AUJOURD’ HUI…..et…. DEMAIN Keep contact with experimentalists, work together Beyond mean-field, but via Particle- Vibration Coupling.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Modern Theory of Nuclear Structure, Exotic Excitations and Neutrino-Nucleus Reactions N. Paar Physics Department Faculty of Science University of Zagreb.

Advertisements

Spectroscopy at the Particle Threshold H. Lenske 1.

RIKEN, March 2006: Mean field theories and beyond Peter Ring RIKEN, March 20, 2006 Technical University Munich RIKEN-06 Beyond Relativistic.

HL-5 May 2005Kernfysica: quarks, nucleonen en kernen1 Outline lecture (HL-5) Collective excitations of nuclei photo-excitation of GDR particle-hole excitations.

CEA DSM Irfu 14 Oct Benoît Avez - [Pairing vibrations with TDHFB] - ESNT Workshop1 Pairing vibrations study in the Time-Dependent Hartree-Fock Bogoliubov.

Isospin dependence and effective forces of the Relativistic Mean Field Model Georgios A. Lalazissis Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece Georgios.

Lectures in Istanbul Hiroyuki Sagawa, Univeristy of Aizu June 30-July 4, Giant Resonances and Nuclear Equation of States 2. Pairing correlations.

12 June, 2006Istanbul, part I1 Mean Field Methods for Nuclear Structure Part 1: Ground State Properties: Hartree-Fock and Hartree-Fock- Bogoliubov Approaches.

What can we learn from vibrational states ? “the isoscalar and the charge- exchange excitations” G. Colò ECT* Workshop: The Physics Opportunities with.

Forces for extensions of mean-field PhD Thesis Marlène Assié Denis Lacroix (LPC Caen), Jean-Antoine Scarpaci (IPN Orsay)  Extensions of mean-field ? 

Le groupe des francophones Heirs of P. Bonche, H Flocard, D Vautherin, … with still two ancestors: P-H Heenen and J. Meyer and many young people: M Bender.

15 June, 2006Istanbul, part 21 Mean Field Methods for Nuclear Structure Part 1: Ground State Properties: Hartree-Fock and Hartree-Fock- Bogoliubov Approaches.

The physics of nuclear collective states: old questions and new trends G. Colò Congresso del Dipartimento di Fisica Highlights in Physics 2005 October.

Systematics of the First 2 + Excitation in Spherical Nuclei with Skyrme-QRPA J. Terasaki Univ. North Carolina at Chapel Hill 1.Introduction 2.Procedure.

Effect of particle-vibration coupling on the single-particle states: a consistent study within the Skyrme framework G. Colò JAPAN-ITALY EFES Workshop Torino,

Etat de lieux de la QRPA = state of the art of the QRPA calculations G. Colò / E. Khan Espace de Structure Nucléaire Théorique SPhN, Saclay, January 11-12,

Higher-Order Effects on the Incompressibility of Isospin Asymmetric Nuclear Matter Lie-Wen Chen ( 陈列文 ) (Institute of Nuclear, Particle, Astronomy, and.

A Hybrid Configuration Mixing model with applications to odd mass nuclei near closed shells G. Colò The future of multi-reference DFT, Warsaw, June 26.

Microscopic particle-vibration coupling models G. Colò.

Methods beyond mean field: particle-vibration coupling G. Colò Workshop on “Nuclear magic numbers: new features far from stability” May 3 rd -5 th, 2010.

1 The Random Phase Approximation in Nuclear Physics  Lay out of the presentation: 1. Linear response theory: a brief reminder 2. Non-relativistic RPA.

XII Nuclear Physics Workshop Maria and Pierre Curie: Nuclear Structure Physics and Low-Energy Reactions, Sept , Kazimierz Dolny, Poland Self-Consistent.

Effects of self-consistence violations in HF based RPA calculations for giant resonances Shalom Shlomo Texas A&M University.

Alex Brown UNEDF Feb Strategies for extracting optimal effective Hamiltonians for CI and Skyrme EDF applications.

Nuclear Structure and dynamics within the Energy Density Functional theory Denis Lacroix IPN Orsay Coll: G. Scamps, D. Gambacurta, G. Hupin M. Bender and.

XII. International Workshop Maria and Pierre Curie, Kazimierz Dolny, Covariant density functional theory for collective excitations in.

The calculation of Fermi transitions allows a microscopic estimation (Fig. 3) of the isospin mixing amount in the parent ground state, defined as the probability.

Giant Resonances - Some Challenges from Recent Experiments

Systematic study of isovector dipole mode up to A=50 KEK 研究会「原子核・ハドロン物理 : 横断研究会」 KEK, 2007 年 11 月 19 日 -21 日稲倉恒法中務孝矢花一浩 ( 筑波大学 ) ( 理研 ) ( 筑波大学 )

Isovector scenario for nuclei near the N=Z line Anatoli Afanasjev S. Frauendorf Kai Neergard J. Sheikh.

Low-lying dipole strength in unstable nuclei. References: N. Ryezayeva et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) P. Adrich, A. Kimkiewicz et al., Phys.Rev.

Constraints on symmetry energy from different collective excitations G. Colò NUSYM Krakow July 2 nd, 2015.

KITPC, Jun 14th, 2012 Spin-Isospin excitations as quantitative constraint for the Skyrme tensor force Chunlin Bai Department of Physics, Sichuan University.

Constraints on Nuclear Functionals from Collective Vibrations Gianluca Colò The 2 nd LACM-EFES- JUSTIPEN Workshop Oak Ridge, 25/1/2008.

Anomalous two-neutron transfer in neutron-rich Ni and Sn isotopes studied with continuum QRPA H.Shimoyama, M.Matsuo Niigata University 1 Dynamics and Correlations.

The correlations between symmetry energy and dipole states G. Colò University of Aizu-JUSTIPEN-EFES Symposium on “Cutting-edge Physics of Unstable Nuclei”

NEUTRON SKIN AND GIANT RESONANCES Shalom Shlomo Cyclotron Institute Texas A&M University.

Variational multiparticle-multihole configuration mixing approach

Three-body force effect on the properties of asymmetric nuclear matter Wei Zuo Institute of Modern Physics, Lanzhou, China.

Evolution Of Shell Structure, Shapes & Collective Modes Dario Vretenar

First Gogny conference, TGCC December 2015 DAM, DIF, S. Péru QRPA with the Gogny force applied to spherical and deformed nuclei M. Dupuis, S. Goriely,

Giant and Pygmy Resonance in Relativistic Approach The Sixth China-Japan Joint Nuclear Physics May 16-20, 2006 Shanghai Zhongyu Ma China Institute of Atomic.

New Era of Nuclear Physics in the Cosmos, RIKEN, September 25-26, 2008 H. Sagawa, University of Aizu 1.Introduction 2.Incompressibility and ISGMR 3.Neutron.

Lectures in Milano University Hiroyuki Sagawa, Univeristy of Aizu March 6,12,13, Pairing correlations in Nuclei 2. Giant Resonances and Nuclear.

F. C HAPPERT N. P ILLET, M. G IROD AND J.-F. B ERGER CEA, DAM, DIF THE D2 GOGNY INTERACTION F. C HAPPERT ET AL., P HYS. R EV. C 91, (2015)

Couplage de phonons = state of the art of “extended” RPA calculations G. Colò Espace de Structure Nucléaire Théorique SPhN, Saclay, January 11-12, 2005.

Nuclear density functional theory with a semi-contact 3-body interaction Denis Lacroix IPN Orsay Outline Infinite matter Results Energy density function.

Otranto 2007 P.F. Bortignon. Nucleons are coupled to phonons, mainly density vibrations (2 +,3 - ). In other words, the nuclear mean.

Few-Body Models of Light Nuclei The 8th APCTP-BLTP JINR Joint Workshop June 29 – July 4, 2014, Jeju, Korea S. N. Ershov.

Continuum quasiparticle linear response theory using the Skyrme functional for exotic nuclei University of Jyväskylä Kazuhito Mizuyama, Niigata University,

Pairing Correlation in neutron-rich nuclei

Active lines of development in microscopic studies of

Nuclear structure far from stability

Probing the neutron skin thickness in collective modes of excitation

Beyond Landau-Migdal theory

Beyond mean-field methods: why and how

Nuclear Structure Tools for Continuum Spectroscopy

Regularized delta interactions for nuclear structure calculations

The Isovector Giant Quadrupole Resonance & Nuclear Matter

Low energy nuclear collective modes and excitations

The Skyrme-RPA model and the tensor force

Self-consistent theory of stellar electron capture rates

Constraints, limits and extensions for nuclear energy functionals

GCM calculations based on covariant density functional theory

Technical University Munich

AUJOURD’ HUI…..et…. DEMAIN

Medium polarization effects and transfer reactions in halo nuclei

A self-consistent Skyrme RPA approach

Constraining the Nuclear Equation of State via Nuclear Structure observables 曹李刚中科院近物所第十四届全国核结构大会，湖州，

Department of Physics, Sichuan University

Presentation transcript:

AUJOURD’ HUI…..et…. DEMAIN Keep contact with experimentalists, work together Beyond mean-field, but via Particle- Vibration Coupling

132Sn low-lying GDR strength

Blue line = theory of 3) (dashed line) convoluted with the detector response by A. Klimkiewicz to compare with the experiment of 2) (green) G. G. G. Colo and PFB, Comex2

References: N. Ryezayeva et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) P. Adrich, A. Kimkiewicz et al., Phys.Rev. Lett. 95 (2005) D. Sarchi, PFB, G. Colò, Phys. Lett. B 601 (2004) 27. N. Paar, D. Vretenar, E. Khan, G. Colò, Reports on Progress in Physics ) 2) 3) 4) 5)

The phonon coupling has been known for many years to be important for the understanding of s.p. states around the 208 Pb core. Exp. HF + HF phonons C.Mahaux et al., Phys. Rep., 1985  PV coupling increases m*

Gamma(s.p.)=0.5 (E-E_F)

Spreading width in GR G.F. Bertsch, P.F. Bortignon, R.A. Broglia, Rev. Mod. Phys. 55 Gamma(GR)=? Gamma(part.)+Gamma(hole) NO!!!

In the last decade we have developed, within a Milano- Orsay collaboration, a microscopic model aimed to a detailed description of GR excitation and decay [G. Colò et al. Phys. Rev. C50, 1496 (1994)]. The model includes the coupling with 1p-1h plus 1 phonon configurations and with the continuum (allowing the description of particle decay). The model has been able to reproduce the total width of the GMR, and total and partial decay widths of GTR and IAR in 208 Pb. Recently, we have extended the model to include pairing correlations (without the continuum coupling).

The IAS: a stringent test ZN The measured total width (Γ exp =230 keV) is well reproduced. The accuracy of the symmetry restoration (if V Coul =0) can be established.

Problem of the 2d3/2 –1h11/2 position, wrong in all mean-field calculations, Not cured by coupling to vibrations (see below, G. Colò and PFB,ISPUN 2007 But tensor contribution may help: G. Colò et al., PLB 646 (2007) 227, However see also T. Lesinski et al., PRC 76 (2007)

F. Barranco….P.Schuck et al., PRC 72

A. Pastore et al. Nucl-th T. Duguet and T. Lesinski, Nucl_th J. Margueron, H. Sagawa, k. Hagino, Nucl-th

IPSE DIXIT The two Thomas, Karim…, want an UNEDF…. Jacek shifts attention from g.s. properties to s.p. properties

IPSE DIXIT Peter propose to use DFT for g.s. properties and Migdal Theory for energy dependence and shows resuls of PV coupling G. Colò:

INSERT CONSTRAINTS FROM COLLECTIVE EXCITED STATES in the fit of the functional. Concrete proposal : K , S(ρ=0.1 fm -3 ), g0’. Giant Monopole Resonance : E GMR constrains K  = 240 ± 20 MeV. (a) Allow in the fit this relatively broad range (one can allow 1.5σ, that is, 210 < K  < 270 MeV). (b) A smaller range is possible if we have an a priori choice for the density dependence. This constraints comes from a comparative study of Skyrme, Gogny, RMF. Giant Dipole Resonance : E IVGDR constraints S 0.1  S(  =0.1 fm -3 ). The constraint, coming from a study with Skyrme, is 22.3 < S 0.1 < 25.8 MeV. Giant Quadrupole Resonance : it mainly involves m*. Low-lying collective states : too much dependent on s.p. spectrum. Giant Gamow-Teller Resonance : imposing that it exhausts about 60% of the 3(N-Z) sum rule constraints the spin-isospin part of the functional. Here the precise constraint depends on the functional. Gianluca Colò, Univ. of Milano, Italy

GMR: S. Shlomo, V.M. Kolomietz, G.C. [EPJ A30 (2006)] Right (left) refers to a softer (stiffer) density dependence: α=1/6 (1/3). IVGDR: L. Trippa, G.C., E. Vigezzi (submitted). GTR: S. Fracasso, G.C. [PRC 76 (2007)].

Collaborators : P.F. Bortignon, S. Fracasso, J. Li, L. Trippa, E. Vigezzi (Milano) N. Van Giai (Orsay) K. Bennaceur, J. Meyer (Lyon) P. Bonche (Saclay)

Paul Bonche et al. Let us emphasize that this study was done at the mean-field (HF) level. However, NO ingredient in our protocol prevents further studies beyond the mean field approximation. If needed be, further correlations can be explored and it is quite legitimate to use these interactions for RPA or configurations mixing (GCM) calculations. This would NOT has been the case if we had included in our protocol detailed information such as s.p. energies of some selected nuclei.