Extrapolation vs. MHD modeling Hardi Peter Kiepenheuer-Institut Freiburg, Germany Contribution to the discussions at the SDO workshop / Monterey Feb 2006.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

MT4510 Solar Theory Thomas Neukirch

Advertisements

Solar Theory (MT 4510) Clare E Parnell School of Mathematics and Statistics.

Laura F. Morales Canadian Space Agency / Agence Spatiale Canadienne Paul Charbonneau Département de Physique, Université de Montréal Markus Aschwanden.

Forward Modeling from Simulations: Full-Sun and Active Regions Cooper Downs ISSI Workshop on Coronal Magnetism (2 nd Meeting), March

Jaroslav Dudík 1,2 Elena Dzifčáková 3, Jonathan Cirtain 4 1 – DAMTP-CMS, University of Cambridge 2 – DAPEM, FMPhI, Comenius University, Bratislava, Slovakia.

Construction of 3D Active Region Fields and Plasma Properties using Measurements (Magnetic Fields & Others) S. T. Wu, A. H. Wang & Yang Liu 1 Center for.

TOWARDS A REALISTIC, DATA-DRIVEN THERMODYNAMIC MHD MODEL OF THE GLOBAL SOLAR CORONA Cooper Downs, Ilia I. Roussev, Bart van der Holst, Noe Lugaz, Igor.

Modeling the Magnetic Field Evolution of the December Eruptive Flare Yuhong Fan High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research.

Can We Determine Electric Fields and Poynting Fluxes from Vector Magnetograms and Doppler Shifts? by George Fisher, Brian Welsch, and Bill Abbett Space.

Emerging Flux Simulations Bob Stein A.Lagerfjard Å. Nordlund D. Benson D. Georgobiani 1.

Simulation of Flux Emergence from the Convection Zone Fang Fang 1, Ward Manchester IV 1, William Abbett 2 and Bart van der Holst 1 1 Department of Atmospheric,

Local Data-driven MHD Simulations of Active Regions W.P. Abbett MURI 8210 Workshop Mar 2004.

MRT workshop, August 10, 2004 Active-region magnetic structures and their perturbations by flares H.S. Hudson SSL/UCB.

Free Magnetic Energy: Crude Estimates by Brian Welsch, Space Sciences Lab, UC-Berkeley.

Magnetic Helicity • Magnetic helicity measures

From detailed magnetoconvection simulations to modelling the convection zone-corona system Mats Carlsson Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, University.

Predicting Coronal Emissions with Multiple Heating Rates Loraine Lundquist George Fisher Tom Metcalf K.D. Leka Jim McTiernan AGU 2005.

Tackling the coronal heating problem using 3D MHD models with spectral synthesis Solar eclipse, , Wendy Carlos & John Kern  observational constraints.

Summary of workshop on AR May One of the MURI candidate active regions selected for detailed study and modeling.

Reconstructing Active Region Thermodynamics Loraine Lundquist Joint MURI Meeting Dec. 5, 2002.

SSL (UC Berkeley): Prospective Codes to Transfer to the CCMC Developers: W.P. Abbett, D.J. Bercik, G.H. Fisher, B.T. Welsch, and Y. Fan (HAO/NCAR)

Feb. 2006HMI/AIA Science Team Mtg.1 Heating the Corona and Driving the Solar Wind A. A. van Ballegooijen Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory Cambridge,

Why does the temperature of the Sun’s atmosphere increase with height? Evidence strongly suggests that magnetic waves carry energy into the chromosphere.

Flows and the Photospheric Magnetic Field Dynamics at Interior – Corona Interface Brian Welsch, George Fisher, Yan Li, & the UCB/SSL MURI & CISM Teams.

Data-Driven Simulations of AR8210 W.P. Abbett Space Sciences Laboratory, UC Berkeley SHINE Workshop 2004.

February 26, 2007 KIPAC Workshop on Magnetism Modeling/Inferring Coronal And Heliospheric Field From Photospheric Magnetic Field Yang Liu – Stanford University.

The Effect of Sub-surface Fields on the Dynamic Evolution of a Model Corona Goals :  To predict the onset of a CME based upon reliable measurements of.

Active Region Flux Transport Observational Techniques, Results, & Implications B. T. Welsch G. H. Fisher

Magnetic Field and Heating of the Corona Valentyna Abramenko and Vasyl Yurchyshyn Big Bear Solar Observatory.

Summary of UCB MURI workshop on vector magnetograms Have picked 2 observed events for targeted study and modeling: AR8210 (May 1, 1998), and AR8038 (May.

Sept. 13, 2007 CORONAL HEATING (Space Climate School, Saariselka, March, 2009) Eric Priest (St Andrews)

SH31C-08: The Photospheric Poynting Flux and Coronal Heating Some models of coronal heating suppose that convective motions at the photosphere shuffle.

Science drivers for wavelength selection: Quiet Sun and Active regions Hardi Peter Kiepenheuer-Institut Freiburg, Germany Contribution to the discussions.

MAGNETIC TWIST OF EUV CORONAL LOOPS OBSERVED BY TRACE RyunYoung Kwon, Jongchul Chae Astronomy Program, School of Earth and Environmental Science Seoul.

Coronal Heating of an Active Region Observed by XRT on May 5, 2010 A Look at Quasi-static vs Alfven Wave Heating of Coronal Loops Amanda Persichetti Aad.

Solar-B/EIS high-cadence observation for diagnostics of the corona and TR S. Kamio (Kyoto Univ.) Solar-B domestic meeting.

Solar eclipse, , Wendy Carlos and John Kern Structure of solar coronal loops: from miniature to large-scale Hardi Peter Max Planck Institute for.

Modeling Magnetoconvection in Active Regions Neal Hurlburt, David Alexander, Marc DeRosa Lockheed Martin Solar & Astrophysics Laboratory Alastair Rucklidge.

Coronal Mass Ejection As a Result of Magnetic Helicity Accumulation

Evolution of Emerging Flux and Associated Active Phenomena Takehiro Miyagoshi (GUAS, Japan) Takaaki Yokoyama (NRO, Japan)

Flows in hot coronal loops: mass cycle and coupling from chromosphere to corona Pia Zacharias, Sven Bingert, Hardi Peter Solar Cycle 24 Napa, California.

3D simulations of solar emerging flux ISOBE Hiroaki Plasma seminar 2004/04/28.

Quasi-periodic upflows in the solar active region Hui Tian High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research ASP research review 2010/10/27.

Amplification of twists in magnetic flux tubes Youra Taroyan Department of Physics, Aberystwyth University, users.aber.ac.uk/djp12.

Feb. 3-5, 20034th Solar-B science meeting1 Corona-Photosphere Connection with Spectropolarimeter Yukio Katsukawa (Univ. of Tokyo)

Emission measure distribution in loops impulsively heated at the footpoints Paola Testa, Giovanni Peres, Fabio Reale Universita’ di Palermo Solar Coronal.

Photospheric MHD simulation of solar pores Robert Cameron Alexander Vögler Vasily Zakharov Manfred Schüssler Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung.

Effect of solar chromospheric neutrals on equilibrium field structures - T. Arber, G. Botha & C. Brady (ApJ 2009) 太陽雑誌会ー 22/01/10.

SHINE Formation and Eruption of Filament Flux Ropes A. A. van Ballegooijen 1 & D. H. Mackay 2 1 Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, Cambridge,

Evolutionary Characteristics of Magnetic Helicity Injection in Active Regions Hyewon Jeong and Jongchul Chae Seoul National University, Korea 2. Data and.

1 Yongliang Song & Mei Zhang (National Astronomical Observatory of China) The effect of non-radial magnetic field on measuring helicity transfer rate.

Nov. 8-11, th Solar-B science meeting Observational Analysis of the Relation between Coronal Loop Heating and Photospheric Magnetic Fields Y. Katsukawa.

Shock heating by Fast/Slow MHD waves along plasma loops

Magnetic Helicity and Solar Eruptions Alexander Nindos Section of Astrogeophysics Physics Department University of Ioannina Ioannina GR Greece.

MHD Turbulence driven by low frequency waves and reflection from inhomogeneities: Theory, simulation and application to coronal heating W H Matthaeus Bartol.

GOAL: To understand the physics of active region decay, and the Quiet Sun network APPROACH: Use physics-based numerical models to simulate the dynamic.

SDO-meeting Napa, Wiegelmann et al: Nonlinear force-free fields 1 A brief summary about nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field modelling.

P.Zacharias1, S. Bingert2 & H. Peter2 1ISSI, Bern, Switzerland

STOCHASTIC COUPLING OF SOLAR PHOTOSPHERE AND CORONA (Astrophysical J

Solar Wind and CMEs with the Space Weather Modeling Framework

GOAL: To understand the physics of active region decay, and the Quiet Sun network APPROACH: Use physics-based numerical models to simulate the dynamic.

Wave heating of the partially-ionised solar atmosphere

Coronal Structure CSI /PHYS Solar Atmosphere Fall 2004

Hyewon Jeong, Jongchul Chae Seoul National University

From the Convection Zone to the Heliosphere

Abstract We simulate the twisting of an initially potential coronal flux tube by photospheric vortex motions. The flux tube starts to evolve slowly(quasi-statically)

Takashi Sakurai National Astronomical Observatory of Japan

Preflare State Rust et al. (1994) 太陽雑誌会.

Magnetic connection between the photosphere and the corona

Sakai, J. I., Nishi, K., and Sokolov, I. V. ApJ, 2002, 576, 1018

Presentation transcript:

Extrapolation vs. MHD modeling Hardi Peter Kiepenheuer-Institut Freiburg, Germany Contribution to the discussions at the SDO workshop / Monterey Feb 2006

 3D MHD model for the corona: 50 x 50 x 30 Mm Box ( ) – fully compressible; high order – non-uniform mesh  full energy equation (heat conduction, rad. losses)  starting with scaled-down MDI magnetogram – no emerging flux  photospheric driver: foot-point shuffled by convection  braiding of magnetic fields (Galsgaard, Nordlund 1995; JGR 101, 13445)  heating: DC current dissipation (Parker 1972; ApJ 174, 499)  heating rate  j 2 ~ exp(- z/H )  loop-structured 10 6 K corona Gudiksen & Nordlund (2002) ApJ 572, L113 (2005) ApJ 618, 1020 & 1031 Bingert, Peter, Gudiksen & Nordlund (2005) 3D MHD coronal modeling horizontal x [ Mm] horizontal y [ Mm] MDI magnetogram vertical z [ Mm] current log 10 J 2 mean B 2 mean J 2 histogram of currents Gudiksen & Nordlund (2002) ApJ 572, L horizontal X [Mm] vertical Z [Mm] Bingert et al. (2005) 10 6 K

Coronal emission and plasma–   atmosphere is mostly in low–  state,  numerous  >1 regions even at high  (but mostly at low density)  source region of coronal emission: 90% of emission from log I/  I  > 0  there ~5% of volume at  >1  corona is not in a pure low–  state: plasma able to distort magnetic field to some extent Peter, Gudiksen & Nordlund (2006) ApJ 638

Coronal emission and magnetic field lines I The "usual" paradigm: The coronal emission is aligned with the magnetic field emission synthesized from a 3D coronal model side view / at the limb Peter, Gudiksen & Nordlund (2004) ApJ 618

Coronal emission and magnetic field lines II Not all emission we see in EUV / X-rays outlines field lines !!! synthesized emission top view / at the limb potential field extrapolation Peter, Gudiksen & Nordlund (2004) ApJ 618 Gudiksen & Nordlund (2002)

Conclusions  field extrapolations (NLFF): – possible to match photospheric B boundary conditions very well – time evolution through sequence of equilibria – do we really "see" field lines in EUV ?  MHD coronal models – proper time evolution – not easy to match observed B at photosphere (all 3 components) – proper interaction of B and plasma – emission properties through forward modeling  One needs both: MHD models and field extrapolations !