Low frequency radio observations of galaxy groups With acknowledgements to: R. Athreya, P. Mazzotta, T. Clarke, W. Forman, C. Jones, T. Ponman S.Giacintucci.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
Advertisements

Low-frequency radio maps for the REXCESS cluster sample S.R. Heidenreich, University of Southampton In collaboration with J.H. Croston, University of Southampton;
AGN FEEDBACK IN TWO INTERESTING GROUPS F. Gastaldello (IASF-MI, UCI) D. Buote (UCI), P. Humphrey (UCI), W. Mathews (UCSC), F. Brighenti (U. Bologna), P.
Radio Mode Feedback in Giant Elliptical Galaxies Paul Nulsen (CfA), Christine Jones (CfA), William Forman (CfA), Eugene Churazov (MPA), Laurence David.
To study x-ray cavity statistically, we retrieved archival data from the Chandra archive. We obtained our initial sample from the Cluster of galaxies (1522),
X-Ray Measurements of the Mass of M87 D. Fabricant, M. Lecar, and P. Gorenstein Astrophysical Journal, 241: , 15 October 1980 Image:
Deep Chandra and XMM-Newton Observations of NGC 4472 R. P. Kraft, S. W. Randall, W. R. Forman, P. E. J. Nulsen, C. Jones, A. Bogdan, M. J. Hardcastle,
Evolution of a Powerful Radio Loud Quasar 3C186 and its Impact on the Cluster Environment at z=1 Aneta Siemiginowska Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
The Radio/X-ray Interaction in Abell 2029 Tracy Clarke (Univ. of Virginia) Collaborators: Craig Sarazin (UVa), Elizabeth Blanton (UVa)
The GMRT Radio Halo survey Results and implications for LOFAR Simona Giacintucci Harvard-Smithsonian CfA, Cambridge, USA INAF-IRA, Bologna, Italy T. Venturi,
24-28 October 2005 Elena Belsole University of Bristol Distant clusters of Galaxies Ringberg Workshop X-ray constraints on cluster-scale emission around.
Luigina Feretti Istituto di Radioastronomia CNR Bologna, Italy Radio observations of cluster mergers X-Ray and Radio Connections, Santa Fe, NM February.
Radio halos and relics in galaxy clusters. NGC315: giant (~ 1.3 Mpc) radio galaxy with odd radio lobe (Mack 1996; Mack et al. 1998). precessing jets (Bridle.
Ben Maughan (CfA)Chandra Fellows Symposium 2006 The cluster scaling relations observed by Chandra C. Jones, W. Forman, L. Van Speybroeck.
Dark Halos of Fossil Groups and Clusters Observations and Simulations Ali Dariush, Trevor Ponman Graham Smith University of Birmingham, UK Frazer Pearce.
Low frequency results from the GMRT and the role of the E-LOFAR Dharam Vir Lal (MPIfR, Bonn)
Radio galaxies in the Chandra Era, Boston, July 2008 Shock heating in the group atmosphere of the radio galaxy B A Nazirah Jetha 1, Martin Hardcastle.
I. Balestra, P.T., S. Ettori, P. Rosati, S. Borgani, V. Mainieri, M. Viola, C. Norman Galaxies and Structures through Cosmic Times - Venice, March 2006.
Jets in Low Power Compact Radio Galaxies Marcello Giroletti Department of Astronomy, University of Bologna INAF Institute of Radio Astronomy & G. Giovannini.
Particles and Fields in Lobes of Radio Galaxies Naoki Isobe (NASDA, MAXI Mission) Makoto Tashiro (Saitama Univ.) Kazuo Makishima (Univ. of Tokyo) Hidehiro.
Centaurus A Kraft, Hardcastle, Croston, Worrall, Birkinshaw, Nulsen, Forman, Murray, Goodger, Sivakoff,Evans, Sarazin, Harris, Gilfanov, Jones X-ray composite.
3C 186 A Luminous Quasar in the Center of a Strong Cooling Core Cluster at z>1 Aneta Siemiginowska CfA Tom Aldcroft (CfA) Steve Allen (Stanford) Jill Bechtold.
XMM results in radio-galaxy physics Judith Croston CEA Saclay, Service d’Astrophysique EPIC consortium meeting, Ringberg, 12/04/05.
Extended Radio Sources in Clusters of Galaxies Elizabeth Blanton University of Virginia.
Annalisa Bonafede PhD student at IRA Radio Astronomy Institute Bologna (Italy) With: L. Feretti, G. Giovannini, M. Murgia, F. Govoni, G. B.Taylor, H. Ebeling,
Radio Sources in High-Redshift Galaxy Clusters: An Initial Look Megan Roscioli University of Chicago In collaboration with Mike Gladders, U. Chicago RCS-1,2.
Dusty star formation at high redshift Chris Willott, HIA/NRC 1. Introductory cosmology 2. Obscured galaxy formation: the view with current facilities,
Estimate* the Total Mechanical Feedback Energy in Massive Clusters Bill Mathews & Fulai Guo University of California, Santa Cruz *~ ±15-20% version 2.
SEARCHING FOR COOLING FLOWS… Silvia Caffi IASF/CNR Sez. Milano.
Bubble heating in groups and clusters: the nature of ghost cavities Nazirah Jetha 1, Martin Hardcastle 2, Simon Weston 2, Arif Babul 3, Ewan O’Sullivan.
Radio lobes of Pictor A: an X-ray spatially resolved study G.Migliori(1,2,3), P.Grandi(2), G.C.G.Palumbo(1), G.Brunetti(4), C.Stanghellini(4) (1) Bologna.
Studying AGN feedback in nearby X-ray groups and clusters Electra Panagoulia Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge, UK With: Andy Fabian Jeremy Sanders Julie.
Santiago Chile (5-9 Dec 2005) 1 “Groups of Galaxies in the nearby Universe” ESO 2005 workshop X-ray Properties of a Mass- Selected Group Catalog P. Mazzotta.
The Environments of Galaxies: from Kiloparsecs to Megaparsecs August 2004 Cool Cores in Galaxy Groups Ewan O’Sullivan Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Jet/environment interactions in FRI radio galaxies
Jet/environment interactions in FR-I and FR-II radio galaxies Judith Croston with Martin Hardcastle, Mark Birkinshaw and Diana Worrall.
Central radio galaxies in groups: cavities, bubbles and the history of AGN heating Central radio galaxies in groups: cavities, bubbles and the history.
Extended X-ray Emissions from the Radio Galaxies Centaurus B and Fornax A Makoto Tashiro 1, Naoki Isobe 2, Masaya Suzuki 1 Kouichi Ito 1, Keiichi Abe 1,
Hot gas in galaxy pairs Olga Melnyk. It is known that the dark matter is concentrated in individual haloes of galaxies and is located in the volume of.
MASS AND ENTROPY PROFILES OF X-RAY BRIGHT RELAXED GROUPS FABIO GASTALDELLO UC IRVINE & BOLOGNA D. BUOTE P. HUMPHREY L. ZAPPACOSTA J. BULLOCK W. MATHEWS.
Galaxy Wakes – Theory & Observations Irini Sakelliou University of Birmingham D.M. Acreman, T.J. Ponman, I.R. Stevens University of Birmingham M.R. Merrifield.
This composite X-ray (blue)/radio (pink) image of the galaxy cluster Abell 400 shows radio jets immersed in a vast cloud of multimillion degree X-ray emitting.
AY202a Galaxies & Dynamics Lecture 17: Galaxy Groups & Clusters continued.
3 Temperature profiles The shape of the temperatures profiles (some examples are shown in Fig.2) resemble the one obtained for hotter, more massive clusters.
2005/9/28 X-ray Universe The electron and magnetic field energies in the east lobe of the radio galaxy Fornax A, measured with XMM-Newton. Naoki.
CHANDRA’s view of cool-core clusters at high-z Joana Santos (ESAC/ESA)
The Fate of the X-Ray Emitting Gas in the Early-Type Galaxy NGC 5044
On the evolution of Cool Core Clusters Joana Santos (INAF-Trieste) Piero Rosati (ESO), Paolo Tozzi (INAF-Trieste), Hans Boehringer (MPE), Stefano Ettori.
Sharp Images of Galaxy Groups: Chandra and XMM Uncover New Intricacies J. M. Vrtilek 1, E. J. O’Sullivan 1, T. J. Ponman 2, L. P. David 1,D. E. Harris.
Gas in Galaxy Clusters Tracy Clarke (NRAO) June 5, 2002 Albuquerque, AAS.
“Astrophysics with E-LOFAR’’ September 2008, Hamburg, Germany Istituto di Radioastronomia, INAF- Bologna, ITALY Cluster Radio Halos in the LOFAR.
Deep Chandra observation of WARPJ at z=1: an evolved cool-core cluster at high-z (and a bonus…) P. Tozzi, M.Nonino (INAF-TS), P. Rosati (ESO),
Feedback Observations and Simulations of Elliptical Galaxies –Daniel Wang, Shikui Tang, Yu Lu, Houjun Mo (UMASS) –Mordecai Mac-Low (AMNH) –Ryan Joung (Princeton)
MASS PROFILES OF X-RAY BRIGHT RELAXED GROUPS: METHODS AND SYSTEMATICS FABIO GASTALDELLO IASF-INAF MILANO & UC IRVINE D. BUOTE UCI P. HUMPHREY UCI L. ZAPPACOSTA.
Energy Balance in Clusters of Galaxies Patrick M. Motl & Jack O. Burns Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy University of Colorado at Boulder X-ray.
RGS observations of cool gas in cluster cores Jeremy Sanders Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge A.C. Fabian, J. Peterson, S.W. Allen, R.G.
Jet Interactions with the Hot Atmospheres of Clusters & Galaxies B.R. McNamara University of Waterloo Girdwood, Alaska May 23, 2007 L. Birzan, P.E.J. Nulsen,
Abstract We present multiwavelength imaging and broad-band spectroscopy of the relativistic jets in the two nearby radio galaxies 3C 371 and PKS ,
Recent Progress in Understanding X-ray Emission From Early-type Galaxies: The Hot Gas Component Jimmy A. Irwin University of Michigan X-rays From Nearby.
Probing the Dynamics of Galaxy-Gas Interactions in Groups and Clusters with Chandra and XMM-Newton Marie Machacek Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory.
TWO SAMPLES OF X-RAY GROUPS FABIO GASTALDELLO UC IRVINE & BOLOGNA D. BUOTE P. HUMPHREY L. ZAPPACOSTA J. BULLOCK W. MATHEWS UCSC F. BRIGHENTI BOLOGNA.
Brigthest Cluster Galaxies Unique class of objects  most luminous  most massive  extended source  some BCG shows multiple nuclei → galaxy merger →
Collaborators: Murgia M. (IRA-INAF-CA), Feretti L. (IRA-INAF- BO), Govoni F. (OAC-INAF-CA), Giovannini G. (University of Bologna), Ferrari C. (Observatoire.
Challenging the merger/sloshing cold front paradigm: A2142 revisited by XMM Mariachiara Rossetti (Università degli Studi di Milano & IASF Milano) D. Eckert,
Ewan O’Sullivan (SAO) thanks to: J. Vrtilek, L. David, S. Giacintucci, S. Raychaudhury, A. Zezas, and others.
Jesper Rasmussen (Univ. of Birmingham)
Molecular gas in cooling flows Interplay with AGN and starbursts
Dying radio galaxies with LOFAR
Polarization of Cluster Radio Sources with LOFAR
Using AGN as Probes of the ICM
Presentation transcript:

Low frequency radio observations of galaxy groups With acknowledgements to: R. Athreya, P. Mazzotta, T. Clarke, W. Forman, C. Jones, T. Ponman S.Giacintucci (CfA), J. Vrtilek (CfA), E. O'Sullivan (CfA), S. Raychaudhury (CfA, U. Birmingham), L.David (CfA), T.Venturi (INAF-IRA Italy), M. Murgia (INAF-Oss. Cagliari)

The project For a sample of nearby groups of galaxies: GMRT observations at low frequency (235, 327 & 610 MHz) X-ray data from Chandra and/or XMM-Newton Questions How do X-ray and radio structures correlate? What are the properties of central radio sources over a broad frequency range and what do they imply for ages, outburst cycles…? What are the effects of AGN at various phases of activity? What are the mechanisms of energy injection?

Why groups? Examining outbursts in systems smaller than the well-studied rich clusters is valuable for a number of reasons: shallow group potential  large impact on intragroup medium low pressure environment  more apparent radio/thermal gas interaction significant influence on galaxy evolution Why GMRT? very high sensitivity at low radio frequency: rms ≈ MHz rms ≈ MHz high resolution: from MHz to MHz 2-3 hrs obs.

Targets and status of the GMRT observations 18 galaxy groups All have Chandra and/or XMM data Temperatures 1-3 keV All have at least NVSS 1.4 GHz data initially Presence of X-ray or radio structure indicative of AGN interaction with hot gas Group Name235 MHz610 MHz UGC 408 Aug 08 X NGC 315 Aug 08 X NGC 383 Aug 08 X NGC 507 Aug 08 X NGC 741 XX HCG 15 Aug 08 X NGC 1407 Aug 08 X NGC 1587 Aug 08 X MKW 2 XX Group Name235 MHz610 MHz NGC 3411 XX NGC 4636 XX HCG 62 XX NGC 5044 XX NGC 5813 Aug 08 NGC 5846 X AWM 4 XX NGC 6269 XX NGC 7626 Aug 08 X observed at 327 MHz

The prototype analysis: AWM 4 Poor cluster (~30 members) centered on giant elliptical NGC 6051 No optical substructure (Koranyi & Geller 2002) X-ray bright (~ 2 x erg s -1 ), T~ 3 keV Apparently relaxed (but disturbance in the temperature and abundance distribution; O’Sullivan et al. 2005, see also O’Sullivan’s poster) GMRT 610 MHz on SDSS Composite XMM - optical image 4C kpc

Radio overview GMRT 610 MHz (res. 5 arcsec) VLA 5 GHz Similar WAT morphology at 235 and 327 MHz Lobes and jets are symmetric in flux, size and spectral index properties Jet-to-counterjet brightness ratio → θ ~ 81°-87° β = 0.5 ± 0.2 Giacintucci et al. (2008), astro-ph/

Spectral analysis and age of the radio source MHz spectral index image (res. 13 arcsec) Fit using a JP model (Jaffe & Perola 1973) and assuming ν b prop. to d -2 - expected under the assumption that the growth velocity is constant - reflects the fact that the electron age increases as electrons move away from the nucleus RESULTS: α inj ~ 0.5 ν b ~ 350 MHz B eq = 5 μG t rad ~ 1.6 x 10 8 yr

Gas heating at the core of AWM 4? AWM 4 occupies an unusual place among groups and clusters O’Sullivan et al. (2005) Regular X-ray emission Monotonic increase of brightness toward the centre Cooling time ~ 2 Gyr Metallicity decline from the centre to large radii Relaxed cluster with a well-established cool core BUT Gas (re)heating by the central AGN: - Required energy ~ 9 x ergs - E tot, RADIO ~ 2.9 x ergs (t ~ 160 Myr) - Mechanical energy?? → ~ 80 kpc bubbles No X-ray cavities in the XMM image (see Giacintucci et al for details)

610 MHz on the keV smoothed Chandra image New 80 ksec Chandra observation (Cycle 9) Preliminary!

Conclusions and future perspectives Our analysis of AWM 4 shows that the combination of X-ray and high sensitivity multi-(low) frequency radio observations offers useful insight into AGN/hot gas interaction, geometry, timescales, energetics... in the central region of groups and clusters A similar study will be carried out for other individual interesting groups in the sample (see preliminary results in E. O’ Sullivan’s poster) Statistical analysis of the whole sample (completion of the GMRT observations at 235/610 MHz in August 2008)

Large scale radio galaxies GMRT 610 MHz (resolution: 5 arcsec) NGC 383 (3C 31) CC? NGC 7626 (NCC?) NGC 741 & NGC 7626: see also E.O’Sullivan’s poster NGC 741/742 (CC) (S. Raychaudhury’s talk)

Small scale radio galaxies GMRT 610 MHz (res. 5’’) NGC 6269 (CC) HCG 62 - res. 14’’ (CC) (S. Raychaudhury’s talk) NGC 1407 (CC) NGC 4636 (CC) (see E. O’Sullivan & A. Baldi posters)

Amorphous radio galaxies GMRT 610 MHz NGC res. 6” (NCC) (E. O’Sullivan’s poster) HCG 15 - res. 18’’ (NCC?) NGC 1587 (NCC?) - res. 5’’ & 20’’

Active and dying radio galaxies UGC 408 GMRT 610 MHz (res. 5’’) NGC 507 (CC) Active Dying Murgia et al. submitted α=0.8 power law CI OFF + pow t OFF /t s =0.3

UGC 408 – GMRT 610 MHz (res. 5’’) keV smoothed Chandra image