 Language barrier, cultural difference and patient involvement are key issues in patient-physician communication for Asian American breast cancer survivors.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services And Clinical Trials (EDICTs CLAS-ACT) Armin D Weinberg Baylor College of Medicine.
Advertisements

Delivering care to the underserved: Increasing the Numbers of Minority Physicians Ruben Gonzalez MD CCRMC.
Health Disparities: Breast Cancer in African AmericansIn Lansing Health Disparities: Breast Cancer in African Americans In Lansing Costellia Talley, PhD,
PHASE 1 Facilitating discussion on treatment preferences and advance care planning in cancer patients using the vignette technique Funding: Department.
Respect aging Respect Aging: Preventing Violence against Older Persons 1. RECOGNITION 2. PREVENTION 3. INTERVENTION Violence Prevention Initiative.
Information Seeking Experiences of Cancer Survivors: Frustrated or Satisfied? Whitney Randolph Steele, PhD, MPH Cancer Prevention Fellowship Program Division.
A Diverse & Aging California Health Issues Steven P. Wallace, Ph.D. Professor, UCLA School of Public Health Assoc. Dir., UCLA Center for Health Policy.
The Role of Cultural Health Beliefs on Health Behaviors among Chinese, Korean & Mexican American Breast Cancer Survivors PI’s: Drs. Patricia Gonzalez,
PROSPEC: Using an information technology-supported patient-centered intervention to reduce disparities in prostate cancer screening discussions John H.
HIV testing and HIV knowledge among sexually active young Chinese, Korean, and Vietnamese women Hyeouk Chris Hahm, Ph.D, LCSW Julie Peterson Mario Feranil.
Implications and Next Steps A linguistically and culturally appropriate intervention should provide information, teach skills to cope with problems and.
Cultural Sensitivity - Texas Provider Training 2013.
Proposed Cross-center Project Survey of Federally Qualified Health Centers Vicky Taylor & Vicki Young.
Critical Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines
Tools for Registration Reporting Race, Ethnicity and Language: A Guide to Helping Patients.
Changes to Meditech Registration A Guide for Data Collection Adapted Training Slides from the Cambridge Health Alliance.
1 The Role of Cultural Health Beliefs on Health Behaviors among Chinese, Korean, & Mexican American Breast Cancer Survivors PI’s: Drs. Patricia Gonzalez,
Tuberculosis Prevalence, Screening and Treatment among Filipinos in Union City, California Christine Araneta PA-C, Stephanie Sario BA, Jennifer Lee MPH.
Health Systems – Access to Care and Cultural Competency Tonetta Y. Scott, DrPH, MPH Florida Department of Health Office of Minority Health.
Heart Health Project University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine American Heart Association Pennsylvania State University Funded by the Robert Wood Johnson.
Health Provider Teams: How you can support cancer survivors after treatment Washington CARES about Cancer Partnership: Survivorship Taskforce June 2012.
Cultural Competency Through CultureVision February 2010.
Cancer Survival Toolbox Lynn Barwick, LCSW Oncology Social Worker ¡Vida! Educational Series - Promoting Good Health.
Secretary’s Advisory Committee on Infant Mortality August 10, 2015 Office of Minority Health Primary Activities Related to Preterm Birth Prevention Chazeman.
Development and results of an older adult health communication program using the Theory of Planned Behavior Virginia Brown, DrPH; Lisa McCoy, MS The National.
Cynthia Baur, Ph.D. Senior Advisor, Health Literacy August 23, 2011 The National Action Plan to Improve Health Literacy Office of the Director Office of.
¡Encuentro! A Healthy Youth Development Project Formative Research – Latino Parent Perspectives Maira Rosas-Lee; Renee E. Sieving, Ph.D., RN McNair Scholar,
Presented by Lynn Barwick, LCSW Presented by Xochitl Gaxiola, MSW in Spanish.
Session Fertility and Pregnancy FL-BBM Specific questions Risk of premature ovarian failure Ability to become pregnant Safety of pregnancy.
Engaging Patients in Healthcare Encounters Ken Wong, GiiC Consultant, RGP of Toronto Mary-Lou van der Horst, GiiC Consultant, RGP Central Janice Paul,
HAE-RA HAN, PHD, RN JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF NURSING Community-Based Participatory Research as a Tool to Maximize Recruitment of Linguistic Minorities.
Introduction to Healthcare and Public Health in the US The Evolution and Reform of Healthcare in the US Lecture d This material (Comp1_Unit9d) was developed.
 Cases of the Jensons and Matthews  Brief Review of Literature  Methodology  Findings  How to Help Families Be Ready for Hospice  Future Studies.
PRINTED BY THE DEPT. OF MEDICAL PHOTOGRAPHY AND ILLUSTRATION A.M.N.C.H. Family Meetings with Vulnerable Patients-An Exploration of Multidisciplinary Team.
April Anderson-Vizcaya California State University Long Beach May 2012.
“A Pilot-test of the Effectiveness of Spanish Health Literacy Skills and Health Knowledge Videos on Health Literacy and Related Outcomes” Centre for Population.
Nursing Facility Transition and Diversion Module 2: Independent Living and Person-Centered Planning.
Colorectal Cancer Survivorship in Greene County, Pennsylvania: Assessment and Provider Education Mary Ann Ealy, Marlene Shaw and Carolyn Wissenbach Background.
The KU Wichita Center for Breast Cancer Survivorship Judy Johnston, MS, RD/LD Research Instructor Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health,
 The underrepresentation of diverse populations in research an important barrier to: ◦ Understanding differences between groups ◦ Developing culturally.
13. International Conference on Health Promoting Hospitals, 2005 Listening to the Patient in Solving Problems Related to Treatment Errors Maria Hallman-Keiskoski.
WHAT DOES MEDICAL HOME MEAN TO YOUR FAMILIES. Medical Care is just part of our lives.
Carol Devine Professor, Division of Nutritional Sciences TRIPLL
Physician Practice Style and Barriers to Referral: Los Angeles Women’s Health Study Danielle Rose Ash, PhD VA HSR&D/Greater Los Angeles Care System Co-Authors:
Definition of Family Medicine General practice / Family Medicine is an academic and scientific discipline, has its own educational content, research, evidence.
AN INTRODUCTION Managing Change in Healthcare IT Implementations Sherrilynne Fuller, Center for Public Health Informatics School of Public Health, University.
The Relationship between Nativity Status, Satisfaction with and Confidence in Health Care Florence J. Dallo, PhD MPH Academy Health Meeting 9 June 2008.
Randy A. Jones, PhD, RN Patricia Hollen, PhD, RN, FAAN Richard Steeves, PhD, RN, FAAN Terran Sims, MSN, RN, ACNP-BC Christopher Thomas, MD University of.
The Role of CIS in Enabling Informed Decision Making Marion E. Morra, M.A. Montreal 2012.
MENG ZHAO, PHD, RN COLLEGE OF NURSING & HEALTH SCIENCES TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY-CC The role of culture on screening mammography utilization among Chinese-born.
1 Reducing Health Disparities Among Hispanic Elders: Lessons from a Learning Network Team San Antonio AHRQ Annual Meeting 2008 September 10, 2008 Washington,
Language Barriers in Health Care Spanish speaking patients (w/ limited English proficiency) & English speaking medical personnel.
Medical Advocacy and Advance Directives Session 3 Staying in the Circle of Life.
Component 1: Introduction to Health Care and Public Health in the U.S. 1.9: Unit 9: The evolution and reform of healthcare in the US 1.9d: The Patient.
Improving the Health Literacy Environment of Wisconsin Hospitals – A Collaborative Model Sue Gaard, RN, MS Wisconsin Primary Care Research & Quality Improvement.
The Role of Response Efficacy on the Relationship between Cultural Orientation and Decision-Making Preference in the Patient-Physician Communication University.
Raise Awareness About National Standards for Health Literacy.
Alberta Medical Association
CAROL TAYLOR, PH.D. Professor, Georgetown School of Nursing and Health Studies Senior Scholar, Kennedy Institute of Ethics ERIN LEVETON, J.D. Adjunct Professor,
BUILDING THE BEST RELATIONSHIP WITH YOUR CLINIC/HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS 1.
The Interface between Primary Care and Specialty Care in Primary Treatment of Cancer Jonathan Sussman Supportive Cancer Care Research Unit Laura-Mae Baldwin.
Health Care Self-Management (Provider Version) Late Effects of Treatment for Childhood, Adolescent and Young Adult (AYA) Cancers Supported by a grant from.
Awareness of the National Standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services (CLAS) at an Academic Health Center Dr. Genny Carrillo Department.
Changes to Meditech Registration A Guide for Data Collection Adapted Training Slides from the Cambridge Health Alliance.
Cultural competency, patient- physician communication and gender disparities in patient satisfaction Alice F. Yan, MD; Desiree Rivers, Ph.D., M.S.P.H.;
From Victim to Survivor: Using Best Practices to Guide the Way Jessica Li, Executive Director, Asian/Pacific Islander Domestic Violence Resource Project.
Mahsa Parviz, BS1 and Jennifer K. Cheng, MD, MPH1
Julia Searl Rusert, M.S.W., Ph.D. David Martin, M.A.
A review of the literature
Emilia Mondragón, BS, Young-Me Lee, PhD, RN, Helen Lee, APN
Presentation transcript:

 Language barrier, cultural difference and patient involvement are key issues in patient-physician communication for Asian American breast cancer survivors.  Proper patient education with linguistically and culturally appropriate information and tools may help improve communication with physician and decision-making process.  As a next step, we plan to design and implement a theory-based, culturally and linguistically appropriate intervention to Korean breast cancer survivors. This will include skills to enhance patient- physician communication. What Is Lacking in Patient-Physician Communication: from Asian American Breast Cancer Patients’ and Oncologists’ Perspectives Sunmin Lee, 1 Grace X. Ma, 2,3 Carolyn Y. Fang 2,3,4 Lu Chen, 1 Youngsuk Oh, 1 Lynn Scully 1 1 Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University of Maryland School of Public Health, College Park, Maryland 2 Department of Public Health, College of Health Professions, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 3 Center for Asian Health, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 4 Cancer Prevention and Control, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania What Is Lacking in Patient-Physician Communication: from Asian American Breast Cancer Patients’ and Oncologists’ Perspectives Sunmin Lee, 1 Grace X. Ma, 2,3 Carolyn Y. Fang 2,3,4 Lu Chen, 1 Youngsuk Oh, 1 Lynn Scully 1 1 Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University of Maryland School of Public Health, College Park, Maryland 2 Department of Public Health, College of Health Professions, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 3 Center for Asian Health, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 4 Cancer Prevention and Control, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Acknowledgments: This research is a pilot project supported by NIH-NCI’s Community Network Program Center, ACCHDC U54 CNPC (1U54CA , PI: Grace Ma)  Patient Characteristics  n=9 (4 Chinese & 5 Koreans)  Participants were between years of age. Majority were married (78%) and had college or above education (77%).  Most of them have completed active cancer treatment (89%). More than half were diagnosed with breast cancer within a year (56%).  Oncologist Characteristics Key Interview Questions To explore patient-physician communication process in Asian American breast cancer patients from both patients and oncologists perspectives.  Breast cancer is the leading cancer in incidence and among top five in mortality in Chinese & Korean women (CKW) in the U.S. (Miller et al., 2008)  Rapid and steady increase of breast cancer incidence in CKW since 1980’s. (Gormez et al., 2010)  Patient-physician communication and coordination is essential in the quality of cancer survivorship care. (Arora et al., 2011)  Asian American patients have reported lower satisfaction with health care compared to Whites and Blacks. (Saha, Arbelaez & Cooper, 2003)  Study Design  Face-to-face in-depth interviews with nine Chinese or Korean breast cancer patients/survivors and three Asian oncologists who routinely provided care for Asian patients in the Washington DC metropolitan area.  Participant Recruitment  A convenience sample of Chinese and Korean breast cancer survivors living in Washington D.C. metropolitan area.  Patients were recruited from community based organizations, posters on websites well known among Korean/Chinese immigrants, and personal contacts.  Oncologists were recruited from personal contacts. They were not necessarily oncologists of women we interviewed.  Data Collection and Analysis  Comprehensive interview guides were developed separately for patients and oncologists based on literature review and input from experts on breast cancer survivorship and oncologists.  Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and translated.  Transcripts were analyzed by two independent coders and their analysis was compared and contrasted, and finally agreed upon in the research team. Oncologist #1Oncologist #2Oncologist #3 Age (in years) Country of birth KoreaIndiaUS Gender FFM Language spoken (other than English) Korean, Spanish, Portuguese Tamil, SpanishKorean Ever communicate with patients in language other than English? Yes Years practicing medicine INTRODUCTION OBJECTIVE METHODS RESULTS Patients How did you feel about the interaction between you and your doctor? Do you have any barriers in communicating with your doctor? Were there cultural differences in your communication? If so, what were they? How would you want to improve this? When it came to the decision of your care, what did you do? How did you feel about your role in the decision making? Oncologists How would you describe your Asian patients’ interaction with you compared with White patients in the following areas: Making decisions Asking questions Talking about fear & distress Are there any difficulties other than language? If you do face a language or communication barrier, what do you do? What is your advice for those who want to be more actively involved in treatment? CONCLUSION, IMPLICATIONS & NEXT STEP Patients’ Perspective Oncologists’ Perspective Language Barrier Language was the biggest barrier to understanding information and making treatment decisions. Medical terms were a challenge even for those who were fluent in English. For some patients, they could only rely on guessing and body language in extreme situations. If the women cannot speak English then this serves as a large barrier for understanding information and communicating. Translation by family members may not be accurate. Some patients may neglect to ask questions due to concerns of burdening family members. Cultural Differences Expected the doctor to be authority and were disappointed when questions were not answered. Dissatisfied with doctor’s advice on physical activity and diet which from the patients’ perspective was not appropriate for Asians. In US culture, having breast cancer is a badge of honor and surviving is something to be proud of. For some Asian women it’s more of a stigma and they are ashamed and hesitant to discuss it. Many Asian patients want to know very specifically what they can and cannot eat, and are surprised when told that they should just eat a healthy balanced diet. Decision-Making on Treatment Physicians played a leading role in most cases. The influence from family members was more evident in participants who were limited in speaking English. Many expressed the desire to be actively involved in decision making. Some Asian patients are not very assertive and will not express their concerns. Asians in general are not very proactive or assertive. They do not want too much information from a physician, they expect the physician to be the expert and make the decisions for them. If they do not receive this they may even switch doctors.