“NERC Hot Topics” Marc Butts May 9, 2008 Marc Butts May 9, 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Interchange Authority Recommendations Board of Directors Meeting December 7, 2007.
Advertisements

Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Standards WECC Board of Directors Meeting December 7-8, 2006.
Road Map for Audit Preparation FRCC Compliance Workshops September / October 2008.
Frequently Asked Questions Alberta Reliability Standards Compliance Version 1.0 – Effective April 30, 2013 (Please visit the website to download the latest.
CIP Cyber Security – Security Management Controls
PER
PER Update & Compliance Lessons Learned
Confidential & Proprietary to Cooper Compliance Corporation Revised September 8, 2014 AUDiT-READY TM.
FRCC Fall Compliance Workshop October , 2013
Key Reliability Standard Spot Check Frank Vick Compliance Team Lead.
CIP Spot Check Process Gary Campbell Manager of Compliance Audits ReliabilityFirst Corporation August, 2009.
Gcpud1 CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE PROTECTION NERC 1200 CIP CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE PROTECTION NERC 1200 CIP
Compliance Application Notice Process Update and Discussion with NERC MRC.
Cyber Security 2005 ERCOT COMPLIANCE ROLLOUT Lane Robinson Reliability Analyst.
Notice of Compliance Audit
Date Texas RE Board Update to TAC November 5, 2009 Susan Vincent Director, Legal Affairs.
Basics of Good Documentation Document Control Systems
June 6, 2007 TAC Meeting NERC Registration Issues Andrew Gallo, Assistant General Counsel, Litigation and Business Operations ERCOT Legal Dept.
Mandatory Reliability Rules Implementing the Electric Reliability Organization David W. Hilt Vice President & Director of Compliance APPA Reliability Symposium.
1 FRCC Compliance Organization and Entity Registration 2008 FRCC Compliance Workshop.
GOP and QSE Relationship Jeff Whitmer Manager, Compliance Assessments Talk with Texas RE June 25, 2012.
Compliance Monitoring Audit Tutorial Version 1.0 April 2013.
Support Systems and Tools Brittany Power Data Coordinator.
1 Texas Regional Entity Report December Performance Highlights ERCOT’s Control Performance Standard (NERC CPS1) score for October – Initial.
Texas Regional Entity Compliance Report TAC July 9, 2009.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission June Cyber Security and Reliability Standards Regis F. Binder Director, Division of Logistics & Security Federal.
Effective Management and Compliance 1 ANA GRANTEE MEETING  FEBRUARY 5, 2015.
1 Arizona Corporation Commission BTA Workshop Presenter: Steven Cobb May 23, 2008.
Nuclear Power Plant/Electric Grid Regulatory Coordination and Cooperation - ERO Perspective David R. Nevius and Michael J. Assante 2009 NRC Regulatory.
“Overview of FERC-NERC-SERC” 2006 Transmission Customer Forum Marc Butts September 21, 2006 Marc Butts September 21, 2006.
How To Prepare For A CIP Audit Scott Barker CISSP, CISA CIP Compliance Workshop Baltimore, MD August 19-20, 2009.
Implementing the New Reliability Standards Status of Draft Cyber Security Standards CIP through CIP Larry Bugh ECAR Standard Drafting Team.
January 2008 Texas Regional Entity Report. 2 Performance Highlights ●ERCOT’s Control Performance Standard (NERC CPS1) score for November – ●Scores.
Document Control Basics of Good Documentation and
NERC as the ERO Craig Lawrence Manager of Organization Registration, Certification, and Compliance Monitoring.
Procedures and Forms 2008 FRCC Compliance Workshop April 8-9, 2008.
SPP.org 1. EMS Users Group – CIP Standards The Compliance Audits Are Coming… Are You Ready?
Texas Regional Entity Update Sam Jones Interim CEO and President Board of Directors July 18, 2006.
1 Texas Regional Entity 2008 Budget Update May 16, 2007.
Overview of WECC and Regulatory Structure
Project System Protection Coordination Requirement revisions to PRC (ii) Texas Reliability Entity NERC Standards Reliability Subcommittee.
Project (COM-001-3) Interpersonal Communications Capabilities Michael Cruz-Montes, CenterPoint Energy Senior Consultant, Policy & Compliance, SDT.
Item 5d Texas RE 2011 Budget Assumptions April 19, Texas RE Preliminary Budget Assumptions Board of Directors and Advisory Committee April 19,
Bill Lewis, Compliance Team Lead NERC Reliability Working Group May 16, 2013 Texas RE Update Talk with Texas RE April 25, 2013.
The Electric Reliability Organization: Getting from here to there. Gerry Cauley Director, Standards ERO Project Manager ERO Slippery Slope NERC Today Uphill.
Problem Areas Updates Penalties FRCC Compliance Workshop September / October
COMPLIANCE ROLLOUT Vann Weldon Compliance Training Administrator March 23, 2005 NERC FUNCTIONAL MODEL REVIEW.
Employee Privacy at Risk? APPA Business & Financial Conference Austin, TX September 25, 2007 Scott Mix, CISSP Manager of Situation Awareness and Infrastructure.
Introduction This presentation is intended as an introduction to the audit process for employees of entities being audited by MACD. Please refer to the.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement Audit Program - The Audit Process.
Texas Regional Entity Report Mark Henry June 6, 2008.
2011 ReliabilityFirst 693 Compliance Audit Process for 6 Year Audit Cycle Entities Glenn Kaht Senior Consultant - Compliance ReliabilityFirst Corporation.
1 Audit Preparation. 2 September 8 – 11, 2008 ERCOT will be audited as the Reliability Coordinator (RC) Transmission Operator ( TOP) Balancing Authority.
Texas Regional Entity ROS Presentation January 15, 2009 T EXAS RE ROS P RESENTATION J ANUARY 2009.
Projects System Protection Coordination Draft 2 of TOP Texas Reliability Entity NERC Standards Reliability Subcommittee November 2, 2015.
SAR 001 DT Presentation Texas RE Presentation to SAR-001 Drafting Team Farzaneh Tafreshi Manager, Reliability Standards Texas Regional Entity.
1 Power System Restoration. 2 Not Active 3 4 Compliance Audit Process APPA E&O Technical Conference – Atlanta April 16, 2007.
MASSACHUSETTS UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK (UST) DATA MANAGEMENT SYSTEM COMPLETING THE COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATION MassDEP, Bureau of Air and Waste.
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT NERC ERO COMPLIANCE Louise McCarren Chief Executive Officer – WECC APPA National Conference June 16, 2009 Salt Lake City, Utah.
Compliance Program Update Lisa Milanes Manager of Compliance Administration.
The Electric Reliability Organization NERC’s Proposal for a Strong and Effective ERO FRCC System Operator Seminar Spring 2006.
Frequently Asked Questions Alberta Reliability Standards Compliance
Updated ERO Enterprise Guide for Internal Controls
ERCOT Technical Advisory Committee June 2, 2005
Background (history, process to date) Status of CANs
[INSERT APPLICABLE REGIONAL ENTITY NAME/LOGO]
The Electric Reliability Organization: Getting from here to there.
NERC Reliability Standards Development Plan
Larry Bugh ECAR Standard Drafting Team Chair June 1, 2005
Presentation transcript:

“NERC Hot Topics” Marc Butts May 9, 2008 Marc Butts May 9, 2008

 List of “hottest” topics  Compliance - Are you ready?  Compliance Filings for 2008  “Audits for Dummies”!  Use the RSAWS  Way’s to keep track of the NERC requirements Hot Topics!

What are the Hottest Topics in the Industry?

The way that NERC reacts to FERC pressure? The continuous budget increases – costs? Will compliance violation penalties be substantial? The volume of work: –FERC NOPR’s, rulemakings –NERC standards comments, drafting teams –SERC standards comments, drafting teams Audit processes – lack of volunteers? What are Your Hot Items?

Compliance – Are you Ready?

Only the “Planning Standards (18) required ‘self-certification’ by 7/1/08. There are also “Statements of Certifications” that have to be signed by each ‘entities’ Executive Signatories. What has to be done by July 1, 2008

The “Cyber Standards (8) will require ‘self- certification’ by 7/13/08. There will be “Statements of Certification” that will need to be signed by your Compliance Officers or Executive Signatories. This standard touches Transmission and Generation. Since the standard covers almost all functions, we’ll all have to file something. The Cyber standards, starting this year, will require two ‘self-certifications’ instead of the normal filing one time (Order 706). What else has to be done in 2008?

The “Operating Standards (36) will require ‘self-certification’ by 10/1/08. What else has to be done in 2008?

What was that “Registration Thing” all about?

Balancing Authority Distribution Provider Generator Operator - G Generator Owner Interchange Authority Load Serving Entity Planning Authority Purchasing-Selling Entity - G Reliability Coordinator Regional Reliability Organization Resource Planner - G Transmission Operator Transmission Owner Transmission Planner Transmission Service Provider * ‘Black’ functions were registered at the SCS level * ‘Red’ functions were registered at the OPCO level Not registered as an RRONot registered as an RRO (This is SERC!!) (This is SERC!!) SoCo Registered for 14 NERC functions

As shown on the previous page, you probably have contact mostly with the Power Coordination Center (PCC) in Birmingham or the Southern Company Fleet Operations (GOP function). In the NERC-world, the PCC in Birmingham is the TOP, BA, INT and RC functions. The GCC, ACC and others in our system do local switching, voltage coordination and other tasks and probably communicate directly with you all also. Who do you make contact with?

Buy the Book: “Audits for Dummies”!

Step #1: Are you Registered for the Correct Functions? Have you reviewed the latest Version 3 of the Functional Model? Have you referred to NERC’s Compliance Monitoring & Enforcement Plan (CMEP) for applicability? Step #2: Review Standards applicable to each Function Are you satisfied that you are registered correctly? If not, contact Regional Entity staff. Review all standards and all requirements for those functions you are registered for. Roadmap for Audit Preparation!

Step #3: Who will be accountable for meeting the requirements of the standards? Will you make a department accountable? Or, will you make a Manager accountable? Maybe even make the specific employee “punching the button” accountable? Step #4: What Type of Documentation is Required? Does evidence warrant written procedure, methodology, or guideline being developed? Is your current documentation up to date for the requirement? Does it meet the latest version of standard? Roadmap for Audit Preparation!

Step #5: Select a Documentation Application It protects documents/evidence from unauthorized edits. Need formal process for making revisions; administrator of the application who is the gatekeeper for all revisions. Step #6: Review Reliability Standards Audit Worksheets for Applicable Standards In 2007, auditor’s questions originated from the corresponding RSAWs. Review the RSAWs thoroughly for each requirement of each standard and assemble evidence needed to prove compliance. Roadmap for Audit Preparation!

Step #7: Assemble all Documents Have an electronic copy of all procedures referenced and provide to the audit team; Flashdrives are great for holding large volumes of information. Projectors are an excellent means to show evidence during the audit. Step #8: Perform “Mock” Audit Prior to Real Audit Have internal team perform audit using RSAW questions. Request documentation and evidence necessary for compliance. Plan to present just like a real audit! Roadmap for Audit Preparation!

It is imperative to have Management place a high emphasis on getting procedures written early and the audit done right. Need to make assignments early. Have meetings regularly to assess where you are. Assign someone to handle the logistics of meals for the auditors, refreshments, parking, badge access, remote internet access, etc. Make the audit “easy” on the auditors! If you have multiple assets in various regions, it will be important for the procedures to look very similar for the same standard & requirement for consistency reasons. Key Lessons Learned

Why is this so important?

Sanction Table Ranges with Adjustment Factors Applied

Penalty and Fine Process ($) Aggravating factors increase the sanction –Time horizon of standard – operations vs. long term ( %) –Repetitive infractions (+ 10, 30, and 50% discrete steps) –Prior warnings (+ 25% initial; 50% multiple) –Lack of cooperation (+0-50%) Mitigating factors decrease the sanction –Prompt disclosure (- 0-25%) –Voluntary corrective measures (- 0-25%) –Substantial cooperation (- 0-25%)

Where Do I Find These Standards?

There are ~ 120 NERC Board Approved, Reliability Standards, with a total of approximately 1,500 specific requirements and sub- requirements 94 have been FERC approved, where fines can be levied ($)! What’s the Magnitude of work here?

Click here

Click here for all FERC approved standards

Click here for matrix of all standard Requirement and what functions they apply to.

This is a great matrix to help you decide what applies to your company and to get organized!

Going back a bit…..do you know where to find the RSAW’s?

Click here

These are the RSAW’s!!

…and Then there’s SERC!!! Also SERC Supplements (soon to be called ‘standards’ that we must consider as well.)