Digital Libraries from Theory to Framework to Application: 5S Model, Open Archives Initiative, and Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
E-Content Service Group Virtual Meeting Digital Preservation: How to Get Started.
Advertisements

Supporting further and higher education The JISC FAIR Programme and International E-theses Developments.
1 Introduction to NDLTD and Brief History of the ETD Movement ETD 2008: 11 th Int. Symp. on ETDs Aberdeen, Scotland: Newcomers Edward A. Fox,
1 NDLTD Union Catalog Panel Session 1C, Auditorium Introduction and Opening Statement ETD 2011: 14 th Int. Symp. on ETDs Cape Town, South Africa Edward.
Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations Croatia - May 1999 Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA
Internet Resources Discovery (IRD) IBM DB2 Digital Library Thanks to Zvika Michnik and Avital Greenberg.
The Open Archives Initiative Simeon Warner (Cornell University) Symposium on “Scholarly Publishing and Archiving on the Web”, University.
Corporation For National Research Initiatives NSF SMETE Library Building the SMETE Library: Getting Started William Y. Arms.
© 2013 Association for Computing Machinery Honeywell Introduction to the ACM Digital Library January 16, 2013 Honeywell Introduction to the ACM Digital.
Data-PASS Shared Catalog Micah Altman & Jonathan Crabtree 1 Micah Altman Harvard University Archival Director, Henry A. Murray Research Archive Associate.
International Cooperation in Digital Libraries CoLIS May 1999 Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA
Digital Libraries and the Open Archives Initiative Louisiana State University June 30, 2000 Edward A. Fox CC CS DLRL Internet.
Continuing Evolution of the NDLTD 18 May 1999 ETD Workshop Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA
Digital Library Architecture and Technology
Dienst Distributed Networked Publishing Carl Lagoze Digital Library Scientist Cornell University.
Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations ( ECDL 2000 Panel 3 “Digital Libraries Programs and International Cooperation” September.
CONTI’2008, 5-6 June 2008, TIMISOARA 1 Towards a digital content management system Gheorghe Sebestyen-Pal, Tünde Bálint, Bogdan Moscaliuc, Agnes Sebestyen-Pal.
Digital Libraries, OAI, ETDs, and NDLTD SEALS ETD Meeting October 25, 2000 Edward A. Fox CS DLRL Internet TIC Virginia.
ECDL Workshop “Extending Interoperability of Digital Libraries: Building on the Open Archives Initiative” Lisbon – September 21, 2000 Edward A. Fox
WVU Electronic Theses & Dissertations Transforming Graduate Education and Research.
Dr. Kurt Fendt, Comparative Media Studies, MIT MetaMedia An Open Platform for Media Annotation and Sharing Workshop "Online Archives:
US-Korea Joint Workshop on Digital Libraries SDSC - August 10-11, 2000 Open Archives Edward A. Fox CS DLRL Internet TIC.
How to participate in the Union Catalogue Project Hussein Suleman Sivulile – Open Access South Africa Advanced Information Management.
OCLC Online Computer Library Center CONTENTdm ® Digital Collection Management Software Ron Gardner, OCLC Digital Services Consultant ICOLC Meeting April.
1 The Chemistry Preprint Server: An Experiment in Scientific Communication James Weeks, ChemWeb Inc. 84 Theobalds Road, Holborn, London WC1X 8RR
Marshall University Electronic Theses & Dissertations Program Implementation Issues & Responsibilities.
LIS 506 (Fall 2006) LIS 506 Information Technology Week 11: Digital Libraries & Institutional Repositories.
1 Introduction to NDLTD and Brief History of the ETD Movement ETD 2009: 12 th Int. Symp. on ETDs Pittsburgh, PA: Newcomers Edward A. Fox, Executive.
1 CS 502: Computing Methods for Digital Libraries Lecture 28 Current work in preservation.
Joining the Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations (NDLTD) ETD Project Team Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA
The Open Archives Initiative (OAI) and Electronic Theses and Dissertations (ETDs) ASIDIC ‘2000 Orlando, FL - March 27, 2000 Edward A. Fox
VTLS, Inc. – NDLTD Collaboration on Electronic Theses and Dissertations (ETDs) VTLS Mtg – Blacksburg, VA May 3, 2000 Edward A. Fox
West Virginia University Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
Collaborative Research: Curriculum Development for Digital Library Education Presentation in May 1,2006
1 NDLTD Welcome and Introduction ETD 2014: 17 th Int’l Symposium on ETDs Leicester, England Edward A. Fox Executive Director, NDLTD,
Creating and Operating a Digital Library for Information and Learning– the GROW Project Muniram Budhu Department of Civil Engineering & Engineering Mechanics.
ETD Rookies: NDLTD Background ETD 2004 University of Kentucky June 3, 2004 Edward A. Fox
ETD’2001, March 22, 2001, Caltech, Pasadena, CA Panel 1: Developing the UNESCO International Guide for ETDs: A Multilingual Training Resource of Best Practices.
WVU Electronic Theses & Dissertations Transforming Graduate Education and Research.
CITIDEL: Computing & Information Technology Interactive Digital Educational Library Web Page: Contacts: Future.
1 NDLTD Welcome and Introduction ETD 2011: 14 th Int. Symp. on ETDs Cape Town, South Africa Edward A. Fox Executive Director, NDLTD,
MARIAN: Searching and Querying Across Heterogeneous Federated Digital Libraries Marcos André Gonçalves Robert K. France Edward A. Fox Tamas E. Doszkocs.
Electronic Theses and Dissertations An American Perspective Gail Digital Library and Archives Virginia.
Topical Categorization of Large Collections of Electronic Theses and Dissertations Venkat Srinivasan & Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA.
Extending Access To Information Resource Discovery Service William E. Moen, Ph.D. Kathleen R. Murray, Ph.D. School of Library and Information Sciences.
Collaboration on Digital Libraries NEC Dec. 27, 2000 Edward A. Fox CS DLRL Internet TIC Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA,
Tsinghua University Library Yang Zhao & Airong Jiang Tsinghua University Library, Beijing China 4 June, 2004 Electronic Thesis and Dissertation System.
XXDL and CSTC and Virginia Tech NSDL Fall 2000 PI Meeting September 22-24, 2000 NSF, Arlington, VA Edward A. Fox CS DLRL.
This presentation describes the development and implementation of WSU Research Exchange, a permanent digital repository system that is being, adding WSU.
Digital Library The networked collections of digital text, documents, images, sounds, scientific data, and software that are the core of today’s Internet.
Digital Libraries1 David Rashty. Digital Libraries2 “A library is an arsenal of liberty” Anonymous.
Corporation For National Research Initiatives Technical Issues in Electronic Publishing Corporation for National Research Initiatives William Y. Arms.
1 Video Message: Welcome ETD 2015: 18 th Int’l Symposium on ETDs New Delhi, India Edward A. Fox Executive Director, Chairman of the Board NDLTD,
Introduction to Concept Maps Edward A. Fox and Rao Shen CS5604 Fall 2002 “Information Storage & Retrieval” Dept. of Computer Science Virginia Tech, Blacksburg,
Information Retrieval
What to Expect from ETDs: Library Issues and Responsibilities Gail McMillan director, Digital Library and Archives University Libraries,
A Resource Discovery Service for the Library of Texas Requirements, Architecture, and Interoperability Testing William E. Moen, Ph.D. Principal Investigator.
ETD Search Services Ming Luo Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech.
Opportunities and Challenges for the NSDL Program October 15, 2003 K20 and the National Agenda Internet 2 Fall Member Meeting Indianapolis.
Open Archives Initiative Gail McMillan Digital Library and Archives, Virginia Tech Society for Scholarly Publishing: June 1, 2000.
ETDs and NDLTD Hussein Suleman University of Cape Town May 2004.
Designing Protocols in Support of Digital Library Componentization Hussein Suleman and Edward A. Fox Digital Library Research Laboratory Virginia Tech.
NDLTD Union Collection User Services Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech DLRL March 2001.
Computing should take the lead in requiring all theses and dissertations to be archived and made available electronically, including multimedia … US universities.
Introduction to USETDA and Brief History of the ETD Movement John Hagen, Consultant – Renaissance Scholarly Communications / Board Member – NDLTD and USETDA.
Electronic Theses and Dissertations: A Status Report for 2001 Paul A. Soderdahl University of Iowa Libraries IACON 2001, Buena Vista University June 1,
CONTENTdm A proven solution September A complete digital collection management software solution Stores, manages and provides access for all digital.
Edward A. Fox Virginia Tech Blacksburg, VA USA
Introduction to NDLTD and Brief History of the ETD Movement ETD 2008: 11th Int. Symp. on ETDs Aberdeen, Scotland: Newcomers Edward A. Fox,
Introduction to NDLTD and Brief History of the ETD Movement ETD 2017: 20th Int’l Symposium of the NDLTD Washington, D.C., USA; August 7-9, 2017 ETDs.
Presentation transcript:

Digital Libraries from Theory to Framework to Application: 5S Model, Open Archives Initiative, and Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations December 6, Seoul Edward A. Fox CS DLRL Internet TIC Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA

Acknowledgements (Selected) F Mentors: JCR Licklider, Michael Kessler, Gerard Salton F Sponsors: Adobe, IBM, Microsoft, NLM, NSF, OCLC, SOLINET, SURA, UNESCO, US Dept. of Ed. (FIPSE), … F VT Faculty/Staff: Tony Atkins, Thomas Dunbar, Debra Dudley, John Eaton, Gwen Ewing, Peter Haggerty, Gary Hooper, Gail McMillan, Len Peters, James Powell, …  VT Students: Emilio Arce, Fernando Das Neves, Brian DeVane, Robert France, Marcos Goncalves, Scott Guyer, Robert Hall, Neill Kipp, Paul Mather, Tim McGonigle, Todd Miller, Constantinos Phanouriou, William Schweiker, Ohm Sornil, Hussein Suleman, Patrick Van Metre, Laura Weiss, …

JCDL 2001  First Joint ACM/IEEE Conference on Digital Libraries (+ NSF DLI-2 PI mtg) F F June 24-28, 2001 in Roanoke, VA F Conference Committee: F General Chair: Edward A. Fox, Virginia Tech F Program Chair: Christine Borgman, UCLA F Treasurer: Neil Rowe, Naval Postgraduate School F Posters Chair: Craig Nevill-Manning, Rutgers U.

Virginia Tech Background F Largest university in Virginia, land-grant, football, town population 35K plus 25K students F Blacksburg Electronic Village, since 1992, with > 80% of community on Internet F Net.Work.Virginia, largest ATM network, with over 900 sites, for education, research, government F LMDS, Local Multipoint Distribution Service, gigabit wireless networking - 1/3 of Virginia F Math Emporium, 500 workstations F Faculty Development Initiative, round 2 F Torgersen Hall, $30M Advanced Communications and Information Technology Center, opening, w. DLRL

Internet Technology Innovation Center Supported by Virginia’s Center for Innovative Technology Statewide University Partners - Governing Board: F Christopher Newport University –William Winter, William Muir, Virginia Electronic Commerce Technology Center / Southeastern Virginia Network (VECTEC/SEVAnet) F George Mason University –Scott Martin, Internet Multimedia Center (ICM) –Steven Ruth, International Center for Applied Studies in IT (ICASIT) F University of Virginia –Alf Weaver, Internet Commerce Group (InterCom) –Jim French, Internet Digital Library F Virginia Tech –Edward Fox, Digital Library Research Laboratory (DLRL), CC, CS –Scott Midkiff, Center for Wireless Telecomm. (CWT), VTISC, ECpE

VT Research Areas F Collaboration (e.g., group decision support) F Community networking (e.g., BEV) F Internet access (e.g., statewide network) F Information services (e.g., digital libraries) F Modeling and simulation (e.g., Web traffic) F Usability (e.g., human factors engineering) F Virtual environments (e.g., CAVE, visualization)

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

Digital Library Courseware F F WWW pages or large PDF copy files F CourseInfo quizzes based on books by Michael Lesk (MKP.com) and William Arms (MIT Press) F Contents based on books, with other popular topics added (e.g., agents) F Separate pages to supplement: Definitions, Resources (People, Projects), and References

Digital Libraries --- Virginia Tech F MARIAN (NLM) F CS DL Prototype - ENVISION (NSF, ACM) F TULIP (Elsevier, OCLC) F BEV History Base (NSF, Blacksburg) F DL for CS Education - EI (NSF, ACM) F WATERS, NCSTRL (NSF) F NDLTD (SURA, US Dept. of Education) F CSTC (NSF, ACM), CRIM (NSF, SIGMM) F WCA (Log) Repository (W3C) F VT-PetaPlex-1 (Knowledge Systems)

Libraries of the Future JCR Licklider, 1965, MIT Press World Nation Province City Community

DL-Related Timeline 1985 CoRR DLI ETDs 1990 xxx 1995 XML OAI 2000 NCSTRL PDF Proposed Ugrad DL NDLTD DLI2 HyperCard TEI SGML PCs Hypertext Conf. DCRDF CSTR NSDL Scholarly EPub in U’s JPEG, MPEG MPEG-7 WWW Java

Computing (flops) Digital content Communicat i ons (bandwidth, connectivity) Locating Digital Libraries in Computing and Communications Technology Space Digital Libraries technology trajectory: intellectual access to globally distributed information lessmore (Slide from S. Griffin, NSF)

Structured Video Browser (making video into hypermedia) F IBrowse F Expository multimedia F Narrative Structures

ICU Information and Communication University Users Web Search Engines WWW Servlet Engine Web Server OS DB Search Server Servlet MPEG-7 Description Module ’ 4’ 5’ MPEG-7 Image Library Systems Tech. t MPEG-7 Image Library Systems

t MPEG-7 Video Library Systems Tech. ICU Information and Communication University MPEG-7 Video Library Systems Tech. Video Data Description Generator Description Schemes Design Tool Description Scheme Meta Database Video Database Retrieval Server Module Player Presentation Module Architecture

Integrated CCLINC Translingual Information System DARPA Extraction What is the north korean movement in the front line? CCLINC SERVER Info Detection Summarization It seems that North Korea launch a missile again After North Korea launched a Daipodong missile last month, NK is perceived to proceed to an additional test launch. Korea, US and Japan enter into an alert state, and prepare for a joint response policy. Korea estimates that the additional launch will be on 09/05. Japan estimates that NK’s missile range is short. US information says that there is no sign of launch yet. Translation What is the status of nk missile launch against japan? BugHanI IlBonE Ddo MiSaIlEul BalSaHan Deus HaDa 2-way Speech Transation

Digital Libraries Shorten the Chain from Editor Publisher A&I Consolidator Library Reviewer

DL = Users Direct (Organized Artifact Mediated Communication) Author Reader Digital Library Editor Reviewer Teacher Learner LibrarianDr.Patient

Digital Libraries --- Objectives F World Lit.: 24hr / 7day / from desktop F Integrated “super” information systems: 5S: streams, structures, spaces, scenarios, societies F Ubiquitous, Higher Quality, Lower Cost F Education, Knowledge Sharing, Discovery F Disintermediation -> Collaboration F Universities Reclaim Property F Interactive Courseware, Student Works F Scalable, Sustainable, Usable, Useful

Benefits F Ease of use F Effectiveness F “The benefits of digital libraries will not be appreciated unless they are easy to use effectively.” - IITA Workshop report

DLs: Why of Global Interest? F National projects can preserve antiquities and heritage: cultural, historical, linguistic, scholarly F Knowledge and information are essential to economic and technological growth, education F DL - a domain for international collaboration –wherein all can contribute and benefit –which leverages investment in networking –which provides useful content on Internet & WWW –which will tie nations and peoples together more strongly and through deeper understanding

Borgman et al.: Workshop Report on Social Aspects of Digital Libraries: ucla.edu/DL/ Information Life Cycle

Grand Challenges Can F Mobilize the community F Spur creativity F Lead to important benefits in society F Push researchers to develop relevant theories F Force people to work in teams/groups F Convince funding agencies to invest F Help bring about integration of systems, interoperability, and seamless interfaces

DL Challenges F World Digital Library (Libraries) F Preservation - so people with trust DLs F Scalability, sustainability, interoperability F (Supporting infrastructure - networks, …) F DL industry - critical mass by covering libraries, archives, museums, corporate info, govt info, personal info - “quality WWW” integrating IR, HT, MM,... –Need tools & methods to make them easier to build

Licklider – Unified Theory? F Not ready in 1960s F Analog – unified field theory in physics F “Mess” today – segmented field, specialities –Database Knowledge Content Mgmnt –Multimedia, Hypermedia, Hypertext –Logic, Algebra, Artificial Intelligence, … F Expensive, annoying for users –Don’t know where to look –Don’t know how to use services

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

Definitions F Library ++ (library+archive+museum+…) F Distributed information system + organization + effective interface F User community + collection + services F Digital objects, repositories, IPR management, handles, indexes, federated search, hyperbase, annotation

Definition: Digital Libraries are complex systems that F help satisfy info needs of users (societies) F provide info services (scenarios) F organize info in usable ways (structures) F present info in usable ways (spaces) F communicate info with users (streams)

5S Layers Societies Scenarios Spaces Structures Streams

Definition: 5S Framework F Societies: interacting people (, computers) F Scenarios: services, functions, operations, methods F Spaces: domains + constraints (e.g., distance, adjacency): 2D, vector, probability F Structures: relations, trees, nodes and arcs F Streams: sequences of items (text, audio, video, network traffic) F (5 Element System: Fire, Wood, Earth, Metal, Water)

5S: Combinations F Societies + Scenarios = user model F Societies + Scenarios + Spaces = user interface F Streams + Structures = markup F Streams + Structures + Scenarios = object F Structures + Scenarios = DBMS

Core of DL F Collecting –Authoring, Repositories, Archives, Museums, … F Organizing –Packaging of Data and Metadata, Storing –Naming/Identifying and Cataloging –Classification, Clustering, … F Serving –Indexing, Linking, Summarizing, Visualizing –Browsing, Accessing, Searching, Filtering, Retrieving, Distributing, Using, …

DL Components User Interfaces Workflow Mgr DBMS Search Engines, Classifiers, … Data, MM Info Gateways Repository Rights Mgr MM/ HT Renderer

Document Models, Representations, and Accesses F Doc = stream + structure + use-scenario; hybrid (paper/electronic), digital only F Multilingual: content, summary, metadata F Multimedia: structure, quality (oS), search F Structured: MARC, SGML, by user: MVD F Distributed collection: Kleisli, CIMI, Z39.50 F Federated search: collecting, picking site(s), parallel search / fall-back, fusing results F Access: IPR, payment, security, scenarios

Architectural Issues F Internet middleware F Independent system / part of federation F Decompositions vary –search engine, browser, DBMS, MM support –repository, handle server, client –information resources + mediators, bus or agent collection + client with workspace/environment F Metrics: e.g., for federated search

Standards F Protocols/federation –Z39.50, CIMI –Dienst, NCSTRL –OAi protocol F Metadata –TEI: inline, detailed (structure in stream) –MARC: two-level, fine-grained –Dublin Core: high-level, 15 elements –RDF: describing resources/collections, annotation –OAMS and others used in OAi

(2 slides from Lee Zia, NSF) Presidential Directive - 12/17/1999 Subject: Use of Information Technology to Improve Our Society “ 13. The Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, the Director of the National Science Foundation, the Director of the National Park Service, and the Director of the Institute of Museum and Library Services shall work with the private sector and cultural and educational institutions across the country to create a Digital Library of Education to house this country's cultural and educational resources.”

Programmatic History Digital Libraries Initiative (DLI 1) - NSF/NASA/ARPA, FY DLI 2 - NSF, et al., initiated in FY 98, continuing Education FY DLI 2 Special Emphasis in Undergrad NSDL Program NSF: FY DL Operational Fall, 2002 DLs & UG Earth Systems Education initiated FY 99, continuing

CS -> CSTC -> CRIM -> JERIC F NSF and ACM Education Committee are funding a 2 year project “A Computer Science Teaching Center” - CSTC - F College of NJ, U. Ill. Springfield, Virginia Tech F Focus initially on labs, visualization, multimedia F Multimedia part is also supported by a 2nd grant to Virginia Tech and The George Washington University: F ACM J. of Educational Resources in Computing

Author‘s tools

DL Components User Interfaces Workflow Mgr DBMS Search Engines, Classifiers, … Data, MM Info Gateways Repository Rights Mgr MM/ HT Renderer

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

Open Archives Initiative OAI

Open Archives Initiative (OAI) F high-energy physics (Ginsparg, 1991) F CSTR + WATERS = NCSTRL (Lagoze,1994) F xxx + NCSTRL = CoRR collaboration (1998) F Universal Preprint Service protoproto, Oct , 1999, Santa Fe – led by LANL, CNI, DLF, Mellon --> OAi F Santa Fe Convention (see Feb. D-Lib Magazine article) F Follow-on mtgs: Antonio, (ECDL) F Archives -> Open Archives –Support unique archive identifiers –Implement Open Archives metadata set (DC, using XML) –Implement OA harvesting protocol (derived from Dienst protocol) –Register the archive F Build tools, layer other services: linking, searching, …

Metadata: Complex -> Simple MARC ($50)Dublin Core (DC)

OAI – Repository Perspective Required: Protocol DO MDO

OAI – Black Box Perspective OA 1OA 2OA 4OA 3OA 5OA 6OA 7

Black Box OAI-ETD Perspective ISTEC (Ibero America) PhysDisNSYSU (Taiwan) ADT (Australia) BN.PT (Portugal) (Francophone) VTDissert.Online (Germany) MITOhioLINKCBUC (Catalunya) NDC (Greece) SEALS (S.Africa) CICU. Bergen (Norway) … …

Tiered Model of Interoperability Mediator services Metadata harvesting Document models

OAi Philosophy F Self-archiving = submission mechanism F Long-term storage system = archive F Open interface = harvesting mechanism F Data provider + service provider F Start with “gray literature” –e-prints/pre-prints, reports, dissertations, …

Archive of Digital Objects Archive Access Protocol Handle (ID) Digital object terms and conditions

Open Archives (protoproto) F ArXiv & Los Alamos National Lab F CogPrints & U. Southampton F NACA & NASA (reports) F NCSTRL & Cornell U. F NDLTD & Virginia Tech F RePEc & U. Surrey F Total of around 200K records

Original Open Archives Members F American Physical Society F California Digital Library F Caltech F Coalition for Networked Info. F Cornell University F Harvard University F Library of Congress F Los Alamos Nat’l Lab F Mellon Foundation F NASA Langley Research Cntr F Old Dominion University F Stanford University F U. of Ghent F U. of Surrey F U. of Southampton F Vanderbilt University F Virginia Tech F Washington University

Open Archives Future F EconWPA (U. Washington) F e-biomed -> PubMed Central (NIH) F PubScience (DOE) F Clinical Medicine Netprints (+ other HighWire Press holdings ) F University ePub (California Digital Library) F All public e-prints (MIT) F Scholar’s Forum (Caltech) F Int’l: CERN, Germany, India, Mexico, … F Goal: millions of books/articles/reports / yr

Approaches to Open Archives Build By Discipline Build By Institution

Approaches to Open Archives Build By Discipline Build By Institution Author Category Interdisciplinary Year Language Query …

Mechanisms F Sharing –Join federation, run software –Make metadata and archive available F Aggregating –By discipline –By institution –By genre F Automating –Workflow –Harvesting and providing services –Federated searching –Dynamic linking (e.g., with SFX)

VT View of the Open Archives Initiative (OAI) F Enable sharing of publication metadata and full- text by digital libraries F Standardize low-level mechanisms to share contents of libraries F Build higher-level user-centric and administrative services in meta-libraries F Install organizational mechanisms to support the technical processes

Virginia Tech Projects F MARC XML-DTD F Computer Science Teaching Centre (CSTC) F W3C Web Characterization Repository F OAI Repository Explorer F Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations (NDLTD)

MARC XML-DTD F XML Transport format for US-MARC records F Standardized metadata exchange format for traditional library services joining OAI

CS Teaching Center (CSTC) F Collection of reviewed online resources used to aid in teaching of Computer Science F Supports author submission and peer-review process for new ACM Journal of Educational Resources In Computing (JERIC) F Connected with NSDL (NSF 00-44) F

W3C Web Characterization Repository F Online database of metadata related to publications, tools and data sets dealing with Web characterization F Project of the Web Characterization Activity working group of the World-Wide-Web Consortium ( F

OAI Repository Explorer F Serves as a compliancy test F Allows browsing of open archives using only OAI protocol F Sends requests on behalf of user, parses and checks responses and displays browsable interface F Will detect most discrepancies in protocol F

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

A Digital Library Case Study F Domain: graduate education, research F Genre: ETDs = electronic theses & dissertations F Submission: F Collection: Project: Networked Digital Library of Theses & Dissertations (NDLTD – remember: ND LTD / NDL TD) (also, newer NUDL: Networked University Digital Library, with e-courseware, etc.)

The Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations Leader of the Worldwide ETD (Electronic Thesis and Dissertation) Initiative Training Authors Expanding Access Preserving Knowledge Improving Graduate Education Enhancing Scholarly Communication Empowering Students & Universities

Grad Program Library IT Ed. (Tech)

Media ETD Web Site ETDs Got Your Interest? Graduate Students Singapore AM Chronicle of Higher Ed. National Public Radio NY Times... U. Laval

Key Ideas: Networked infrastructure Scalability Education is the rationale University collaboration Workflow, automation Authors must submit Maximal Access PDF, SGML, MM, MARC, DC, URNs, Federated search Standards 8th graders vs. grads

What led to today’s meeting? F 1987 mtg in Ann Arbor: UMI, VT, … F 1992 mtg in Washington: CNI, CGS, UMI, VT and 10 universities with 3 reps each F 1993 mtg in Atlanta to start Monticello Electronic Library (MEL): SURA, SOLINET F 1994 mtg in Blacksburg re ETD project: std of PDF + SGML + multimedia objects F 1996 funding by SURA, US Dept. of Education (FIPSE) for regional, national projects F 1997 meetings in UK, Germany,... F 1998 – 1 st symposium – Memphis (20) F 1999 – 2 nd symposium – Blacksburg (70) F 2000 – 3 rd symposium – St. Petersburg (225) -> Caltech

What are the long term goals? F Attract all TDs/yr: 50K D-US, 25K D-Germany, 10K TD-Canada, … F >200K/yr rich hypermedia ETDs that may turn into electronic portfolios (images, video, audio, …) F Dramatic increase in knowledge sharing: literature reviews, bibliographies, … F Services providing lifelong access for students: browse, search, prior searches, citation links F Hundreds/thousands of downloads / year / work

ETDs: Library Goals F Improve library services –Better turn-around time –Always available F Reduce work –catalog from e-text –eliminate handling: mailing to UMI, bindery prep, check-out, check-in, reshelving, etc. F Save space

F Aiding universities to enhance graduate education, publishing and IPR efforts F Helping improve the availability and content of theses and dissertations F Educating ALL future scholars so they can publish electronically and effectively use digital libraries (i.e., are Information Literate and can be more expressive) What are we doing?

NDLTD Computer Resources Research Literature Student Prepares Thesis/Dissertation

Student Defends & Finalizes ETD My Thesis ETD

Student Gets Committee Signatures and Submits ETD Signed Grad School

Graduate School Approves ETD, Student is Graduated Ph.D.

Library Catalogs ETD, Access is Opened to the New Research WWW NDLTD

Status of the Local Project F Approved by university governance Spring 1996; required starting 1/1/97 F Submission & access software in place F Submission workshops for students (and faculty) occur often: beginner/adv. F Faculty training as part of Faculty Development Initiative F Over 3000 ETDs in collection – some have audio, video, large images, software, …

Archiving ETDs F Every 15 minutes back-ups made of not- yet-approved submissions F Hourly back-ups of newly approved ETDs F Weekly back-ups of entire ETD collection F Copies stored on-site and off-site

VT ETD Cataloging F same as current cataloging policies, except: –author-assigned keywords (not LCSH) –generic (not LC) call no. –fields/subfields as required for computer files –full abstracts F time savings –cataloger familiar with computer files –equipment, software for word processing –5 minutes avg. (10-15 minutes for paper TDs)

Library Costs F $12/vol. for paper thesis processing – catalog, bind, security strip, label, shelve vols./yr. = $11,466 F $3.20/vol. ETD processing – vols./yr. = $3040 F $.07/vol. shelving F $.04/vol. circulation

Costs/Savings at VT F Graduate School stopped shipping to the library 3000 copies of paper TDs/year F Library stopped binding, shelving, and circulating 3000 copies of TDs/year F 166 ft of shelf space saved/year by the library F VT used existing equipment in Library (vs. start-up costs for staff, hardware and software from from a zero-base estimate: $65,000 – see

Institutional Members F Coalition for Networked Information (CNI) F Committee on Institutional Cooperation (CIC) F Diplomica.com F Dissertation.com F Dissertationen Online (Germany) F ETDweb, a Division of Answer4.com F Ibero-American Science & Technology Education Consortium (ISTEC) F National Documentation Centre (NDC), Greece F National Library of Portugal (for all universities) F OCLC Online Computer Library Center F Organization of American States (SEDI/OAS) F Southeastern Library Network (SOLINET) F UNESCO (

National / Regional Projects F Australia –U. New South Wales (lead) –U. of Melbourne –U. of Queensland –U. of Sydney –Australian National U. –Curtin U. of Technology –Griffith U. F Germany –Humboldt University (lead) –3 other universities –5 learned societies: Math, Physics, Chemistry, Sociology, Education –1 computing center –2 major libraries F Consorci de Biblioteques Universitàries de Catalunya, as group, –Universitat de Barcelona –Universitat Autonòma de Barcelona –Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya –Universitat Pompeu Fabra –Universitat de Girona –Universitat de Lleida –Universitat Rovira i Virgili –Universitat Oberta de Catalunya –Biblioteca de Catalunya F South Africa: ECHEA/SEALS F India, Portugal, …

OhioLINK F Statewide Consortium F Represents 79 colleges, universities, libraries F Public Universities F Private Universities and Colleges F 2-Year Colleges F Only a few (e.g., Miami U. of Ohio) are also NDLTD members on their own

US University Members (44) F Penn. State University F Rochester Institute of Tech. F U. of Colorado Health Science Center F U. of Florida F U. of Georgia F University of Hawaii, Manoa F U. of Iowa F U. of Kentucky F U. of Maine F U. of North Texas – required since 8/99 F U. of Oklahoma F U. of South Florida F U. of Tennessee, Knoxville F U. of Tennessee, Memphis F U. of Texas at Austin – required in 2001 F U. of Virginia F U. Wisconsin - Madison F Vanderbilt U. F Virginia Commonwealth U. F Virginia Tech - required since 1/97 F West Virginia U. - required fall 1998 F Western Michigan U. F Worcester Polytechnic Inst. F Air University (Alabama) F Baylor University F Brigham Young University (part, whole) F Caltech F Clemson University F College of William & Mary F Concordia University (Illinois) F East Carolina University F East Tenn. State U. – require fall 2000 F Florida Institute of Technology F Florida International University F George Washington University F Louisiana State University F Marshall University (W. Va.) F Miami University of Ohio F Michigan Tech F Mississippi State University F MIT F Naval Postgraduate School (CA) F New Mexico Tech F North Carolina State University

Other Countries with Members F Belgium F Brazil F Canada F Germany F Hong Kong F India F Italy F Korea F Mexico F Netherland F Norway F Russia F Singapore F S. Africa F S. Korea F Spain F Taiwan F UK

For professional societies F Like “writing across the curriculum”, e.g., Chemical Markup Language, MathML, … F Besides writing: computing/communications, information literacy, personal digital library management, tool use, research methods, collaboration, archiving/preservation F Data sets, communities of users of them F Classification systems / browsing / searching F NRC’s “On becoming a researcher”

Usage of ETDs in VT Collections Jan-Aug Total requests 37,171247,537465,974907,104 Daily Requests ,7223,121 Abstract requests 25,829112,633177,647143,056 Hosts served 9,01522,72528,02252,663

Popular Works Seevers, Gary L. Identification of Criteria for Delivery of Theological Education Through Distance Education: An International Delphi Study (Ph.D., Educational Research and Evaluation, April 1993; 1353Kb) 432 Hohauser, Robyn Lisa. The Social Construction of Technology: The Case of LSD (MS in Science and Technology Studies, Feb. 1995; 244Kb) 390 Childress, Vincent William. The Effects of Technology Education, Science, and Mathematics Integration Upon Eighth Grader's Technological Problem-Solving Ability (Ph.D. in Vocational and Technical Education, July 1994; 285Kb) 310 Kuhn, William B. Design of Integrated, Low Power, Radio Receivers in BiCMOS Technologies (Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering, Dec. 1995; 2Mb) 287 Sprague, Milo D. A High Performance DSP Based System Architecture for Motor Drive Control ( MS in Electrical Engineering, May 1993; 878Kb) 165 Wallace, Richard A. Regional Differences in the Treatment of Karl Marx by the Founders of American Academic Sociology (MS in Sociology, Nov. 1993; 479Kb) 150 McKeel, Scott Andrew. Numerical Simulation of the Transition Region in Hypersonic Flow (Ph.D. in Aerospace Engineering, Feb. 1996; 3Mb)

Popular Works Liu, Xiangdong. Analysis and Reduction of Moire Patterns in Scanned Halftone Pictures (Ph.D. in Computer Science, May 1996; 6.6Mb) 7656 Petrus, Paul. Novel Adaptive Array Algorithms and Their Impact on Cellular System Capacity (Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering, March 1997; 5Mb) 2781 Agnes, Gregory Stephen. Performance of Nonlinear Mechanical, Resonant-Shunted Piezoelectric, and Electronic Vibration Absorbers for Multi-Degree-of-Freedom Structures (Ph.D. in Engineering Mechanics, Sept. 1997; ? Kb) 2492 Gonzalez, Reinaldo J. Raman, Infrared, X-ray, and EELS Studies of Nanophase Titania (Ph.D. in Physics, July 1996; 4607Kb) 1877 Shih, Po-Jen. On-Line Consolidation of Thermoplastic Composites (Ph.D. in Engineering Mechanics, Feb. 1997; 3.3Mb) 1791 Saldanha, Kevin J. Performance Evaluation of DECT in Different Radio Environments (MS in Electrical Engineering, Aug. 1996; 3.2Mb) 1431 DeVaux, David. A Tutorial on Authorware (MS in CS, April 1996; 2.3Mb) 1394 Kuhn, William B. Design of Integrated, Low Power, Radio Receivers in BiCMOS Technologies (Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering, Dec. 1995; 2518Kb)

International Use   United Kingdom  6082, Australia  Germany  Canada  South Korea  France  Italy  Netherlands  Brazil  Thailand  Greece

NUDL F 1/15/99 Networked University Digital Library (NUDL) proposal to NSF under DLI2 international program –VT: Library, Grad School, Industrial&Systems Eng. –Partners: UK (2), Singapore, Russia, Korea, Greece, Germany, plus Iberoamerican group (Spain, Portugal, Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Mexico) –Problems: Multilingual search, multimedia submissions, requirements/usability, international performance, … F Start with ETDs, then expand to other student works, portfolios, data sets, (CS) courseware,...

NUDL Research Partners F Ricardo A. Baeza-Yates, Universidad de Chile, Chile F José Luis Brinquete Borbinha, Biblioteca Nacional, Portugal F José Hilario Canós Cerdá, Universidad Politécnica de Valencia, Spain F Stavros Christodoulakis, Technical University of Crete, Greece F Eberhard Hilf, University of Oldenburg, Germany F Peter Diepold, Susanne Dobratz, …, Humboldt University, Germany F David Garza-Salazar, Monterrey Inst. of Technology (ITESM), Mexico F Sung Hyon Myaeng, Chungnam National University, Korea (+ colleagues) F Ana Maria Beltran Pavani, Prédio Cardeal Leme, Brazil F Lim Ee Peng, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore F Alexander I. Plemnek, St.-Petersburg State Technical University, Russia F Berthier Ribeiro-Neto, Federal U. of Minas Gerais (UFMG), Brazil F J. Alfredo Sánchez, Universidad de las Américas-Puebla, Mexico

Who are sponsors / cooperators? F Funding, Donations of hardware/software –SURA –US Dept. of Education (FIPSE) –Adobe Systems –IBM –Microsoft –OCLC F Others Serving on Steering Committee –National/Regional Projects: Australia, French speaking group (Montreal, Lyon), Germany, IberoAmerica (ISTEC, OAS), UK (UTOG) –CGS, National Lib. Canada, NSF, SOLINET, UMI, UNESCO,...

Relationship with publishers F Concern of faculty and students that still wish to publish books or journal articles, voiced: campus, Chronicle, NPR, Times F Solution: Approval Form gives students, faculty choices on access, when to change access condition; use IPR controls in DL F Solution: by case, work with publishers and publisher associations to increase access – AAP, AAUP – AAAS, ACM, ACS, Elsevier,...

Some responses from publishers F ACM: need to acknowledge copyright F Elsevier: need to acknowledge copyright F IEEE-CS: endorse initiative F ACS: After first publication, can release F Textbook publishers: different market, manuscript significantly reworked F General: restricting access to local campus will not cause any problems

How does this relate to UMI? F Generally, they are independent decisions. F 1987 UMI workshop was first to explore ETDs. F UMI wrote support letter for US Dept. of Ed. proposal. F UMI is on Steering Committee. F ProQuest Direct pilot of scanning works started 1/1/97, with free 2 yr access to front part. F We are collaborating on: – accepting electronic author submissions – standards (e.g., representation)

ETD Initiative (and UMI) Students Learn about DL, EPub TDs become more expressive N. Amer. (T)Ds are accessible, archived Global TDs become more accessible, archived UMI Universities

User Search Support (multilingual, XML) Note: All groups shown are connected with NDLTD.

F James Powell student project, D-Lib Magazine description in Sept F XML description of each site –type of search engine / service –language –coverage (for resource discovery) F Adding Z39.50 gateway capability and integrating with MARIAN, along with Harvest and Open Archives protocols

Interoperability Tests Planned F IBM DL: donated equipment, technical support, powerful IPR (see TOIS, D-Lib) F Z39.50: OCLC SiteSearch / VT tailored s/w –university libraries w. catalogs of freely shared MARC records pointing to archival copies –via URNs: handles & PURLs F Dienst / NCSTRL - CS depts., DARPA, NSF, CNRI, Cornell – UVA, MIT have worked on extensions for ETDs - Portugal is studying use for Europe - VT is working on Dienst to Z39.50 gateway

Access Approaches F Goal: Maximize access and services, e.g., by encouraging: F UMI centralized services F VTLS: planned free union collection of metadata F Distributed service: Dienst, Z39.50 F Regional services (e.g., OhioLink, AZ/NM) F Local servers with browse, search – From local catalogs to local archives F WWW robot indexing and search services

Access Possibilities Web search engines library catalog clients www. theses. org www. openarchives. org 3 rd Party Services (e.g., UMI) Virginia Tech National Library of Portugal CBUC (Spain) Ohio Link MITNational Projects: AU, GE, …

Why might a university want to be involved? F To improve graduate education / better prepare your students / increase their knowledge and visibility F To unlock university information F To save money for students and for the university / improve workflow F To build an important digital library

Multiple objectives F Sharing research results –Decrease costs, increase services –Increase knowledge of users F Adding to author knowledge/skills –Epub, DL, IPR F Enhancing organization’s infrastructure –CS department, library –University, Laboratory

DL Submission Software F Similar software developed for W3C’s WCA, CSTC, and NDLTD F CSTC version field-tested to manage papers for ACM Digital Libraries ‘99 F May generalize for –conferences –electronic journal –resource description (e.g., courses, Web content)

How can a university get involved? F Select planning/implementation team – Graduate School – Library – Computing / Information Technology – Institutional Research / Educ. Tech. F Send us letter, give us contact names – F Adapt Virginia Tech solution – Build interest and consensus – Start trial / allow optional submission

Contact Our Project Team Phone Call Visit Video Tape

Convene Local Planning Group ETD

Build Local ETD Site Digital Library Policies Inspection/Approval Workshop/Training ETD

Responsibilities F Handle local education and collection –Contact information for helpers –Archive F Utilize standards –Metadata: MARC / DC-based concensus specification F Share metadata –Union services, mirrored services F Allow access – / –Open Archives Initiative (

Type 1 Members University Requires ETDs F Adobe Acrobat and/or XML/SGML tools F Automated submission & processing F Archive/access through UMI, (OCLC,) Virginia Tech,... F (Local) WWW site, publicity F (Local) Assistance provided as requested: , phone, listserv(s)

Type 2 Members University Agrees to Require ETDs F Like Type 1 but set date not reached F Usually has an option or pilot F May: wait for new AY; start with all who enter after; … F Build grass roots support – Advisory committee: representative? expert? – Champions to spread by word of mouth – Approval: Senates, Commissions, Deans, Students – Publicity to reach community

NDLTD Members, Types 3-7 F 3. Part of university requires ETDs F 4. University allows ETDs F 5. University investigating, has pilot F 6. University consortium joins: –CIC (Big 10 coordinating body) F 7. Non-university organization joins –CNI (Coalition for Networked Info.)

Support Services Developed F WWW site with > 300 Mb, CD, videotape F Automated submission system (MySQL, UNIX, WWW scripts - grad school/library) F Student guidelines, style sheets, multimedia training materials, FAQs, press info F SGML and XML DTDs for ETDs F SGML to HTML (web generator) F LaTeX, Word templates, converters F FTP site for PS to PDF conversion with UNIX distiller

Special Support F OCLC –Hosting Jan DC-XML metadata std meeting –Might help with preservation or Worldcat extract F VTLS –Machine, software, support staff to run free –Union catalog server: multilingual, MARC/DC-XML F UNESCO –ETD Guide in English, French, Spanish: book, Web –Scholarships to attend Int’l ETD Conference –Assistance with regional workshops: Columbia, …

Accessibility Activities / Plans F Interface design (simple, 3D, VR) F Usability studies F Generic multi-lingual support F Support for those with disabilities F Hybrid collection (paper, MARC, abstracts, full-text, multimedia) F Disciplinary classifications, tools F Visualization of results, collection

CAVE Experiments F Use a familiar metaphor –building / floor / room / shelf / book F Rearrange orderings / shelving –use categories, clustering, ranking –use visualization: colors and gaps –study space mappings: physical, logical F Simplify movement for key tasks

CAVE-ETD F CAVE-ETD is a simulation of a library that runs in a CAVE (VR environment). F Populated with a subset of ETD records. Main Foyer room

Book Browsing

Reading Book Abstract

SPIRE Visualization

Support Offered F Software, documentation, tech support F , listservs -eval, -grad, -library, -technical) F Donations: Adobe, Microsoft F Evaluation: instruments, analysis - solutions/statistics F (Temporary storage / archiving; aid - in setting up an int’l service & archive)

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

MARIAN F Multiple Access Retrieval of Information with Annotations F (Marian the Librarian …) F Evolved from CODER system to a distributed Online Public Access Catalog (OPAC), then DL backend, now becoming a full DL system F From C/C++ to Java F Future: NDLTD, NUDL, PetaPlex F Use for campus collection management F Use for as centralized system with gateway services: OAi, Harvest, Z39.50, …

MARIAN Layers Database Layer Search Engine Layer User Information Layer User Interface Layer User

MARIAN Parallelism

ENVISION F NSF “A User-Centered Database from the Computer Science Literature” ( ) F Collected bib/typesetter data, converted to SGML F Scanned thousands of page images F MARIAN search engine - can be made available (also applied to the Virginia Tech library catalog) used as part of a prototype object-based DL, with tailored visualization interface (L. Nowell dissertation)

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

PetaPlex Top View 4 ft. side

PetaPlex Side View 4 ft. wide 8 ft. high Roles: * Support * Cooling * Power 15 shelves

PetaPlex F Digital Library Machine (“super” object store): Parallel computer / storage utility F Research: inverted files, video server, … F Knowledge Systems Incorporated is supplying VT-PetaPlex-1 with 2.5 terabytes through 100 nodes : u Net connection + 25GB disk MHz Pentium + Linux

PetaPlex Complex FRONT END MACHINE RS/6000, 1G RAM, 4 Proc. Nanoserver Service Machine 1 Service Machine 2 Service Machine 3 Service Machine 4

PetaPlex Service Machine Possibilities F Front-end provides handle/repository abstraction through hashing F Small object server F Large object server –video on demand –streaming audio F Information retrieval server F Proxy / cache server (e.g., 1 terabyte server of 1000 worldwide for Comsat/Intelsat)

Sornil & Mather Dissertations F Mather: efficiently handling very large numbers of objects of varying sizes F Sornil: efficiently handling IR for very large dynamic collections, large numbers of users, high transaction rates, large inverted files –modeling and simulation –data organization –parallelization of algorithms, alone and in combination for retrieval (related) tasks

Comparison Network of Workstations (NOW) BeowulfPetaPlex Archi- tecture Cluster of general purpose workstation class machines using off-the-shelf network interconnect General purpose PCs, interconnected with a custo- mized network Special purpose architecture tuned for superstorage. Uses a mix of off-the-shelf PC compo- nents and specialized network interconnects. Cost per node Workstation prices. Between $2000-$2500/node Mid to low-end PC prices. Between $1200- $1800 per node Mass produced components will reduce price to around $100/node Target area Computation Storage, computation is a secondary function Filesystem support UNIX flavors Replaces location dependant files with location independent fine-grained URN named objects

OUTLINE F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

Outline of Online Course - 1 F Section 1. Foundations –Early visions, definitions, resources/references, projects F Section 2. Search, Retrieval, Resource Discovery –Information storage and retrieval, Boolean vs. natural language –Indexing: Phrases, Thesauri, Concepts –Federated search and harvesting, OAI, Crawlers/spiders/metasearch –Integrating links and ratings

NESTOR Map: Intro to DLs

Outline of Online Course - 2 F Section 3. Multimedia, Representations –Text/audio/image/video/graphics/animation –Capture, Digitization, Compression –Standards, Interchange: JPEG, MPEG –Content-based retrieval, Playback, QoS, SMIL F Section 4. Architectures –Modular/componentized, Protocols –InfoBus (Stanford, Java), Mediators, Wrappers (TSIMMIS)

Outline of Online Course - 3 F Section 5. Interfaces –Workflow, Environments, Taxonomy of interface components, Visualization –Design, Usability testing F Section 6. Metadata –Ontologies, RDF –MARC, Dublin Core, IMS –Mappings, Crosswalks

Outline of Online Course - 4 F Section 7. Electronic Publishing, SGML, XML –Authoring, Presenting, Rendering, Document Object Model (DOM) –Dual-publishing, Styles (XSL) –Structure, Semi-structured information, Tagging/markup, Structure queries F Section 8. Database Issues –Extending database technology –Structured and unstructured information –Multimedia databases, Link databases –Performance/replication/storage

Outline of Online Course - 5 F Section 9. Agents –Distributed issues –Protocols, Negotiation F Section 10. Commerce, Economics, Publishers –Preservation and archives –Terms and conditions, Open collections, Self-archiving –Economic models, Micropayments

Outline of Online Course - 6 F Section 11. Intellectual Property Rights, Security –Legal issues –Copyright, Rights management F Section 12. Social Issues –Cooperation and collaboration, Ratings, Annotation (PICS) –Educational applications (NSDL), Digital divide –Museums (AMICO), Cultural heritage, International concerns –Organizational acceptance/issues, Personalization

Remember F Introduction, Grand Challenge F Definitions, 5S F OAI F NDLTD F MARIAN, ENVISION F PetaPlex F For more information

Conclusions F Consider DLs: to use, to teach, to add to, to build F Education is one important application of DLs F Cultural heritage, linguistic diversity, new knowledge – all are important to preserve F Technology opens up exciting opportunities in DLs to yield seamless “super” information systems F Having a framework and theory may lead to better (more effective) systems and broader applicability F Interoperability is part of the DL grand challenge

URLs   (Courseware)  (D-Lib Magazine)  and later  and  (CSTC and JERIC)   (JCDL’2001 – June 24-28)