Reviewing and developing the Scottish regeneration scene ‘Innovation or institutional clutter?’ Greg Lloyd Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum Annual Conference.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Kicking off Innovation Capacities through Regional cooperation in the Western Balkan Region Zoran Aralica, the Institute of Economics, Zagreb
Advertisements

Marine and Coastal Management in England and Wales Heidi Roberts, Principal Environmental Consultant Plancoast Conference, Berlin 21 st November 2007.
Partnerships: influencing local economic and employment development Brussels, October 9th, 2007 Gabriela Miranda Policy Analyst OECD, LEED Programme.
John Goddard Emeritus Professor of Regional Development Studies Universities and Smart Specialisation How can universities be mobilised for regional economic,
The political framework
Greg Lloyd The Irish – Scottish Forum University of Aberdeen June 2009 Re-presenting Scottish Cities.
March 2012 Ports and Cities Conference Newcastle Dorte Ekelund, Executive Director Major Cities Unit Department of Infrastructure and Transport
2009 Japan Day Seminar The role of local government in recession: strategies and solutions Sarah Longlands, Director of Policy Centre for Local Economic.
TOWARDS THE DIGITAL CITY IN eTHEKWINI: An overview of debates and issues Nancy Odendaal School of Architecture, Planning and Housing University of KwaZulu-Natal.
Cyprus Project Management Society
Greg Lloyd Scotland in Context (2) Politics and Governance The Geddes Institute.
Community Planning in Dundee Peter Allan Dundee Partnership Co-ordinator.
Instrumental Museum and Galley policy in Scotland Devolution - All Change?
Peter Peacock Ideas, to policy, to action. Long term Ageing population Climate change Technology advances Medium term Public spending constraint/decline.
Economic Change and the Community Grant Anderson Policy Manager Economic Development Dundee City Council.
Fiona Malcolm, Scottish Govt Pauline Graham, Social Firms Scotland.
2 Part 1 – Introduction, context and background Political context Economic context The Strategic Economic Plan Part 2 – Content The outline of the Strategic.
Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum – Perth, 7 th November 2006 Tom Warburton Head of Regeneration, One NorthEast.
Shaping the relationship between people and place: a constructive interface between community planning and spatial planning 11 September 2014 Gavan Rafferty.
Creative Knowledge and the Competitiveness of EU Metropolitan Regions The EU ACRE FP6 Project Julie Brown, Caroline Chapain, Alan Murie, Austin Barber,
A MANIFESTO FOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT IN SCOTLAND?
Regional and local economics Slide 1 Lecture 9b The Renaissance of local economic regeneration in the UK – Main themes and activities Aims  Examine local.
Geddes Institute PhD Seminar Series Thursday 27 October, 2005 The Social Re-construction of University Real Estate Deborah Peel The.
Scotland’s Economic Strategy Gary Gillespie Chief Economist Scottish Government.
Lord Peter Smith Chair of the Association of Greater Manchester Authorities Greater Manchester Localism through Collaboration.
Centre for Cities Dermot Finch, Director Chris Urwin, Economist 10 March 2006.
East of Scotland European Partnership Commuting and migration Dundee Contemporary Arts 2nd February 2005.
Adrian Colwell Visiting Senior Research Fellow November 2007.
New directions in learning and skills The story so far Martyn Waring.
The Territorial Dimension in the legislative proposals for cohesion policy Zsolt SZOKOLAI Policy Analyst, Urban development and territorial cohesion.
+ Bilbao’s Vision: Values for the Strategic Development of Cities Fundamental values acknowledged as key for the competitive and sustainable development.
Implementing the Lisbon Strategy The Role of Regions Kirsty Macdonald Head of Office Scotland Europa.
Summary of Review of capital city strategic planning systems Brian Howe Chair, Cities Expert Advisory Panel COAG Reform Council.
“Strong and Prosperous Communities” The New Local Government White Paper.
EU SEN Peer Review Glasgow June  Devolution - strong commitment to third sector  Reframing Government focus and relationships  Reforming public.
EU Funding- Part 2 Jim Millard European Structural Funds.
Community planning and national planning – where next? MG Lloyd The Geddes Institute University of Dundee The Social Inclusion Partnership Monitoring and.
Blurring boundaries? New Labour, civil society and the emergence of social enterprise Alibeth Somers Senior Lecturer MPA Programme.
A paradigm shift in local publicness: Examining the experiences in Europe Katsutaka Shiraishi Leader of Group 1, LORC.
Regeneration and Enterprise in Scotland Chik Collins, School of Social Sciences, University of Paisley SURF Open Forum: Being Enterprising Around Regeneration.
Craig McLaren Chief Executive Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum.
The Future of Regional Development and Planning in South Africa Presenter: Eric Nyembezi Makoni Annual TCI Conference 2008.
A Leaner and Greener Scotland Colin Mair, CEO, The Improvement Service.
TSRC Third Sector Research Centre The Third Sector Policy Environment in England: Partnership or Takeover?
RFA - Setting the scene Economic Development Jonathan Coe 17 th October 2008.
Sir Howard Newby Chief Executive Higher Education Funding Council for England Multilateral Higher Education Policy Forum May 2004.
1 SMALL TOWNS TASK GROUP Ian Lindley Director of Planning and Economic Development Scottish Borders Council Chair of Small Towns Task Group May 2007.
– Opportunities for a low-carbon economy – Focus on Italy Brussels, 30 September 2015 Rosanna Micciché European Commission, DG REGIO 1.
SMALL TOWNS TASK GROUP Douglas Scott Chief Executive’s Development Scottish Borders Council February 2009.
Maximising Opportunities for London Patricia Muotto Regeneration Manager, Structural Funds 00 Month 2004.
Centre for Local Economic Strategies Lessons from the United States 7 th October 2015, Manchester Matthew Jackson, Deputy Chief Executive.
DBA Plymouth University. Recent examples Ethical problems Theoretical links History and the now.
Understanding Cultural Planning Considering a Cultural Plan for Erie and Niagara Counties Impact and Issues Presented to the Greater Buffalo Cultural Alliance.
"The challenge for Territorial Cohesion 2014 – 2020: delivering results for EU citizens" Veronica Gaffey Acting Director EUROPEAN COMMISSION, DG for Regional.
Government Office for the East Midlands Janet Mills Head of Third Sector and Stronger Communities.
Community Planning: Monitoring & Evaluation Geddes Institute Research The Geddes Institute Emma Coles.
1 Towards alternative rural economies: paths, mechanisms and options for the future Dr Sarah Skerratt Senior Researcher & Team Leader: Rural Society Research.
Regional Policy European Semester / 2013 CSRs and Period John WALSH DG Regional and Urban Policy Brussels, 11 March Cohesion Policy.
EU Urban Policy: An overview Dr. Haroon Saad Director QeC-ERAN.
Update: South Africa’s Preparatory Process for HABITAT III Presentation to Portfolio Committee on Human Settlements 15 March
October 2004 Metropolitan governance in Lyon Capacity to act and perspectives.
Developing coherence mechanisms (ERDF/EARDF) in Poland Andrzej Hałasiewicz, PhD Nicolaus Copernicus University in Torun Foundation of Assistance Programmes.
Regional Policy Future of Cohesion Policy and Investments in Health Christopher Todd, Head of Unit, Slovakia European Commission, Directorate General for.
A snapshot of the main challenges and opportunities of rural areas
Employability in Scotland
Working Party on Urban Statistics Luxembourg, 9th-10th December 1999
The European political-economic governance Thematic orientation implementation programs A New Start, short term macroeconomic coordination 1-3.
Background: the draft strategy
Hazel Benza Employability and Third Sector Secondment Overview.
Background: the draft strategy
Presentation transcript:

Reviewing and developing the Scottish regeneration scene ‘Innovation or institutional clutter?’ Greg Lloyd Scottish Urban Regeneration Forum Annual Conference 2006 Dundee March 10, 2006

Overview  To review the emerging development of urban regeneration in Scotland.  To identify what represents innovation or institutional clutter.  To consider a way forward.

The urban challenge – degeneration, regeneration and connectivity  History, culture and identity of urban change and development.  Devolution and new spatial economic agendas.  Scalar relative economic performances – between and within urban areas.  Differential institutional arrangements & infrastructure deficits – ‘planning backwards’.  ‘Pariah’ urban change – growth, decline and ‘trickle down’.

Social democratic Influence Neo-liberal influence Third Way agenda 1997 to the present Thesis of market failure; Keynesian & expenditure based; Passive citizens; Overcrowded & rational state. Anti-thesis of government failure; ‘Supply-side’ & competitive; Clients; Fragmented & weakened state Synthesis of ideas; ‘Supply-side’ & competitive; Active citizens Congested state.

Social democratic Influence Neo-liberal influence Third Way agenda 1997 to the present National & regional economic policy emphasis Regional development agencies Inner city agenda – 1960s. Property market focus Enterprise Zones & UDCs New Life for Urban Scotland Priority Partnership Areas Devolution, public sector relocation & city-regions BIDs & URCs SIPs & community planning Regeneration policy statement

Third Way modernisation  Egan Review 2003  Lyons Review 2004  Gershon Review 2004  Barker Report 2005  Hampton Review 2005  Arculus Report 2005  Audit Commission 2006

Parallel ideas: The congested state? Evidence  Cities Review 2001 Political  Partnership Agreement 2003 Policy  Framework of Economic Development in Scotland 2004  Smart Successful Scotland 2004  Modernising Planning White Paper 2005  Planning etc (Scotland) Bill 2006  Infrastructure Statement 2005  City regions  Community planning  Regeneration statement 2006

Towards the organic state?  Scalar tensions – space versus place  Strategic versus local  Territory versus theme  Efficiency versus inclusion  Integration versus fragmentation  Voluntarism versus contractualisation