Business Practices Subcommittee

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements Parallel Flow Visualization Data Requirements NERC ORS Meeting Toronto, Ontario September 23-24, 2009 Jim.
Advertisements

Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2013.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair May 17 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 23, 2012 DRAFT.
e-Tag Functional Specification
1 R12010 Default Scheduling Intervals. 2 Submitted by Southern Company In response to Order 764s 15 minute scheduling intervals Establish default scheduling.
Parallel Flow Visualization/Mitigation Proposal
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair November 9 th, 2011.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz – IDCWG Chair September 13 th, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 26, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 2, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 1, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2012.
North American Energy Standards Board Upadate Presented by Bob Harshbarger.
Overview Seams Coordination Process. 2 Introduction Midwest ISO Non-profit organization that manages the reliable flow of electricity across much of the.
Western Electricity Coordinating Council Status of NERC Standards Activity WECC PCC Meeting March 6-7, 2008.
FEBRUARY 27, 2013 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS Parallel Flow Visualization Overview 1.
IDCWG Update. September 2013 December 2013 February 2014 April 2014 July 2014 Data Submission WEQ 008 Assessment CO 283 Report GTL CO’s Draft CO’s Development.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, August 26, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Pseudo-Tie Reservations
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, January 19, :00 to 4:00 p.m. EST 4 th Quarter
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
NERC Congestion Management Congestion Management Option 3 Vendor Meeting Julie Pierce – NERC IDCWG Chair.
2013 Calendar Year Customer Survey Results
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, December 2, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 13th, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update May 4, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 18, 2014.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 19, :00 to 4:00 p.m. EDT 2 nd Quarter 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 24, 2015.
Flowgate Allocation Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Parallel Flow Visualization Project NERC ORS Meeting May 4, 2011.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update April 29, 2014.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting October 20, 2015.
NAESB WHOLESALE ELECTRIC QUADRANT BUSINESS PRACTICES SUBCOMMITTEE ACTIVITIES UPDATE TO JOINT ELECTRIC SCHEDULING SUBCOMMITTEE JANUARY 5, 2012 BY ED SKIBA.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update February 18, 2014.
2013 Wind Conference. Congestion Management & Communication Processes CJ Brown.
WEQ Executive Committee Contract Path Task Force Additional Issues Related To Contract Path Management ( WEQ and WEQ )
Generator Prioritization Option Parallel Flow Visualization Business Practices Subcommittee Meeting June , 2010.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update Yasser Bahbaz IDCWG Chair BPS Update September 13 th, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting April 29, 2014.
BPS Two-Tier Curtailment Sub Team Sep 23, 2011 Conference Call Sub team members- – Chris Advena, Art Wolfe, Mike ColbyPJM – Nelson Muller, OATI – Steve.
NAESB BPS Yasser Bahbaz– IDCWG Chair January 5 th, 2016.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 27, 2009.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting August 18, 2015.
Parking Lot Item 19. BPS Bert Bressers 10/31/2011 Firm rights of resources that have a Firm priority to what load (Sink area granularity)
WEQ Executive Committee Contract Path Task Force Additional Issues Related To Contract Path Management ( WEQ and WEQ )
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 19, 2014 Co-Chairs Rebecca Berdahl, BPA Marie Knox, MISO.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 16, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 23, 2016.
NAESB BPS UPDATE TO EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AUGUST 21, 2012 BY NARINDER K SAINI ED SKIBA BPS-CO-CHAIRS PARALLEL FLOW VISUALIZATION PROJECT 1.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 18, 2015 Chair Rebecca Berdahl, BPA.
1 Parallel Flow Visualization Goals NAESB BPS Meeting September 15-16, 2010.
RELIABILITY COORDINATOR TOPICS 2006 FRCC SYSTEM OPERATOR SEMINAR.
Interchange Distribution Calculator Working Group (IDCWG) Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Standard Review Subcommittee Update
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting
Standard Review Subcommittee Update
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and WEQ OASIS/BPS Subcommittees
Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Overview
NERC Congestion Management
Standards Review Subcommittee Update
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and BPS Subcommittees
Presentation transcript:

Business Practices Subcommittee NAESB BPS UPDATE TO Executive Committee February 19, 2013 BY NARINDER K SAINI Ed Skiba Bps-Co-chairs

OVERVIEW Business Practices Subcommittee (BPS) Status Parallel Flow Visualization (PFV) Status Background Objectives NAESB Responsibility IDC Input Proposed Solution Concerns/Dependencies Next Steps

BPS Status Meetings since last report Results: Subcommittee – 3 two-day meetings Recommendation Sub-team – 5 three-hour conference calls IDC/SDX Users Manuals Sub-team (8) 1-hour conference calls (2) review sessions with IDC Workings Group Results: Draft standards/recommendation Redlined IDC Users Manual and SDX Users Manual NERC Support Document

BPS Status Draft Standards include Changes to the Transmission Loading Relief Process (WEQ-008) Postings on OASIS ATC Information Link (WEQ-001) ScheduleDetail Template (WEQ-002, WEQ-003, WEQ-013) Glossary Updates (WEQ-000 and conforming changes)

BPS Status Draft Standards Address Annual Plan Items: 1.a Parallel Flow Visualization/Mitigation for Reliability Coordinators in the Eastern Interconnection – Permanent Solution 1.b Perform consistency review of WEQ-008 Transmission Loading Relief Business Practice Standards and develop recommendation 1.d Revise TLR level 5 to be treated similarly to TLR Level 3 in terms of treating the next hour allocation separately from that of current hour. (R11020)

PFV Background: IRO-006 IRO-006 Transmission Loading Relief Each Reliability Coordinator and Balancing Authority that receives a request pursuant to an Interconnection-wide transmission loading relief procedure (such as Eastern Interconnection TLR, WECC Unscheduled Flow Mitigation, or congestion management procedures from the ERCOT Protocols) from any Reliability Coordinator, Balancing Authority, or Transmission Operator in another Interconnection to curtail an Interchange Transaction that crosses an Interconnection boundary shall comply with the request, unless it provides a reliability reason to the requestor why it cannot comply with the request.

PFV Background: Interconnections IRO-006-EAST Transmission Loading Relief Procedures for the Eastern Interconnection WEQ-008 Transmission Loading Relief (TLR) – Eastern Interconnection Tools – (IDC)Interchange Distribution Calculator (SDX )System Data eXchange IRO-006-WECC Qualified Transfer Path Unscheduled Flow Relief (WECC) IRO-006-TRE IROL & SOL Mitigation in the ERCOT Region

PFV Background: Primary Players IDC SDX

PFV Objectives Generation to load (GTL) impacts reported to the IDC on a real-time basis More accurate assignment of relief obligations to entities causing congestion Near real-time data using generator output provided by RC Include impacts of intra-BA generation-to-load and point-to-point transactions Differentiate between intra-BA firm and non-firm transmission service IDC has better data to perform calculations for TLR Levels 3 and 5

PFV: NAESB RESPONSIBILITY NAESB will establish methodology for assigning the generation to load flows into the appropriate buckets.

NAESB Parallel Flow Visualization PFV: IDC Input Inter-BA Network Interchange Current IDC Inter-BA Point-to-Point Interchange Current IDC Intra-BA Network NAESB Parallel Flow Visualization Intra-BA Point-to-Point NERC S‐ Ref 10132* * http://www.nerc.com/docs/standards/sar/All_Directives_Report_2012-04-05.pdf

PFV Proposed Solution Coordination Arrangements Two-Tier Firm Curtailment Two Methods* Tag Secondary Network Transmission Service, or Generator Prioritization Additional Key Concepts *Assumes that all point-to-point transactions are tagged under NERC standards

PFV Coordination Arrangements Coordination Arrangements Types Coordination Agreements An agreement between two or more Transmission Service Providers for coordination of: a) granting Transmission Service by honoring a set of Flowgate limits and b) managing real-time congestion through congestion management process. Unilateral Declarations allowed if Transmission Service Providers cannot agree Reciprocity A commitment by two Transmission Service Providers to provide Last-to-Curtail treatment of parallel flows on one another’s system without having a direct Coordination Agreement. Two-Tier Firm Curtailments – encourages Coordination Arrangements

PFV: Two-Tier Firm Curtailment First-to-Curtail The Firm Transmission Service curtailment priority assigned by the IDC to parallel flows due to a lack of Coordination Agreement, Reciprocity, or unilateral declaration. Last-to-Curtail The Firm Transmission Service curtailment priority assigned by the IDC to: a) on-path flows and b) parallel flows when a Coordination Agreement, Reciprocity, or unilateral declaration exists between the Transmission Service Provider experiencing congestion and (at least one of) the Transmission Service Provider(s) on the path of the transaction whose Transmission Service is contributing to the congestion.

PFV: First-to Curtail/Last-to-Curtail TSP with Coordination Arrangements   Last to Curtail TSPs SOCO TVA DUK PJM MISO SPP EES CONGESTION X Congested TSP: TVA Last to Curtail if tag has TVA, PJM, MISO or SPP on path Congested TSP: PJM Last to Curtail if tag has TVA, DUK, PJM or MISO on path Congested TSP: SPP Last to Curtail if tag has TVA, MISO, SPP or EES on path

PFV: Methods for Intra-BA Transactions Tag Secondary Network Transmission Service Method A method used to submit to the IDC Transmission Service curtailment priority of the Secondary Network Transmission Service using e-Tags. Generator Prioritization Method A method used to submit to the IDC Transmission Service curtailment priority of the generator output. Difference between what is reported and the real-time generator output is firm

PFV Additional Key Concepts Balancing Authority to choose either one but not both Methods Balancing Authority can switch Six month notice LSE (or entity acting on their behalf) enters Tags for Tag Secondary Network Transmission Service Method Generator Priority Schedules for Generator Prioritization Method Transactions or generation-to-load impacting 5% or greater considered for assigning relief obligations

PFV Additional Key Concepts Credit for Redispatch IDC Processing Sub-priorities for TLR Level 5a Reloads of Curtailed Transactions Reallocations for TLR Level 5b Pseudo-Ties (generator physically in one BA but electrically located in another) OASIS ScheduleDetail template modified to identify firm tagged curtailments as First-to-Curtail or Last-to-Curtail.

PFV Concerns/Dependencies NERC INT standards modified to require tagging on all intra-BA Point-to- Point transactions (Project 2008-12) IRO-006-EAST modified to allow a Reliability Coordinator to request curtailments on intra-BAA Point-to-Point tags (Project 2012- 09) IDC Association NAESB/Association coordination Visibility into changes in the IDC Access to data during parallel test/full staffing (NAESB formal request) Parallel Flow Visualization priority

Next Steps Informal Comment Period (February 15 – March 15) Recommendation (WEQ-000, 001, 002, 003, 008, 013) IDC User’s Manual SDX User’s Manual NERC supporting document Industry overview of Parallel Flow Visualization (February 27) Address informal comments (March – June) Post for formal comments by end of second quarter

Next Steps Meetings March 20-21 – Little Rock, AR (hosted by SPP) April 24-25 – Carmel, IN (hosted by MISO) May 22-23 – Valley Forge, PA (hosted by PJM) June 19-20 – Minneapolis, MN (hosted by OATI)

QUESTIONS ?