Damasio’s Somatic Marker Hypothesis Originated from the observation of individuals who had sustained damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Normal.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Business Ethics for Real Estate: A. Glean
Advertisements

Chapter 16: Focquaert, F., & Platek, S.M. Social cognition and the evolution of self-awareness (pp ). Hypothesis: Human self-awareness arose because.
Brain functions and kinematics Mostafa M. Dini July 2012.
Pre-frontal cortex and Executive Function Squire et al Ch 52.
Course Behavioral Economics Alessandro InnocentiAlessandro Innocenti Academic year Lecture 16 Emotions LECTURE 16 EMOTIONS Aim: To explore the.
Evidence from the Cognitive Sciences
The Cerebral Cortex is split into four LOBES, with half of each one on the left, and half of each one on the right: The FRONTAL LOBE The PARIETAL LOBE.
Learning - Dot Point 2. Part A. Learning and Changes in the Brain – Brain Structures Associated with Learning.
Psych 216: Movement Attention. What is attention? There is too much information available in the world to process it all. Demonstration: change-detection.
To what extent do biological and cognitive factors interact?
Copyright © 2006 by Allyn and Bacon Chapter 7 Mechanisms of Perception, Conscious Awareness, and Attention How You Know the World This multimedia product.
Emotion. The heart has reasons that reason does not recognize -- Pascal Reason is and ought to be the slave of passion -- Hume Are Emotions Necessary.
Emotion-based Agents: putting the puzzle together Rodrigo Ventura Institute for Systems and.
Decision-making I choosing between gambles neural basis of decision-making.
Principles of High Quality Assessment
PowerPoint Presentations for Passer/Smith Psychology: Frontiers and Applications by David K. Jones Westminster College and Diane Feibel, Ed. D. Raymond.
Memory Systems Chapter 23 Friday, December 5, 2003.
Chapter One: The Science of Psychology
Notes: 1. Exam corrections and assignment 3 due Thursday.
Leadership Theories Edu 567 Summer What is Leadership?
4th Annual Thoughtful Pain Management
Emotions S. Suchitra. Simplest way to introduce emotions into a computational model – add emotion nodes Nerb & Spada (2001) provided a computational account.
OTHER MOTIVATIONS.
Attention as a Limited Capacity Resource
‘All that is psychological is first physiological’ Session 2: Localisation of Brain Function.
Chapter 8: Motivation and Emotion
The Nervous System and the Brain Information in this presentation is taken from UCCP content.
Anthony Correa Stephanie Regan Kasha Geels
Module 12 Remembering & Forgetting. INTRODUCTION recall –retrieving previously learned information without the aid of or with very few external cues recognition.
Emotions: a computational semiotics perspective Rodrigo Gonçalves, Ricardo Gudwin, Fernando Gomide Electrical and Computer Engineering School (FEEC) State.
 Limbic System  Emotions & higher mental functions  Blends primitive emotions (rage, fear, joy, sadness) with high mental functions (reason, memory)
Emotions and Cognition  Emotions consist of 3 components 1.Physiological Changes – These changes are not conscious 2.Subjective feeling 3.Associated behaviour.
Background The physiology of the cerebral cortex is organized in hierarchical manner. The prefrontal cortex (PFC) constitutes the highest level of the.
THE BRAIN AND BEHAVIOR. THE HINDBRAIN Medulla attaches to spinal cord; circulation, breathing, reflexes, muscle tone Pons, “bridge”, connects brainstem.
Orbitofrontal Cortex and Its Contribution to Decision-Making Part 1 Group 1 Amanda Ayoub, Alyssa Nolde, Cor Baerveldt, Baoyu Wang.
Our Brains Control Our Thinking, Feeling, and Behavior.
Central nervous system (CNS) Brain + Spinal Cord
 How does memory affect your identity?  If you didn’t have a memory how would your answer the question – How are you today?
Case study. Case and case study A case is a phenomenon, or an event, chosen, conceptualized and analyzed empirically as a manifestation of a broader class.
Chapter 3: Neural Processing and Perception. Neural Processing and Perception Neural processing is the interaction of signals in many neurons.
“The Role of the Human Prefrontal Cortex in Social Cognition and Moral Judgment” Group 3: Kindra Akridge, Antoinette Sellers, Hannah Stolarczyk, Tawni.
Autism Presented by : Hosein Hamdi. Autism manifests during the first three years of life Genetic factors play a significant and complex role in autism.
Emotional experience December 1, Emotional experience - introduction Subjective experience – not perception or expression ‘Qualia’ Consciousness.
PHYSIOLOGICAL UNDERPINNINGS OF LANGUAGE, PROBLEM SOLVING, AND REASONING.
Module 16 Emotion.
The Brain The Parts, Memory & Why Use it. Memory As a definition is… As a definition is… –The way in which we record the past and later refer to it so.
The Role of the Pre Frontal Cortex in Social Cognition Group 5 Alicia Iafonaro Alyona Koneva Barbara Kim Isaac Del Rio.
LECTURE 19: ANATOMICAL & FUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION OF LEARNING & MEMORY REQUIRED READING: Kandel text, Chapter 62 LEARNING: The process through which an.
Emotion Theories.
The potential anomalous component of Intuition Empirical evidence and an integrated theoretical approach Dick J. Bierman, University of Amsterdam 1.
DREAMS.
Neural Correlates of Conscious Emotional Experience Group 3 Week 8 Youngjin Kang Alyssa Nolde Antoinette Sellers Zhiheng Zhou.
The Brain Emotion and Motivation Prof: T. Curwen.
The Process of Forming Perceptions SHMD219. Perception The ability to see, hear, or become aware of something through the senses. Perception is a series.
Cognitive Development Adolescence. Getting Older…and Smarter Experience significant intellectual growth Due to changes in the brain and in part to gain.
The Neuropsychology of Memory Ch. 11. Outline Case studies Korsakoff’s Amnesia Alzheimer’s Disease Posttraumatic Amnesia Clive Wearing video Theories.
Session 5: Biological Factors & Cognition. 1. Human beings are information processors and mental processes guide behaviour 2. The mind can be studied.
A cerebral hemisphere is defined as one of the two regions of the brain that are delineated by the body's median plane.
The Brain. The Brain Stem The brain stem is the most basic part of the brain that regulates necessary life processes. It is a stalk that connects the.
On a new page in the front of your books, miss the top two lines and…
Physiology of Cerebral Cortex
What causes Antisocial Personality Disorder?
The Emotional Nature of Intelligence
Limbic forebrain Domina Petric, MD
Arousal and Emotion.
Wallis, JD Helen Wills Neuroscience Institute UC, Berkeley
Central nervous system
Damasio’s Somatic Marker Hypothesis
Associational cortex introduction
Presentation transcript:

Damasio’s Somatic Marker Hypothesis Originated from the observation of individuals who had sustained damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Normal intellectual function Normal Neuropsychological function Normal on tests sensitive to frontal lobe function However, severe impairment in personal and social decision making and conduct. –Difficulty with planning in the immediate, and future. –No longer able to make personally advantageous decisions –Often sustain social, personal, economic losses

The only deficit that could be detected was one in which these individuals failed to display emotion in situations in which emotion would be normatively expected. This led Damasio to posit that these individuals manifest a deficit in reasoning that is secondary to deficits in emotional processing. Within Damasio’s theory, the concept of convergence zones is important (This concept is also important in LeDoux’s theory of emotional experience, which we will discuss in two weeks’ time). Convergence zones are areas in the brain in which inputs from geographically / anatomically / functionally disparate regions come together and are integrated. Keeps a record (in the form of a memory trace or predisposition) of regions that, when active simultaneously (as a set) define the characteristics of a particular complex situation. –For example, information from primary sensory regions (including somatosensory cortex), secondary sensory regions, association cortices, the hippocampus, the amygdala, and other prefrontal regions.

The VMPFC is ideally situated to fulfill such a role given its extensive bi-directional connections with brain regions responsible for the processing of the characteristics of complex situations. Damasio believes that the VMPFC is the crucial structure for learning the association between the characteristics of certain complex situations and the emotional state (and thus the somatosensory pattern) that has predominantly been associated with that situation in an individual’s past (through learning). –Note that this theory is fully compatible with the James-Lange theory of emotion in that the relevant feature of emotion is the perception of bodily changes (Damasio refers to these as ‘somatic’, and includes musculoskeletal, visceral, and internal milieu components of physiology). When a situation occurs again, the VMPFC can reactivate the somatosensory pattern of the relevant emotion. These represent the ‘gut feelings’ that we have when we encounter particular stimuli or situations.

This can occur in two ways: –1) Through a ‘body loop’ in which bodily changes actually occur, and the information is relayed back to the somatosensory cortex. –2) Through an ‘as if’ loop in which the information about the relevant somatosensory patterns are conveyed directly to the somatosensory cortex, and thus bypass the bodily route. Damasio believes that the establishment / experience of a somatosensory (feeling state) appropriate to particular situations (based on an individual’s learning history) help us to reason about what is the most appropriate / adaptive course of action by constraining the process of reasoning over multiple options and outcome scenarios. The constraint operates according to a mechanism of qualification in which results from somatosensory patterns are juxtaposed to the information about the situation that triggered that pattern, and thus ‘marks’ it as potentially favourable or harmful.

That is, as you consider an option-outcome scenario, the somatic changes that are elicited by the VMPFC mark the scenario as one that is good or bad, and help you to make your decision. This process can happen in either an overt manner (you actually feel the somatic changes), which serve as an ‘alarm function’ (which theories does this invoke?), or a covert manner in which the changes affect attention and working memory by biasing them towards certain option-outcome scenarios (which theory does this invoke?). Thus, the somatic changes triggered by the VMPFC help to constrain the ‘problem space’ by allowing us to reason among fewer option-outcome scenarios… this biases us away from particular scenarios and towards others, based on our previous experience with these situations, and the feelings that are engendered when we consider or experience them again.

Consequently, the problem space becomes manageable for cost-benefit analysis. In the absence of a somatic marker, all option-outcome scenarios are given equal weighting, and logical / rational analysis must operate over too many contingencies… consequently, and individual may become ‘lost in thought’, or may respond randomly or impulsively (which is exactly what is seen in VMPFC patients). This notion of constraining the problem space, and the instrumental role of emotion in reason is integral to another theory we have studied… Which one?

Neuroanatomical justification: the VMPFC receives projections from all relevant brain structures necessary to link the characteristics of complex situations to particular emotional states and somatosensory response patterns. Also, the VMPFC is the only frontal lobe structure to have access to autonomic control regions (amygdala, hypothalamus, and brain stem), in order to cause bodily changes through activation of the ANS and consequent changes in the viscera, and endocrine system. Why emotion? Certain classes of situations concerning personal and social matters are frequently linked to reward and punishment, and thus to approach and withdrawal related systems in the brain related to emotion.

Thus, in normal individuals, the experience of complex situations (formed and processed in a distributed manner as a collection of propositional facts) are accompanied by body states that represent the typical emotional response that has been associated with that situation in the individual’s learning history. The propositional facts are held in dispositional form in appropriate association cortex (I.e. memory), while the somatic state does not have to be stored, because it can be reconstituted. All that has to be stored are the linkages between situations and the somatic states that accompany them, and Damasio believes that this these linkages are held in dispositional form in the VMPFC. Thus, individuals with damage to the VMPFC cannot elicit somatic states appropriate to the particular scenario encountered or considered, and thus cannot use these to guide their information processing and decision making.

Evidence for Damasio’s hypothesis 1) Psychophysiological investigation of emotional arousal in patients with damage to the VMPFC. –Measured SCR in normal controls, brain damaged controls, and patients with VMPFC damage when presented with neutral / abstract or emotionally charged visual images. All groups reliably elicited increased SCRs to startle and deep breathing. Normal and brain damaged control subjects showed SCRs to emotionally evocative stimuli, while VMPFC patients did not. Damasio suggests that these results support the contention that VMPFC patients cannot generate somatic markers to emotionally arousing stimluli.

Gambling Experiments: Patients with VMPFC damage continue to select cards from the decks that incur losses, while normal controls sample from all decks for a while, but then gradually begin playing more frequently from the good decks (net gain) than from the bad decks. This is analogous to VMPFC patients’ inability to decide upon an advantageous course of action, when contingencies / future outcomes are uncertain. It is not possible to cognize the ‘rules’ or contingencies for the decks, so subjects must rely on their intuition or ‘gut instinct’ of which decks to play from. Normal controls manifest a SCR just prior to selecting a card from a bad deck (but not from a good deck… ‘somatic marker’?), while patients with VMPFC damage do not.