The SW Sextantis stars and the evolution of cataclysmic variables

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Stellar Structure Section 6: Introduction to Stellar Evolution Lecture 18 – Mass-radius relation for black dwarfs Chandrasekhar limiting mass Comparison.
Advertisements

The Secondary Stars of Cataclysmic Variables Christian Knigge arXiv: v2 reporter:ShaoYong.
X-ray pulsars in wind-fed accretion systems 王 伟 (NAOC) July 2009, Pulsar Summer School Beijing.
SDSS finds the period minimum spike Boris Gänsicke John Southworth John Thorstensen M Dillon, P Rodríguez-Gil, A Aungwerojwit, TR Marsh, P Szkody, SCC.
EF Eri: Onset of Chromospheric Activity in the Sub-Stellar Secondary
Small is Beautiful: Cataclysmic Variables from the SDSS John Southworth Boris Gänsicke Tom Marsh + many others.
Cataclysmic Variable Stars Nataliya Ostrova Astronomical observatory of the Odessa National University, T.G. Shevchenko Park, Odessa,
RXTE Observations of Cataclysmic Variables and Symbiotic Stars Koji Mukai NASA/GSFC/CRESST and UMBC.
Christian Knigge University of Southampton School of Physics & Astronoy P. Marenfeld and NOAO/AURA/NSF Christian Knigge University of Southampton Low-Mass.
Christian Knigge University of Southampton School of Physics & Astronoy Disk Stability vs Close Binary Evolution Rob Hynes (LSU) Christian Knigge University.
Neutron Stars and Black Holes Please press “1” to test your transmitter.
2009 July 8 Supernova Remants and Pulsar Wind Nebulae in the Chandra Era 1 Modeling the Dynamical and Radiative Evolution of a Pulsar Wind Nebula inside.
Accretion in Binaries Two paths for accretion –Roche-lobe overflow –Wind-fed accretion Classes of X-ray binaries –Low-mass (BH and NS) –High-mass (BH and.
Getting to Eddington and beyond in AGN and binaries! Chris Done University of Durham.
Mass transfer in a binary system
AS 3004 Stellar Dynamics Mass transfer in binary systems Mass transfer occurs when –star expands to fill Roche-lobe –due to stellar evolution –orbit, and.
Neutron Stars and Black Holes
X-ray polarisation: Science
Compact Objects Astronomy 315 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 15.
Variable Stars clues: timescale, amplitude, light curve shape, spectrum Eclipsing: Algol ß Lyr W UMa B8-M (hrs-days) B8-G3 F0-K0 (hrs) Eruptive: single.
Variable Stars clues: timescale, amplitude, light curve shape, spectrum Eclipsing: Algol ß Lyr W UMa B8-M (hrs-days) B8-G3 F0-K0 (hrs)‏ Eruptive: single.
X-ray pulsars through the eyes of INTEGRAL A.Lutovinov, S.Tsygankov (IKI) & the discussion with J.Poutanen, M.Revnivtsev and V.Suleimanov Funasdalen 2008.
VLT spectroscopy of SDSS cataclysmic variables John Southworth Boris Gänsicke Tom Marsh.
Presented by Anna Hourihane Searching for Dwarf Novae in Globular Clusters Anna Hourihane a, Paul Callanan a and Adrienne Cool b a Department of Physics,
Spectroscopy in Stellar Astrophysics Alberto Rebassa Mansergas.
Mass Determinations of Short Period CV Donors Authors: Christopher D.J. Savoury*, S.P Littlefair*, V.S. Dhillion*, T.R. Marsh #, B.T. Gänsicke #, *The.
He star evolutionary channel to intermediate-mass binary pulsars with a short-orbital-period Chen Wen-Cong School of Physics, Peking University Department.
1 Diagnostics of thermal plasma with eV-level Resolution Manabu ISHIDA Tokyo Metropolitan University.
SSS in young stellar populations: progenitors of the “prompt” Sne Ia? Thomas Nelson NASA Goddard Space Flight Center University of Maryland – Baltimore.
High energy Astrophysics Mat Page Mullard Space Science Lab, UCL 4+5. Accretion and X-ray binaries.
Basics of Cataclysmic Variables iPTF Summer School August 28, 2014 Paula Szkody U of Washington.
INAF, Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma XI Advanced School of Astrophysics, Brazil, 1-6 September 2002.
Cataclysmic variables as hard X-ray emitters seen by INTEGRAL The X-ray Universe 2008, Granada, Spain, May R. Gális 1,2, R. Hudec 1, F. Münz 3, M.
Populations of Galactic X-ray (compact) sources visible to Spectrum-RG Revnivtsev M., Space Research Institute; Moscow, Russia.
Interacting Binary Stars Algol-Type Binaries Geary E. Albright SMP March 2, 2013.
AG Dra - a symbiotic mystery The 14th North American Workshop on Cataclysmic Variables and Related Objects March 2009, University of Arizona, Tucson,
Summary of Experiences from Observations of the Be  binary  Sco Anatoly Miroshnichenko University of North Carolina at Greensboro USA Properties of Be.
Constraints on progenitors of Classical Novae in M31 Ákos Bogdán & Marat Gilfanov MPA, Garching 17 th European White Dwarf Workshop 18/08/2010.
Cataclysmic Variables in the UV D.de Martino INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte Napoli & B.T. Gaensicke (Warwick), K.Long (STScI), T.R.Marsh.
Lars Bildsten Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics University of California Santa Barbara Unusual Binaries made via Interactions.
CV and pre-CV populations in the SDSS era Ulrich Kolb with Phil Davis (OU), Bart Willems (NWU)
Time-domain astronomy on the WHT Boris Gänsicke …or… Rare objects from wide-field surveys.
A Test for the Disruption of Magnetic Braking in Cataclysmic Variable Evolution P. Davis 1, U. Kolb 1, B. Willems 2, B. T. Gänsicke 3 1 Department of Physics.
INTRODUCTION OVERVIEW  Classical Novae (CNe) are thought to occur in binary systems known as Cataclysmic Variables (CV’s).  CV’s are close, interacting.
Binary millisecond X-ray pulsars Department of Physics University College Cork Paul Callanan and Mark Reynolds Alexei Filippenko, Department of Astronomy,
Death of Stars III Physics 113 Goderya Chapter(s): 14 Learning Outcomes:
Makishima-Nakazawa lab seminar Oct.3, 2013 An Introduction to Low- Mass X-ray Binaries Dipping LMXBs -- Suzaku observation of XB Zhongli Zhang.
Constraining close binaries evolution with SDSS/SEGUE: a representative sample of white dwarf/main sequence binaries Matthias Schreiber ESO, May 4th, 2006.
(University of Texas at El Paso) (New Mexico State University at Doña Ana) Radio Observations of Cataclysmic Variables Paul A. Mason (University of Texas.
Orbital evolution of compact Black-hole binaries and white dwarf binaries Wencong Chen Astro-ph/ Astro-ph/
PCEBs from the SDSS testing disrupted magnetic braking Matthias Schreiber Tucson, March-2009 Boris T. Gaensicke, John Southworth, S. Stylianos (Warwick)
Cataclysmic Variables: A Perfect Testbed for Variability Brokering Paula Szkody University of Washington Santa Barbara May 13, 2015.
Black holes and accretion flows Chris Done University of Durham.
Black Holes Accretion Disks X-Ray/Gamma-Ray Binaries.
RXTE has doubled the number of known cyclotron lines sources RXTE has observed multiple line sources in outburst RXTE has provided multiple visits to both.
UW SALT Science Update SALT Science Day November 2012.
The Character of High Energy Emission From The Galactic Binary LS Andy Smith Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (for the VERITAS collaboration)
Observational Evidence for Quasi-soft X-Ray Sources in Nearby Galaxies and the link to Intermediate-mass Black Holes Albert Kong and Rosanne Di Stefano.
Accretion onto Black Hole : Advection Dominated Flow
Cataclysmic Variables in K2 Paula Szkody ( U Washington ), Zhibin Dai ( Yunnan Obs ), Peter Garnavich ( Notre Dame ), Mark Kennedy ( ND+Ireland )
Three Challenges to standard assumptions 9/27/13Rosanne Di Stefano, 27 September 2013.
Accretion #3 When is the thin disk model valid? Reynolds number, viscosity Time scales in disk BH spectra Using X-ray spectra to determine BH mass and.
Accretion High Energy Astrophysics
FOUR NEW ECLIPSING CATACLYSMIC VARIABLES FROM THE SDSS John Southworth and Boris Gänsicke Department of Physics, University of Warwick, UK
Scattered Radiation and Unified Model of Active Galactic Nuclei
Very hard X-ray binaries containing white dwarfs
Multiwavelength spectroscopy of high accretion rate polars
Mariko KATO (Keio Univ., Japan) collaboration with
Observations of compact binaries using XMM-Newton
Koji Mukai (NASA/GSFC/CRESST & UMBC)
Presentation transcript:

The SW Sextantis stars and the evolution of cataclysmic variables Pablo Rodríguez Gil The SW Sextantis stars and the evolution of cataclysmic variables 5 January 2006

Summary Introduction. Cataclysmic variable structure and evolution. The SW Sextantis stars: new insights on their accretion structure. Towards a global understanding. The HQS and SDSS and CV evolution.

Astrophysical context Most of the stars are born in binary or multiple systems. ~50% of the binaries will interact at some point (Iben 1991). Many exotic astrophysical objects (e.g. binary pulsars, black holes, LMXBs, symbiotics…) are descendent from binary systems. Type Ia supernovae: accretion on to white dwarfs. Cosmological distance scale.

Compact binaries They harbour a compact stellar remnant (i.e. WD, NS or BH). Their evolution critically depends on the angular momentum loss rate (dJ/dt). t Envelope ejection AML: magnetic braking or gravitational radiation Contact Common envelope AML; a decreases Detached binary

Summary Introduction. Cataclysmic variable structure and evolution. The SW Sextantis stars: new insights on their accretion structure. Towards a global understanding. The HQS and SDSS and CV evolution.

What is a cataclysmic variable? Donor star White dwarf Primary component <M1> ~ 0.7 M Bright spot White dwarf ~ Main sequence Secondary star Late type (K-M) M2~ 0.05-1 M Gas stream Accretion disc

CVs have magnetic fields…

…accretion discs…

…or both!

The intermediate polar CVs

Magnetic accretion The height of the shock front depends on the cooling mechanisms in the column. The emission spectrum of the column: 108 K 105 K Bremsstrahlung: Hard X rays (kTbr ~ 30 keV) Compton: UV and soft X rays (kTBB ~ 40 eV) Cyclotron: IR-optical-UV (POLARISED)

Orbital period distribution Gives observational input on the AML rate Ritter & Kolb (2003): 496 systems

Flashback – 1983: ‘Disrupted magnetic braking’ Two AML mechanisms: Magnetic braking (stellar wind) & gravitational radiation MB+GR GR Paczynski & Sienkiewicz; Spruit & Ritter; Rappaport et al. (1983)

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr

The ‘period gap’

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr  - Minimum Porb of ~ 65 min

The minimum orbital period

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr  - Minimum Porb of ~ 65 min X - Pile-up of systems at Pmin

Population syntheses: the minimum period Kolb & Baraffe (1999)

The minimum orbital period

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr  - Minimum Porb of ~ 65 min X - Pile-up of systems at Pmin X - 99% of all CVs should have Porb < 2 hr

Orbital period distribution 191=38% 250=51% 55=11%

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr  - Minimum Porb of ~ 65 min X - Pile-up of systems at Pmin X - 99% of all CVs should have Porb < 2 hr X

Standard theory predictions - Paucity of the number of CVs in the range Porb=2-3 hr  - Minimum Porb of ~ 65 min X - Pile-up of systems at Pmin X - 99% of all CVs should have Porb < 2 hr X - CV density ~ Observed ~ X We are in deep trouble!

An alternative AML prescription Verbunt & Zwaan (1981) vs. Sills et al. (2000). Nevertheless, something is happening above the gap……………

Summary Introduction. Cataclysmic variable structure and evolution. The SW Sextantis stars: new insights on their accretion structure. Towards a global understanding. The HQS and SDSS and CV evolution.

The SW Sextantis stars ~50% of all CVs in the 3-4 hr strip are SW Sextantis stars. Unusual spectral features, inconsistent with a standard optically thick, geometrically thin accretion disc. Extremely high mass accretion rates. No place for such maverick systems in the standard evolution theory.

A likely magnetic nature LS Pegasi Trailed spectra. Pulsed S-wave (Rodríguez-Gil et al. 2001) Pulse separation ~ 0.1 Porb

A likely magnetic nature DW UMa (Smith et al., unpublished) V533 Her (Rodríguez-Gil & Martínez-Pais 2002) Emission-line flaring also characteristic of IPs.

A likely magnetic nature LS Pegasi PEW = 33.5  2.2 min

A likely magnetic nature LS Pegasi Circularly polarised continuum. P1 = 29.6  1.8 min 1/ P1 - 1/PEW = 1/Porb (PEW  synodic period) Cyclotron radiation B1 ~ 10 MG (Rodríguez-Gil et al. 2001)

A likely magnetic nature RX J1643.7+3402 Strong HeII l4686 emission, typical of mCVs. (Martínez-Pais, de la Cruz & Rodríguez-Gil, submitted)

A likely magnetic nature RX J1643.7+3402 Discovery of circular polarisation. P1 = 19.4 min (Martínez-Pais, de la Cruz & Rodríguez-Gil, submitted)

A likely magnetic nature V1315 Aql Variable HeII l4686 EW. P =25.5 min (coherent for at least 15 cycles).

A likely magnetic nature HS 0728+6738 Light curve oscillations (QPOs).

Summary Introduction. Cataclysmic variable structure and evolution. The SW Sextantis stars: new insights on their accretion structure. Towards a global understanding. The HQS and SDSS and CV evolution.

Magnetism and CV evolution Magnetic fields can play a crucial role in CV evolution. At least half the CVs in the 3-4 h range can be magnetic (only 3% of isolated WDs are!). 1) Masses involved. A comprehensive study of the SW Sextantis stars is therefore mandatory. 2) Search for more systems. 3) Circular polarimetry.

Weighing the components SW Sextantis stars ocassionally fade. ’LOW STATES’. (Honeycutt & Kafka 2004) The absence of DN-type outbursts during the low states supports a magnetic scenario (Hameury & Lasota 2002).

Weighing the components Photometric monitoring campaigns in the North and South. ToO programmes at the VLT, and the WHT and NOT. HS 0220+0603 Sp(2)=dM3-4 V T1 > 25000 K d ~ 0.7-1.0 kpc VLT

Weighing the components First donor star radial velocity curve at the WHT (R = 19.4). HS 0220+0603 K2 = 330 km/s i = 83º M2 = 0.3 M M1 = 1.0 M

Weighing the components WD exceeds the average mass of 0.65 M. T1 is unusually high. DW UMa has ~ 50000 K. Secular heating of the WD. Why such a high transfer rate? Fundamental to measure the physical parameters of a large sample of systems!

A growing family Search programmes in both hemispheres. Linda Schmidtobreick (ESO), Boris Gänsicke (Warwick, UK). Targets: CVs in the 3-4 h orbital period range. Asymmetric line profiles with enhanced wings. Short-time scale photometric variability (QPOs). Presence of the HeII l4686 line and Bowen. Low states. ... Preliminary results in the south show great success.

A growing family V380 Ophiuchi NTT + WHT P = 3.72 hr

A growing family AH Mensae NTT P = 2.97 hr

Summary Introduction. Cataclysmic variable structure and evolution. The SW Sextantis stars: new insights on their accretion structure. Towards a global understanding. The HQS and SDSS and CV evolution.

The HQS and the SDSS The current CV population is a mixed bag (novae, DN outbursts, rapid variablility, blue colour, X rays). Need for an UNBIASED CV sample. The HQS and the SDSS CVs are spectroscopically selected.

The HQS: 53 new CVs, 35 Porb SW Sextantis excess @ 215 min (20%)

The HQS and the SDSS The current CV population is a mixed bag (novae, DN outbursts, rapid variablility, blue colour, X-rays). Need for an UNBIASED CV sample. The HQS and the SDSS CVs are spectroscopically selected. The SDSS (g < 21) have provided ~120 new CVs.

The SDSS: 120 new CVs, 45 Porb

The HQS and the SDSS Major revision is expected… The current CV population is a mixed bag (novae, DN outbursts, rapid variablility, blue colour, X-rays). Need for an UNBIASED CV sample. The HQS and the SDSS CVs are spectroscopically selected. The SDSS (g < 21) have provided ~120 new CVs. The period distribution of the SDSS CVs will serve as a fundamental test to the standard theory. Major revision is expected…

The SW Sextantis stars and the evolution of cataclysmic variables Pablo Rodríguez Gil The SW Sextantis stars and the evolution of cataclysmic variables 5 January 2006