Dr. Christof Veit BQS Institut for Quality and Patient Safety Dusseldorf / Hamburg Quality and Regulation. Experiences from the German Health Care System.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Quality Benchmarking and Dialog Dr. Christof Veit, Hamburg The Structured Dialog National Quality Benchmarking in Germany Annual Research Meeting 2006.

Advertisements

Developing our Commissioning Strategy Richard Samuel.

Hospital and Physician Outcomes Reports Presenter: Brian Paciotti, PhD.

Dr. Robert Bree Collaborative: Improved Quality and Outcomes through Transparency and Collaboration Steve Hill, Bree Collaborative Chair Rachel Quinn,

March 28 th, 2014 Total Joint Replacements Community Dialogue.

Almagro 26 October 2006 Dr L J Patterson OBE MB FRCP Dr L J Patterson Consultant Physician OBE MB FRCP Quality of Care in UK National Health Service.

Patient-Focused Funding & Payment by Results The UK Experience CEO Forum, Kananaskis, Alberta February 16, 2009 Robert J. Bell – Chief Executive Royal.

Key Health Data Launch The Role of the CBSA September 08.

Session 3: Can the Best Practice Tariff and price benchmarking lead to better care? Elaine Young Director of Operations National Joint Registry & Peter.

Bringing Transparency to Quality Outcomes 2015 Washington State of Reform Policy Conference January 8, 2015.

NICE in a changing world National Leading Improvement for Health and Well-being programme 12 May 2011 Gillian Mathews Implementation consultant.

1 Measuring health care quality at the international level: Challenges and preliminary results from the OECD Health Care Quality Indicators Project Ed.

Healthcare Associated Infection Prevention and Control Program: Campaign to Reduce Hospital Acquired Infections Goal 3: Mandatory Reporting & Oversight.

The German Health Care System and the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) Norbert Schmacke FJC/ University of Bremen.

Brian Day Past President Canadian Medical Association Kananaskis February 16 th 2009 Coping with Change in Canada: Best and Emerging Practice.

Health Economics & Policy 3 rd Edition James W. Henderson Chapter 16 Medical Care Systems Worldwide.

Health Care Inspectorate patientsafety and quality in hospitals.

Achieving Quality in a New Era Paul Dunnery Operations Director Alzheimer’s Society.

Saving the lives of mothers and babies and of many others.

Health care reform in the Netherlands – role of the employer

PHC4 - “Pay for Performance” Toolkit Mike Berney Community and Purchaser Relations Manager Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council ALPHA BENEFITS.

Paediatric Palliative Care and Policy Development Dr Chantal Wood Chair EAPC Paediatric Taskforce National Health Ministry PPC Taskforce Head of the Paediatric.

How to facilitate supervision? How to improve quality? How to improve transparency? Dutch hospitals.

Spotlight on the Federal Health Care Reform Law. 2. The Health Care and Education Affordability Reconciliation Act of 2010 was signed March 30, 2010.

Nancy Clarke Thomas Syltebo “Am I Doing This Right? Quality Measurement and Standards of Care.

Conducting Research in the UK National Health Service Dr Stephen Brett Reader In Critical Care.

Co-ordinated by: World Health Organization European Office for Integrated Health Care Services, Barcelona Technically supported by: WHO Collaborating Centre.

Vermont Department of Banking, Insurance, Securities and Health Care Administration Act 53 of 2003 Hospital Community Reports Community Needs Assessments.

The Leapfrog Hospital Recognition Program A program of The Leapfrog Group.

Texas Health Care Reform Coverage Institute September 26, 2007.

Dr. Christof Veit, Hamburg The Structured Dialog National Quality Benchmarking in Germany Bipartisan Congressional Health Policy Conference, Miami 2006.

Enhancing Quality – Dementia Pathway Dr Kate Jefferies Dementia Clinical Lead.

Bariatric Surgery: Outcomes and Safety MISS 2010 Bruce M. Wolfe, MD Professor of Surgery Oregon Health & Science University.

In Healthcare, Is More Always Better? Thérèse Stukel Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Toronto Dartmouth Medical School, US Graham Woodward Cancer.

Lessons Learned from the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) Congenital Database September 25, 2015 Robert J. Dabal, MD Associate Professor of Surgery.

The Swiss Health Care System Robert E. Leu University of Bern November 2008.

DIFFICULT DECISIONS IN HEALTH CARE Presentation to OJHOSC Dr Ljuba Stirzaker Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust 13 March 2008 ITEM JHO8(a) JHO3.MAR1308R03.ppt.

An Honest Conversation about Cost Drivers Paul Fletcher, M.D. Group Health September 12, 2013.

Rural Hospital Collaborative for Excellence Using IT AHRQ UC1 HS15431 Kathy Mechler, MS, RN, CPHQ Texas A&M University Health Science Center Rural and.

Performance Measurement & Public Reporting: Consumer Perspective and Principles To schedule a presentation of “Performance Measurement & Public Reporting”

This incentive improves productivity, rewards innovation and encourages moderate risk taking Profit Motive.

Designing a national health care performance system in the Netherlands: ZORGBALANS prof dr Gert Westert.

The DUTCH approach Top-down and bottom-up approach of malnutrition leads to a decrease in malnutrition prevalence rates in all health care settings in.

A Comparison of Quality of Care in General Hospitals, Specialty Hospitals, and Ambulatory Surgery Centers Cheryl Fahlman, PhD Phil Kletke, PhD Chuck Wentworth,

Inpatient Quality Reporting In Colorado Sept HCUP User Group Meeting.

1 Quality of Care and Patient Safety: Impact on Healthcare January 22, 2009 Presenter: F. Lisa Murtha, Practice Leader and Managing Director, Huron Consulting.

Pay for Performance Value based purchasing Maarten Boon.

NAT as part of routine tests ? I disagree ! Dr Anjali Arun Mysore.

NICE Policy Update Michael Rawlins Chairman, National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, London Emeritus Professor, University of Newcastle.

European Health Forum Gastein Workshop International Quality Comparisons 6 October 2005 "Measuring the patient's perspective: Current and future work in.

1 Brussels 16 January What is HOPE? HOPE is an excellent example of the diversity of European healthcare system What is HOPE? HOPE is an excellent.

Creating incentives for better quality: Lessons from the English NHS Jennifer Field, Associate Director National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.

What is good health? How would you describe good health for yourself? How would you describe good health for those you love? How would you describe a good.

RTHL Board to Board Meeting Dr Andrew Everett SELHIN Primary Care Lead (Lanark, Leeds & Grenville)

Hanke Timmermans & Anne-Berit Harmsen CBO & National Action Programme Self-management.

PARALLELSESSION III. Follert, P. & Doebler, K. Use of administrative data from health insurances for mandatory nationwide performance measurement in Germany.

Multinational Comparisons of Health Systems Data, 2011

Healthcare Quality Data:

The German Health Care System and the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA)

Annual relative resource use*

Highmark QualityBLUE Pay for Performance Program

Enhancing Quality – Dementia Pathway Dementia Clinical Lead

Health System in Germany

Hospitals Role in The Accountable Marketplace

Provider Peer Grouping: Project Overview

Annual Quality Framework

Market Mover? The Emerging Role of CMS in P4P

The Health Care Reform 2002 – 2004 Slovak Republic

Medicaid Collaboration

Presentation transcript:

Dr. Christof Veit BQS Institut for Quality and Patient Safety Dusseldorf / Hamburg Quality and Regulation. Experiences from the German Health Care System. London, 14th February 2013

Solidarity is a core social value in European culture. Good quality Health Care for each citizen is a central part of our European societies.

Self Government Ministry of Health: Framework for the Health Care System Self Government: Joint Federal Committee Sickness Funds Hospitals Practices Patients Services. Prices. Quality.

Self Government Regulation of Quality Regulation of Care Regulation of Quality Management

Self Government Regulation of Quality Regulation of Care Structure Process Case volume

Self Government Regulation of Quality Regulation of Quality Management National mandatory benchmarking Public reporting Sample testing

Measurement areas:30 Quality indicators:289 (88% risk adjusted) Data sets: Million 96.6% Hospitals:1, % Data validity:good (different validation procedures) Results:ranging from „requires national level intervention“ to „excellent“ National Mandatory Benchmarking

Benchmarking: Projects. >30 Projects on the National Level: Hip- and Knee Replacement Cholecystectomy Gynaecological Operations Breast Cancer Operations Obstetrics Cardiac Pace Makers Coronary Catheters Heart Surgery Decubital Ulcers Community acquired Pneumonia Transplants and others

Admission Discharge IndicationProcess (short term) (long term) 20% 60% Distribution of quality indicators Outcome Hospital Care

National Mandatory Benchmarking Nat. Institute Experts 1,708 Hospitals in 16 States project offices

Project Office Experts National Benchmarking

Project Office Experts numerical outliers Structured Dialog

Project Office Experts qualitative outliers Correct! Check! Steering Committee National Committee and National Experts Structured Report

Project Office Experts regional meetings Regional Learning.

Self Government Regulation and Culture

Self Government Patient involvement.

Quality Improvement starts with a narcistic wound: I am not as brilliant as I would love to believe. And besides of 1000 excuses: I could have done better. I do better.

personal responsibility and system design

Quality is team work. Sharing, networking institutions instead of castles.

Self Government Pay for Performance?

P4P Modell

Self Government You cannot replace primary motivation with financial incentives.

Pay for Performance Quality of health care is guaranteed by primary motivation.

Pay for Performance There also are limits to sanctions.

Quality and Market.

Market lives from differences. Trust comes from equal quality of care at all places. Quality improvement is about lowering variation towards better care. Good quality care + Patient’s choice.

But: market mechanisms also want to differentiate access to care. Prime offers for a smaller number of wealthy patients. Solidarity? We call it: the freedom of the free fox in the free hen house.

Quality rule: Work with motivation but without pain no change.

Self Government Quality: Regulation and Culture

Quality