Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. IPv4 Countdown Policy Proposal (LAC-2007-09) Toshiyuki Hosaka Working Group on the policy for IPv4 address.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Internet Number Resource Status Report As of 30 June 2005.

Advertisements

RIPE Network Coordination Centre Axel Pawlik LACNIC X, 22 May 2007, Isla Margarita IANA Policy for Allocation of ASN Blocks to RIRs.

LACNIC Policy Update Roque Gagliano LACNIC. Current Policies Proposals - LACNIC As a result of the Open Policy Forum at LACNIC XI four policy proposals.

IPv6 allocations to closed networks LACNIC VI Mar 29 – Apr 1, 2004 Montevideo, Uruguay.

Kuala Lumpur February 2004 APNIC 17 Kuala Lumpur February 2004 APNIC 17 IPv4 /8 Address Space Status.

Axel Pawlik. LACNIC VI, March 2004, Montevideo. An RIR in 2010 History, Continuity and Future presented by: Axel Pawlik.

Internet Number Resource Status Report As of 30 September 2004.

Montevideo 31 DE MARZO 2004 LACNIC VI Prepared By NRO (APNIC, ARIN, LACNIC, RIPE NCC)

Public Policy Forum Foro Público de Políticas Fórum Público de Políticas co-Chairs: Max Larson Henry Nicolás Antoniello.

Current Policy Topics Emilio Madaio Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC RIPE May 2013, Dublin.

Geoff Huston, APNIC March 2006 APRICOT 2006 IPv4 Numerology.

ARIN Public Policy Meeting

IPv4 Address Transfer proposal APNIC prop-050-v002 Geoff Huston.

4-Byte AS number registry Policy Proposal [LACNIC Proposal ] Geoff Huston APNIC 25 May.

IPv4 Consumption Update

Where are we with IPv6? Geoff Huston APNIC. The minister for communications and information technology does not believe that regulatory intervention is.

Internet Number Resource Status Report As of 30 September 2006.

Internet Number Resource Status Report As of 31 December 2004.

Internet Number Resource Status Report As of 31 March 2005.

Large Space IPv4 Trial Usage Program for Future IPv6 Deployment ACTIVITIES UPDATE Aug. 29, 2001 Kosuke Ito IPv6 Promotion Council of Japan.

Introduction of JPNIC Open Policy Meeting Japan Network Information Center Ruri Hiromi(IP address committee) Yuka Suzuki(JPNIC secretariat) NIR Meeting.

Proposal-062: Use of Final /8 Jonny Martin, Philip Smith & Randy Bush Policy APNIC 26 28th August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand.

Copyright © 2007 Japan Network Information Center Distribution of the last piece IPv4 address block in APNIC region Japan Network Information Center Izumi.

Policy SIG report 29 February 2008 APNIC 25, Taipei Toshiyuki Hosaka Randy Bush Jian Zhang.

1 IP Policy update - comparative status in all RIR regions Policy SIG 7 Sep 2006 APNIC 22, Kaohsiung, Taiwan Save Vocea.

JPNIC Update Toshiyuki Hosaka Japan Network Information Center (JPNIC) NIR SIG APNIC Indonesia.

1 13 th Policy SIG Report Kenny Huang Toshiyuki Hosaka Eugene Li Chair/co-chair of APNIC Address Policy SIG.

1 RIR Policy Development Update Policy SIG 8 Sep 2005 APNIC20, Hanoi, Vietnam Save Vocea.

ARIN IP Address Stewardship 3 February About ARIN Regional Internet Registry (RIR) – Established December 1997 by Internet community 100% community.

Policy Proposals: AfriNIC-10 Public Meeting Vincent Ngundi AfriNIC PDP-MG Chair AfriNIC-10, Cairo, Egypt.

Analysis of the impact of IPv4 transfer policies; Issues and solutions Dawit Bekele & John Schnizlein Internet Society AfriNIC-9 Mauritius.

Spearheading Internet technology and policy development in the African Region IPv4 exhaustion The Situation in Africa AfriNIC-9 Mauritius, 27th November.

Address Supporting Organization Status Report ICANN San Juan June 2007.

R I P E N e t w o r k C o o r d i n a t i o n C e n t r e. h t t p : / / w w w. r i p e. n e t. n c r i p e. n e t 1 The Internet Registry System IPv4.

Internet Number Resources 1. Internet IPv4 addresses IPv6 addresses Autonomous System number Fully Qualified Domain Name Key Internet resources.

Copyright (c) 2006 Japan Network Information Center Comments from JP on “End site allocation policy for IPv6” (prop-033-v001 ) Izumi Okutani Japan Network.

APNIC update ARIN XX 17 October 2007 Srinivas Chendi.

ARIN Update Aaron Hughes ARIN Board of Trustees Focus IPv4 Depletion & IPv6 Uptake Developing, adapting, and enhancing processes and procedures.

Sofía Silva Berenguer lacnic.net Paramaribo - Surinam IPv4 Exhaustion And IPv6 Deployment.

IPv4 Final Distribution Business Processes Andrea Cima, RIPE NCC RIPE 64.

Running Out of Space: IPv4 Exhaustion Brian Nisbet Network Operations, HEAnet.

December 2013 Internet Number Resource Report. December 2013 Internet Number Resource Report INTERNET NUMBER RESOURCE STATUS REPORT As of 31 December.

March 2014 Internet Number Resource Report. March 2014 Internet Number Resource Report INTERNET NUMBER RESOURCE STATUS REPORT As of 31 March 2014 Prepared.

1 Overview of policy proposals Policy SIG Wednesday 26 August 2009 Beijing, China.

Current Policy Topics Emilio Madaio Policy Development Officer RIPE NCC RIPE Oct - 4 Nov 2011, Vienna.

Overview of policy proposals Policy SIG 27 February 2008 APNIC 25, Taipei.

Copyright © 2008 Japan Network Information Center JPNIC's review of IPv4 address transfer  Izumi Okutani  Japan Network Information.

APNIC Depletion of the IPv4 free address pool – IPv6 deployment The day after!! 8 August 2008 Queenstown, New Zealand In conjunction with APAN Cecil Goldstein,

1 APNIC allocation and policy update JPNIC OPM July 17, Tokyo, Japan Guangliang Pan.

Copyright © 2007 Japan Network Information Center Global Policy for the Allocation of the remaining IPv4 Address Space  Japan Network Information Center.

A proposal to lower the IPv4 minimum allocation size and initial criteria in the AP region prop-014-v001 Policy SIG APNIC17/APRICOT 2004 Feb

Anne Lord & Mirjam Kühne. AfNOG Workshop, 10 May IP Address Management AfNOG Workshop, 11 May 2001 Accra, Ghana presented by:

Copyright (c) 2006 Japan Network Information Center Survey results in JP on IPv6 assignment size Izumi Okutani Japan Network Information Center (JPNIC)

IPv4 Address Lifetime Expectancy Geoff Huston, APNIC 26 October 2005 ARIN XVI.

Izumi Okutani JPNIC IP Department NIR Meeting Feb 2004 JPNIC Open Policy Meeting Update.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E Emerging Registry Criteria ASO General Assembly Budapest, 19 May 2000.

Current Policy Topics Emilio Madaio RIPE NCC RIPE November 2010, Rome.

1 IANA global IPv6 allocation policy [prop-005-v002] Policy SIG 1 Sept 2004 APNIC18, Nadi, Fiji.

Prop-077: Proposal to supplement transfer policy of historical IPv4 addresses Wendy Zhao Wei, Jane Zhang & Terence Zhang Yinghao.

Advisory Council Shepherds: David Farmer & Chris Grundemann Global Policy for post exhaustion IPv4 allocation mechanisms by the IANA.

Policy SIG Report APNIC AGM Friday 29 August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand 1.

Copyright (c) 2002 Japan Network Information Center Proposal for IPv6 Policy for Essential Infrastructure in the AP region Izumi Okutani IP Address Section.

The Status of APNIC’s IPv4 Resources: Exhaustion & Transfers

IP Addresses in 2016 Geoff Huston APNIC.

/48 assignment status report

RIPE Policy Landscape Filiz Yilmaz ESNOG, February 2008.

IPv4 Address Lifetime Expectancy

IPv4 Address Lifetime Expectancy Revisited

Overview of policy proposals

IPv6 Address Space Management A follow up to RIPE-261

Presentation transcript:

Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. IPv4 Countdown Policy Proposal (LAC ) Toshiyuki Hosaka Working Group on the policy for IPv4 address exhaustion, Japan Network Information Center (JPNIC) May 23, 2007 LACNIC-X, Isla Margarita, Venezuela

1 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Introduction This proposal is : –to respond in an orderly way to the upcoming exhaustion of the IPv4 free address space. –to ensure that LIRs can receive IPv4 address allocation until pre-determined date (T-date). This proposal does not : –intend to artificially drive up IPv4 addresses –promote IPv6

2 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. How much IPv4 address left? Source : Geoff Huston - IPv4 address space report RIR pool IANA pool 48 /8s left 2010 March 2010 Nov. Actual recordProjection Consumption rate 2004 : 9 * / : 13 * / : 10 * / : 7 * /8 (As of )

3 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Current Problems The final date of IPv4 allocations is ambiguous –LIRs do not consider IPv4 address exhaustion as an imminent issue –They will face confusions such as re-addressing their network or making subsequent requests at the last minute within a limited time (last minutes rush) –LIRs will be forced to build networks with a big architectural change either with hierarchical NAT or with IPv6, or even with another solution in a very short timeframe

4 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Proposal principles 1.Global Synchronization 2.Set and announce the date when the IPv4 allocation is terminated 3.Not change the current address policy for the extension of IPv4 address lifetime 4.Separate discussions on recycle issue

5 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Proposal principles (cont.) 1.Global Synchronization –All 5 RIRs should proceed at the same time for measures on IPv4 address exhaustion –Ensuring fairness across the regions –Prevent confusion such as an attempt to receive allocations from an RIR outside their region 2.Set and announce the date when the IPv4 allocation is terminated –To ensure all LIRs/ISPs can receive IPv4 allocation until such date –Also, to give time to LIRs/ISPs to prepare for the network re-configuration (Large-scale-NAT, IPv6, or other technical solution)

6 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Proposal principles (cont.) 3.Not change the current address policy for the extension of IPv4 address lifetime –Making large changes in the current policy towards conservation is difficult in reality 4.Separate discussions on recycle issue –Recovery of unused address space is very important and should be addressed, but should not be tied with this proposed policy

7 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Details of the proposal Announce the day in which the IANA pool becomes less than 30*/8 (A-Date) Terminate new allocation/assignment from RIR on the day (T-Date) exactly 2 years after A-Date (Now)(A-Date)(T-date) 2 years No new allocation/assignment Allocation/assignment based on current policy IANA pool got less than 30* /8 Some /8 IANA pool may be left

8 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Benefits Final date of IPv4 allocation is clearly demonstrated well in advance (2 years) –LIRs and users can prepare for the exhaustion (subsequent allocation, renumbering, business plan, IPv6 etc.) –RIRs can make the last allocation and avoid causing feelings of unfairness among LIRs

9 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Discussion in APNIC Consensus reached: –Global Synchronization –Not change the current address policy for the extension of IPv4 address lifetime –Separate discussions on recycle issue Consensus NOT reached: –Set and announce the date when the IPv4 allocation is terminated Back to ML for further discussion

10 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Discussion in ARIN Public Policy Meeting resulted in few in favor(4/93) and many against(47/93) Broad comments on this policy… –Inappropriate action Artificial measures to move IPv6 Anti-trust issue - Denial of Service by the dominant supplier It is enough if Community stays informed of size of remained space –Influence by the exhaustion Issue of reclaiming the unused legacy space Emergence of trade market

11 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Other RIRs RIPE NCC –Introduced in RIPE 54 (May 2007) –Back to ML for further discussion AfriNIC –Introduced in AfriNIC 6 (May 2007) –Informational presentation with no decision

12 Copyright © 2007 JPNIC All Rights Reserved. Gracias!