Impacts 101 The What, the Why, and the How of Impacts.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

POLITICS KENDALL KAUT. WHY WE NEED TO UNDERSTAND THE DA Links to nearly everything Links to nearly everything Key reason most affirmatives do not occur.

Advertisements

How to Give an Effective 2ar. 1. Think About the Big Picture  Remember: focus on offense – defend your house  Isolate 1 or 2 Impacts  Decide on impacts.

Matt Gomez Debating the Disadvantage (DA). 4 Part One: What is a Disadvantage?

By Mark Veeder-SCFI How to properly construct an AC and NC -Getting the most out of cross-ex -How to structure a rebuttal.

Debating the Politics DA By Jason Russell University of Oklahoma.

DISADVANTAGES. What is a Disadvantage?  Disadvantages are offcase positions that the negative advances to prove that the costs of the plan outweigh its.

Debating Case and Disadvantages CODI 2014 Lecture 1.

Topic Lecture: Disadvantages Rachel Photo Courtesy of BBC.

 Debating the Case Mikaela Malsin, Univ. of Georgia DUDA 2012

Before We Start…  Debate functions on two basic levels: pre-fiat and post-fiat.  Pre-fiat: everything that really has not much to do with the case,

Introduction to Debate -Negative- To access audio: Skype: freeconferencecallhd and enter # Or call and enter # © L. Husick,

Part 8 Future Consequences of Global Warming. United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) T HE K YOTO P ROTOCOL WILL BE EXTENDED.

ECONOMIC COLLAPSE ALEJANDRES GANNON UC BERKELEY. INTERNAL LINKS What causes the economy to collapse matters for The manner in which it collapse The type.

How to Debate Disadvantages. Selecting disadvantages to run  Be strategic in selecting them—a few things to remember—  Don’t run multiple disadvantages.

WHAT IS THE DARK SIDE OF GLOBALIZATION? Moises Naim’s central argument in Illicit: The globalization of crime is fundamentally changing global politics:

Most important things Keep your personal views outside the room Debaters must adapt to you Be honest about your judging experience.

Counterplans on the Topic The Honorable James R. Stevenson, Ph.D, J.D., M.D., Th.D., A.F., A.D.N.

Overview Discuss major “topic impacts” Discuss how to prepare for and win impact debates Impacts discussed will include Leadership Growth Everything else.

And other things… DISADVANTAGES. BUT FIRST, LETS REVIEW FOR THE QUIZ The quiz on Wednesday will be open note and will cover the two primary topics and.

ELECTIONS DISAD PATRIOT CLASSIC 2012 JOMEL J. ANGAT.

World Conservation Congress Beyond Zoonoses: One World - One Health, The Threat of Emerging Diseases to Human Security and Conservation, and the Implications.

To everything--turn, turn, turn…. Overview  Discuss major “topic impacts”  Discuss how to prepare for and win impact debates  Impacts discussed will.

Population and Growth Overpopulation: Proponents and Critics.

The Disadvantage Provides an added measure to vote against the affirmative plan and vote for the present system.

Debating the Case GDI Glossary Aff case Advantage Offense Defense Card Analytic.

Going Negative The Surveillance Topic. Outline for the topic I. Categories of neg ground -Go over the specific arguments we have II. Dealing.

Advanced Debate Speaking Drills Discuss First Exam Impact Calculus Practice tomorrow after school.

Policy Debate THISPAD.

Debating the case.

Affirmative Strategy Austin Layton. Overview At least, take two things from this lecture Main Advantage of Being Aff: Familiarity – Preparation Matters.

Critiques Brian Rubaie, Debate Central. What is a critique?  Disadvantages question desirability of action  Counterplans question methods of action.

Critical Debate Don’t Fear the Reaper. What Is A Critique? Way of understanding information Aff and Neg Tool.

Disadvantages “Advanced” theory.

Chapter 17: Danger… and Opportunity. Crisis Terrorism as globalization Response to terrorism as globalization Crisis as turning point and “danger and.

Impact Calculus 101 Casey Parsons. What is impact calculus? You might remember on the first powerpoint that something called “impact calculus” was referenced.

How to Debate Disadvantages. DA Uniqueness: Status of a key issue in the SQ – Example: The economy is improving Link: how the plan disrupts the SQ – Example:

How to Flow And why you should do it – always, all the time, in every round.

Parts of a DA in 1NC2ac answers to a DA Uniqueness1. Non-unique Link2. No link Internal Link3. No internal link Impact4.

 If you can convince the judge that passing your affirmative plan is a good idea, you will win the debate. Essentially, you need to prove that the affirmative.

AP World History Review Period 6: Accelerating Global Change and Realignments c CE - present.

POLICY DEBATE. WHAT IS POLICY DEBATE? A structured format for fairly arguing a topic of policy TEAM DEBATE: two teams of two students each 8 speeches.

Beginning Policy Debate: I ain’t scared ! NSDA Nationals 2014 Jane Boyd Grapevine HS, TEXAS.

REFUTATION. CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE IS JUSTIFIED BECAUSE OF THE GOOD IT CAN DO FOR THE COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE. DURING THE 1960’S, THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT DID.

Matt Gomez.  What will occur in the status quo  Factors for good uniqueness  Post-dating – things change  Brink – why is the squo good but not guaranteed.

This next section will teach you the core set of ideas that are behind every debate decision… From Junior High Novice to College Varsity, the same concepts.

The Affirmative.

BASICS OF BEING AFFIRMATIVE

Mandatory National Service

Introduction to the Negative

WELCOME TO DEBATE! Negative Basics.

With William Kim and Friends

Developed by Jenny Alme, The Harker School

Impact Calculus.

How to be negative Gabi Yamout.

Analyze a problem Conduct research Utilize principles of argumentation

Hegemony (Heg) Economic, military, and political influence a nation has. It’s America’s street cred Soft Power + Hard Power= Heg Amount of Soft + Amount.

Global Studies 9 Mrs. Hart and Mrs. Weber

Introduction to the aff

Vulnerability Factors

Wining the DA Casey Parsons.

With Pleasure says the Neg

The 2AC: Answering Disads

1AC The 1st speech given in a RND. Includes: inherency, advantages, & solvency, as well as a plan text – the textual expression of the aff. Policy option.

Negative Attacks.

The Politics DA Casey Parsons.

Introduction to the Neg

Thinking like a Policy Debater

Advanced Debate Speaking Drills Discuss First Exam Impact Calculus

Getting To Know Debate:

Especially in the Rebuttals

Presentation transcript:

Impacts 101 The What, the Why, and the How of Impacts

What is an Impact?  Uniqueness, Link, and Impact  What makes an Impact Claim Good?  What are the impacts of the 1AC?  Economy  Hegemony  Global Warming  International Cooperation?  African Instability  Zoonotic Disease Spread  And Many Others  Terrorism DA?  Nuclear Terrorism

Parts of an Impact  General Impact/”Impact Scenario” – Terrorism (Nuclear Terrorism)  Terminal Impacts  Nuclear Terrorism  Global Nuclear War and Extinction

Types of Impacts  Event Based Impacts  War  Nuclear Terrorism  Others?  Systemic/Structural Impacts  Poverty  Gendered Violence  Starvation  Rights

Impact Framing/Why Your Impact is More Important  Other Names  “Impact Filter”  “Outweighs”  “Impact Calculus”  “Impact Comparisons”  How to Frame Impacts  Probability  Time Frame  Magnitude  Interaction

Probability  How likely something is to occur  Asteroids  Poverty  Economic Decline  War  Nuclear Terrorism  Aliens?  What affects probability in a debate round?

Time Frame  How quickly something will occur  Global Warming  Economy  Asteroids  Poverty  What arguments speak to time frame in a debate?

Magnitude  How bad something would be  Asteroids  Global Warming  Nuclear Terrorism  Poverty  Extinction  “Try-or-Die”

Interaction  Case Turns/Solves DA  Tech Leadership Advantage vs. Terrorism DA  Hegemony (Keck, 14)  Global Warming  DA turns Case  Terrorism DA vs. Net Freedom Advantage  Economic Decline  Global Internet/Nationalization Bad  What are some others?  Hegemony and Economy  Subsumes  Global Nuclear War includes India/Pakistan Nuclear War

Impact Turns  Internal/General Impact  Hege Good/Bad  Economic Growth Good/Bad (“De Dev”)  Nationalization of Internet Good/Bad  External/Terminal Impact  Death Good (Malthus AKA Population)  Extinction Good (Wipeout)  War Good (Spark, Nuclear Malthus, US- China)

How to Impact Turn  _____________ = Inevitable  Better Now than Later  Impact Defense/Turn For All Other Team’s Impacts

Example: Economic Growth Bad  Neg: Economic Growth Bad (De- Development)  Aff Advantages: Net Freedom and Human Rights  Human Rights:  Credibility - WMD Conflict  International Cooperation – Laundry List  Net Freedom:  Economy – War  Global Connections: Laundry List (Global Warming, Diseases)

De-Dev  A. Economic Growth is unsustainable (collapse inevitable)  Economic Growth Causes Global Warming  Warming Causes Extinction (Collapse Now is Good)  Economic Collapse Not Cause War (Impact Defense)

Pro Tips  Better to win one well than to sort of win 2  Read impact defense to the other sides impacts  Impact Uniqueness  Global Warming (Yes/No)  Economic Decline (Yes/No)  When to Impact Turn