BANKING IN CEE: adequate risk appetite crucial to win the upside UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Vienna, November 9, 2009.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Growth of bank credit in central and eastern Europe: housing markets and the role of foreign-owned banks Dubravko Mihaljek Senior Economist Bank for.
Advertisements

Households Financial Behaviour, Housing Market and Credit in SEE Debora Revoltella UniCredit Group CEE Chief Economist Euromoney Conference, Dubrovnik.
UK – CROATIA Trade & Investment Forum 2013 London, October 24 th Boris Vujčić
Report on Financial Stability Vonnák Balázs director 1 12th November 2014.
Semana de Moçambique em Portugal Millennium bim Business review and development plans June 20, 2007.
The Hungarian financial system can make only a limited contribution to the economic recovery Report on Financial Stability November 2010.
FROM THE COLLAPSE OF SOCIALISM TO THE CRISIS OF CAPITALISM FROM THE COLLAPSE OF SOCIALISM TO THE CRISIS OF CAPITALISM Experiences of Central and Eastern.
FOREIGN TRADE IN CENTRAL-EASTERN EUROPE Speaker: Andrew England Head of Global Transaction Banking, CEE Bucharest, April 5 th 2011 Agenda:  UniCredit.
BANCA NAŢIONALĂ A ROMÂNIEI BANCA NAŢIONALĂ ROMÂNIEI.
2008 RESULTS 12 Feb 2009 PRESS CONFERENCE : Another satisfactory year in a troubled environment 2008 RESULTS.
AIG New Europe Fund 1 Bundling the Local Loop Financing Doina Popescu AIG New Europe Fund June, 2004.
BONJOUR! YVES DRIEUX CEO BNP PARIBAS POLAND Jeudi, 23 Janvier, 2003.
XPRIMM Insurance Report FY countries: CEE, SEE, CIS Full length statistics in EUR and national currency on
Maintaining Macroeconomic Stability in Turbulent Times: The Case of Macedonia Maintaining Macroeconomic Stability in Turbulent Times: The Case of Macedonia.
Financial turmoil and Transition Countries Fabrizio Coricelli University of Siena and EBRD Istanbul June 25, 2008.
N ATIONAL B ANK SEE-5 & Turkey: Macro Challenges Paul Mylonas Chief Economist, General Manager of Strategy and Governance, National Bank Group N ATIONAL.
RUSSIAN PRIVATE BANKS – KEY MARKET PLAYERS! Michel Perhirin, CEO, MDM Bank Russian Economic and Financial Forum in Switzerland Seventh Session, Zurich.
Czech & Slovak Republics Jaromír Sladkovský Director of Group Retail Marketing Prague April 19, 2004 Dynamics of Banking Sector.
ECA REGION AND THE GLOBAL CRISIS PRODUCTIVITY AND THE HUMAN FACTOR Klaus Rohland Country Director for Russia Europe and Central Region The World Bank Higher.
KBC Bank & Insurance Group Full year results 2001 Brussels 4 March 2002.
Company presentation April 2004 Financial Year 2003 Results and Outlook for the Future.
1 Strategy for Competing in Russia’s Banking Market Oleg Tumanov, Deputy CEO Alfa Bank, Moscow London, December 2003.
1 st Bank of Greece Workshop on Economies of Eastern European and Mediterranean Countries The Global Financial Crisis and SEE: Lessons for Macro-economic.
Rome, June 8, 2004 HOUSEHOLD WEALTH: GROWTH PROSPECTS IN NEW EUROPE Alessandro Profumo CEO UniCredit.
NATIONAL BANK OF AZERBAIJAN KHAGANI ABDULLAYEV, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.
Financial sector crisis in emerging Europe and international policy response Alexander Pivovarsky EBRD Office of the Chief Economist USAID Regional Competitiveness.
Financial System and Economy and the Reponses to the Financial Crisis
Study initiated by Open Society Forum Team Leader: D. Jargalsaikhan, MBA (Finance), Daniels College of Business, University of Denver, USA Senior Researcher:
Banking considerations for foreign investors in Albania
Warsaw, 6 th September 2004 HOUSEHOLD WEALTH IN THE NEW EUROPE COUNTRIES.
Private Equity World Middle East 2005 Russia and Eastern European markets: opportunities in the “new” European Economies Kestutis Sasnauskas, East Capital.
Overview What we have seen : achievements Crisis less bad than feared What we can expect : challenges Fragile, slow and varied recovery What should be.
E R S T E G R O U P AAFBR Conference Bucharest, November 2010 Outlook on the CEE Region Financial Markets & Debt Fritz Mostböck, CEFA Head of Group Research.
Standing its ground in a challenging environment RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY MARKET IN CEE EBRD Annual Meeting Kiev, 18 May 2008 Erich Hampel, Head of CEE Division.
Financial Stability Report – May 2014 Balázs Vonnák 22 May 2014.
Slide 1 / “Efectele crizei economice in Europa Centrala si de Est - ce diferentiaza România?” Ionut DUMITRU, Economist-sef Raiffeisen Bank.
Slide 1 / Romania and the international financial and economic crisis Ionut DUMITRU Chief-Economist Raiffeisen Bank Romania.
World Bank EU 10 Regular Economic Report Safeguarding Recovery Brussels, 16 July 2010.
The Trinidad and Tobago Banking System: Some Stylized Facts Ewart S. Williams Governor Central Bank of Trinidad and Tobago.
EPC EDUCATION AND TRAINING – Applications for Membership of the EU Turkey - April 1987 Cyprus - July 1990 Malta - July 1990 Hungary.
Kazakhstan at times of market turmoil Kazakhstan’s Banking market from the viewpoint of ATF Bank Almaty, September 2008 Alexander Picker, Chief Executive.
Global Problems--Regional Implications Presentation to the 5 th Vienna Economic Forum: Investment Possibilities in the Countries from the Adriatic to the.
1 Asociaţia Societăţilor Financiare - ALB România The Financial Companies Association – ALB Romania 8 th ALB National Conference Evolution of the consumer.
Banking in SEE: moving into the spotlight Euromoney Conference, Dubrovnik October 16 th Debora Revoltella UniCredit Group CEE Chief Economist.
UNICREDIT GROUP PROFILE Milan, March UNICREDIT HAS SYSTEMATICALLY OPTED FOR BREAKTHROUGHS, ENABLING IT TO ACHIEVE EXCELLENT RESULTS … Selective.
Wiener Institut für Internationale Wirtschaftsvergleiche The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies The Balkans: Turning the.
Prospects and Challenges for Economic Growth in the South Caucasus and other Transition Economies C. Felipe Jaramillo The World Bank Tbilisi, Georgia,
1 Global Financial Crisis and Central Asia Ana Lucía Coronel IMF Mission Chief for Kazakhstan Middle East and Central Asia Department International Monetary.
Economy and Banking Sector in Turkey Beirut, Lebanon December, 2010.
Wiener Institut für Internationale Wirtschaftsvergleiche The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies Vladimir Gligorov Economic.
K&H Bank Bába Ágnes CFO The outlooks of the Hungarian Banking Sector Budapest, 21 April 2004.
1 How to avoid another serious financial crisis: Harnessing the benefits of financial integration Manfred Schepers, Vice President Finance, EBRD.
1 Development of total loans (in % of GDP) Year-end figures, * forecast Source: BA-CA Economics Department % CEE*... excl. Russia and Ukraine CEE total...
BANKING CLIMATE IN BULGARIA - access to finance, corporate sector funding sources and loan conditions Kristofor Pavlov, Chief Economist Bulbank member.
Vienna Insurance Group Financing of Investments
Summary results of our bi-annual Central Eastern Europe business benchmarking survey June 2015.
Presents CEE, Russia & CIS Insurance markets 2009 AGREGATED REGIONAL RESULTS COUNTRY RESULTS TRENDS COMPANIES RANKINGS MAJOR GROUPS.
July 2010 Regular Economic Report CROATIA Supporting Recovery.
The New Growth Model for Serbia: Monetary and Fiscal Policy Challenges Dejan Soskic – Governor, National Bank of Serbia Athens, 11 February 2011.
International Monetary Fund, Regional Economic Outlook for Sub-Saharan Africa, June Time for a Policy Reset Regional Economic Outlook for Sub-Saharan.
Erste Group Bank AG We provide banking services for the real economy in the eastern part of the European Union Update as of June 2016 General Presentation.
Comparative analysis on wages
Summary results of our bi-annual Central Eastern Europe business benchmarking survey December 2016.
Sr. Financial Sector Specialist
Sanja Madzarevic Sujster Podgorica, November 16, 2017
Competiveness and Sustainability of the Euro
The euro area sovereign debt crisis and its
BANKING CLIMATE IN BULGARIA -
The New Growth Model for Serbia: Monetary and Fiscal Policy Challenges
1st Bank of Greece Workshop on Economies of Eastern European and Mediterranean Countries The Global Financial Crisis and SEE: Lessons for Macro-economic.
Presentation transcript:

BANKING IN CEE: adequate risk appetite crucial to win the upside UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Vienna, November 9, 2009

2 Executive Summary 1  World economic growth is recovering and this boosts prospects in CEE will show a positive regional growth, though this will remain below potential and subject to risks  Strong regional differentiation is confirmed, with Central Europe better prepared to catch the international recovery. The performance of different banks in the same market can widely differ  Markets are out of a “liquidity-crisis mood” – credit quality and risk appetite are today’s key constraints for CEE banking  Medium term: “CEE convergence story” holds, but the banking model has to be rebalanced  Financial penetration will continue, but the pace of growth will moderate, with availability of funding (domestic or external) the main driver  Changing competition allows for leaner structure of costs  Cost of risk to stay high, representing a constraint for banking profitability

3 Executive Summary 2  The changing competitive environment means also opportunities  All CEE players have been affected by the crisis – access to funding, credit quality, business/network diversification and strength the determinants of future success  New entrants might take opportunities  Winners – new entrants or consolidated players, with appropriate risk appetite for CEE, able to leverage on strong funding, capital and network positioning and sound risk  UCG ready to take the upside – the Group can leverage on diversification, a strong regional network and newly raised capital to strengthen and optimize its positioning in the market

4 AGENDA 1.How the CEE banking landscape has changed in the short term 2.Banking through the crisis 3.International players - UniCredit ready to take the upside

5 Note: (1) CEE-17: Poland, Hungary, Czech R., Slovakia, Slovenia, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Romania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Bosnia-H, Serbia, Turkey, Ukraine, Russia and Kazakhstan Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis, CEE Research Signs of recovery: still 2010 implies growth below potential and countries confirm to be very different Low macro vulnerability 25 High macro vulnerability 341 Country Rank PL SK Turkey Russia CZ BG Ukraine RO HU KZ Baltics Poland Hungary Czech Rep Slovakia Slovenia Lithuania Latvia Estonia Romania Bulgaria Croatia Bosnia-H Serbia Turkey Ukraine Russia Kazakhstan CEE Real GDP growth (%) HR BH SI

6 Drivers of growth differ among countries. Recovery comes from the production sector, but both investment and consumption remain subdued Source: UniCredit Group CEE Research Investments (real % growth) Consumption (real % growth)

7 Out of a “liquidity-crisis mood”, but funding availability and cost remain a constraint for CEE banking Country Risk Premium 5Y CDS (USD, bp) CEE external liabilities (1) (1) CEE-17 Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis 3,274 1,168 € bn Banking sector external liabilities (% on total liabilities, June 2009)

8 Notes: (1) Nominal growth rates are corrected for the exchange rate changes weighted by the relevance of FX in loans' volumes in the previous period. This allows to have an idea of growth of loans and deposit which is independent from the pure effect of depreciation of the currency Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Banks are rebalancing the loans/deposits gap Total banking system deposits (1 ) (June 09 vs Dec 08 % change FX adj) Loan-to-deposits ratio (banking system level, %) Total banking system Loans (1 ) (June 09 vs Dec 08 % change FX adj)

9 (1)Incl. loans classified under substandard, doubtful and loss categories; in Ukraine, data refer to problem credits (overdue and doubtful); in Kazakhstan, data refer to doubtful loans under category 2,4,5 and bad loans; in Romania, data refer to loans classified under doubtful and loss categories Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis, local CBs Non-performing loans ratio (total banking system, in % of gross loans) (1 ) Deterioration in credit quality is today’s challenge

10 AGENDA 1.How the CEE banking landscape has changed in the short term 2.Banking through the crisis 3.International players - UniCredit ready to take the upside

11 The long term potential of the CEE region is intact Real income convergence in CEE (1) (1) CEE incl. new EU member states, Croatia and Turkey; calculation based on GDP per capita expressed in dollar terms Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis, IMF, ECB Financial deepening process (% of GDP and PPS in dollar terms) GDP per capita Total banking assets Western Europe CEE The story of economic and income convergence towards the standards of Western countries, as well as the potential related to the banking sector penetration gap, continue to hold

12 KEY COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES More balance growth model – still with external funding Lending tied to funding strategies, but external funding still necessary Strong advantage for banks with a widespread network and/or strong and motivated foreign owner More moderate “convergence” Retail network crucial for deposit gathering Lending growth to re-start from corporate In retail, a structural gap holds for mortgage, while consumer credit already at international standards Change in demand – simpler products / services In the short term, less retail lending and less investment financing. More trade financing and in general services Risk appetite and cost of risk Quality of existing loan portfolio key in determining whether banks will be forced to concentrate on risk control or might start leveraging on new opportunities KEY CONSTRAINTS CEE banking - the medium-term scenario implies new constraints and new competitive advantages Cost control The crisis opening the way to leaner structures and deflating “bubbles” in staff and network costs Substantial change in the competitive framework ■Stronger state role ■New entrants profiting from others’ risk aversion ■Systemic banks with long term approach might benefit, provided adequate risk appetite

13 Financial penetration moderating but continuing; credit expansion more tied to deposits’ growth (1) CEE aggregate including all EU member states, Bosnia, Serbia, Croatia, Turkey, Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis After some re-balancing in 2009 and H loan-to-deposits ratio in CEE 1 to gradually increase over time Our forecast

14 Lending growth will gradually restart from corporate, with deposits also showing some moderate acceleration (1) CEE aggregate including all EU member states, Bosnia, Serbia, Croatia, Turkey, Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis

15 A structural change in the cost structure Cost-to-income ratio (%) (1) (1) CE: Czech R., Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia; SEE: Bosnia, Bulgaria, Croatia, Romania, Serbia; Other: Kazakhstan, Russia, Ukraine, Turkey Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Cost savings programmes coming into the spotlight Branch expansion plans halted during the crisis by almost all banking groups operating in the region Players who want to catch the region’s upside need to restart some investment activities as soon as market conditions allow

16 Non-performing loans to peak in 2010, but cost of risk already converging Non performing loans, in % of gross loans (1),(2) (1) Substandard, doubtful and loss on average gross loans; in Ukraine, data refer to problem credits (overdue and doubtful); in Kazakhstan, data refer to doubtful loans under category 2,4,5 and bad loans; in Romania, only doubtful and loss; (2) CE: Czech R., Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia; SEE: Bosnia, Bulgaria, Croatia, Romania, Serbia; Other: Kazakhstan, Russia, Ukraine, Turkey; (3) Generic + Specific provisions. Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Cost of Risk (provisions (3) in % Ø gross loans) (2)

17 Credit quality the key concern - our stress test (1) for the region performed at the beginning of the year still valid (1) NPL in percentage of gross loans; in Ukraine, data on non-performing loans differ from the official CB reporting as they include also off-balance sheet items; data for Croatia include off-balance sheet items; stress test has been performed assuming additional collateral haircut (30% in CIS and 10% in the rest of CEE countries). Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Non-performing loans and stress testing (1)

18 Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Size of banking profits of each period Return on Assets Banking profitability subdued in the short term as cost of risk is the main cause. Single players can perform quite differently from the market

19 AGENDA 1.How the CEE banking landscape has changed in the short term 2.Banking through the crisis 3.International players - UniCredit ready to take the upside

20 Total Assets (1) EUR bn Net Profit (2) EUR mn Number of Branches Countries of presence (3) OTP KBC Raiffeisen Erste UniCredit IntesaSP ,577 1,569 4,005 3,231 2,099 1,940 2,609 1,781 1, SocGen 1, %..% Contribution of CEE in Group Net Profit (After tax, after minority interests) Notes: (1) 100% of total assets, and profit after tax (before minority interests) for controlled companies (stake > 50%) and pro rata for non- controlled companies (stake < 50%). (2) After tax, before minority interest. (3) Including direct and indirect presence in the 25 CEE countries, excluding representative offices. (4) KBC Group recorded a loss in (5) SocGen including ProFin Bank in Ukraine. Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis 1, (4) 53% 2051% 157% 41% 5% n.s. CEE, % share in Group Assets (5) UniCredit Group is the largest player in CEE, well diversified, with 12% of group assets in the region DATA AS OF 2008

21 Winners and losers - times of change bring strong opportunities for those able to catch them Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis

22 Note: (1) T1 ratio is pro-forma Jun. 2009; CDS as of Oct. 2009, Cost of Risk as of Jun.2009, other data as of Dec. 2008; (2) ROA and CDS for each player have been calculated as weighted average of each country of presence (CEE17 perimeter, weighted for total assets of the player in each market); (3) The dimension of the balls is total controlled assets in CEE (2008); (4) It includes private and public T1 injections announced till mid October 2009; (5) Net loans; (6) CEE gap = sum of various (loans-deposits) only if loans > deposits. Loans are net loans; (7) Calculated for "International Subsidiary Banks", which include also Bank of Alexandria in Egypt Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis, Bloomberg CEE International players - Key strategic drivers (1) Profit potential of top players (2), (3) Winners to be those who enjoy an adequate risk appetite and can leverage on diversification and strong funding and network base UCG Raiffeisen Intl ErsteKBCSoGenIntesaOTP Assets in CEE, % of Group Assets Group T1 Ratio (4), % CEE Loans (5) / Deposits, % CEE GAP (6), % Group Assets Group CDS (current), bps CEE Cost of Risk, bps ~ 200> 300~ 200n.a. ~ 200 (7) > 300

23 Good market potential in 2010: UCG well positioned to catch it Note: (1) Ranking on Y axis taking into account countries’ macro and banking growth potential (based on expected GDP growth, level of financial deepening, relevance of mortgage market etc.) and risk factors (credit quality, funding gap etc.); ranking on X axis taking into account relevance of UCG CEE banks in the local market, potential for expansion and structure, quality and funding position compared to market average. Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis UCG Banks positioning Economy/banking growth potential vs. Risk environment low high low high CEE REGION: ASSESSMENT OF COUNTRY AND BANK POTENTIALS (1 ) Romania Croatia Hungary Bosnia-H. Bulgaria Baltics Ukraine Kazakhstan Serbia Slovenia Slovakia Czech R. Weight in total UCG CEE Revenues (full year 2008&H quarterly average) ~56% of UCG CEE Revenues ~79% of UCG CEE Revenues RussiaPolandTurkey

24 Source: UniCredit Group CEE Strategic Analysis Top 10 banks by total assets (Rank as of Dec.2008) Local competition likely to change: network optimization, some new entrants, state in CIS countries

25 Conclusions  Economic recovery, but risk and volatility remain. Strong regional differentiation is confirmed  Credit quality and risk appetite today’s key constraints for CEE banking  Medium term: “CEE convergence story” holds, but the banking model has to be rebalanced  The changing competitive environment means also opportunities  Winners – new entrants or consolidated players, with appropriate risk appetite for CEE, able to leverage on strong funding position (both through a strong domestic network or through international channels) and with sound risk  UCG ready to take the upside – can leverage on diversification, strong regional network and newly raised capital to strengthen and optimize its positioning in the market