Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris Disks Stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) ( 1) Observatorio Nacional.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Origin & Evolution of Habitable Planets: Astronomical Prospective D.N.C. Lin University of California, Santa Cruz, KIAA, Peking University, with Pathways.
Advertisements

Debris disks with CCAT Jane Greaves: ~2012??
Probing the Conditions for Planet Formation in Inner Protoplanetary Disks James Muzerolle.
Spitzer IRS Spectroscopy of IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks Christine H. Chen (NOAO) IRS Disks Team astro-ph/
Resonant Structures due to Planets Mark Wyatt UK Astronomy Technology Centre Royal Observatory Edinburgh.
Signatures of Planets in Debris Disks A. Moro-Martin 1,2,3, S. Wolf 2, R. Malhotra 4 & G. Rieke 1 1. Steward Observatory (University of Arizona); 2. MPIA.
Overview on Extra Solar Planets Rahul I. Patel PHY 599 – Grad Seminar Oct. 18 th 2010.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris disks stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) (1) Observatorio Nacional.
Dust Dynamics in Debris Gaseous Disks Taku Takeuchi (Kobe Univ., Japan) 1.Dynamics of Dust - gas drag - radiation 2. Estimate of Gas Mass 3. Dust Disk.
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
High-resolution Imaging of Debris Disks Jane Greaves St Andrews University, Scotland.
New Results from the GALEX Nearby Young-Star Survey David R. Rodriguez (Universidad de Chile), B. Zuckerman (UCLA), Joel H. Kastner (RIT), Laura Vican.
Detecting the signature of planets at millimeter wavelengths F. Ramos-Stierle, D.H. Hughes, E. L. Chapin (INAOE, Mexico ), G.A. Blake ???
Debris Disks, Small Bodies, and Planets Alexander V. Krivov Astrophysical Institute and University Observatory Friedrich Schiller University Jena 4th Planet.
1 Debris Disk Studies with CCAT D. Dowell, J. Carpenter, H. Yorke 2005 October 11.
Extrasolar Planets More that 500 extrasolar planets have been discovered In 46 planetary systems through radial velocity surveys, transit observations,
February 10-11, 2011ANR EXOZODI Kick-Off meeting Transient dynamical events. The FEB hypothesis  Pictoris and Vega Hervé Beust Institut de Planétologie.
Physics and Astronomy University of Utah Extreme Solar Systems II Fall 2011 The Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks and the Diversity of Giant Planets Diversity.
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told us about (exo)-planetary science?
Spitzer Space Telescope Observations of the Fomalhaut Debris Disk Michael Werner, Karl Stapelfeldt, Chas Beichman (JPL); Kate Su, George Rieke, John Stansberry,
From Brown Dwarfs to Giant Planets Stan Metchev (Stony Brook Astronomy Group) Stan Metchev (Stony Brook Astronomy Group) Artist’s rendition of a brown.
Search for a Debris Disk Around GJ 876 Paul Shankland (USNO, JCU) David Blank (JCU) Dave Boboltz (USNO) Joe Lazio (NRL) Graeme White (JCU)
« Debris » discs A crash course in numerical methods Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
Zodiacal Cloud: The Local Circumstellar Disk Sumita Jayaraman.
ihorn To see a world in a grain of sand… Michael R. Meyer Institute for Astronomy, ETH-Zurich Dynamics of Discs and Planets Isaac Newton Institute.
Star and Planet Formation Sommer term 2007 Henrik Beuther & Sebastian Wolf 16.4 Introduction (H.B. & S.W.) 23.4 Physical processes, heating and cooling.
Exo-planets: ground-based How common are giant planets? What is the distribution of their orbits? –3.6m HARPS: long-term radial velocity monitoring of.
Gas in Transitional Disks Sean Brittain Clemson University, Clemson, SC, USA Joan Najita National Optical Astronomy Observatory, Tucson, AZ, USA 5 th Planet.
A new class of warm debris disks? Rachel Smith, Institute for Astronomy; Mark Wyatt, Abstract.
Decoding Dusty Debris Disks AAAS, Februrary 2014 David J Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
A Systematic Search and Characterization of Dusty Debris Disks M. McElwain, B. Zuckerman (UCLA) Joseph H. Rhee, & I. Song (Gemini Obs.) Photo Credit: T.
How Unique Are Nearby Debris Disks? Alycia Weinberger (DTM/CIW)
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
Debris Belts Around Vega 0 Topic: Exoplanets Concepts: Infrared observations, debris disks, exoplanet detection, planetary systems Missions: Spitzer, Herschel.
Debris Disk Imaging with HST/NICMOS: The GO/10177 Debris Disk Survey Part 2: The Resolved Disks GLENN SCHNEIDER NICMOS Project Steward Observatory 933.
The JCMT Debris Disk Legacy Survey: the (long) Calm before the Storm Brenda Matthews Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics.
UNESP- Guaratinguetá O.C. Winter 1,3, R. de la Reza 2, R.C. Domingos 3, L.A.G. Boldrin 1, C. Chavero 2 1 – Grupo de Dinâmica Orbital & Planetologia –
Infrared Signatures of Planetary Systems Amaya Moro-Martin Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University.
Leonardo Testi: Intermediate-Mass Star Formation, IAU Symp 221, Sydney, July 23, 2003 Formation and Early Evolution of Intermediate-Mass Stars  Intermediate-Mass.
Non-symetrical Protoplanetary Disks Annibal Hetem Jr. (FAFIL/FSA) Jane Gregorio-Hetem (IAG/USP)
Slide 1 (of 18) Circumstellar Disk Studies with the EVLA Carl Melis UCLA/LLNL In collaboration with: Gaspard Duchêne, Holly Maness, Patrick Palmer, and.
Science with continuum data ALMA continuum observations: Physical, chemical properties and evolution of dust, SFR, SED, circumstellar discs, accretion.
October 20, 2005 Nearly Resolved Debris Disks STScI, Baltimore Hervé Beust Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Grenoble, France FOST group The origin of the.
WHY THERE ARE APPARENTLY SO FEW DEBRIS DISKS AMONG POST- T TAURI STARS ? R. de la Reza (1), R. Almeida (1), I. Oliveira (1), P. Bourget (1), C.A.O. Torres.
Alice Quillen University of Rochester Department of Physics and Astronomy Oct, 2005 Submillimet er imaging by Greaves and collaborato rs.
P4-1 Precision Radial Velocity Spectrometer (PRVS) 2nd generation (“Aspen”) instrument for Gemini R=70,000,  m, RV stability < 1 m/s Goal: Find.
The ε Eridani debris disk Jane Greaves St Andrews, Scotland with Wayne Holland, Mark Wyatt & Bill Dent and cast of thousands...
The AU Mic Debris Ring Density profiles & Dust Dynamics J.-C. Augereau & H. Beust Grenoble Observatory (LAOG)
Occultation Studies of the Outer Solar System B. Scott Gaudi (Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics)
C. Catala, Observatoire de Paris, P. Feldman, JHU A. Lecavelier des Etangs, IAP C. Martin, LAM A. Roberge, Carnegie Institution of Washington T. Simon.
Gaspard Duchêne UC Berkeley & Obs. Grenoble From circumstellar disks to planetary systems – Garching – Nov
2003 UB313: The 10th Planet?. Extra-Solar or Exoplanets Planets around stars other than the Sun Difficult to observe Hundreds discovered (> 2000 so far)
The Birth of Stars and Planets in the Orion Nebula K. Smith (STScI)
The Formation & Evolution of Planetary Systems: Placing Our Solar System in Context Michael R. Meyer (Steward Observatory, The University of Arizona, P.I.)
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?  Pic, A5V star AU Mic, M1Ve star.
Pinpointing Planets in Circumstellar Disks Mar 2009 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Submillimeter Observations of Debris Disks Wayne Holland UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh With Jane Greaves, Mark Wyatt, Bill.
High Dynamic Range Imaging and Spectroscopy of Circumstellar Disks Alycia Weinberger (Carnegie Institution of Washington) With lots of input from: Aki.
ACS Multiband Coronagraphic Imaging of the Debris Disk around ß Pictoris David Golimowski STScI/NRDD 19 Oct 2005.
MOLECULAR HYDROGEN IN THE CIRCUMSTELLAR ENVIRONMENT OF HERBIG Ae/Be STARS Claire MARTIN 1 M. Deleuil 1, J-C. Bouret 1, J. Le Bourlot 2, T. Simon 3, C.
A Low Mass H 2 Component to the AU Microscopii Circumstellar Disk Kevin France – CITA/U Toronto Aki Roberge – GSFC Roxana Lupu – JHU Seth Redfield – U.
Kate Su, George Rieke, Karl Misselt, John Stansberry, Amaya Moro-Martin, David Trilling… etc. (U. of A) Karl Stapelfeldt, Michael Werner (NASA JPL) Mark.
Terrestrial Planet Bombardment & Habitability Jane Greaves St Andrews, Scotland.
Extended debris discs around nearby, Sun-like stars as a probe of disc-planet interactions Astronomical Society of Australia ASM 5th July 2016 Dr. Jonty.
Young planetary systems
Debris Discs in Binaries
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?
The Hunt For Other Worlds
The origin of gas in debris disks
Debris disks Basic properties Observational methods & constraints
Presentation transcript:

Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris Disks Stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) ( 1) Observatorio Nacional - Rio de Janeiro (2) Laboratorio Nacional de Astrofísica

Properties Debris disks (DD) are evolved disks presenting the following properties: 1) in general absence or few gas content 1) in general absence or few gas content 2) structural pattern dominated by new generation dust produced by 2) structural pattern dominated by new generation dust produced by strong collisions of planetesimals strong collisions of planetesimals 3) in general disks are assymmetrical 3) in general disks are assymmetrical 4) presence of warps and local perturbations of the dust 4) presence of warps and local perturbations of the dust 5) longlife structures 5) longlife structures 6) difficult to be detected, only approximatley 12 are resolved 6) difficult to be detected, only approximatley 12 are resolved

Questions 1) are there planets hidden in their disks ? At present only one planet have been clearly detected around a resolved disk in Epsilon Eridani (Greaves et al. 2005) 2) are these disks failed planetary disks ? 2) are these disks failed planetary disks ? 3) are these disks left over debris of incomplete planetary formation ? 3) are these disks left over debris of incomplete planetary formation ? 4) are hidden planets producing the observed warps and assymmetries, gaps or rings ? 4) are hidden planets producing the observed warps and assymmetries, gaps or rings ? 5) why they are longlived structures ? what maintain their dynamical stability ? is that due to a special configuration of dust maintained in resonances and what is the role of eventual planets ? 5) why they are longlived structures ? what maintain their dynamical stability ? is that due to a special configuration of dust maintained in resonances and what is the role of eventual planets ? 6) when DD evolution begins ? 8 Myr following de la Reza et al ) when DD evolution begins ? 8 Myr following de la Reza et al COROT can in principle detect for the first time the passage of dust structures or planets in unresolved Debris Disks candidates. Motivation

Distance: 3.2 pc SpT: K2V M * :0.8 Msun Planet 1 : Eps Eri b a: 3.3 AU M p : 0.86 M Jup Method : RV Planet 2 : Eps Eri c -Unconfirmed a: 40AU M p : 0.1 M Jup Method : Dust ring morphology 850 microns. 450 microns. Epsilon Eridani Epsilon Eridani The only example of a DD star with a planet close to the star detected by radial velocity surveys. Planet 2 is sheppering the ring?

β Pic The β Pic star with an edge-on disk. This is an example of a convenient geometry for COROT observations.

(Lecavelier et al. 1997) Unique emission absortion event detected on Nov 10 th 1981 by ground based photometric observations

(Lecavelier et al. 1997) 1 First interpretation of the 1981 event; a planet into the disk.

(Lamers et al. 1997) 2 3 Two other geometrical interpretations: 2-a spherical cloud; 3- a cometary cloud falling into the star.

(Lamers et al. 1997) The most successful model (3); a large comet or a fragmented falling comet.

(Galland et al. 2005) Result of a radial velocity survey of the β Pict star

Search for DD candidates stars for COROT: Distribution of resolved DD stars in an IRAS Color-Color diagram BD Myr 1-HR Myr 2 – Bpic - 11 Myr 3 – AB Aur - 4 Myr 4 – HD ? 5 – Fomahault - 200Myr 6 – Vega Myr (1( AeBe – HD Myr A B 1 – HD Myr G M Epsilon Eridani- 850Myr K – Tau Cet - 10Gyr Au Mic - 11Myr B BD A 1-HR Bpic 3 - AB Aur 4 - HD Fomahault 6 - Vega F AeBe- HD G 1- HD Tau Cet K Epsilon Eridani M Au Mic

Unresolved DD candidate stars with high IRAS quality

Conclusions Up to the present only one planet has been discovered in a resolved Debris Disk star (Epsilon Eridani). CoRoT can in principle discover some new cases and give an important insight on studies of the evolution of Debris Disks and on planetary formation. The only problem is the difficulty to find targets for 11<V<14 M type DD candidates obtained from IRASare in general M giants stars We are now looking for hot B/A/F stars with IR excesses. References: De la Reza et al., submitted to the AJ Galland et al., 2005 A&A, 443,337 Lamers et al.., 1997, A&A 328, 321 Lecavelier des Etangs, 1997, A&A, 328, 311