Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation Presented by Lorin E. Patterson, JD, Partner, Reed Smith LLP Todd J. Mello, ASA, AVA, MBA, Principal,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Business Valuation – What You Need to Know Frankel & Reichman LLP
Advertisements

PRIVATE EQUITY: INDIAS GROWTH CATALYST BY J. MAITRA & ASSOCIATES.
Succession Planning for Small Business Ralph T. Mooney, CPA Mooney & Thomas, PC
What Should the Appraiser Ask the Broker or Principal of the Sale When Confirming a Transaction? Presented By Jeff Binder, MAI Senior Living Investment.
VALUATION METRICS USED IN PRICING LIFE INSURANCE MANAGING GENERAL AGENCIES Daryn S. Hobal, CBV, CFP.
Dividend Policy and Retained Earnings (Chapter 18) Optimal Dividend Policy Conflicting Theories Other Dividend Policy Issues Residual Dividend Theory Stable.
EQUITY VALUATION: APPLICATIONS AND PROCESSES Presenter Venue Date.
Revise lecture 31.
© 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved McGraw-Hill/Irwin Slide 1 CHAPTER TEN VALUATION OF INCOME PROPERTIES: APPRAISAL AND THE MARKET.
The Financial Statements
Pesented by: Brooke A. Liggett, CPA, CVA. “How much is my business worth?”
Savings and Investing…. What’s the difference?
C A V Employee Stock Ownership Plans Basics of ESOP Stock Valuation 21 st Annual Ohio Employee Ownership Conference Fairlawn, OH April 20, 2007 Richard.
2 NZ Framework Definition of an asset: An asset is a resource controlled by the entity as a result of past events and from which future economic benefits.
17 Chapter Financial Management.
Valuations and Equity Awards October 14, 2014 Robert W.
2 Key Valuation Issues I. The Value of Shares for Physician Buy-in and II. Valuing Compensation Relationships in Under Arrangement Models 14 th Annual.
TAX ISSUES TO CONSIDER IN COMMON ACQUISITION SCENARIOS
“I Will Return!!” (not GEN MacArthur) A Charter Class member returns to speak on PE Valuation Bruce B. Bingham, FASA, FRICS 23 September 2013.
E. N. Kemp & Associates, Inc. Aloha. BUSINESS VALUATION 101 Where do I begin to tell the story…...
© 1 Fair Value Measurements SFAS What Does SFAS 157 Accomplish? Defines fair value Establishes a framework for measuring fair value in GAAP Expands.
This week its Accounting Theory
Preparing for a Sale of the Business Marc D’Annunzio Siavage Law Group, LLC November 10, 2010.
Investment Basics Clench Fraud Trust Investment Workshop October 24, 2011 Jeff Frketich, CFA.
 Business valuation is a logical, defendable process of arriving at the opinion as to the worth of a business given the information available, assumptions.
Why Do We Need Accounting? Companies of all sizes need to implement a streamlined accounting system in order to accurately record and report business transactions,
© 2012 VMG Health AARON MURSKI SENIOR MANAGER VMG HEALTH ASC Valuation Update & Current M&A Trends.
Valuation Program USMSS Richard Flom, CPA/ABV/CFF, CVA.
Chapter 24 Chapter 24: The Role of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) Andrew Davidson Anthony B. Sanders Lan-Ling Wolff Anne Ching.
Leveraging Investment Assets Chapter 42 Tools & Techniques of Investment Planning Copyright 2007, The National Underwriter Company1 What is it? Leveraging.
Slide 1-1 Chapter 1 Introduction. Slide 1-2 Areas of Opportunity in Finance Financial Services: –Banking –Personal financial planning –Investments –Real.
Auditing Fair Value Measurements. 2 General Challenges presented to auditors:  Obtain a sufficient understanding of the entity’s processes and relevant.
Value: An Introduction to Alternative Structures and Transactions Involving MHS Presentation to the City Assets & Enterprises Sub- Committee of the Committee.
Presented by: Todd J. Mello, MBA, AVA, Principal How Do the ASC Companies Assess Value? A Presentation by HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. based upon its 4.
CORPORATE FORM OF ORGANIZATION A corporation is a legal entity created by law that is separate and distinct from its owners.
CORPORATIONS: ORGANIZATION AND SHARE CAPITAL TRANSACTIONS CHAPTER 14.
Role of Financial Management Objectives Liquidity Profitability Efficiency Growth Return on Investment Strategic role To provide and manage the financial.
The Fundamentals of Investing
Business Valuations. Reasons for wanting to know about value:  Market transactions  Scorecards  Estate planning  Family transfers  ESOP  Litigation.
Bona Fide Service Fees Context –Impact of arrangements with Distributors/Wholesalers on Government Pricing Calculations Letter to HDMA re fee-for-service.
CHAPTER 3: BUYING A LOCAL BUSINESS. OBJECTIVES: To find the factors you need to consider when purchasing a local business. To get a better idea of what.
Essentials of Managerial Finance by S. Besley & E. Brigham Slide 1 of 23 Chapter 1 An Overview of Managerial Finance.
Receivables Management For Management Related Notes and Assignments, Visit
BUSINESS VALUATION & SELLING YOUR BUSINESS Alina Niculita, CFA, ASA, MBA 1.
Fair Value Measurement By: Feras Alghamdi Shawneen Kelly Austin Tullos Meredith Whitaker.
Revenue.  Definition of Income: ◦ Income is increases in economic benefits during the accounting period in the form of inflows or enhancements of assets.
Slide 4.1 Chapter 4 Annual Report: Additional Financial Statements.
Private Placements and Venture Capital Chapter 28 Tools & Techniques of Investment Planning Copyright 2007, The National Underwriter Company1 What is it?
Revise lecture IAS 18 Revenue 2 What is revenue? Revenue is the gross inflow of economic benefits during the period arising in the course of the.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright (c) 2002 by the McGraw-Hill Companies Inc Principles of Taxation: Advanced Strategies Chapter 11 Chapter 11 Dispositions of.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin © The McGraw-Hill Companies 2010 Auditing the Financing/Investing Process: Long-Term Liabilities, Stockholders’ Equity and Income Statement.
Financial Statements, Forecasts, and Planning
PRE-PARED BY: AZHAR AHMED 1-1 CHAPTER 4 The Financial Statements.
Chapter 4 Measurement PowerPoint Presentation by Matthew Tilling ©2012 John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd.
上海金融学院 1-1 Lecture 3 Investment Banking Basics: The Financial Statements.
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
CHAPTER 8 DIVIDEND POLICY. Concept of Dividend Policy Dividend policy involves the decision to –pay out earnings to shareholders –retain them for reinvestment.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright (c) 2003 by the McGraw-Hill Companies Inc Principles of Taxation: Advanced Strategies Chapter 11 Dispositions of Equity Interests.
Chapter 4 The Legal and Regulatory Environment of Health Care.
Areas covered Role of valuations and valuer Definitions of market value, price and worth Five methods of commercial property valuation – Applications –
Lessons Learned: Dispositions & Improving Organizational Execution in Year
Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation
Types of Business Structures
Valuation Issues for ASCs
Business Valuations What should I know?.
17 Chapter Financial Management. 17 Chapter Financial Management.
What is the business worth?
Why You Should Know the True Value of your Business & Calculation Methods By HPACCOUNTING.COM.
Presentation transcript:

Uncovering the Gem: Hidden Elements in ASC Valuation Presented by Lorin E. Patterson, JD, Partner, Reed Smith LLP Todd J. Mello, ASA, AVA, MBA, Principal, HealthCare Appraisers

Presentation Outline Regulatory Considerations Practical Considerations Valuation Framework & Issues Specific to ASCs Factors Affecting Value Selection and Application of Appropriate Valuation Methodologies Other Relevant Issues (Partnership Life Cycle; Impact of Changes in Reimbursement; Minority Interest and related discounts; Industry Multiples) Managing the Valuation Process

Regulatory Considerations Cardinal Rule: In healthcare ventures, ALL relationships MUST be conducted on FAIR MARKET VALUE terms. –Adherence provides participants the best protection against possible liability under Federal and State anti-kickback statutes and other applicable laws. –“Kickbacks” can include any form of remuneration, including overpayments or underpayments for interests in physician-owned ASCs.

Regulatory Considerations Risk Scenarios: Surgery Center grappling with the “Price of Success.” –Years of successful operations result in prohibitively high unit prices making recruiting additional investors difficult. Unreasonably low price or easy terms offered to “heavy hitter” physician investors. –The “spread” between FMV value and price offered could be a kickback.

Regulatory Considerations Risk Scenarios –Hospital anxious to maintain market share and appease groups of specialists overpays for share in existing ASC or offers to provide services or benefits (e.g., below FMV rent) to the venture on non-FMV terms. Again, “spread” between FMV and actual terms could be deemed a kickback to procure referrals. Real world example: Advisory Opinion (6/19/2007). OIG issues unfavorable opinion where Hospital buys units in ASC directly from orthopedic surgeon at possibly inflated prices.

Practical Considerations When validating FMV, a third-party appraisal by an experienced third-party appraiser will be the best means of procuring protection. –Not necessarily required. –Keep in mind that businesses are being valued – not referrals.

Practical Considerations Occasions where third-party valuations may be appropriate or necessary: –Combination between two existing healthcare ventures. –“Out of the ordinary course” sale of interests in existing ASC to group practice, corporate partner or hospital. –Commencement of service or other relationships between referral sources.

Practical Considerations –“Out of the ordinary course” buyouts of participants in existing healthcare ventures. –The commencement of a re-syndication by an existing ASC to a number of physician investors.

Practical Considerations Occasions when obtaining an appraisal may not be necessary: –In connection with the raising of capital by a newly formed healthcare venture (value of interests will be speculative). –True arms-length negotiations between participants of a healthcare venture. –Buyouts of existing participants where means of valuation is set forth within the governing documents (e.g., through the use of a formula).

Valuation Framework  What is the ownership interest being valued?  What is the purpose of the valuation?  Pending transaction (e.g., a physician buy in/out or a transaction with an ASC company)  Compliance with federal ASC safe harbors and IRS private inurement issues  Shareholder disputes/litigation  What is the standard of value?  Fair Market Value (“FMV”)  Fair Value  Investment Value  What is the premise of value?  Going concern  Liquidation

Definition of FMV IRS Definition: In Revenue Ruling the Internal Revenue Service defines fair market value as “the amount at which property would change hands between a willing seller and a willing buyer when the former is not under any compulsion to buy and the latter is not under any compulsion to sell and when both have reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.” –CMS Definition: “the value in arm's-length transactions, consistent with the general market value. “General market value” means the price that an asset would bring, as the result of bona fide bargaining between well-informed buyers and sellers who are not otherwise in a position to generate business for the other party, on the date of acquisition of the asset.” Usually, the fair market price is the price at which bona fide sales have been consummated for assets of like type, quality, and quantity in a particular market at the time of acquisition.”

Valuation Issues Specific to ASCs  Physician ownership makeup or lack thereof is critical  Physician risk is the most important risk factor in ASC valuation  Value related to distributions (i.e., dividends) as compared to capital appreciation – much higher liquidity built into investment  Divestiture typically required upon retirement, relocation, and inactivity – buyout typically formulaic or fair market value  Importance of restrictive covenants  Numerous regulatory hurdles – anti kickback statutes and potentially private inurement regulations  Publicly traded corporations are generally not relevant comparisons  Sales of similarly sized blocks of stock often not comparable  In valuing entity, important to understand uniqueness of industry

TWO PRIMARY DRIVERS OF ASC SHAREHOLDER VALUE  Future Cash Flow available to shareholders (Distributions)  Volatility or Risk associated with future cash flow There are a multitude of variables that impact the assessment of risk and the projection of future cash flow. The value of a business is not based upon historical earnings but rather future earnings! Historical earnings are only relevant to the extent they help predict future earnings. Future earnings in a surgery center partnership can be very volatile! Proper partnership management can reduce volatility. Primary Factors Affecting Value

Factors Affecting Risk of Future Cash Flow Cash Flow Projection Factors  Case volume, mix, and reimbursement  Expected changes in volume and reimbursement  Opportunities for expansion (rooms, surgeons)  Stability of operating expenses Risk Assessment Factors  Diversification (e.g., # of surgeons, number & type of specialties, payors)  Size and demographics of physician ownership, appropriate non-competes and ability to attract new investors  Financial leverage, working capital, and on-going capital expenditures  Nature of payor contracts; is there a substantial portion of “out of network?”  Quality and age of facility and equipment  Competent management  Barriers to entry (e.g. CON)

Valuation Methodology Selecting the Valuation Approach Asset-Based Approaches PURPOSE: Measures the value of an ASC by identifying and individually valuing the ASC’s tangible and intangible assets and liabilities. Based upon the Principle of Substitution; i.e., the premise that a prudent individual will pay no more for a property than he/she would pay to acquire a substitute property with the same utility. Asset-based approaches are useful when:  The ASC has no expected earnings or other attributes of value whereby an “orderly liquidation value” yields the highest valuation; or  To establish a “floor” of value when using other valuation methods

Valuation Methodology Selecting the Valuation Approach Market Approach PURPOSE: Measures the value of an ASC by evaluating comparable companies and/or transactions in the marketplace. Market Valuation Methodologies include:  Guideline Publicly Traded Company Method – generally not applicable  Comparative Transaction Method – depends Market Approach may be useful if:  Valuing a controlling (as opposed to a minority) interest  Truly comparable entities are available

Valuation Methodology Selecting the Valuation Approach Income Approach PURPOSE: Measures the value of an ASC by determining the present value of its expected future cash flow stream. Income Methodologies include:  Capitalization of Earnings  Discounted Cash Flow Income Approach is useful when:  The ASC is generating significant, normalized cash flow from operations to fund ongoing distributions  When valuing minority interest in cash flowing centers  When the ASC has significant intangible value and when reasonable market comparables are not available

Valuation Methodology Decision Tree Depending upon standard of value and size of interest, apply discounts Compare value to market transactions Adjust for atypical working capital Use asset approach to establish floor of value ASC Attributes

Other Relevant Valuation Issues ASC Partnership Life Cycle Minority vs. Controlling Interest Valuation Pending Changes in Medicare Reimbursement; potential impact to non- Medicare payors Industry Consolidation, Valuation, and Competition

ASC Partnership Life Cycle

ASC Partnership Life Cycle Consequences of Decline Stage  High Staff Turnover  High Volume Physicians Slowing Down  Non-Owner Physicians Disgruntled/ Exiting Facility  Lack of Sufficient Capital to Reinvest in Business  Capital Calls  Deferred Maintenance on Equipment and Building  ASC becomes less attractive to outside physicians

ASC Partnership Life Cycle Relationship to Value  Unmanaged Partnerships will Eventually Enter into Decline Stage  Profits Decline Faster than Revenues  ASC Partnerships are difficult to turn around  Quality Governing Documents Assist in Extending the Life Cycle (e.g. divestiture guidelines, restrictive covenants, safe harbor requirements)  Accurate Valuations are Crucial to Sustaining ASC Partnerships  Future Cash Flow and risk are related to life cycle

Valuing Minority Interests  Simply stated: Interests providing absolute control (i.e., greater than a 50% interest whereby key aspects of control are not diminished by governing documents or otherwise) are worth more than interests which do not have the same control rights  Control granted by the governing documents (examples on next slide)  Concept of “effective” control – physicians control with their feet  Valuation Guidance: absence of control adjustments in financial projection (preferable approach) or application of minority interest discount (reliance on published studies or other; more difficult to quantify and support)

Valuing Minority Interests Matters Subject to Control  Capital Calls  Admission of new investors  Borrowings greater than a certain amount  Acquisition of equipment greater than a certain amount  Selling, assigning or otherwise disposing or encumbering assets  Entering into material contracts  Selling, liquidating, or merging the entity  Changing the core governing documents  Typical ASC ownership agreements are very friendly to the minority shareholder  Note: Physicians display a certain level of control regardless of ownership interest level

Additional Valuation Considerations  Medicare reimbursement reasonably “certain” through 2011; additional uncertainty and hence risk related to non-Medicare payors  Despite declining public EBITDA multiples between 2004 and 2006 (see next slide), market multiples for controlling interests remain strong; a 12/06 survey performed by HealthCare Appraisers indicates that 92% of ASC respondents are observing multiples of 6X EBITDA or higher  Multiples paid also driven by private equity transactions (e.g. USPI and Symbion)  Despite continued consolidation within industry, per an August 2007 Market Letter published by Verispan the top 5 outpatient surgery center chains still account only for 10.5% of the market share  Minority interest multiples are based upon the individual center’s facts and circumstances and are more difficult to determine  Market multiples are interesting “rules of thumb” and are easy to calculate; however, do not generally constitute an appropriate method for calculating fair market value

Additional Valuation Considerations

Managing the Valuation Process Opposing parties will have inherently conflicting interests during the valuation process. –Adding “structure” will streamline the process significantly. Avoid “dueling valuations” unless a means of reconciling differences is agreed upon. –Consider joint engagement of a single appraiser selected from a list of qualified appraisers.

Managing the Valuation Process Determine the degree of involvement of both parties in the valuation process. –Both parties may have the right to individually meet with the appraiser and submit factors which they feel are most pertinent. –Both parties may have the right to receive drafts of the appraisal report and comment upon it. –Agreement may be reached as to what price within the range of fair market value in the final report value (e.g., mid-point) will be used in the purchase agreement.

Todd J. Mello, ASA, AVA, MBA Principal HealthCare Appraisers, Inc. 858 Happy Canyon Road, Suite 240 Castle Rock, CO (303) Lorin E. Patterson, JD, Partner Reed Smith LLP 3110 Fairview Park Drive, Suite 1400 Falls Church, VA (703)