Impact plumes: Implications for Tharsis C.C. Reese & V.S. Solomatov Dept. of Earth & Planetary Sciences Washington University in St. Louis Saint Louis,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Interior structure, origin and evolution of the Moon Key Features of the Moon: pages
Advertisements

Do Plumes Exist? Gillian R. Foulger Durham University GEOL 4061 Frontiers of Earth Science.
Plate tectonics is the surface expression of mantle convection
The Mars Dichotomy Evidence for Plate Tectonics or Erosion?
EVOLUTION OF VOLCANISM ON VENUS
1 The Hesperian. 2 What’s important in the Late Noachian/Hesperian/Early Amazonian? Impact rate declining rapidly Volcanic resurfacing at a maximum? Hesperian.
The first 80% of the History of Venus?. Some Geological Conclusions from Magellan Analysis -Volcanism and tectonism are the most abundant geological processes.
An example of applying Lacey et al.’s (1981) model.
Grain size-dependent viscosity convection Slava Solomatov Washington University in St. Louis Acknowledgements: Rifa El-Khozondar Boulder CO, June 23.
Lithospheric flexure at the Hawaiian Islands and its implications for mantle rheology Perspective view (to the NW) of the satellite-derived free-air gravity.
1; movies Topography of a fast spreading ridge (EPR)
GEO 5/6690 Geodynamics 05 Nov 2014 © A.R. Lowry 2014 Read for Fri 7 Nov: T&S Last Time: Flexural Isostasy Tharsis example Is the Tharsis province.
Dynamic elevation of the Cordillera, western United States Anthony R. Lowry, Neil M. Ribe and Robert B. Smith Presentation by Doug Jones.
Upper Mantle Dynamics Expressed in Hotspot Basalt Chemistry Garrett Ito, Todd Bianco, John Mahoney, Janet Becker, & Michael Garcia Dept. of Geology & Geophysics,
GreatBreak: Grand Challenges in Geodynamics. Characteristics of a Desirable Geodynamic Model Ties together observational constraints on current state.
Dynamic Earth Class February 2006.
VOLCANISM ON MARS: The Tharsis Region and Olympus Mons A view of Olympus Mons.
9 Planetary Geology Planets Rock!. 9 Goals What determines why planets look the way they do. What are the 4 main process that affect a planet’s surface.
Class 1. Earth Structure and Plate Tectonics William Wilcock OCEAN/ESS 410.
Chapter 12 Earth’s Interior
Plate Tectonics 1 September 10, 13,700,002,008. The earth history of our planet for the last 4.2 Ga: slow cooling Slow cooling of the earth mantle temperatures.
Terrestrial Planets. Sources of internal heat.
Solar System Exploration: Space Science Highlight Featuring the Research of Suzanne E. Smrekar, Pierre Moreels, and Brenda J. Franklin To be published.
Mantle Convection and the Martian Hemispheric Dichotomy John Hernlund.
Power Requirements for Earth’s Magnetic Field Bruce Buffett University of Chicago.
Geodynamics DayLecturerLectures 2BBTemperature in the mantle 3BBGoverning equations and approximate solutions 4CLBNumerical, analytical and laboratory.
Are the predictions of the plume hypothesis borne out by observation? 1.Temperature Natalie Starkey.
Roland Burgmann and Georg Dresen
Geophysics & Meteorology on the surface of Mars P.Lognonné, T.Spohn, F.Forget IPGP, DLR, IPSL.
GEO 5/6690 Geodynamics 24 Oct 2014 © A.R. Lowry 2014 Read for Wed 5 Nov: T&S Last Time: Flexural Isostasy Generally, loading will occur both by.
GEO 5/6690 Geodynamics 24 Oct 2014 © A.R. Lowry 2014 Read for Fri 31 Oct: T&S Last Time: Flexural Isostasy Isostasy is a stress balance resulting.
Integrated 2-D and 3-D Structural, Thermal, Rheological and Isostatic Modelling of Lithosphere Deformation: Application to Deep Intra- Continental Basins.
Dynamics of Mantle Plumes Methods for modeling basic thermal plumes (with and without tracers) Plumes interacting with plates (and ridges) Plumes in thermo-chemical.
An Introduction to Geology Chapter 1.  Geology is the science that pursues an understanding of planet Earth ▪ Physical geology – examines the materials.
The science of Geology Geology is the science that pursues an understanding of planet Earth Physical geology - examines the materials composing Earth.
Past, Present and Future What have we learned? -Mantle and Plates are an intimately coupled system -Deep mantle structure is important for the surface.
An model for mantle structure evolution and its implications for mantle seismic and compositional structures and supercontinent process Nan Zhang,
Dynamical Consequences of a Chemical Layering in the Martian Mantle Sylvaine Ferrachat Doris Breuer Klaus Gottschaldt Louise Kellogg Inst. für Planetologie.
Cooling of the Earth: A parameterized convection study of whole versus layered models by McNamara and Van Keken 2000 Presentation on 15 Feb 2005 by Group.
Inner Planetary Geology I. Terrestrial Planets  The Terrestrial Planets cooled from molten masses  Acquired structure during cooling  Made primarily.
Influences of Compositional Stratification S.E.Zaranek E.M. Parmentier Brown University Department of Geological Sciences.
Influence of Magma on Rift Evolution: A Modeler’s Perspective Mark D. Behn Department of Geology & Geophysics, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Roger.
Geological data, geophysics and modelling of the mantle Yanick Ricard & Joerg Schmalzl " Geophysical observations; Introduction " Geochemical measurements.
The Lithosphere There term lithosphere is in a variety of ways. The most general use is as: The lithosphere is the upper region of the crust and mantle.
G. Marquart Gravity Effect of Plumes Geodynamik Workshop, Hamburg, Modeling Gravity Anomalies Caused by Mantle Plumes Gabriele Marquart Mantle.
Plumes, hotspots and the CMB Lecture 6: Geodynamics Carolina Lithgow-Bertelloni.
C.M. Rodrigue, 2014 Geography, CSULB Mars: First Order Landscapes Geography 441/541 S/14 Dr. Christine M. Rodrigue.
EART 160: Planetary Science 13 February Last Time Planetary Interiors –Pressure and Temperature inside Planets –Heat Sources Accretion Differentiation.
Are plumes predicted by realistic convection experiments and numerical situations? John Watson.
Why does Venus lack a magnetic field? Francis Nimmo, Department of Geological Sciences, University College of London.
E. M. Parmentier Department of Geological Sciences Brown University in collaboration with: Linda Elkins-Tanton; Paul Hess; Yan Liang Early planetary differentiation.
Gravimetry Geodesy Rotation
Dynamical modeling of Mars deep interior Sylvaine Ferrachat Institut für Planetologie Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster.
Layers _______ of the Earth ayers.
Tectonic and Thermal Evolution of Venus and the Role of Volatiles: Implications for Understanding the Terrestrial Planets Suzanne E. Smrekar et al. Discussed.
Mars Geology Dr. Ganna (Anya) Portyankina September, 2015.
Gravity anomalies and flexure at the West Taiwan basin:
MAGE postdoc presentation - MAGE midterm meeting Peter van Thienen D épartement de Géophysique Spatiale et Planétaire, Institut de Physique du Globe de.
Geology 5640/6640 Introduction to Seismology 13 Apr 2015 © A.R. Lowry 2015 Read for Wed 15 Apr: S&W (§3.6) Last time: Ray-Tracing in a Spherical.
The Principles of Planetary Geology By: Katie McCormick and Kyle Lennox.
Geology 6600/7600 Signal Analysis 18 Nov 2015 Last time: Deconvolution in Flexural Isostasy Tharsis loading controversy: Surface loading by volcanic extrusives?
Class 1. Earth Structure and Plate Tectonics William Wilcock
Earth’s Interior “Seeing into the Earth”
Are there currently active volcanoes on Venus?
ONTOLOGICAL REPRESENTATION OF RIFTS
Plate Tectonics on Planetary Bodies William Wilcock
Length scale of heterogeneity
How do plates move? MANTLE CONVECTION.
5% of all known volcanoes in the world are not located close to a plate margin. These are known as intraplate volcanoes and occur as a result of mantle.
Session 5: Higher level products (Internal)
Presentation transcript:

Impact plumes: Implications for Tharsis C.C. Reese & V.S. Solomatov Dept. of Earth & Planetary Sciences Washington University in St. Louis Saint Louis, MO 63130, USA

Tharsis province, Mars: geological & geophysical observations ● Broad topographic rise & center of large scale magmatism ● Shield volcanoes: Tharsis Montes, Olympus Mons ● Layered volcanics in Valles Marineris [McEwen et al., 1999] ● GTR consistent with surface loading & flexure of lithosphere [Zhong & Roberts, 2003] MGS/MOLA Interpretation: massive volcanic pile Thick complex crust [Zuber, 2001] 3 x 10 8 km 3 [Phillips et al., 2001] emplaced by late-Noachian 3.5 Ga

Mantle convection dominated by a single thermal plume originating at the CMB similar to a terrestrial plume but larger Conventional hypothesis for Tharsis formation The thermal plume model [e.g.Harder and Christensen, 1996] provides a heat source for early large scale magmatism could account for some present day topographic uplift [Redmond & King, 2004] might explain geologically recent volcanism [Kiefer, 2003; Hartmann and Neukum, 2001]

Conventional thermal plume model: 1 plume stabilization spinel to perovskite phase transition near the core mantle boundary [Harder and Christensen, 1996]

Reasons to consider alternative hypotheses No thermal plume model has reproduced Tharsis formation on a timescale consistent with observations which indicate emplacement by late Noachian [Banerdt & Golombek, 2000] Core radius [Yoder et al., 2003] may exclude a lower mantle perovskite layer which is key to stabilizing a single plume pattern of convection [Harder and Christensen, 1996] Geochemical heterogeneity [Kleine et al., 2004] suggests limited mantle mixing which is difficult to reconcile with vigorous mantle convection [Zuber 2001] Immobile lithosphere implies early mantle heating [Solomatov & Moresi, 2000] and core heat flow shut-off [Nimmo and Stevenson, 2001] making thermal plume formation difficult

Tharsis is related to early mantle dynamics associated with the evolution of a local magma pond produced by a very large impact. An alternative hypothesis for Tharsis formation The impact model can produce long-lived upwellings which may play a role in areoid evolution [Reese et al., 2002] can produce localized episodes of mantle magmatism [Reese et al., 2004]

Criterion for magma pond formation after [Tonks and Melosh, 1992]

Fluid dynamics of magma pond crystallization: isostatic adjustment versus crystallization Crystallization, t crys Isostatic adjustment, t iso

Fluid dynamics of magma pond crystallization: isostatic adjustment versus conductive cooling Isostatic adjustment, t sprd & conductive cooling, t cool

The idea: qualitative description of magma pond evolution fast crystallizationisostatic adjustment and merger with solid state convection impact and melt pond formation

Numerical simulation of an impact induced plume Spherical shell geometry Immobile lithosphere Viscous lid & rigid surface Spatial and temporal melt distribution is calculated Initial conditions

All melt is extracted to form crust Isostatic equilibrium maintained Yield strength limited topography (e.g. 2 km relief over 1000 km) Crustal growth & spreading parameterization

Case 1.No bottom heating Low interior viscosity Animation

Case 2.Bottom heating High interior viscosity

Conclusions 1. Evolution of impact induced local magma ponds depends on solid planet rheology, mode of crystallization, and magma pond size. Smaller melt regions  incomplete isostatic adjustment & merger with subsequent solid state evolution Large melt regions  rapid formation of a global melt layer 2. Impact induced plumes can focus magmatic activity and result in the development of a large igneous province. 3. Model predicts Tharsis development on a timescale consistent with observation