Presented by: Todd J. Mello, MBA, AVA, Principal How Do the ASC Companies Assess Value? A Presentation by HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. based upon its 4.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Valuing an Acquisition
Advertisements

Control vs. Minority Interests and Marketability Discounts for ESOPs Ohio Employee Ownership Center Akron/Fairlawn Hilton Fairlawn, Ohio April 16, 2004.
Healthcare Appraisers General Overview Founded in 2000 Two offices (in Florida and Colorado) Hundreds of clients across the country; thousands of completed.
Long-Term Liabilities: Bonds and Notes 12.
©CourseCollege.com 1 18 In depth: Bonds Bonds are a common form of debt financing for publicly traded corporations Learning Objectives 1.Explain market.
VALUATION METRICS USED IN PRICING LIFE INSURANCE MANAGING GENERAL AGENCIES Daryn S. Hobal, CBV, CFP.
Noble Royalties, Inc. Sellers and Investors. The Balanced World of Royalties. Presentation to IPAA Private Capital Conference | April 19, 2004.
Fundamentals of Corporate Finance, 2/e
When Thinking About Valuation…  Key valuation questions are:  What is the company worth?  What would another party pay?  Remember that valuation involves.
Mergers and Acquisitions Chapter 21  Types of Mergers  Merger Analysis  Role of Investment Bankers  Corporate Alliances  Private Equity Investments.
ESOPs for CPA Firms Corey Rosen National Center for Employee Ownership.
© 2009 Corporate Executive Board, All Rights Reserved. Health Plan Dictionary How to Understand Your Plan and Make Cost- Effective Choices.
Chapter07 Comparable Companies Analysis II Step III. Spread Key Statistics, Ratios, and Trading Multiples Step IV. Benchmark the Comparable Companies Step.
Chapter 14 Forms of Business Organization
Valuing an Acquisition
If someone could tell you how to save thousands of dollars in taxes would you listen? Yes? Answer the following 3 questions…
Valuation: Comps and Premiums Executive Masters Program Tim Thompson.
C A V Employee Stock Ownership Plans Basics of ESOP Stock Valuation 21 st Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference Fairlawn, OH April 20, 2007 Richard.
D UFF & P HELPS, LLC Valuing ESOP Shares Presented by Lee Bloom 18 th Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference D UFF & P HELPS, LLC Akron, OH April 16,
2 Key Valuation Issues I. The Value of Shares for Physician Buy-in and II. Valuing Compensation Relationships in Under Arrangement Models 14 th Annual.
©2009, The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved 3-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter Three Interest Rates and Security Valuation.
CPA, MBA BY RACHELLE AGATHA, CPA, MBA Bonds Payable & Investment in Bonds Slides by Rachelle Agatha, CPA, with excerpts from Warren, Reeve, Duchac.
Health Insurance Law and You Mr. Blais. Managed Care Plans These involve arrangements between the insurance companies and a certain network of health-care.
Company Outlook April 1, 2014 Harry Fleming, CFO 1.
Valuation Terms and Ratios Tanveer Chandok (Director of Mentorship)
How To Value Your Business Presented to the 43rd Annual Business Administration Conference NRMCA October 24,2001 New Orleans.
Chapter 14 Farm Business Organization and Transfer
Chapter 9 Non-owner Financing.
Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation Presented by Lorin E. Patterson, JD, Partner, Reed Smith LLP Todd J. Mello, ASA, AVA, MBA, Principal,
© 2012 VMG Health AARON MURSKI SENIOR MANAGER VMG HEALTH ASC Valuation Update & Current M&A Trends.
FOR WHAT IT’S WORTH: HOW AN APPRAISER VALUES YOUR BUSINESS Presented by Sherry C. Smith To The Rotary Club of Pawleys Island May 3, 2007.
Exhibit ES-1. Synergistic Strategy: Potential Cumulative Savings Compared with Current Baseline Projection, 2013–2023 Total NHE Federal government State.
Value: An Introduction to Alternative Structures and Transactions Involving MHS Presentation to the City Assets & Enterprises Sub- Committee of the Committee.
Chapter McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Cost of Capital 11.
Goal of the Lecture: Understand how to properly value a stock or bond.
Leverage Buyouts Arzac, Chapter 13.
Valuing Business Methods of valuation DCF valuation (e.g. using WACC) DCF valuation (e.g. using WACC) Relative valuation (comparables) Relative valuation.
Annual Report NovaMed Kristin Catlin ACG2021 Sect. 004.
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT Investment in Maa TV Deal Update November 15, 2013.
Long-Term Liabilities: Bonds and Notes 12.
Long-Term Liabilities: Bonds and Notes
3 - 1 © 2005 Accounting 1/e, Terrell/Terrell Organizing a Business: Equity and Debt Financing Chapter 3.
Chart 2.1: Number of Community Hospitals,(1) 1993 – 2013
© 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part. Company.
Benefit Trends in Minnesota’s Small Group and Individual Health Insurance Markets State Health Research and Policy Interest Group Meeting June 24, 2006.
Tri-Party Arrangements: Considering All Perspectives Presented by, Max Reiboldt, CPA, President / CEO Coker Group 2015 New York Metro ASC Symposium October.
Business Plan By : Paula Grundy HIP AND KNEE: TRANSITIONAL HOME.
Physician Options in the ASC Marketplace October,
Robert Goettling, Principal, The Bloom Organization LLC Curtis Bernstein, Managing Director of Valuation & Transaction Services, Altegra Health October.
Trends and Issues in Health Care presented by Dan Kosmicki, Tom Hamernik, Daryl Obermeyer.
Lonni Steven Wilson, Medaille College chapter 11 Capital Budgeting.
THE INS & OUTS OF AN OUT-OF-NETWORK STRATEGY FOR NON-GOVERNMENTAL PAYORS & PATIENTS.
CONFIDENTIAL – NON-BINDING DISCUSSION DOCUMENT Embassy Row Discussion Document March 26, 2008.
Expanding Your Sales Through multi-life opportunities.
Health Insurance Anyone been to the doctor this year? Have they used the health plan in the past year that they know of?
An Introduction to SLA. MISSION STATEMENT Senior Lifestyle Associates, Inc. is capitalizing on unprecedented opportunities in the Senior Living industry.
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT Investment in Maa TV Deal Update November 15, 2013.
Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation
Types of Business Structures
Valuation Issues for ASCs
Investor Presentation March, 2015
CHAPTER 2 Organizational Trends.
Exam 3 Review.
ASC Transactions – Current Analysis & Valuation Trends
Investment Analysis.
ANESTHESIA MACHINES MARKET - SIZE, TREND, SHARE, OPPORTUNITY ANALYSIS & FORECAST,
Financial Metrics October 10, Jigar Bhakta.
Investment in Maa TV Deal Update November 13, 2013.
Presentation transcript:

Presented by: Todd J. Mello, MBA, AVA, Principal How Do the ASC Companies Assess Value? A Presentation by HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. based upon its 4 th Annual ASC Valuation Survey Presented June 23, 2006

Presentation Outline  Participating Companies  Why do we care?  Company Profiles  Factors Impacting Value  Valuation Trends and Multiples

Participating Companies Affiliated Surgery Center Group, LLC AmSurg Corporation * Blue Chip Surgical Center Partners Health Inventures, LLC HealthMark Partners, Inc. HealthSouth Corporation * Meridian Surgical Partners National Surgical Care NovaMed, Inc. * Pinnacle III Regent Surgical Health, LLC Surgis Inc. Symbion Healthcare * Titan Health Corporation United Surgical Partners International ** Publicly Traded

Why Do We Care?  Detail to actual transactions occurring in marketplace provides valuable insight in the private company valuation process (i.e., “sanity check” to Income Approach)  Provides mechanism for ASC owners to readily estimate value  Provides mechanism for ASC owners to monitor reasonableness of formula- driven buy/sell provisions in governing documents

Company Profiles  Public – 5; Private – 10  ASCs under ownership/management  10 or fewer: 4  11-30:5   51+4

Company Profiles  Preferred number of physician owners  Fewer than 10:13%  11-20:60%  The more, the better27%  Most desired specialties: orthopedics; ENT; GI; pain management; podiatry, ophthalmology; and general surgery  Preferred equity ownership percentage

Company Profiles  Management Fees Charged  None:1  Less than 4%1  4% to 4.9%0  5% to 5.9%9  6% to 6.9%3  7% or higher1  Acquisition Strategy

Company Profiles  Determining Value for Recurring Transactions (i.e., investments and divestitures)  Independent appraisal14%  Formula set forth in governing documents72%  Other14%  Periods incorporated in valuation/purchase offer  Trailing 12 months75%  YTD, annualized12.5%  Other12.5%  Primary earnings measure relied upon in valuation  EBITDA less i-bearing debt79%  Net Income7%  Other14%

Factors Impacting Value FactorNoneMod.High Opportunities for Growth014%86% Age of Owners064%36% Managed Care Penetration 064%36% Extent of hospital penetration 43% 14% Nature of specialties7%36%57% Existing presence in market 077%33% Hospital affiliation/ownership 14%57%29% Extent of MD ownership021%79% Extent of indebtedness21%50%29% Size of center057%43%

Factors Impacting Value  MedPAC rate freezes  2004: 54% No Impact; 38% generally lowered valuation multiples  2005: 100% No Impact  Existence of barriers to entry (e.g. CON)  92% report paying a premium for an ASC in a CON state  Value of premium: 20% - less than a 0.25 multiple; 30% to 0.50 multiple; 40% to 0.75 multiple; 10% - greater than a 0.75 multiple  Out-of-Network benefits  64% report that the existence detracts from value  36% report that it depends upon the extent of out-of-network contracts

Valuation Trends & Multiples  In the past year, what best describes your observations related to the following:  Acquisition activity: 57% report no change form previous year; 43% report increasing activity  Competition for acquisitions

Valuation Trends & Multiples  What valuation multiples are you most typically observing in the marketplace during the past 12 months for controlling interests?  In the past year, what best describes the multiples paid or considered by your company?  67% report no change form previous year  33% report increasing multiples (i.e., higher valuations)

Valuation Trends & Multiples  Discounts involved in the purchase/sale of minority interests:

Valuation Trends & Multiples  By comparison, publicly traded “pure play” ASC companies were valued in the market during their 2005 fiscal year as follows Company NameMarket Value ($ in millions) Enterprise Value (“EV”) ($ in millions) EBITDA ($ in millions) EV/EBITDA Multiple AmSurg$727.9$825.0$ X Symbion$494.9$580.0$ X USPI$1,370.0$1,590.0$ X NovaMed$159.7$167.2$ X Group Average17.6X

HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. Florida Office 75 N.W. 1 st Avenue, Suite 201 Delray Beach, FL phone (561) fax (561) Colorado Office 858 Happy Canyon Road, Suite 240 Castle Rock, CO phone (303) fax (303)