellation in sheared arcades. Antiochos, et al. model SAIC model Antiochos, et al. model SAIC model

The Photospheric Background Field is not Dipolar in strength…

…or in polarity

Active region distributions can be simple or complex (synoptic maps from SOHOMDI of CR , , and )

Coronal field helmets like these exist outside of the Helmet Streamer Belt (cartoons from Antiochos, ApJ, August 1998)

Real Sun CMEs can be simple if the photospheric field is simple (Images from SOHO LASCO C2 and Yohkoh SXT: NRL & MSSL websites, respectively, KPNO magnetograms)

Real Sun CMEs can be complex if the photospheric field is complex (Images from SOHO LASCO C2 and Yohkoh SXT: NRL & MSSL websites, respectively, KPNO magnetograms)

Here we focus on the simple photospheric field period during Aug – Nov 1996 (CR )

All these CMEs (and more) occurred during this simple photospheric field period

In fact, many CMEs were entered in the CDAW online CME catalogue for Aug - Nov 1996 (catalogue compiled by Seiji Yashiro)

(SOHO EIT map from NRL LASCO website) The potential field source surface model can be used to approximate coronal holes, helmet streamer belt and active region field connections. We use it to try to learn more about CME coronal field context. The example shown here is for CR1915.

Differential rotation can cause effective active region bipole rotation

Does a model using the basic idea of a tilting bipolar active region at -15º latitude interacting with the background field resemble the observations for our simple Sun period?

Model Spherical Projections

22 August 1996 CME: “Model” and SOHO EIT/LASCO image

26 September 1996 Halo CME: “Model” and SOHO EIT/LASCO image

5 November 1996 CME: “Model” and SOHO EIT/LASCO image

Model “experiment” with equatorial bipolar active region, showing coronal field configurations for North, East, South, and West bipole axis orientation.

Equatorial Bipole Model Spherical Projections

Model “experiment” with bipolar active region at 45º N Latitude.

45º N Latitude Bipole Model Spherical Projections

Model “experiment” with two bipolar regions at 30º N and S Latitude. Only the N bipole axis orientation is changed.

30º N and S Latitude Bipole Model Spherical Projections

Model “experiment” with three bipolar regions.

Three Bipole Model Spherical Projections

Flux emergence that effectively introduces bipole polarity reversal would have the same effect. (models without the E-W phase)

Halos may be secondary streamer cylinders produced as a transient phase (right panel from ISTP website at GSFC) (bottom: hypothetical backside view)

The basic principle is reminiscent of Dungey’s 1961 idea for a magnetosphere: parallel and antiparallel interactions.

One can think of bipolar active regions as noses of “magnetospheres” poking into the larger scale coronal magnetic field. (Image adapted from Guhathakurta and Sittler, Solar Wind Nine Proceedings, 1999) (MDI Image)

The “zoo” comes from the many options for active region number, location,, complexity, evolution, and flux emergence variations. The “zoo” comes from the many options for active region number, location, orientation, complexity, evolution, and flux emergence variations.

Thanks to those who made the following web available: Acknowledgments Thanks to those who made the following web references available: CUA/cdaw CME Catalogue ISAS/LMSAL/MSSL Yohkoh SXT images NSO-Kitt Peak image archive