Urban Charter Schools Demographics in OHIO March 2015

Introduction The is a report on urban charter schools in major cities in Ohio Urban charter schools are at the forefront of public education and on-going efforts to create better outcomes for students. Many urban charter schools have a specific mission to target and serve students with the greatest educational disadvantages, either by virtue of family background or poor prior instruction. Others got their start as a way to deal with rapid urban growth that axed the capacities of local districts to provide buildings and staff to meet growing demand. CREDO studied the attributes of students and schools in Cleveland & Columbus. 2

Introduction Five criteria were used to select which urban communities to study; full details are in the Technical Appendix. CREDO developed a narrow definition of “urban” to select schools for this study. The aim was to choose schools that were within the joint boundaries of cities and school districts. Multiple sources are used to develop boundaries for “urban regions,” including NCES locale codes, school addresses, and school district information. More detailed information is included in the Technical Appendix for the study. Student & School Counts are derived from student test data. 3

Research Questions This study answers the following questions: What does the urban public education landscape look in Ohio? How do the student attributes in urban charter schools differ from their traditional public school (TPS) counterparts? Does the level of achievement differ between students in charter schools and TPS in their same cities? Given the mission of some charter operators to target disadvantaged students, do we see proof they do so? 4

Overview of Public Charter Schools in OHIO 5

OH Student Demographics 6 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL TPS S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

OH Student Demographics 7 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL C HARTER S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

TPS Market Share Over Time 8 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL TPS S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

Charter Market Share Over Time 9 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL C HARTER S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

TPS Growth Rates 10 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL TPS S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

Charter School Growth Rates 11 S TATEWIDE D EMOGRAPHIC T RENDS BY L OCATION – A LL C HARTER S TUDENTS Source: National Center for Education Statistics, Core of Common Data 2011

OH Student Demographics 12 A GGREGATE S TATISTICS FOR S TUDENTS IN C ITIES S ELECTED FOR S TUDY

OH Student Demographics 13 A GGREGATE S TATISTICS FOR S TUDENTS IN C ITIES S ELECTED FOR S TUDY

OH Student Demographics 14 A GGREGATE S TATISTICS FOR S TUDENTS IN C ITIES S ELECTED FOR S TUDY

OH Student Demographics 15 A GGREGATE S TATISTICS FOR S TUDENTS IN C ITIES S ELECTED FOR S TUDY

Comparison of Achievement Scores for Charter Schools and TPS 16

Achievement Scores Because charter schools may not be located in all parts of a city, they may not have the array of students and academic talent that exists across the larger number of schools in the greater public education school district. To show these relationships, we first present the community-wide average results for math and reading, as revealed via statewide testing regimes. The results are then parsed to show the results for TPS and charter schools in each region. 17

Urban Achievement 18 R EGIONAL A VERAGE M ATH A CHIEVEMENT S CORE BY T YPE OF S CHOOL FOR C LEVELAND & C OLUMBUS C OMPARED TO S TATE A VERAGE M ATH A CHIEVEMENT

Urban Achievement 19 W EIGHTED A VERAGE M ATH A CHIEVEMENT S CORE OF C LEVELAND & C OLUMBUS C OMPARED TO S TATE A VERAGE M ATH A CHIEVEMENT

Urban Achievement 20 R EGIONAL A VERAGE R EADING A CHIEVEMENT S CORE BY T YPE OF S CHOOL FOR C LEVELAND & C OLUMBUS C OMPARED TO S TATE A VERAGE R EADING A CHIEVEMENT

Urban Achievement 21 W EIGHTED A VERAGE R EADING A CHIEVEMENT S CORE OF C LEVELAND & C OLUMBUS C OMPARED TO S TATE A VERAGE R EADING A CHIEVEMENT

Cleveland Demographics 22

Regional Enrollment Trends by Year 23 C LEVELAND S TUDENT C OUNTS BY S ECTOR AND BY Y EAR

Where Do Urban Students Come From? 24 L OCALE OF SCHOOL PREVIOUSLY ATTENDED BY STUDENTS TRANSFERRING TO C LEVELAND C HARTER S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 25 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY R ACE IN C LEVELAND S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 26 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY R ACE IN C LEVELAND S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 27 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY D EMOGRAPHICS IN C LEVELAND S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 28 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY D EMOGRAPHICS IN C LEVELAND S CHOOLS

Columbus Demographics 29

Regional Enrollment Trends by Year 30 C OLUMBUS S TUDENT C OUNTS BY S ECTOR AND BY Y EAR

Where Do Urban Students Come From? 31 L OCALE OF SCHOOL PREVIOUSLY ATTENDED BY STUDENTS TRANSFERRING TO C OLUMBUS C HARTER S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 32 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY R ACE IN C OLUMBUS S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 33 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY R ACE IN C OLUMBUS S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 34 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY D EMOGRAPHICS IN C OLUMBUS S CHOOLS

Regional Urban Student Demographics 35 R EGIONAL E NROLLMENT T RENDS BY D EMOGRAPHICS IN C OLUMBUS S CHOOLS