The purpose of this study is to investigate the association between the satisfaction with HRM practices in an organization and the workers' perceived performance.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Using the SmartPLS Software “Structural Model Assessment”
Advertisements

Gaining a Competitive Advantage
Abstract The Knowledge, Perceptions, and Practice of Pharmacovigilance among Community Pharmacists in Lagos State, Southwest Nigeria Oreagba, Ibrahim Adekunle.
Paid Staff and Volunteers: Do Their Attitudes Differ? Riikka Teikari and Christeen George Abstract The aim of the present study was to explore whether.
Recently.... The IfA has began a major new initiative to establish an Academic Special Interest Group (SIG) The IfA Registered Organisations Committee.
Perceptions on organisation commitment in a selected Chinese organisation in South Africa: A case study approach. Mr Steven Paterson and Professor Lynette.
Method IntroductionResults Discussion Effects of Plans and Workloads on Academic Performance Mark C. Schroeder University of Nebraska – Lincoln College.
The concept of HRM perceptions is a growing interest in the literature, as one of the antecedents of HRM outcomes. Regardless, not only the cognitive aspect.
Corporate Governance across Ethics, Culture & Citizenship; What to give and what to expect? The Effects of HRM Practices on Organizational Performance.
Maria Cristina Matteucci, Dina Guglielmi
Effect of Staff Attitudes on Quality in Clinical Microbiology Services Ms. Julie Sims Laboratory Technical specialist Strengthening of Medical Laboratories.
AMOS TAKING YOUR RESEARCH TO THE NEXT LEVEL Mara Timofe Research Intern.
CORRELATIO NAL RESEARCH METHOD. The researcher wanted to determine if there is a significant relationship between the nursing personnel characteristics.
Making Human Resource Management Strategic
Keeping older workers committed and employed by means of in/formal HRD initiatives Dr. A.A.M. (Ida) Wognum M. (Martine) Horstink MSc. Wognum-HorstinkCedefop.
Factors affecting contractors’ risk attitudes in construction projects: Case study from China 박병권.
Work and Employment Research Centre John Purcell Professor of Human Resource Management University of Bath Sustaining the People Management and Performance.
PERFORMANCE-RELATED PAY POLICIES FOR GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES: MAIN TRENDS IN OECD MEMBER COUNTRIES 7 October, 2004 HRM Working Party Meeting Dorothée Landel.
For use with Human Resource Management in South Africa 4e by Grobler, Wärnich et al ISBN: © 2010 Cengage Learning Human Resource Management.
Chapter 3: THEORIES BASED ON ATTITUDES AND BELIEFS Active people have attitude!
Human Resource Management Gaining a Competitive Advantage
GSU-NACDD-CDC Chronic Disease and Public Health Workforce Training Training Needs Survey and Public Health Certificate in Chronic Disease Training for.
An investigation of factors moderating the relationship between job satisfaction and turnover intention among bank’s staff in Thailand By Warayu Thienpramuk.
Chapter 4 Performance Appraisal
STAFFING VAIBHAV VYAS.
Implication of Gender and Perception of Self- Competence on Educational Aspiration among Graduates in Taiwan Wan-Chen Hsu and Chia- Hsun Chiang Presenter.
Stuart Hollis Where are we now? An exploration of the provision of teacher training programmes for the Learning and Skills Sector following the 2007 Workforce.
The relationship between trust, HRM practices and firm performance Dr. Shay S. Tzafrir University of Haifa, Israel.
National Hsinchu University of Education Graduate Institute of Human Resource Development The Challenges and Trends of HRD in High-Tech Industry Hsiu-Yen.
Student volunteers and the volunteer- involving community organisations vinspiredstudents research.
By Cao Hao Thi - Fredric W. Swierczek
Information commitments, evaluative standards and information searching strategies in web-based learning evnironments Ying-Tien Wu & Chin-Chung Tsai Institute.
Agile Method Paper Report 資工 4A 余修丞. 2 Agile methods rapidly replacing traditional methods at Nokia: A survey of opinions on agile transformation.
BCO Impact Assessment Component 3 Scoping Study David Souter.
Introduction A small but growing literature points to an important connection between forgiveness and physical health (Worthington, Witvliet, Lerner, &
Personalisation and its implications for work and employment in the voluntary sector Dr Ian Cunningham and Professor Dennis Nickson, Strathclyde University.
HEInnovate A self-assessment tool for higher education institutions (HEIs) wishing to explore their entrepreneurial and innovative potential.
LOGO Mamdouh Abdel Aziz Refaiy Dr. Associate Professor, Business Administration Department, Faculty of Commerce, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt. Evaluating.
Kerry Cleary An evaluation of the impact of Values Based Interviewing at the OUH Values Based Conversations and wider engagement strategies.
1 The National Center for Interprofessional Practice and Education is supported by a Health Resources and Services Administration Cooperative Agreement.
Sharmake Hassan Osman  MEANING OF HRM AND PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT  Personnel management can be defined as obtaining, using and maintaining a satisfied.
Online students’ perceived self-efficacy: Does it change? Presenter: Jenny Tseng Professor: Ming-Puu Chen Date: July 11, 2007 C. Y. Lee & E. L. Witta (2001).
"I'm doing my best, considering” the relationship between worker satisfaction with HRM practices and worker perception of individual performance in the.
STATISTICS STATISTICS Numerical data. How Do We Make Sense of the Data? descriptively Researchers use statistics for two major purposes: (1) descriptively.
Introduction Method United States Belgium Discussion Katherine Quigley & Emily Prosser Faculty Mentors: Dr. Jennifer Muehlenkamp, Department of Psychology,
Employment Skills for Communications Technology..
Parental, Temperament, & Peer Influences on Disordered Eating Symptoms Kaija M. Muhich, Alyssa Collura, Jessica Hick and Jennifer J. Muehlenkamp Psychology.
Monday, June 23, 2008Slide 1 KSU Females prospective on Maternity Services in PHC Maternity Services in Primary Health Care Centers : The Females Perception.
1-1 Human Resource Management: Gaining a Competitive Advantage HRM.
Managing Human Resources
Barleti School of Public Affairs. Public service in all countries of the Western Balkans (WB) faces many challenges and weaknesses in regards to public.
Learning Objectives Functions of Human Resource Management
HEInnovate A self-assessment tool for higher education institutions (HEIs) wishing to explore their entrepreneurial and innovative potential.
Motivation and Job Satisfaction among Hospital Nurses Working in Port-Harcourt, Rivers State, NIGERIA. by LILLY-WEST, R. BULOALA.
Practices in Global Environments
Job design & job satisfaction
MANAGING HUMAN RESOURCES
HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
Research amongst Physical Therapists in the State of Kuwait: Participation, Perception, Attitude and Barriers Presented by Sameera Aljadi, PT, PhD Assistant.
Justin D. Hackett, Benjamin J. Marcus, and Allen M. Omoto
14 Cultural Competence Training, Assessment, and Evaluation of Cultural Competence, and Evidence-Based Practices in Culturally Competent Agencies.
Prof. Devpriya Dey Spirit of HR.in
Social Practical Charlie.
Changing practice to support self-management and recovery in mental illness: application of an implementation model M Harris1, P Jones2, M Heartfield1,
Presenter Zeeshan Iqbal Bahauddin Zakariya University Multan-Pakistan
SERVICE QUALITY & OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE OF TOUR OPERATORS IN KENYA
SERVICE QUALITY & OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE OF TOUR OPERATORS IN KENYA
Job design & job satisfaction
Wanlee Putsom and Damrong Sattayawaksakul
Presentation transcript:

The purpose of this study is to investigate the association between the satisfaction with HRM practices in an organization and the workers' perceived performance. We are interested in learning if indeed workers that are more satisfied with the organization’s practices will also perceive themselves as more hardworking than others, thus confirming the happy-productive worker hypothesis, from an individual perception standpoint. Data originates from a large Portuguese hospital, with a sample of 952 clinical and nonclinical hospital workers. Data was originally explored using SPSS software and later tested in AMOS software where a multiple regression model was constructed and tested. Results indicate that overall satisfaction with HRM practices are related with the workers’ perceived performance; most of the HRM satisfaction subscales also relate, except for pay and performance appraisal, that do not seem to be good predictors of the workers perceived performance. The present study is based on a single large public hospital, and thus, these findings need to be further tested in other settings. This study offers some clues regarding the areas of HRM that seem to be more related with the workers’ perceived performance, and hence provide an interesting framework for managers dealing with healthcare teams. This study contributes to the happy-productive worker hypothesis research, by including seldom used variables in the equation and taking a different perspective. Results provide new clues for investigation and practice regarding the areas of action in HRM that seem to be more prone to elicit perceived effort from the workers. Throughout the world, hospitals are facing many challenges including increased costs, per capita decreases in government funding, technology that delivers both less invasive surgery (consequently capacity to perform more inpatient procedures) and the capacity to deal with more complex medical interventions; also, healthcare systems that include hospitals have been under constant and continuing pressure to deliver quality improvements, better accountability, consumer choice and cost savings (Kabene, 2006; Grimshaw, Rubbery & Marchington, 2010). As such, it is arguable that one important area of improving and maintaining service delivery as well as facing current challenges is through the hospital’s arguably most important assets: the people that work in hospitals: Human Resources (HR). Around the world it is an undisputed fact that the health care industry is a knowledge intensive field, and its main assets are the people that work for them (West et al., 2006) and within many health care systems worldwide, increased attention is being focused on HRM (Kabene et al, 2006). Human resources have been described as “the heart of the health system in any country” (Joint Learning Initiative, 2003), “the most important aspect of health care systems” (Narasimhan et al, 2004, pp.) and “a critical component in health policies” (Dussault & Dubois, 2003). Therefore it is reasonable to expect that performance of healthcare organizations will rely heavily in HR performance. Throughout the world, hospitals are facing many challenges including increased costs, per capita decreases in government funding, technology that delivers both less invasive surgery (consequently capacity to perform more inpatient procedures) and the capacity to deal with more complex medical interventions; also, healthcare systems that include hospitals have been under constant and continuing pressure to deliver quality improvements, better accountability, consumer choice and cost savings (Kabene, 2006; Grimshaw, Rubbery & Marchington, 2010). As such, it is arguable that one important area of improving and maintaining service delivery as well as facing current challenges is through the hospital’s arguably most important assets: the people that work in hospitals: Human Resources (HR). Around the world it is an undisputed fact that the health care industry is a knowledge intensive field, and its main assets are the people that work for them (West et al., 2006) and within many health care systems worldwide, increased attention is being focused on HRM (Kabene et al, 2006). Human resources have been described as “the heart of the health system in any country” (Joint Learning Initiative, 2003), “the most important aspect of health care systems” (Narasimhan et al, 2004, pp.) and “a critical component in health policies” (Dussault & Dubois, 2003). Therefore it is reasonable to expect that performance of healthcare organizations will rely heavily in HR performance. Over the past two decades, research for the causal links between human resource management (HRM) and business performance has dominated both academic and practitioner debate (Purcell and Kinnie, 2007): the present study aims at contributing towards this body of knowledge. Many authors have dedicated their careers to understanding this connection that in some ways justifies the relevance of Human Resources Management (HRM) in companies by making return on investment in HRM clearer. However intuitive this connection, between how much a company values HRM (hence the people that work for them) and how well a company does, may be, empirical evidence has been elusive, and some authors go so far as to refer to this “happy-productive worker hypotheses” as the Holy Graal of Human Resources Management research (Fisher, 2003). The relationship between human resources management and health care is very complex, and merits further examination and study (Kabene et al, 2006). This is often complicated because of many circumstances, such as multiple employers (many healthcare workers have more than one job in different organizations) and a very diverse workforce (including clinical and non-clinical workers [WHO, 2000]); in the Portuguese context other political and economic factors can be included such as a strong organizational culture in the public sector that is very different from the private sector’s, and that has managerial implications in the movement of privatization of healthcare. Thus management of what is meant to be a joined-up healthcare experience can be potentially confusing and subject to multiple influences (Wilkimson et al, 2010). HR practices provide employees with concrete evidence of the organisation’s intent to anticipate and meet their needs (Armstrong-Stassen & Schlosser, 2010). When an organisation engages in HR practices that reflect investment in, and support of its employees, it signals that the organisation is seeking to continue a social exchange relationship with its employees (Allen et al., 2003). Despite the extensive examination of the effects of a company’s overall HR practices, or HR bundle, the effects of employees’ overall perception of HR effectiveness have rarely been studied (Chang, 2005). This might be due to the fact that perception is classically a construct approached by Psychologists whereas HRM is mainly a management field. In this work we propose to assess if Satisfaction with Human Resources Issues Management (SHRIM) impacts Performance Related Observations of Self-Efficacy (PROSE) in a Hospital context. Data was collected in January of 2012 in a large public Hospital in the north of Portugal that employs circa 2000 workers, using both paper and electronic format. Paper format was distributed among workers that preferred this method or that did not have access to the intranet of the institution with envelopes so that responses could be sealed and anonymity ensured. Electronic questionnaires were divulged in the Hospital’s intranet. Sample is composed of a total of 942 subjects, with ages of respondents between 20 and 66 years old (mode=28 years and M= 38.5 years; standard deviation= 9.6); most respondents are female (80.3%; 16.9% male respondents; 2.2% missing). In terms of the job, the distribution of staff per job group is shown in Figure 1. In terms of seniority, values range between less than a year to up to 39 years (mode=3 years and mean= years, standard deviation= 8.46), where a significant amount of workers (71%) have an effective contract (hired with no predetermined ending date of the bond with the organization). When it comes to schooling, 17% of subjects have a school level inferior to the mandatory Portuguese level (9th year), 28.8% attended or graduated from middle school, 42.8% attended or graduated from College and 19.7% have post-graduate schooling (Specializations, Masters Degree, etc.). Data was collected in January of 2012 in a large public Hospital in the north of Portugal that employs circa 2000 workers, using both paper and electronic format. Paper format was distributed among workers that preferred this method or that did not have access to the intranet of the institution with envelopes so that responses could be sealed and anonymity ensured. Electronic questionnaires were divulged in the Hospital’s intranet. Sample is composed of a total of 942 subjects, with ages of respondents between 20 and 66 years old (mode=28 years and M= 38.5 years; standard deviation= 9.6); most respondents are female (80.3%; 16.9% male respondents; 2.2% missing). In terms of the job, the distribution of staff per job group is shown in Figure 1. In terms of seniority, values range between less than a year to up to 39 years (mode=3 years and mean= years, standard deviation= 8.46), where a significant amount of workers (71%) have an effective contract (hired with no predetermined ending date of the bond with the organization). When it comes to schooling, 17% of subjects have a school level inferior to the mandatory Portuguese level (9th year), 28.8% attended or graduated from middle school, 42.8% attended or graduated from College and 19.7% have post-graduate schooling (Specializations, Masters Degree, etc.). Sample description was performed using descriptive statistics (mean, standard deviation, range, etc.) and graphic depiction of data (bar charts, pie charts, etc.). We tested our hypotheses using structural equations modeling (SEM) since all our hypotheses included complex latent variables and SEM has been proven to report some advantages when compared to traditional methods that include calculating the total scores of global scales and their dimensions and disregard measurement errors for the larger part. According to Hoopler et al. (2008), SEM has become one of the techniques of choice for researchers across disciplines and increasingly is a ‘must’ for researchers in the social sciences. SEM provides a unifying framework under which numerous linear models may be fit using flexible, powerful software. It is essential that researchers using the technique are comfortable with the area since assessing whether a specified model ‘fits’ the data is one of the most important steps in structural equation modelling (Yuan, 2005). Sample description was performed using descriptive statistics (mean, standard deviation, range, etc.) and graphic depiction of data (bar charts, pie charts, etc.). We tested our hypotheses using structural equations modeling (SEM) since all our hypotheses included complex latent variables and SEM has been proven to report some advantages when compared to traditional methods that include calculating the total scores of global scales and their dimensions and disregard measurement errors for the larger part. According to Hoopler et al. (2008), SEM has become one of the techniques of choice for researchers across disciplines and increasingly is a ‘must’ for researchers in the social sciences. SEM provides a unifying framework under which numerous linear models may be fit using flexible, powerful software. It is essential that researchers using the technique are comfortable with the area since assessing whether a specified model ‘fits’ the data is one of the most important steps in structural equation modelling (Yuan, 2005). Standardized path beta coefficients regarding PROSE revealed that satisfaction with staffing->PROSE is the most significant path (B Prose.Staffing =0.22, SE=0.05, β PROSE.Staffing =0.22, p PROSE (B PROSE.Pay =-0.23, SE=0.03, β PROSE.Pay =-0.15, p PROSE (B PROSE.Teamwork =0.09, SE=0.04, β PROSE.Teamwork =0.07, p=0.05); the remainder trajectories were non-significant. Hence, we can conclude that satisfaction with staffing, satisfaction with pay and satisfaction with teamwork affect performance related self-efficacy. Standardized path beta coefficients regarding PROSE revealed that satisfaction with staffing->PROSE is the most significant path (B Prose.Staffing =0.22, SE=0.05, β PROSE.Staffing =0.22, p PROSE (B PROSE.Pay =-0.23, SE=0.03, β PROSE.Pay =-0.15, p PROSE (B PROSE.Teamwork =0.09, SE=0.04, β PROSE.Teamwork =0.07, p=0.05); the remainder trajectories were non-significant. Hence, we can conclude that satisfaction with staffing, satisfaction with pay and satisfaction with teamwork affect performance related self-efficacy. Results show that SHRIM actually impacted the WSE, but only in some dimensions. Namely, satisfaction with staffing practices, pay/compensation and teamwork seem to directly impact PROSE. Satisfaction with information, training, performance appraisal and service cooperation, do not seem to be directly associated with WSE. We believe that the three dimensions that appear to influence WSE reflect the subjects most direct relationship with the organization, in the sense that they are the processes that directly and personally affect the subjects relationship with their performance perceptions. Thus, we believe that it is shown that some dimensions of SHRIM affect WSE directly, but we wonder if there might be a moderator effect of other variables that enable the remaining dimensions to impact PROSE as well. Future studies should try to replicate this study and test if this relationship is confirmed, but also use moderator variables such as organizational commitment and other organizational psychology variables. Results show that SHRIM actually impacted the WSE, but only in some dimensions. Namely, satisfaction with staffing practices, pay/compensation and teamwork seem to directly impact PROSE. Satisfaction with information, training, performance appraisal and service cooperation, do not seem to be directly associated with WSE. We believe that the three dimensions that appear to influence WSE reflect the subjects most direct relationship with the organization, in the sense that they are the processes that directly and personally affect the subjects relationship with their performance perceptions. Thus, we believe that it is shown that some dimensions of SHRIM affect WSE directly, but we wonder if there might be a moderator effect of other variables that enable the remaining dimensions to impact PROSE as well. Future studies should try to replicate this study and test if this relationship is confirmed, but also use moderator variables such as organizational commitment and other organizational psychology variables. Helena Martins & Teresa Proença Faculty of Economics of the University of Porto Polytechnic of Porto CEF.UP Scales of the Satisfaction with Human Resources Issues Management Questionnaire (SHRIMQ) are: Information - referring to the satisfaction with the way information that does not concern patients is conveyed in the organization Performance appraisal - regarding satisfaction with the process and results of performance appraisal in the organization Compensation - considering satisfaction with compensation and benefits the organization offers Interdepartment cooperation - regarding satisfaction with the way different departments cooperate and share information that is general or concerns patients Staffing - satisfaction with recruitment and selection practices Teamwork - satisfaction with the way teams work Training - satisfaction with the contents and quantity of training offered by the Hospital Scales of the Satisfaction with Human Resources Issues Management Questionnaire (SHRIMQ) are: Information - referring to the satisfaction with the way information that does not concern patients is conveyed in the organization Performance appraisal - regarding satisfaction with the process and results of performance appraisal in the organization Compensation - considering satisfaction with compensation and benefits the organization offers Interdepartment cooperation - regarding satisfaction with the way different departments cooperate and share information that is general or concerns patients Staffing - satisfaction with recruitment and selection practices Teamwork - satisfaction with the way teams work Training - satisfaction with the contents and quantity of training offered by the Hospital Discussion & Conclusions Results Analysis Method Context Abstract Introduction Scale Constructs