Presented by:William B. Reeves, Atlanta September, 2007 The Changing Profile of Directors and Trends in Corporate Governance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
BOARD EFFICIENCY: The Agenda Setting Role and Information Needs of the Supervisory Board Holly J. Gregory Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP.
Advertisements

ASX Corporate Governance Council
Towards More Effective Board Functioning Fall Lausanne Confidential to CEO-CF and CEO-CF members.
W. Richard Frederick Governance Consultant. 1. Is the board effective, passive, or dysfunctional? 2. Is the board composition good?  Skills, experience,
1 ACI Annual Audit Committee Survey - Global M A R K E T I N G & C O M M U N I C A T I O N S R E S E A R C H Charles Garbowski Research February 21, 2006.
Corporate Governance Chapter 2.
Stewardship – taking action Janet Williamson TUC Senior Policy Officer and Trustee of the TUC Pension Fund.
Selection, Compensation, and Removal
1 Governance 1. Board Size and Composition 2. Board Committee Structure 3. Board Membership and Recruitment 4. Director Compensation and Ownership 5. Senior.
Managing Your ALMO Members Survey. Survey Questions 1.Board Structure 2.Performance Management 3.Annual Delivery Plan 4. and 5.Services in the MA or SLAs.
ELECTION AND QUALIFICATIONS OF DIRECTORS Robert D. Strahota, Assistant Director * SEC Office of International Affairs Prepared for the panel on Improving.
Third ICAC Symposium The New York Stock Exchange – A Regulator and a Listed Company James F. Duffy Executive Vice President & General Counsel NYSE Regulation,
Corporate Governance Dilemmas Watchdog vs. Co-Pilot Lecture 2.
Competing For Advantage Part IV – Monitoring and Creating Entrepreneurial Opportunities Chapter 11 – Corporate Governance.
THE EVOLVING ROLE OF THE INED JOHN HARTY. Harty International Executive Search John Harty A look back to 2008 Where are we now today What does the future.
Stockholder Rights and Corporate Governance Stockholders Corporate Governance Executive Compensation: A Special Issue Shareholder Activism Government.
Are CEOs Paid Too Much? CEO Salary Year Compared to Blue-Collar Worker Avg times times times Source: Business Week.
CHAPTER 2 Corporate Governance
OEOC Annual Conference Board of Directors April 16, 2004.
Chapter 4 Governance Context.
Wu Jinglian State Council Development Research Centre China Europe International Business School 26 February 2004 The Role of Special Board Committees.
Corporate Governance Best Practices: Implications for Commercial Underwriters Dr. Gail S. Russ Dr. Meredith Downes Associate Professors of Management Illinois.
1 The Code of Best Practices and the Board of Directors Professor Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes Yale University School of Management International Institute.
The Importance of Transparency and Disclosure Presented by Brian S. Brown Seoul, Korea - March 1999 OECD Conference: Corporate Governance in Asia.
Challenges in Recruiting Independent Board Members Andrea Redmond Russell Reynolds Associates March 10, 2003 R USSELL R EYNOLDS A SSOCIATES.
1 Charles Garbowski Senior Director Research March 16, 2007 R E S E A R C H K P M G L L P ACI Second Annual Global Audit Committee Survey.
2007 Spencer Stuart Board Index Findings Review of S&P 500 Proxies Spencer Stuart William B. Reeves Managing Director, Atlanta.
©2008 Pearl Meyer & Partners NECC Executive Compensation Forum Trends in Long-Term Incentives March 6, 2008 Melissa Means Vice President Pearl Meyer &
1 Practical Issues in Corporate Governance Robin Louis Ventures West March 20, 2002.
Creating National Values with Global Accumulations 11 th Turkey Internal Audit 9 th November, 2007 Istanbul Accountability: Value that only Internal Auditing.
Executive Compensation Dilemmas Lecture 5. Shareholder dilemmas Do all shareholders want the same thing? How much emphasis should be placed on short term.
2012 Governance & Leadership Institute January 29 – 30, 2012.
1 Developing Board Opportunities: From Ideas to Action November 15, 2011 Tracy E. Houston, MA; Laurence J. Stybel President, Board Resource ServicesVP,
1 GFNORTE Corporate Governance. 2  DIVIDEND POLICY In the Ordinary General Stockholders Assembly held on April 29, 2003, a dividend policy with a minimum.
Role of the Board of Directors
COPYRIGHT © 2010 South-Western/Cengage Learning..
1602: Current Trends in Risk Management for Life Insurance Companies LOOKING BACK…focused on the future.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando.
Compensia SILICON VALLEY 1731 TECHNOLOGY DRIVE SUITE 810 SAN JOSE CALIFORNIA What Compensation Consultants Are Telling Compensation.
CHOATE HALL & STEWART LLP 1 New Rules for Proxy Statement Disclosures Presentation to The National Association of Stock Plan Professionals, Boston Chapter.
Rating Compliance & Corporate Responsibility Presentation to 5 th Annual Pharmaceutical Regulatory & Compliance Congress By: Andrea M. Esposito Managing.
Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Major legal rights of stockholders To receive dividends, if declared To vote on: Members of board of directors Major mergers and acquisitions Charter and.
ECON 308 Week 15 Corporate Governance Chapter 18 1.
© The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 2002 All Rights Reserved. McGraw-Hill/ Irwin 14-1 Business and Society POST, LAWRENCE, WEBER Stockholders and Corporate.
CHAPTER 2 Corporate Governance
By Abdur Rashid Mirza University of Lahore School of Accountancy and Finance.
Week 7 Directors: A Background Faisal AlSager MGT Corporate Governance.
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT & BUSINESS POLICY 10 TH EDITION THOMAS L. WHEELEN J. DAVID HUNGER Corporate Governance.
Page 1 John F. Levy Board Advisory (O): (908) (O): (201)
RESPONSIBILITIES OF TOP MANAGEMENT 1 - FULFILLS KEY ROLES (MINTZBERG, 73) INTERPERSONAL ROLES –FIGUREHEAD –LEADER –:LIAISON INFORMATIONAL ROLES –MONITOR.
Main Board Issues in Chile Ricardo Escobar C. Carey Cía. Ltda.
Getting Back to Business Investors Who Move the Market and the 2003 Proxy Season: Hold Onto Your Hats! Lyle Ganske, Head of M&A Practice Rich Koppes, Of.
ACE Institute Raising the Bar on Cooperative Governance David A.H. Brown, Executive Director © Brown Governance Inc. and the Canadian Co-operative Association.
HEALTH WEALTH CAREER April 28, 2016 STRICTLY PRIVATE & CONFIDENTIAL The information included in this report is strictly confidential and is proprietary.
Chapter 5 ASX Guidelines for Listed Companies
THE DYNAMICS OF GETTING ON A PUBLIC CORPORATE BOARD
What Keeps Boards Up At Night
Chapter 4 Governance Context.
Governance of High-Tech Startups
Corporate Governance Corporate governance is the set of processes that provides an assurance of a fair return to outside investors. Resolve the conflict.
Mutual Fund Boards vs. Corporate Boards
CHAPTER 2 Corporate Governance
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION
Board of Directors Roles and Responsibilities
What is corporate governance?
Singapore Code of Corporate Governance 2012
Dr. Gail S. Russ Dr. Meredith Downes
CHAPTER 10 Corporate Governance
YWCA's of the Great Lakes Alliance Region Redesigning Board Meetings: Increasing Impact of the Board's Work May 24, 2012.
Presentation transcript:

Presented by:William B. Reeves, Atlanta September, 2007 The Changing Profile of Directors and Trends in Corporate Governance

2 Spencer Stuart’s Board Index Highlights >Board Composition: Average board size stable at 10.7 Demand for independent directors increased 17% since last year 31% of new directors had never before served on a public company board Average age and retirement age are increasing Women account for 15% of directors, no change over previous year 96% of boards have a lead or presiding director in place (up from 36% in ’03) Minorities account for 14% of directors * Financial expertise in greatest demand, followed by CEOs ** * Analysis of top 200 S&P 500 companies. ** From supplemental survey, 145 respondents.

3 >Compliance Requirements Met: Board independence is a reality 81% of directors are independent (only 2 insiders on average) On 39% of S&P 500 boards, CEO is only insider 33% of boards have separated the Chair and CEO roles, up from 26% in ’01; however, only 10% of chairs are independent Independence of key committees: audit, compensation and nominating committees comprise only independent directors

4 >Profile of new S&P 500 directors has changed (391 selected in 2006 for S&P 500) Fewer active CEOs – 29% in ‘06; down from 47% in ‘01 31% are first-time public company directors –an impressive group (e.g., $50B CFO, $20B head of mktg/strategy, $30B division president) More women – 23% in ’06 vs. 16% in ’01. (However, women make up only 15% of all directors, which reflects only a slight increase from 12% in ’01 and no change since ’05) Greater diversity of skills and experience International experience and perspective are increasingly important >Mandatory retirement age and higher age limit more prevalent More boards have mandatory retirement: 78% vs. 58% in ’01 But at older age: 62% at age 72+ vs. 34% in ’01

5 >Audit Committees: More emphasis on true financial expertise Boards with 11 or more audit committee meetings annually: 37% vs. 1% in ‘02 Fewer active CEOs serve as members: 23% vs. 30% in ‘01 54% of boards designate more than one financial expert; 20% designate all audit committee members as financial experts >Audit chairs less likely to be CEOs Fewer active CEOs: 19% vs. 27% in ‘01 More retired CEOs: 25% vs. 16% in ‘01 More active/retired CFOs: 10% vs. 2% in ‘01 More active/retired accountants: 9% vs. 2% in ‘01

6 >Board compensation has increased Average cash retainer today of $63,600, is 12% greater than last year and 70% greater than it was in ‘01 Fewer boards paying meeting fees: 57% vs. 72% in ’01 But, meeting fees are higher: $1,955 vs. $1,535 in ‘01 More pay equity in addition to retainer: 64% vs. 42% in ‘01 Fewer pay with stock options: 51% vs. 72% in ’01 >Committee compensation has also increased 70% increase in average committee chair retainer: $9,100 vs. $5,354 in ‘01 More companies pay committee chair retainers: 84% vs. 57% in ‘01 Although down from 2001, majority of boards still pay committee meeting fees: 58% vs. 68%. And meeting fees are $1,500, up from $1,200 More companies have switched to paying committee member retainers: 29% vs. 13% in ‘01. Average retainers are $6,400, up from $5,600 in ‘01

7 >Average total compensation (including committee fees) is $179,056 (per Supplemental Survey) On average, 62% of this is paid in equity Total compensation is up to $211,179 in 2007 survey (not yet released)

8 Spencer Stuart’s Board Index 2006 Supplemental Survey >Boards seek new skills and more diversity (145 boards surveyed) Financial expertise - 75% Active CEO/COO – 71% Retired CEO/COO – 35% International expertise – 52% Technology expertise – 40% Marketing expertise – 27% HR expertise – 5% Minority – 62% Women – 50%

9 >CEO evaluation, succession, and compensation Entire board increasingly responsible for CEO evaluation – 43% up from 13% in ‘01 94% of boards discuss CEO succession at least once a year Responsibility for CEO succession lies with compensation (44%) or nominating committee (36%), although many boards now cite that multiple committees or the entire board are responsible 31% of boards surveyed still do not have an emergency succession plan CEO compensation includes restricted stock (79%) and options (81%); 74% of companies say at least a portion of equity awards is performance based

10 >Shareholder engagement 31% of boards have seen increase in shareholder efforts to contact the board Majority voting and CEO compensation are the most frequently raised topics 22% report that individual directors had direct contact with shareholders, most often the lead director

11 Preliminary Findings from the 2007 Survey * >The profile of new S&P 500 directors continues to shift away from active CEOs and toward other corporate executives and first-time public company directors >Fewer active CEOs – 33%; down from 41% in ’02 and 53% in ’00 >More active and retired senior corporate executives (e.g., division managers and functional unit leaders) – 21% vs. 7% in ’02 >33% are first-time public company directors >Mandatory retirement age more prevalent and older >35% of boards have separated the CEO/chair roles, up from 32% in ’06 and 25% in ’02 >More boards shifting toward lead director designation; 40% designate lead director, up from 28% in ‘04 >Total director compensation is now disclosed in proxies; all-inclusive average total compensation is $211,179 >Committees meeting more; number of meetings for Big 3 committees all up from last year * Not yet released

12 Future Trends >More first-time directors >Greater need for director education >More new directors are likely to be heir-apparent executives versus active CEOs >More diversity in the boardroom >More strategic focus in board composition >Board agenda: succession and strategy