Individuals with Lower Literacy Levels: Accessing and Navigating Healthcare Herbert, H. 1, Adams, J. 1, Lowe, W. 1, Leuddeke, J. 2 1 - Faculty of Health.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
GOOD QUESTIONS FOR GOOD HEALTH
Advertisements

"What I really needed was the truth" Exploring the information needs of people with CRPS. Sharon Grieve 1,2, Jo Adams 2, Candida McCabe 1,3. 1 Royal National.
ESTABLISHED 1875 – 125 YEARS OF EXCELLENCE Developing Reflexivity in Students: an essential component for clinical reasoning and decision making Dr Marie.
Relieving distress, transforming lives Data Collection in IAPT The Importance of collecting data in IAPT-compliant services (References: The IAPT Data.
Health Sciences and Practice & Medicine Dentistry and Veterinary Medicine Higher Education Academy Subject Centres Wendy Hardyman, Mark Stacey, Alison.
Personal Budgets and the carer - service user relationship: developing the knowledge base about carers and personalisation Carers Federation and De Montfort.
Nursing Care Management of Dying Persons in Rural & Urban Areas of Ontario May 19, 2010 Sharon Kaasalainen, RN, PhD.
Involving acute hospital inpatients in the evaluation of an occupational therapy service Cathy Robertson Senior occupational therapist Wirral Hospital.
Developing Best Practice in Ascertaining LMP in Adolescent Patients Ami Cook Dr Christine Ferris.
Improving health outcomes across England by providing improvement and change expertise How to Measure Patient Activation Measuring Patient Activation In.
Awareness of Speech and Language Therapy amongst Pakistani women in Edinburgh Alia Yasin* and Ineke Mennen** *NHS Forth Valley, **Bangor University.
Collaboration, Evidence Based Practice and Shared Governance: A coming together ! Richelle Buckley, Professional Development Facilitator, Heywood, Middleton.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence November–December 2006.
The spatial dimensions of Skills for Life workplace provision Dr. Natasha Kersh Institute of Education,, University of London Paper prepared for the Seminar.
1 The Ford Wheel Results of pilot 1 Various forms of analysis were carried out on a large data set Significant results occur by chance about fifty times.
Work Survey Instrument Revision for Case Management Work Jane Christianson, RN; MSN L. Sue Davis, RN; PhD.
The Evaluation of Training for IAPT therapists in Cumbria Professor Dave Dagnan Consultant Clinical Psychologist.
Students’ writing and issues of suitability: Assessing and managing suitability issues during the student life-cycle Dr Lucy Rai and Dr Theresa Lillis.
Embedding Information Literacy into Staff Development at an acute NHS Trust Sharon Hadley Kim Hacker
Thinking Actively in a Social Context T A S C.
Building Research Capacity in social care: An untapped potential? Jo Cooke &Linsay Halladay University of Sheffield Others in the research team: Ruth Bacigalupo.
1 Final Version© Ipsos MORI Final Version Evaluation of Adult Cancer Aftercare Services Quantitative and Qualitative Service Evaluation for NHS Improvement.
Stephanie Jones, RN, PhD Student Arthur Labatt School of Nursing University of Western Ontario Lorie Donelle, RN, PhD Arthur Labatt School of Nursing University.
Development and results of an older adult health communication program using the Theory of Planned Behavior Virginia Brown, DrPH; Lisa McCoy, MS The National.
Cynthia Baur, Ph.D. Senior Advisor, Health Literacy August 23, 2011 The National Action Plan to Improve Health Literacy Office of the Director Office of.
Children’s perceptions of hospitalisation Theresa Pengelly Senior Lecturer in Child Health University of Worcester
The ACT Health inter-professional learning project Inter-professional learning: an international perspective A/Professor Jeffrey Braithwaite Ms Jo Travaglia.
Speech and Language Therapists and the Stroke Association Support Co-ordinator working together to provide communication support: an evaluation Background.
Perceptions of Medicaid Beneficiaries Regarding the Usefulness of Accessing Personal Health Information and Services through a Patient Internet Portal.
Defining general and subject specific language competences for mainstream education The Norwegian Framework for Basic Skills Jorunn Berntzen, Strasbourg,
Strathkinness Primary School An introduction to the Curriculum for Excellence – 24 th March 2010 (Revised March 30 th 2010 with new links added)
Jill Rutland My Background Public Health Library Service to Public Health Professionals Need to reach out to ‘frontline’ staff Interested to know.
Asthma Patients and the Patient-Practitioner Relationship: A Qualitative Study of Continuity of Care Margaret M. Love, PhD Family Practice and Community.
Research Utilization in Nursing Chapter 21
The Role of Study Circles in Promoting Health Literacy A Presentation to NIFL Health Literacy Summit Regional Resource Center I Indianapolis, Indiana March.
Institute of Health Sciences Education
Professionally Speaking : Qualitative Research and the Professions. Using action research to gauge the quality of feedback given to student teachers while.
Dr J M Mathibe-Neke Department of Health Studies Unisa.
Results Student Engagement : Students generally found logbooks easy to use and practical in the hospital setting. Purpose : There appeared to be a perceived.
Clinical Decision Support Systems Paula Coe MSN, RN, NEA-BC NUR 705 Informatics and Technology for Improving Outcomes in Advanced Practice Nursing Dr.
Cleveland Clinic Science Internship Program for Nursing How do Families of Surgical Patients Perceive Communication of their Family Members’ Surgical Status?
Standard 10: Preventing Falls and Harm from Falls Accrediting Agencies Surveyor Workshop, 13 August 2012.
Extending the librarian role A Conversation Briefing with Linda Ward, Library Services Manager, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust.
Assessing the Impact of the Interactive Learning Space Initiative on Faculty Morale and Student Achievement Ball State University 2015 Spring Assessment.
Background Outcomes / Results Qualitative methodology was used to collect data about parent and professional views of the current services.
Presented by Dr. Vivek Indramohan Faculty of Health / CHSCR BCU Evaluating student experiences when undertaking an objective structured clinical examination.
Collaborative Working: Speech and Language Therapy and the Stroke Association RCSLT Conference September 2012.
Graduate School of Medicine University of Wollongong Educators learning together and modeling interprofessional collaboration Sue Vella, Sal Sanzone, Helen.
Teach-back Method for Patient Education Tracy Grant Viterbo University.
Conducting a research project. Clarify Aims and Research Questions Conduct Literature Review Describe methodology Design Research Collect DataAnalyse.
Patients' Perspectives of the Doctor- patient Relationship and Information Giving within the Health Context Adrienne Shaw, London South Bank University.
Becoming the professional: The experiences of final year physiotherapy students on practice placement in the acute setting NAEP Conference 2016 Charlotte.
Conclusions  Carers of people with dementia report a higher need for information and holistic, structured support from health and social care services.
Communicating concerns of NAI: A qualitative study on parents’ experiences Dr Sirkka Komulainen Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health Science and.
Title of the Change Project
Jones, Amy1; Anderson, S2; Murphy, T1 and Martino, D3.
Dr Phyllis Easton Health Intelligence Manager NHS Tayside
Background information of respondent and intensive care unit
Jones, Amy1; Anderson, S2; Murphy, T1 and Martino, D3.
Dr Anna Stodter FST Department of Sport and Exercise Sciences
Coole C, Nouri F, Narayanasamy, Drummond A
‘See Me’: Exploring unmet need among young adults in Bristol
Health Literacy “Health literacy is about people having the knowledge, skills, understanding and confidence they need to be able to use health and care.
Exploring hospital pharmacists’ perceptions of their medication communication with prescribers Dr. Michael Lloyd, Dr. Simon Watmough, Professor Sarah O’Brien,
Organisational factors
Addressing older care recipients’
What are risk-scoring tools?
The perception and operation of cancer rehabilitation services in South Wales from healthcare professionals’ perspective: a qualitative study Judit Csontos,
Real-life clinical decision-making: Examining the role of multiple clinical and non-clinical factors on decisions to admit patients to acute psychiatric.
Visual Aid for Hemoglobin A1c Results in Primary Care: A Pilot Study
Presentation transcript:

Individuals with Lower Literacy Levels: Accessing and Navigating Healthcare Herbert, H. 1, Adams, J. 1, Lowe, W. 1, Leuddeke, J Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southampton. UK, 2 Brockenhurst College UK. Background An individual’s level of literacy influences their ability to function effectively in a health care environment. This in turn can mediate the individual’s health outcomes. The way that literacy influences function and health outcomes is called health literacy which is described as seeking, understanding and using health information (Buchbinder et al, 2011; Berkman et al, 2010). Different levels of health literacy include functional, interactive and critical (Nutbeam, 2000).The complex and evolving health care system, creates additional barriers to accessing and navigating health care. Methods Adults attending a 30 week literacy class were approached to take part in the study. In-depth interviews were carried out following a 3 week period of class observation and contribution to the class as a learning assistant (HH). A pilot study was conducted to inform the content and process of semi structured interviews. Participant information and consent forms were at a level 1-2 reading ability (approximately school age years) and read aloud twice. Chosen interview questions and prompts were informed by the literature; they included: o When visiting your Doctor or having a hospital appointment, how would you describe the information they gave you? o Have you ever explained that you have difficulty reading, writing or spelling to your Doctor or nurse? What did you say? o (show NVS) This is one of the ways to look at health literacy and numeracy. What do you think of it? - How many can you answer? Interviews were transcribed and thematically analysed using a grounded theory approach. Findings were considered under each level of health literacy; functional, interactive and critical (Nutbeam, 2000). Rigour was enhanced through respondent validation and independent assessment of themes within the text. Results Functional literacy: navigating the hospital environment for an appointment was a challenge. Interactive literacy: The greatest difficulty was in this area; all found communication with clinicians challenging. The continual use of medical jargon was identified as a significant barrier in understanding. All disliked the use of written information. Critical literacy: There was less evidence of decision making. Conclusions Individuals with lower levels of literacy experienced most difficulty in the area of interactive health literacy. This indicates that perhaps greater attention and time is needed to develop the interactive skills of health care professionals so they can support people in their health care needs. Participants were not averse to having literacy screening and subsequent documentation in their clinical records. Implications for Practice These findings support further research into the use of a ‘Flag’ system to highlight peoples’ lower health literacy when accessing the NHS. However, the flag system needs to be considered alongside the development of an appropriate screening device, the up skilling of the health care professional s and the resource implications of a substantial, previously unidentified, need in the NHS. Further information may be obtained from: Dr Jo Adams, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southampton, UK, or Harriet Herbert Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Southampton, UK, Authors have no conflicts of interest. References: Berkman, N.D.., et al., Health Literacy: What Is It? Journal of Health Communication 15, 9–19. Buchbinder, et al., Health literacy: what is it and why is it important to measure? J RHEUMATOL 38, 1791–1797. NICE clinical guideline Nutbeam, D., Health Promotion International 15, 259 –267. Rudd R., Anderson J., ( ) Objectives The purpose of this study was to explore the perceptions that individuals with lower literacy levels have of accessing and navigating health care. This study also investigated individuals’ thoughts and feelings about being screened for lower literacy levels in a clinical NHS setting “It’s extremely difficult for a person like me to admit to another person that...they don’t know how to read or write, it’s very embarrassing.” P9 ParticipantAgeGenderLiteracy level P2 (J)52FE2 P8 (I)63FL1 P9 (J)57ME2 “That was quite sort of difficult, sort of like knowing which room, you know actually place you had to be in, in the hospital, could sometimes get confusing.” P2 “They came out with some word that was three miles long, and I sat there and said what does that mean?” P9 “No, it’s no use to me. It’s got to be, shown.”P8 “They write to my doctor first, they don’t write to me anymore, they write to my doctor first, my doctor calls me in and he says “look XXXX, this is what’s going to happen...” P9 “No I've just, no I just generally go away and hope for the best.” P2 Yeh, I’d prefer them to know, because actually when I go into hospital now I call the staff nurse over and say, right, I can’t read, I can’t write and I’d like to know everything, word for word what’s going on. P9 Motivation for literacy assessment: Participants supported the idea of literacy screening in the NHS because they felt this would help them to navigate clinical systems. However, strong feelings of anxiety and embarrassment make this a sensitive and complex area.