© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Predicting Persistently High Primary Care Use James M. Naessens, MPH Macaran A. Baird,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

What characteristics of patients and local health systems are associated with ED utilization?

Advertisements

Accra, Ghana October 19-23, Extending Health Insurance: How to Make It Work DESIGN ELEMENT 4: BENEFITS PACKAGES AND COST CONTAINMENT 2/9/2014October.

1 Physicians Involved in the Care of Patients with Recently Diagnosed Cancer CanCORS Provider Composition Writing Group Academy Health Annual Research.

Cost-sharing for Emergency Care and Unfavorable Clinical Events: Findings from the Safety And Financial Ramifications of ED Copayments (SAFE) Study AcademyHealth.

Paying for Care Coordination Gerard Anderson, PhD Johns Hopkins University.

Update on Recent Health Reform Activities in Minnesota.

Medical Insurance Chapter 18 ICBS 120.

Overview of Rural Health Care Ethics Training materials from Rural Health Care Ethics: A Manual for Trainers. WA Nelson and KE Schifferdecker, Dartmouth.

Patient Encounters and Billing Information Chapter 3

Employee Wellness Committee – January 29, 2009 Lee Covella / Paul Hackleman / Bill Tugaw.

Evidence for Transition Programs in Cystic Fibrosis Care Advanced Lung Disease Program : Adult Cystic Fibrosis.

Exhibit 1 NOTES: Other setting of usual care includes: neighborhood or family health center, free standing surgery center, rural health clinic, company.

Utilization of Integrated Hepatitis Services Among People with a History of Injection Drug Use in an STD Clinic 2004 National STD Prevention Conference.

Bill Stockdale, MBA, Celeste Beck, MPH, Lisa Hulbert, PharmD, Wu Xu, PhD Utah Department of Health Comparison with other methods of analysis: 1) Assessing.

Improving Office Care for Chest Pain Thomas D. Sequist, MD MPH Associate Professor of Medicine and Health Care Policy Brigham and Women ’ s Hospital, Division.

ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFITS & HHS GUIDANCE JAMES GOLDEN, PHD DEPUTY ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER - DHS FEBRUARY 8, 2011 Health and Human Services Reform Committee.

HIV and Aging Kathleen K Casey, MD Director, AIDS Ambulatory Care Center Jersey Shore University Medical Center.

Lafayette Parish School System Joint Meeting of the Board Insurance Committee & Employee Insurance Advisory Committee May 2006.

Cap.org v. # Pathologists’ Role in Coordinated Care and Managing Patient Populations.

Using AHRQ Prevention Quality Indicators to Assess Program Performance in Medicaid Managed Care Sandra K. Mahkorn MD, MPH, MS Chief Medical Officer Wisconsin.

Quality Improvement Research Methods: Issues in Detecting Changes in Clinician Performance Haya R. Rubin, M.D., Ph.D. Lynne Nemeth, R.N., Ph.D. Hoangmai.

CATHERINE ALBIN PHD MD REGIONAL PICU DIRECTOR KAISER PERMANENTE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA 2015 VPS USER CONFERENCE MARCH Alignment of a Health Care System.

Printed by Asthma in Women of Color and/or Low Income Noreen M. Clark, PhD, Molly Gong, MD, Sijian Wang, MS, Melissa Valerio, MPH,

Decision Trees Farrokh Alemi, Ph.D.. Coming Up How to construct a decision tree? –Components of a tree –Interviewing decision makers How to analyze a.

Medicare OT 232 Chapter 10 1OT 232 Chapter 10. Medicare Established?! – 1965 Managed by?! – CMS under… – DHHS Eligible beneficiaries – 65+ – Disabled.

1 Canadian Institute for Health Information. Disparities in Primary Health Care Experiences Among Canadians With Ambulatory Care Sensitive Conditions.

+ HEALTH INSURANCE TERMS TO KNOW. + Premiums A premium is a fixed dollar amount that will stay the same each month whether you use the doctor a lot or.

1 Managed Health Care Pricing for Provider Arrangements Presented by Vanessa Olson Seminar on Health and Managed Care October 18, 1999.

Risk Adjustment Data For Business Insight Health Care Service Corporation September 2012.

What is it? An organization of physicians or other health care professionals that provides a broad and nearly complete range of health care services on.

Variation in the Delivery of Medical Care: Is More Better? Todd Gilmer, PhD Professor of Health Policy and Economics Department of Family and Preventive.

The Business Case for Bidirectional Integrated Care: Mental Health and Substance Use Services in Primary Care Settings and Primary Care Services in Specialty.

Risk Adjustment Models

Racial Differences in Quality of Care for Bipolar Disorder Center for Health Equity Research and Promotion Departments of Medicine and Psychiatry, University.

Excess cost growth in Medicare, Medicaid, and all other health care spending Source: CBO, A Federal Perspective on Health Care Policy and Costs, 2008.

Management & Health Delivery Systems (MGMS-101) By Dr. Hoda Zaki Prof. Hospital Administration Chair Department of Health Administration &Behavioral Sciences.

Veterans Using and Uninsured Veterans Not Using VA Health Care Karin Nelson, MD, MSHS Gordon A. Starkebaum, MD Gayle E. Reiber, PhD, MPH VA Puget Sound.

Gregory Sawicki MD, MPH Skyler Kelemen BA Jay Berry MD, MPH Holly Gooding MD Maryanne Quinn MD Elissa Weitzman ScD, MSc.

Tele-Medicine Risk Adjustment. Agenda What is Medicare Risk adjustment? Conclusion Summery of project specification Why Tele-Medicine? Team Workflow Design.

Prescription Drug Expenditures and Healthcare Burdens in the Medicaid Population G. Edward Miller, Jessica S. Banthin and Thomas M Selden AHRQ Conference.

How do low-income limited English proficient adults use ambulatory health services when they have health insurance and access to interpreters? Elinor A.

Overview Essential Health Benefits in the Affordable Care Act Deborah Reidy Kelch January 26, 2012 California Health Benefit Exchange Board Meeting.

Hospital racial segregation and racial disparity in mortality after injury Melanie Arthur University of Alaska Fairbanks.

 Agreed upon fees paid for coverage of medical benefits for a defined benefit period. Premiums can be paid by employers, unions, employees, or shared.

Quality Improvement and Care Transitions in a Medical Home Maryland Learning Collaborative May 21, 2014 Stephanie Garrity, M.S., Cecil County Health Officer.

University of Michigan Health System Children with Special Health Care Needs: Looking Back; Looking Forward Gary L. Freed, MD, MPH Director, Division of.

Medical Insurance Copyright © Texas Education Agency, All rights reserved. 19.

Community Asthma Prevention Program Improving Asthma Outcomes through Closing the Circle of Care Community Asthma Prevention Program Improving Asthma Outcomes.

Pediatric Asthma Hospitalizations: Impact of Managed Care in the Patterns of Outpatient Healthcare Utilization Capriles, JA., Rodríguez, MH., Rios, R.,

1 Other State Programs: CCS, GHPP and CHDP. 2 CCS - California Children Services Started in 1927 California’s program for providing diagnosis, treatment,

Advancing Knowledge to Improve Health Evaluation of the Effects of Complex Care Management on Health-Related Quality of Life within a Medicaid Population.

Innovations in Primary Care: Implementing Clinical Care Management in Primary Care Practices Judith Steinberg, MD, MPH Deputy Chief Medical Officer Jeanne.

Shubhangi Arora1; Eden Haverfield2; Gabriele Richard2; Susanne B

Health Insurance Why do people get health insurance?

Burden of acute otitis media, recurrent otitis media and tympanostomy tube insertion in urban, minority children less than 7 years of age in Boston: Comparison.

Mental and Behavioral Health Services

Models of Primary Care Primary Care – FAMED 530

Use of BCBSRI Primary Care Provider Profile to Improve Performance

Patient Encounters and Billing Information Chapter 3

AN OVERVIEW OF JOHN HOPKINS ACG-PREDICTIVE MODELING TOOL AND UNDERSTANDING RESOURCE UTILIZATION BANDS (RUBs)

Resolving outcome disparities in depression for minority primary care patients with collaborative care management Kurt B. Angstman, MS MD Associate Professor.

White River Junction, Vermont VA Outcomes Group REAP

John Tooker MD,MBA,FACP Chief Executive Officer/EVP

Robert Hall Director, Government Relations 6/12/2018

Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Zahid Chairman, Department of Psychiatry,

Severe Chronic Conditions Substantial Service Needs

Susan R. Kirsh, MD, MPH, P. Michael Ho, MD, PhD, David C. Aron, MD, MS

Presented to the System Leadership Team July 9, 2010 Robin Kay, Ph.D.

The Research Question Continuity of care: does having the same primary care provider over time matter? S.T. Wong, A. Katz, Peterson, S., & Taylor, C. Does.

Provider comparison reveals no difference between training levels

Presentation transcript:

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Predicting Persistently High Primary Care Use James M. Naessens, MPH Macaran A. Baird, MD, MS Holly K. Van Houten, BA David J. Vanness, PhD Claudia R. Campbell, PhD James M. Naessens, MPH Macaran A. Baird, MD, MS Holly K. Van Houten, BA David J. Vanness, PhD Claudia R. Campbell, PhD

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Identification of Costly Patients Many factors related to high use Patient demographics Certain diagnoses Chronic conditions Disability Severity of disease Prior use (health care and medications) Many factors related to high use Patient demographics Certain diagnoses Chronic conditions Disability Severity of disease Prior use (health care and medications)

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Focus of Identification Total health care spending Case management Hospitalization Disease management Total health care spending Case management Hospitalization Disease management

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Physician Visits Employee Health Plan, 1997

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Physician Visits - Specialty Care

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Physician Visits - Primary Care

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Reactions Expect a small number of individuals to have a large number of visits to specialists; however, we did not expect such concentration of visits to primary care providers

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Persistence of High Primary Care Use

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. High Primary Care Use A large percentage of primary care use may be incurred by patients seeking help on non- medical issues (Lundin, 2001; Sweden)

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Dr. Bairds Questions Do we have people who are over-serviced, but under-served? Can we predict who they might be (and possibly intervene)? Do we have people who are over-serviced, but under-served? Can we predict who they might be (and possibly intervene)?

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Study Population 54,074 eligible patients with research authorization 6% of population excluded due to HIPAA and Minnesota regulations Outpatient office visits: Primary care: Family medicine General internal medicine General pediatrics Obstetrics 54,074 eligible patients with research authorization 6% of population excluded due to HIPAA and Minnesota regulations Outpatient office visits: Primary care: Family medicine General internal medicine General pediatrics Obstetrics

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Methods Identify factors associated with persistent, high primary care use: 10+ visits in two consecutive years Develop logistic model on data Confirm model on data Identify factors associated with persistent, high primary care use: 10+ visits in two consecutive years Develop logistic model on data Confirm model on data

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved.

Potential Risk Factors Age Gender Diagnoses Employee/dependent status (During timeframe: no copays, deductibles) Age Gender Diagnoses Employee/dependent status (During timeframe: no copays, deductibles)

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Clinical Risk Factors Adjusted Clinical Groups – Johns Hopkins Based on all diagnoses for patient in year Clinically meaningful Developed by medical experts in primary care Predictive of utilization and resource costs Adjusted Clinical Groups – Johns Hopkins Based on all diagnoses for patient in year Clinically meaningful Developed by medical experts in primary care Predictive of utilization and resource costs

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Going from Diagnosis Codes to ACGs Diagnosis Codes Adjusted Diagnosis Groups (ADGs): 32 (ACGs)-Adjusted Clinical Groups Age, Gender ©1998 The Johns Hopkins University School of Hygiene and Public Health

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Illustrative ACG Decision Tree Assignment is based on age, gender, ADGs, and optionally, delivery status and birthweight There are actually around 106 ACGs Entire Population ACG XACG YACG Z ©1998 The Johns Hopkins University School of Hygiene and Public Health

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. To better understand what factors may be important in predicting primary care visits, we used the ADGs as our clinical risk factor

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Model Results – Overall: Development

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Persistent High Primary Care Use by Model Score

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Yield of Model Score - Adults Using a score of 1 or greater Sensitivity – 80.3%Specificity – 62.7% Using a score of 2 or greater Sensitivity – 50.3%Specificity – 81.2% Area under ROC curve – Using a score of 1 or greater Sensitivity – 80.3%Specificity – 62.7% Using a score of 2 or greater Sensitivity – 50.3%Specificity – 81.2% Area under ROC curve – 0.794

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Yield of Model Score - Pediatrics Prediction among pediatrics is not useful: score of 1 or greater Sensitivity %Specificity % score of 2 or greater Sensitivity %Specificity % Prediction among pediatrics is not useful: score of 1 or greater Sensitivity %Specificity % score of 2 or greater Sensitivity %Specificity %

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Persistence of High Primary Care Use – Confirmatory Sample

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Comparison of Model Scores 1998 vs 1999

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Yield of Model Score – Adults Confirmatory Data Using a score of 1 or greater Sensitivity – 75.8%Specificity – 57.9% Using a score of 2 or greater Sensitivity – 49.8%Specificity – 80.0% Area under ROC curve – New persistent – Recurrent – Using a score of 1 or greater Sensitivity – 75.8%Specificity – 57.9% Using a score of 2 or greater Sensitivity – 49.8%Specificity – 80.0% Area under ROC curve – New persistent – Recurrent – 0.594

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Discussion Unstable chronic medical conditions were predictive of continued high use. Good candidates for disease management. Unstable chronic medical conditions were predictive of continued high use. Good candidates for disease management.

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Discussion 2 Time-limited minor psychosocial conditions, minor signs and symptoms, and see and reassure conditions were also predictive. These over-serviced, under-served may benefit from alternative social support services or integrated consultations with primary care providers to better address patient needs through non medical approaches. Time-limited minor psychosocial conditions, minor signs and symptoms, and see and reassure conditions were also predictive. These over-serviced, under-served may benefit from alternative social support services or integrated consultations with primary care providers to better address patient needs through non medical approaches.

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Discussion 3 Scoring model was able to consistently identify a sizeable portion of the persistent high users, but not effective among pediatric patients.

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Limitations Single group of covered employees and dependents in small urban setting in a Midwestern state. Fee-for-service coverage with no co-payments, co-insurance or deductibles at time of study. Limited risk factors considered. Single group of covered employees and dependents in small urban setting in a Midwestern state. Fee-for-service coverage with no co-payments, co-insurance or deductibles at time of study. Limited risk factors considered.

© 2004 – Mayo College of Medicine, Mayo Clinic. All rights reserved. Further Research Family Practice team is evaluating reflective interviews and integrated consultations among patients with high primary care use. Need to evaluate cost effectiveness of proposed interventions. Family Practice team is evaluating reflective interviews and integrated consultations among patients with high primary care use. Need to evaluate cost effectiveness of proposed interventions.