Refining the free function of MOND Workshop Program Dark Matter and Alternative Gravities.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Challenges for the Standard Cosmology Tom Shanks Durham University.
Advertisements

Week 10 Dark Matter Reading: Dark Matter: 16.1, 16.5d (4 pages)
Matter Content of the Universe David Spergel March 2006 Valencia, Spain.
MOND Modified Newtonian Dynamics A Humble Introduction Johannes Kepler Isaac Newton Markus Nielbock.
Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and the Fate of the Universe.
Chapter 20 Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and the Fate of the Universe.
P1X Frontiers of Physics Lectures, October 2007
Modified Newtonian Dynamics: a phenomenological review Benoit Famaey (ULB, Brussels)
The Life Cycles of Stars and our Sun. Your Questions 1.Have you ever heard of the sun song by the group They Might be Giants?
Particle Astrophysics & Cosmology SS Chapter 7 Dark Matter.
Modified Gravity Takeshi Chiba Nihon University. Why?
PRESENTATION TOPIC  DARK MATTER &DARK ENERGY.  We know about only normal matter which is only 5% of the composition of universe and the rest is  DARK.
Chapter 23: Our Galaxy Our location in the galaxy Structure of the galaxy Dark matter Spiral arm formation Our own supermassive black hole.
MOND (Modified Newtonian dynamics) habitats inside the Solar system
Particle Astrophysics & Cosmology SS Chapter 8 Structure Formation.
Prof. Eric Gawiser Galaxy Formation Seminar 2: Cosmological Structure Formation as Initial Conditions for Galaxy Formation.
GALAXY FORMATION AND EVOLUTION - 2. DISCOVER Magazine’s 2007 Scientist of the Year David Charbonneau, of the Harvard-Smithsonian Canter for Astrophysics.
Constraining Galactic Halos with the SZ-effect
Program 1.The standard cosmological model 2.The observed universe 3.Inflation. Neutrinos in cosmology.
THE STRUCTURE OF COLD DARK MATTER HALOS J. Navarro, C. Frenk, S. White 2097 citations to NFW paper to date.
What is the Dark Matter? What about “ordinary” non-luminous matter (basically, made from proton, neutrons and electrons)? “Dead stars” (White Dwarfs,
Galaxy Formation Models Cold Dark Matter is the dominant component of galaxies and is key to their formation and evolution. CDM models have been wonderful.
The Dark Universe Dark Matter Matters! Exploring the Dark Universe June 28-29, 2007 Indiana University.
Astro-2: History of the Universe Lecture 5; April
A generic test for Modified Gravity Models* Emre Onur Kahya University of Florida * astro-ph/
Incompatible Gravity Pouria Khalaj Physics Department Sharif University of Technology May 11, 2010.
Observational Evidence for Extra Dimensions from Dark Matter Bo Qin National Astronomical Observatories, China Bo Qin, Ue-Li Pen & Joseph Silk, PRL, submitted.
1 Dynamical Effects of Cosmological Constant Antigravity Μ. Αξενίδης, Λ. Περιβολαρόπουλος, Ε. Φλωράτος Ινστιτούτο Πυρηνικής Φυσικής Κέντρο Ερευνών ‘Δημόκριτος’
Modified Gravity vs. ΛCDM Roman Shcherbakov Astronomy 202b final presentation 12 December 2007.
Why modify gravity? Explain Tier I problems: Extra gravity in galaxies & clusters Today In growth of baryonic structure post-recombination Accelerating.
Robert Foot, CoEPP, University of Melbourne June Explaining galactic structure and direct detection experiments with mirror dark matter 1.
Dark Matter, Dark Energy, How Come Some People Think We Need It and Others Don’t and the Fate of the Universe.
Frédéric Henry-Couannier CPPM/RENOIR Marseille The Dark Side of Gravity and our Universe.
Our Evolving Universe1 Vital Statistics of the Universe Today… l l Observational evidence for the Big Bang l l Vital statistics of the Universe   Hubble’s.
Dark Matter and Dark Energy components chapter 7 Lecture 4.
QUADRATIC POTENTIALS, AND ROTATION CURVES IN THE CONFORMAL THEORY James G. O’Brien APS April Meeting May 1 st, 2011.
Astronomy 1143 – Spring 2014 Lecture 30: Dark Matter Revisted…..
The dark side of the Universe: dark energy and dark matter Harutyun Khachatryan Center for Cosmology and Astrophysics.
Similarity of DM/DE and TeVeS HongSheng
Composition Until 30 years ago, we thought all matter was “baryonic” matter (protons, neutrons, electrons). Now: 4.6% is baryonic matter 95% is non-baryonic.
Review MOND: an alternative to DM?
Title Galaxy Structure and Dark Matter Michael Merrifield University of Nottingham.
Cosmology and Dark Matter IV: Problems with our current picture Jerry Sellwood.
Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Constraining Inverse Curvature Gravity with Supernovae O. Mena, J. Santiago and JW PRL, 96, ,
DCMST May 22 nd, 2007 Dark matter and dark energy Gavin Lawes Wayne State University.
MOND and baryonic dark matter Benoit Famaey (Brussels, ULB)
The cosmic connection There is a very close connection between particle physics and astrophysics. I’m going to show two examples: Type II supernovas Dark.
Dark Energy vs. Dark Matter Towards a unification… Centre de Recherche Astronomique de Lyon Alexandre ARBEY March 5, 2006.
From dark matter to MOND
Historical Development of Cosmology
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Dark Universe: Dark Matter Dark Energy and the Fate of the Universe.
Modified gravity: Brief summary
THE CASE FOR MODIFIED GRAVITY James Binney Oxford University.
The Dark Side of the Universe L. Van Waerbeke APSNW may 15 th 2009.
Beyond MOND: TeVeS and its Tests (Depeche MOND) Scott Noble CCRG RIT July 2, 2010.
2. April 2007J.Wicht : Dark Matter2 Outline ● Three lecturers spoke about Dark Matter : – John Ellis, CMB and the Early Universe – Felix Mirabel, High-Energy.
Wormholes. The simplest example The r = 2m singularity is more complicated than previously mentioned… Has solution (the Schwarzschild metric):
The Dark Side of the Universe
WEIGHING THE UNIVERSE Neta A. Bahcall Princeton University.
Observational Evidence for Extra Dimensions from Dark Matter
Recent status of dark energy and beyond
ASTR 1040 – November 28 Planetarium, December 5
Dark Matter.
Chapter 23 Our Galaxy.
Differences of LCDM vs. TeVeS HongSheng Andrews
Dark Matter on Galactic Scales (and the Lack Thereof)
Dark Matter Background Possible causes Dark Matter Candidates
Pedro G. Ferreira University of Oxford
Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and the Fate of the Universe
Strong lensing constraints on modified gravity models
Presentation transcript:

Refining the free function of MOND Workshop Program Dark Matter and Alternative Gravities

Day 1: Galaxies and Solar System Day 2: Large Scale and Lensing Day 3: Satellites and Challenges for all theories

Day 1: Galaxies The acceleration discrepancy problem Large halos of DM CDM: Large Scale Structure and best candidate

Is the missing satellite problem solved? How do we solve the cusp problem in CDM? Is WDM the solution? (cf. e.g. dSph) What about the  -WDM cosmological model? Wiggles of the rotation curves?

ggWith DM, how do we explain the « order » encapsulated in the well-known MOND formula?  (  g  /a 0 ) g = g N baryons with  (x) = x for x « 1 (MONDian regime)  (x) = 1 for x »1 (Newtonian regime) Is this going to end as an equivalent of Titus Bode’s law for the solar system? If not, could it be the signature of exotic DM somehow interacting with baryons? Are there candidates?

Day 1: Solar System Pioneer anomaly: end of gravity as we know it? Thermal emission anisotropy of the spacecraft? Is acceleration different for different orbits? => Modified Inertia? End of « metric » gravity?

Day 2: Large Scale Are massive galaxies at very high redshift a challenge to standard hierarchical model? CMB anisotropies: the most serious challenge to any modified gravity theory? Galaxy clusters: failure of the MOND formula + lensing of interacting clusters : => surviving « hybrid » theory? (e.g. BSTV)

Dark Energy: do we know enough about supernovae? (models don’t explode, while they are the only direct evidence) Isn’t there too much dark energy in a flat TeVeS Universe, in order to fit supernovae? Running cosmological constant? Non-MOND modifications of the left-hand side of Einstein equation? Is unification with DM possible?

Day 2: Lensing Is the scatter observed in the lenses gravity vs. lenses baryonic content real, or due to too many uncertainties in the analysis? If confirmed, this scatter cannot be fitted by any modified gravity theory What about lensing in conformal gravity?

Day 3: Galactic Satellites MOND: Dwarf spheroidals need DM if their size is primarily determined by tides, as distant globular clusters are Not all internal velocity dispersion profiles of dSph are compatible with the MOND formula (bigger problem than in galaxy clusters)

Day 3: Challenges DM: cusps DM: wiggles of RC’s MOND: CMB, galaxy clusters,  function (precise M/L could fix  and rule TeVeS out) E.g. in conformal gravity, how do we handle complex geometries? What happens to dynamical friction in any modified gravity theory? Can a hybrid theory save e.g. the issue for dSph? ETC.