MEASURING CONDUCT AND COST PARAMETERS IN THE SPANISH AIR TRANSPORT MARKET Xavier Fageda Grup de Recerca en Polítiques Públiques i Regulació Econòmica.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Market-based DEMAND MANAGEMENT strategies Giovanni Andreatta, University of Padova Lorenzo Brunetta, Milan Polytechnic Un. Guglielmo Guastalla, Eurocontrol.
Advertisements

Paul E. Kent, Ph.D., Vice President and Port Specialist, Nathan Associates Inc. Port Competition Regulation: Leveling the Playing Field.
Can Money Matter in small island developing states? Evidence using the Solow estimator Associate Professor Dr K. C Jankee (University of Mauritius) Chairman,
Airport Forecasting. Forecasting Demand Essential to have realistic estimates of the future demand of an airport Used for developing the airport master.
Lecture #11: Introduction to the New Empirical Industrial Organization (NEIO) - What is the old empirical IO? The old empirical IO refers to studies that.
3. Results (2). ! 4. Conclusions 1.The strong hub competition in Europe and the lack of new route developments may damage Heathrow’s position as a.
Preferences for Transfers in Ireland and Europe Liam Delaney Department of Economics,TCD ISPA Policy Conference Dublin September 17, 2004.
TRANSPORT RESEARCH CENTER – ETSI CAMINOS, CANALES Y PUERTOS UNIVERSIDAD POLITÉCNICA DE MADRID Thredbo 9 Lisbon, Portugal 5-9 September 2005 Performance.
European Commission Slot allocation at Community airports Infrastructures and Airports Unit Klaas Pel.
School of something FACULTY OF OTHER DTC Low Carbon Technologies Faculty Of Engineering University of Leeds, UK Holly Edwards Rail Revolution or Carbon.
Monopoly Practices and Competitive Behaviour in the French Satellite Pay-TV Market Michele Cincera and Abdul G. Noury CEPR Discussion Paper #4174.
The impact of network density, travel and location patterns on regional road network vulnerability Erik Jenelius Lars-Göran Mattsson Div. of Transport.
LMI Airline Responses to NAS Capacity Constraints Peter Kostiuk Logistics Management Institute National Airspace System Resource.
NUOVE TEORIE DEI MERCATI: L’APPROCCIO SPERIMENTALE PATRIZIA SBRIGLIA SIEPI 2010.
Developed by Cool Pictures and MultiMedia Presentations Copyright © 2004 by South-Western, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. All rights reserved. Developed.
C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to Describe and identify monopolistic competition.
ARE COMBINATION GAS AND ELECTRIC UTILITIES MULTIPRODUCT NATURAL MONOPOLIES? - Merrile Sing Presentation Eco 435 Date 31 January 2012.
Is a mixed funding model for the highway network sustainable over time? The Spanish case Germà Bel (Cornell University and Universitat de Barcelona) &
Agricultural Productivity and Economic Growth: Empirical Analysis on the Contemporary Developing Countries.
ECW2731 Managerial Economics. ECW2731 Week 1-2 Subject Adviser Dr Gennadi KAZAKEVITCH Berwick campus, Room 129. Phone: (03) Fax: (03)
Competition’s effect on poor consumers: Mexican experience Heidi Sada and Manuel Sánchez CUTS March 2013 COMISIÓN FEDERAL DE COMPETENCIA 1.
Air Transport Director Ministry of Transport and Telecommunications
Route Planning and Evaluation
ANALYSIS FRAMEWORK FOR OPERATIONAL EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT CONGESTION MANAGEMENT MEASURES AT CLUSTERED AIRPORTS Loan T. Le Research Sponsors: NASA ARC, FAA.
1 MICROECONOMIC REFORM VCE ECONOMICS. 2 Microeconomic reform refers to government policies which aim to improve the individual sectors of the markets.
Competition Reforms in Bus transport sector In Zambia National Advocacy Plan (CREW Project) CREW NRG-IV Meeting, 22 nd April, Lusaka.
Introduction Class 1. Economics of I-O Industrial economics is a branch of applied microeconomics which seeks to understand the causes and effects of.
Benefits of Product Market Competition National Training Workshop on Competition Policy and Law Gerald Gregory (CUTS Fellow)
Lecture 4 Transport Network and Flows. Mobility, Space and Place Transport is the vector by which movement and mobility is facilitated. It represents.
When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T Explain how price and quantity are determined.
Lecture 1 Introduction- Manifestations of Transport and Tourism.
Type author names here © Oxford University Press, All rights reserved. Operations Management Chapter 2 Winning Customers and Competing Effectively.
1 Cross-border Bank Acquisitions: Is there a Performance Effect? By Ricardo Correa Discussant: Elijah Brewer III, DePaul University and the Federal Reserve.
1 ECONOMIC REGULATORS CONFERENCE NERSA & TIPS AUGUST 2012 The sensitivity of the South African industrial sector’s electricity consumption to electricity.
Young Scientist’s 1st International Baku Forum Shahriyar Nasirov Universidad Del Pais Vasco ( Spain) How Entrance of Renewable Energy Sources Affected.
TEAM 1 – Airbus AXX Future of Air Transportation and Possible Air Response.
The Significance of Competition Law and Policy in Economic Development and Integration April 2004 Ross Jones Deputy Chairman, Australian Prudential Regulation.
Does EC balances efficiency gains against anti-competitive effects? A Preliminarily Empirical Evaluation Zafeira Kastrinaki EC Competition Enforcement.
Local export spillovers in France P. Koenig, University Paris West & Paris School of Economics F. Mayneris, Paris School of Economics S. Poncet, University.
1 Some Comments on “What Borders are Made of: An Analysis of Banking Integration Using European Regional Data” (M. Affinito and M. Piazza) Ron Martin Department.
TRADING THE UNTRADEABLE A Gravity Model for Large-Scale Land Acquisitions (LSLAs) Marcello De Maria PhD Student, Department of Economics University of.
Monopolistic Competition CHAPTER 16 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Describe.
Migration and Firms’ Growth: evidence from Spanish cities Mercedes Teruel-Carrizosa Agustí Segarra-Blasco (very preliminary version) Grup de Recerca d’Indústria.
Why Do Countries Use Capital Controls? Prepared by R. Barry Johnston and Natalia T. Tamirisa - December 1998 Presented by: Alyaa Ezzat.
Building the Case for Privatization and Deregulation of Urban and Intercity Transportation Systems Clifford Winston The Brookings Institution.
By Christina Barr Oligopoly. A market form in which an industry is dominated by a small number of large scale producers. Because of their smaller numbers,
WHEN TRAINS GO FASTER THAN PLANES: THE STRATEGIC REACTION OF AIRLINES IN SPAIN JUAN LUIS JIMÉNEZ OFELIA BETANCOR IRU OJEDA RAMÍREZ.
Objectives of the Session By the end of this session, it will be hoped to achieve the following objectives;  To understand the nature and scope of managerial.
MARKET APPRAISAL. Steps in Market Appraisal Situational Analysis and Specification of Objectives Collection of Secondary Information Conduct of Market.
1© 2009 by Nelson Education Ltd.. 2 The Airline Industry Chapter 6.
Monopolistic Competition CHAPTER 16 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Describe.
Endogenous deregulation: evidence from OECD countries Duo and Roller, Economics Letters, 2003,
Methodology: IV to control for endogeneity of the measures of innovation. Results (only for regions with extreme values) Table 2. Effects from the 2SLS.
Ryanair / Aer Lingus case: Some comments ACE Annual Conference Toulouse – November 30, 2007 Marc IVALDI.
PHYSICAL INVESTMENT, HEALTH INVESTMENT AND ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS IN AFRICA By Abiodun O. Folawewo and Adeniyi Jimmy Adedokun Department of Economics,
Copyright © 2010 Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. Chapter 14 Global Cost and Availability of Capital.
Economic Issues: An Introduction DE3A 34 Outcome 1 Topic 6 Elasticity.
Competition Policy and Economic Growth: Evidence from Latin America Esteban Greco Diego Petrecolla Carlos A. Romero.
SECTION (2) Chapter 5 Competition policy By DAVID YOUNG & STAN METCALFE 1997.
What influences advertising price in television channels?: An empirical analysis on the Spanish market. Germà Bel & Laia Domènech (Universitat de Barcelona.
CIS Today and in the future Simon McNamara European Regions Airline Association.
Nuclear Power Economics and Project Structuring 2017 Edition
Isabelle Laplace (ENAC), Chantal Roucolle (ENAC), Aliya Ussinova (TSE)
ESTIMATION OF MARKET POWER IN PAKISTAN’S SUGAR INDUSTRY
16 Monopolistic Competition CHAPTER. 16 Monopolistic Competition CHAPTER.
ECO 550Competitive Success/tutorialrank.com
ECO 550 Education for Service-- tutorialrank.com.
Scheduled service vs personal transportation: the role of distance
Eurostat Management Plan for Regional and Urban statistics
The Competition Assessment Framework (The CAF)
Presentation transcript:

MEASURING CONDUCT AND COST PARAMETERS IN THE SPANISH AIR TRANSPORT MARKET Xavier Fageda Grup de Recerca en Polítiques Públiques i Regulació Econòmica. Institut de Recerca en Economia Aplicada Universitat de Barcelona Motivation The worldwide liberalisation of air transport services has been considered one of the most successful experiences in the wider process of regulatory reform. However, there is a consensus in the academic literature that benefits of liberalisation depend fundamentally on the existence of an effective competition on the markets where airlines compete; the air routes that link city pairs. In this context, the two typical market structures that have emerged in the domestic markets of the European Union are monopolies and asymmetric oligopolies. This paper estimates a model of airline competition for the Spanish air transport market in order to examine airlines behaviour under these market structures. Aims Route traffic density normally determines the particular strategic scenario. Indeed, oligopoly with a dominant firm is the predominant market structure in thick routes. Monopoly is the predominant market structure in thin air routes. In addition, it must be said that airlines face capacity constraints as long as main European airports are currently congested. In this context, our main goals are the following: 1) For thick routes, I test the explanatory power of alternative oligopoly models with capacity constraints. In particular, I test if price competition is à la Cournot (Kreps and Scheinkman, 1983) or follows a leader-follower scheme (Deneckere and Kovenock, 1992). 2) For thin routes, I analyse the degree of density economies to assess whether thin routes should be considered as natural monopolies Methodology We deal with these issues through an empirical model of competition that is estimated for a representative sample of routes of the Spanish market in the period , using demand and cost information. It is needed to mention that the results of this particular study can be expanded to the rest of the European Union because the Spanish market is the largest domestic market in this area. Our empirical model is based on a simultaneous estimation of a demand and pricing equation for monopoly and oligopoly routes (k) in period (t): Demand equation: log(q kt )= a 0 + a 1 log(pop kt ) + a 2 log(inc kt ) + a 3 D island k +  ’ 0 p kt +  ’ 1 D intermodal k p kt + e d kt Pricing equation: p kt = b 0 + b 1 dist k +  Q kt -  (1/  ’ k ) + e o kt where: q: demand p: prices pop: population Inc: income per capita D island : dummy variable that takes value 1 for routes with an island as an endpoint. D intermodal : dummy variable that takes value 1 in routes with an island as an endpoint and/or in routes whose distance is more than 650 kilometres. dist: distance The estimation of this equation allows measuring the average degree of collusion (  ) and the average degree of density economies (  ). In addition, we estimate two alternative specifications of the pricing equation, where: 1)  depend on variables related to market concentration on the route and on the airports and tourist intensity 2) Demand is disaggregated into the frequency, the load factor and the average aircraft size. Conclusions We find evidence that: 1) Conduct of Spanish airlines in oligopoly routes is less competitive than predicted by a Cournot model. 2) Airport concentration arises as the main determinant of airlines mark-ups. 3) Density economies are substantial. Thus, routes with a low traffic density can be considered as natural monopolies. The existence of a natural monopoly in thin routes along with a conduct generally not competitive of airlines could justify economic regulation in the former case and a more proactive competition policy in the latter case. Regardless the suitability of these two policy measures, we claim that the improvement of competition conditions in the Spanish market requires fundamentally a more balanced allocation of the airport slots. In turn, given that a high proportion of monopoly routes are short-haul routes it is desirable to promote intermodal competition.