Dr. Eilionóir Flynn, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Disability Law and Policy, National University of Ireland Galway
International human rights norms: sources and substance (UN, Council of Europe, EU) Factual situation encountered in Council of Europe Member States: some key issues Major international campaigns for reform: legal capacity, torture, institutionalisation, indicators of human rights Future directions and new opportunities for Member States: National Disability Strategies
Covers all rights: civil, political, economic, social cultural Consolidates all existing IHRL and applies to a disability context Use in European human rights structures e.g. in interpreting ECHR
Disability as a health/social policy issue disability as a human rights issue Law and policy made for people with disabilities made with/by disabled people Substitute decision-making supported decision-making (public and private?) Dependence on state interdependence, facilitate independence
LEGAL NORMS European Convention on Human Rights (application to disability and interpretation using CRPD) European Social Charter (significance of socio- economic rights in disability context) POLICY COMMITMENTS Council of Europe Disability Action Plan (15 action lines, cross- cutting issues and coordination via CAHPAH)
LEGAL NORMS Charter of Fundamental Rights Framework Directive 78/2000 CRPD (as State Party which has ratified) POLICY COMMITMENTS European Union Disability Strategy (and implementation via High Level Group on Disability) Code of Conduct for Implementing CRPD between Council, MS and Commission
Factual situation at grassroots level – preparing for ratification, or post-ratification implementation of CRPD Aligning with commitments in EU and Council of Europe legislation and policy, as well as national priorities, resource constraints, etc. Prioritise key issues which will lead to law and policy reform, structural/procedural reform, and programmatic change
Legal Capacity – Article 12, CRPD Repeal of archaic guardianship laws Introduction of mechanisms for supported decision-making (e.g. starting in contract law) Innovating: continuum of support (information advocacy supported decision-making)
Focal point(s) within government (Art 33.1) Co-ordinating mechanism between focal points (Art 33.1) Monitoring framework, with one or more independent mechanism(s) (Art 33.2) Active civil society involvement in monitoring Information collection (statistical and research data) to implement Convention (Art 31)
Changing the way supports are provided to people with disabilities Reviewing current funding/spending on services to make sure resources are going to the types of supports which bring about the change envisaged in Convention Introduce personalised supports (e.g. individual budgets, direct payments) and supports for independent/community living
MDAC Campaign to Change Guardianship Campaigns in MS to reform legal capacity (e.g. Ireland, N. Ireland) Committee on Rights of Persons with Disabilities seek submissions on Article 12
MDRI report on Judge Rotenberg Center UN Special Rapporteur on Torture Guardian Newspaper Expose CoE Commissioner for Human Rights statement
ENIL/ECCL Free Our People Now! Desegregation, deinstitutionalisation Genuine community living, not ‘mini’ institutions Barriers to community living explored e.g. hate crime
Article 31 – data and statistics Need to measure impact of CRPD on people with disabilities UN Secretariat to Human Rights Treaty Bodies FRA and ANED work
Vehicles to embed CRPD dynamic of change at domestic level (NDS) More opportunities for member states sharing best practice and learning (CAHPAH, HLGD, Conference of States Parties) Focus on aligning international and domestic priorities through NDS to showcase progress in implementing human rights norms
Renew the commitment Connect national to international Enhance transparency Broaden participation Draft detailed implementation plan Independent monitoring Tools to measure progress Mainstream disability equality Broaden the frame Ensure sustainability