Calgary  Toronto  Moscow  Almaty/Atyrau  Caracas  Rio de Janeiro Financing Alternatives in Today’s Economic Climate: A Canadian Assessment Presenter: Janne Duncan Partner, Toronto office November 30, 2009 Tel.:

Emerging from the Dark Ages? Dark Ages for Mining Companies: Late 2008 to Current –Global financial crisis following the collapse of Lehman Brothers in mid-September 2008 negatively impacted almost every industry Commodity prices suffered as a result of lower demand for goods and services Gilded Age: 2001 to 2008 –Long bull market, driven by growth in the BRIC countries: Brazil, Russia, India and China Renaissance? –Market rally during last half of 2009

Where are we today? As of March 2009 (the middle of the plunge), commodity prices were still above historical norms 60% rise in stock prices since March 2009 (but still off cyclical highs) Current PriceMarch 2009Cyclical Low 2001 Cyclical High 2008 CopperUS$3.09/lb (100% rise) US1.97/lb (Drop of >50%) US$0.60/lbUS$4.10/lb AluminumUS$0.88/lbUS$0.64/lbUS$0.55/lbUS$1.48/lb GoldUS$1180/oz (US$1104 November 27) US$882/ozUS$265/ozUS$1000/oz

Traditional sources of financing Mining companies have 3 traditional sources of financing : –Internal cash flow from operations –Borrowing (issuing debt) –Equity (issuing shares)

Effects of volatility on traditional sources of financing Before the crash, listed companies (of all stages) could raise equity: –Initial public offering (IPO) –Secondary offering of equity (short form prospectus) –Sometimes, secondary bond offerings

Effects of volatility on traditional sources of financing Stock price volatility has made it extremely difficult to obtain cash flow from its 3 traditional sources of financing: –Internal cash flow from operations - affected by low commodity prices –Borrowing (issuing debt) – unavailable during the financial crisis –Equity (issuing shares) – companies that issue stock while stock prices are low risk substantial dilution

Exploration, Development, Production Phase of development Issues ExplorationCompanies that try to discover new deposits Very risky; may not find any deposits; no cash flow to fund operations or service debt DevelopmentDevelop the discoveries (upgrade resources to reserves, conduct feasibility studies, arrange project finance) ProductionProduce the minerals for sale May have saved cash generated by high commodity prices enjoyed between 2001 and 2007 Need to replenish depleted reserves through exploration and development, or through acquisitions

Exploration, Development, Production Phase of development Issues ExplorationFew equity financings for junior to mid-exploration companies on the TSX or TSX-V during 2009 Continue to struggle to survive as risk equity not available Rely on alternative sources, such as joint ventures May be acquired

Exploration, Development, Production PhaseIssues DevelopmentDormant during the first half of 2009, with some exceptions  Banro Corporation, a TSX-listed gold exploration and development company with properties in DRC, successfully completed a Cd$100 million common share offering (June 2009) Debt financing may now be available, but at higher interest rates to mitigate repayment risk.  Yields range widely Debt financings may include equity component such as warrants to convertible feature to mitigate repayment risk Debt financings may be secured against all property and assets Alternative financing sources less available Alternative forms of financing may be attractive: off-take agreements, royalty agreements. Macleod Dixon presentation is available on request.

Exploration, Development, Production PhaseIssues ProductionMid- to senior tier miners have used market strength in commodities during last half of 2009 to access the capital markets through equity financings in the secondary market Gold producers have been very successful in raising capital on the TSX  Barrick Gold Inc. secondary offering of Cd$4 billion common shares (September 2009) Tier 1 mining companies have been able to raise debt during first half of 2009  Newmont Mining Corp. US$1 billion financing (February 2009) Tier 2 mining companies have also successfully raised debt during second half of 2009  Teck Resources US$4.2 billion bond financing (May 2009)  First Quantum US$500 million bond financing (June 2009)

Trends IPOs have been almost non-existent during the economic crisis but appears to be picking up New listings on the Toronto Stock Exchange include international mining companies with non-Canadian assets that are already listed on other exchanges  ASX and, to a lesser degree, AIM-listed companies are listing on TSX (and we are seeing a lost of interest from AIM listed companies) UK = Cluff Gold (UK-based company with assets in West Africa) Australia = Allied Gold Limited (Australian-based company with assets in Papua New Guinea) Bought deals have been successful for gold companies that are already listed: Gammon Gold: $100 million bought deal (October 2009) Great Basin Gold: $110 million bought deal (November 2009)

Mergers and Acquisitions Anticipate continued consolidation in the mining industry Valuations a challenge given volatility of stock prices Deals may be friendly (between strategic partners in order to survive) or hostile because of perceived gaps in what the seller thinks the company is worth, and what the buyer is willing to pay Possible increase in deals involving distressed companies

How to prepare Listing on recognized exchange Corporate Transparency –corporate governance –continuous disclosure, including in Technical Reports Political stability Favourable mining regulatory environment

Macleod Dixon’s Offices Calgary, Toronto Caracas Moscow Macleod Dixon LLP is a global law firm with offices in six key centers of the energy industry: Canada (Calgary and Toronto), Venezuela, Brazil, Russian Federation and Kazakhstan. Nine lawyers from Macleod Dixon have just been ranked as leading practitioners by Who's Who Legal, Mining the highest number of any Canadian- based firm. PLC Which Lawyer has also just ranked Macleod Dixon as the #1 Energy firm in Canada and Venezuela for Almaty, Atyrau Rio de Janeiro