Increasing Residency Training of Goal-oriented Treatment Options in Patients with Life-limiting Illnesses Tae Joon Lee, Qing Cao, Stella Hayes, Phillip.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 POST FORM How does this affect me?. 2 Tennessees Health Care Decision Act In 2004, the Health Care Decision Act was passed thus revising Tennessee law.
Advertisements

Decision-making at End-of-Life Dr Mary Kiely Consultant in Palliative Medicine Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust.
New Documentation for Patients & Quality Care
Advance Care Planning Lynne Jackson - RPC Project Officer GPV August 6 th 2009 Austin Health - Directorate of Strategy, Quality and Service Redesign.
Medical Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment (MOLST) Promoting communication and respect for end of life care choices across the continuum of care.
I NTRO TO I LLINOIS ’ S NEW IDPH UNIFORM DNR A DVANCE D IRECTIVE POLST Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment Presented for Long Term Care by:
Palliative Care and End of Life Issues Denise Spencer, MD Palliative Care Center of the Bluegrass January 10, 2007.
Materials adapted and used with permission from the Coalition for Compassionate Care of California, 1 The POLST Conversation.
Legal and Ethical Issues Affecting End-of-life Care Advance Directives.
Advance Directives Residency Curriculum Authors: Ashley E. Wofford Leong, MD, MPH, Carol Becerra, MD, Judith Gordon, PhD, Anne Ryan, JD Department of Family.
SPIRITUAL LEADERSHIP: THE ART OF FACILITATING ADVANCED CARE PLANNING (ACP) Kathleen Blanchfield, PhD, FCN, RNJanice M. Smith PhD, RNLewis University CONHP.
Why do Patients Request “Do Not Resuscitate?” Robert A. Pearlman, MD MPH Professor, Departments of Medicine and Bioethics and Humanities (UW) Chief of.
Anticipatory Care Planning in Dementia
The Continuum of Advance Care Planning Kathie Supiano, PhD, LCSW Associate Professor University of Utah College of Nursing.
1.A 33 year old female patient admitted to the ICU with confirmed pulmonary embolism. It was noted that she had elevated serum troponin level. Does this.
Advance Directives and End-of-Life Issues  This presentation is intended as a template  Modify and/or delete slides as appropriate for your organization.
Advance directives, advance care planning, and POLST Alexander R Nesbitt MD Susquehanna Hospice and Palliative Care This.
Advance Directives What Are They and Why Are They Important? Denise J. Brandon, PhD.
Version MOLST for EMS & First Responders MOLST Program Overview for EMS Providers, First Responders and other initial decision makers.
IMPACT OF A PARENT DIRECTED TEACHING PROGRAM IN FAMILY CENTERED CHRONIC CARE Teri L Turner, MD, MPH, MEd 1, Elaine Hime 2, Mark A Ward, MD 1 1 Department.
Integrating Advance Care Planning Discussions into Routine Patient Care Nancy Guinn, MD Lorrie Griego.
1 Advance Directives Ethics Champions Program June 4, 2008 John F. Wallenhorst, Ph.D. Vice President, Mission & Ethics Bon Secours Health System.
This presentation is meant to serve as a guide for your community presentation Modify slides as needed to be appropriate for your organization and community.
Advance Care Planning: How We Respect Your Values and Choices Barb Supanich,RSM,MD Medical Director, Holy Cross Palliative Care Team April 10, 2008.
SCHEN SCC-CSI MUSC Walter Limehouse MD MA MUSC Emergency Medicine.
Ohio MOLST Initiative Jeff Kaufhold, MD FACP Chair, Grandview Bioethics Advisory Committee Aug 2012.
Talking to Your Patients about Advance Directives Stephanie Reynolds, ACHPN Dawn Kilkenny, LCSW Palliative Care Department (Pager)
Transitioning in to Retirement Spiritual Health and End of Life Planning by Roy O. Elam, III, M.D. Associate Professor of Medicine Medical Director, Vanderbilt.
Advance Directives Presentation developed by Holly Hoing RN, Countryside Hospice, Inc. Pierre SD Developed with support and funding from The Wellmark Foundation.
What is actually written? Resuscitation documentation in clinical case notes: ethical, legal and clinical issues Margaret BROWN Research Fellow, Hawke.
Views on Resuscitation Research study Jeena Ackroyd Lynne Russon Rob Newell.
Company LOGO Understanding the Montana POLST Program Montana Board of Medical Examiners Credits: Thank you to the Washington State POLST project and Idaho.
POLST Physician Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment Adrienne Mims, MD Georgia POLST Collaborative Member.
Emily Papile END OF LIFE DECISIONS. Importance of Advanced Directives Some states family isn’t allowed to make decisions regarding life- sustaining treatments.
Materials adapted and used with permission from the Coalition for Compassionate Care of California, 1 The POLST Conversation Modified.
POLST and Hospice An Update for Oregon Gary Plant MD FAAFP Madras Medical Group Oregon POLST Task Force Oregon Academy of Family Physicians.
Indiana Physician Orders for Scope of Treatment (IN POST) Sonya M. Zeller, MBA, MSN, RN September 11, 2013.
Departments Pediatric Critical Care Pediatrics Respiratory Care Nursing Education Physician CPR Training No Physician Left Behind Project Team Josey Cavazos.
Will This Admission Help? Leonard Hock, D.O., CMD Covenant Hospice.
Advance Directives PowerPoint Presentation
POLST New Documentation for Patients & Quality Care I LLINOIS ’ S IDPH U NIFORM DNR A DVANCE D IRECTIVE.
Advance Care Planning Dr Regina McQuillan FRCPI. What is planned? Why? Who? How? When? Where?
Telling Medical Providers What to Do When You Can’t Tell Them What You Want Them to Do: Advance Directives & Medical Orders For Scope of Treatment (MOST)
Insert your organization’s logo here. Advance Directives Outreach Guide This presentation is intended as a template Modify and/or delete slides as appropriate.
E RIK K. F ROMME, MD, MCR D IVISION OF H EMATOLOGY & M EDICAL O NCOLOGY OHSU C ENTER FOR E THICS IN H EALTH C ARE D ANA Z IVE, MPH D EPARTMENT OF E MERGENCY.
J. Aaron Johnson, PhD 1 and J. Paul Seale, MD 2 1 Institute of Public and Preventive Health and Department of Psychology, Georgia Regents University, Augusta,
CPR/DNR THE ETHICAL ISSUES. FEATURES TO BE CONSIDERED REALISTIC ASSESSMENT OF BENEFITS –RESTORATION OF HEARTBEAT –SURVIVAL TO LEAVE HOSPITAL –RETURN TO.
 Friends and Family Test (FFT) -single question ‘would you recommend…’  The Adult National Inpatient Survey (AIPS) - AIPS uses validated questions based.
Using Simulated Encounters with Standardized Patients to Teach and Evaluate Difficult Discussions Rebecca Stetzer, MD Kathleen M Young, PhD, MPH Albany.
End of Life Conversations & Advance Care Planning Katherine Abraham Evans, DNP, FNP-C, GNP-BC, ACHPN Clinical Assistant Professor and DNP Program Coordinator.
From EBM to SDM: Michel Labrecque MD PhD Michel Cauchon MD Department of Family and Emergency Medicine Université Laval Teaching how to apply evidence.
Advance Directives  This presentation is based on the July 2003 AHRQ WebM&M Spotlight Case  See the full article at
End of Life Care in the Nursing Home Steven Zweig Family and Community Medicine MU School of Medicine.
Do Decision Aids Promote Shared Decision-Making for Prostate Cancer Screening? Alex Krist MD Steven Woolf MD MPH Robert Johnson PhD Department of Family.
Advanced Care Planning: Code Status Travis Nesbit Ucimc im pgy-1 Minilecture 1/15/2015.
Advance Care Planning: Making Preparations in the Event Life Changes Unexpectedly.
EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE AGS UPDATED 2012 BEERS CRITERIA AS AN EDUCATIONAL TOOL IN A FAMILY MEDICINE RESIDENCY TRAINING PROGRAM Eseoghene Abokede.
Chapter Ten End-of-Life Issues Chapter 10-1 Fourth Edition Linda D. Urden Kathleen M. Stacy Mary E. Lough Priorities in C RITICAL C ARE N URSING Copyright.
Sexual Assault and Confidentiality in Adolescent Minors
Being Mortal- Atul Gawande Presenters:
Evaluation of new medical school curricula: identifying and treating
University of Akron – Akron, OH For further information
NICAP Initiative: Advance Directives
VA Life-Sustaining Treatment Decisions Initiative
Goals of Care Dr. P. Methvin, Langley Division of Family Practice
Systems of Care Initiative People & Organizations working together to improve healthcare Jan Gillespie, MD President, SOCI.
Decision-making at End-of-Life
Provider comparison reveals no difference between training levels
POLST 2014: CA Updated Form Brandy Shannon, RN, MSN, DSD
Planning Ahead: Advance Directives and End-of-Life Decisions
Presentation transcript:

Increasing Residency Training of Goal-oriented Treatment Options in Patients with Life-limiting Illnesses Tae Joon Lee, Qing Cao, Stella Hayes, Phillip Austin, Muhammad Zafar, Shiv Patil, Robert Newman East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina Results Abstract Conclusion References Poster A80 Qing Cao, MD, HRSA 1-K01 HP20471 Geriatric Academic Career Award. The investigators retain full independence in the conduct of this research Objectives: For many patients with life-limiting illnesses, defining and discussing goals of future medical care (advance care planning) are very important. This study measures the effects of education to the in-training residents of family medicine (FM) and internal medicine (IM) residency programs at East Carolina University (ECU). Design: Based on the results of the informal assessment of need from the residents and faculty, educational materials were developed. These included discussion of advance care planning, MOST (POLST) form, FIVE WISHES, healthcare power of attorney, and living will. A 2-hour education and discussion session was given to all in-training FM and IM residents at ECU. Pre- and post-tests were administered to measure their medical knowledge as well as attitudes toward advance care planning. Results: A total of 70 pre-test and 53 post-test scores were analyzed. Overall knowledge improved with the educational sessions (74.9% vs 90.5% correctly answered pre- and post-test, respectively). Also, the residents’ own attitude toward advance care planning changed favoring less aggressive care at the end-of-life (EOL). Conclusions: Educational sessions significantly impacted residents’ knowledge and attitude about advance care planning and EOL care. Background  Most seriously ill patients are not able to make decisions at the end of life  Surrogate decision maker to patient concordance about treatment preferences is often poor  Improvement of surrogate understanding of patient preferences has the potential to improve both patient and surrogate outcomes  Structured, facilitated patient-surrogate conversations are associated with improved surrogate understanding of patient wishes.  Resident physician training in discussion of goal- oriented treatment options is not standardized. Methods  Based on the results of the informal assessment of need from the residents and faculty, 2-hour educational materials were developed.  These included discussion of advance care planning, MOST (POLST) form, FIVE WISHES, healthcare power of attorney, and living will.  Pre- and post-tests were administered to measure their medical knowledge as well as attitudes toward advance care planning. Sample Educational Material Age (yr) Patients with In-Hospital CPR number (percent) Survival to Hospital Discharge percent (95%CI) ,299 (14.6)22.2 ( ) ,353 (19.4)20.9 ( ) ,263 (22.6)19.1 ( ) ,471 (21.1)17.0 ( ) ,530 (14.4)15.1 ( ) >=9034,069 (6.9)12.2 ( ) Admitted from a SNF Yes10,924 (2.5)11.5 ( ) No423,061 (97.5)18.5 ( )  Educational sessions significantly impacted residents’ knowledge and attitude about advance care planning and EOL care.  Some residents felt more comfortable with discussion regarding goals of care, MOST (POLST) form use, advance directives, HCPOA, and living will.  Time and training are significant factors in residents’ ability to discuss these issues with patients.  More targeted educational opportunities and longer follow up are needed and need to be standardized in medical training. CPR & Sudden Cardiac Arrest (SCA), Fact Sheet, as of April 26, Epidemiologic Study of In-Hospital Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Elderly, The New England Journal of Medicine Jul 2, Vol. 361, Iss. 1; pg. 22The New England Journal of MedicineJul 2, 2009 One-year trajectories of care and resource utilization for recipients of prolonged mechanical ventilation: A cohort study, Unroe M, Tulsky JA, Cox CE, Ann Intern Med : Survival of people with clinical diagnosis of dementia in primary care: cohort study, BMJ 2010; 341:c3584 doi: /bmj.c3584 (Published 5 August 2010), Cite this as: BMJ 2010; 341:c3584 Survival and comfort after treatment of pneumonia in advanced dementia, Arch Intern Med Jul 12;170(13):1102-7Arch Intern Med. Survival analysis in percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy feeding: a worse outcome in patients with dementia, The American Journal of Gastroenterology (2000) 95, 1472– 1475 Goals of Care: Knowledge Scores Pre- Test Post- test p value Overall Knowledge75%91% < Which EOL planning tools do you know about?77%92% < In which order can the following individuals make medical decisions if a patient is incapable? 56%89% < How many patients with a witnessed cardiac arrest survive CPR? 84%91% < If pneumonia is not treated with antibiotics, does this increase discomfort level for patients with advanced dementia? 64%85%0.017 How many patients with advanced illnesses who get CPR in the hospital survive? 79%93%0.057 Does tube feeding eliminate the risk of aspiration pneumonia for patients with advanced dementia? 90%94%0.643 Attitude Test Score Pre Test Post Test p value Overall Attitude33%41%0.037 Whether to treat infections at EOL 24%40%0.095 Location of care at EOL52%69%0.090 Interest in advanced directives62%75%0.197 Whether to use tube feeding at EOL 63%58%0.245 Whether use IV fluids at EOL19%27%0.543 Desire CPR10%15%0.578 Resident comments: 1. Not enough time 2. Family or patient did not want to talk about end of life issues or code status 3. Resident is not familiar with resources available (still not sure how to use MOST, living will, 5 wishes, etc)