Patient and carers’ experiences of Ankle Foot Orthosis (AFO) and Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) for the correction of dropped foot after stroke.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Carers' involvement in decisions in hip fracture care 1 Carers Research Partnership Carers involvement in decisions regarding patients admitted to hospital.
Advertisements

"What I really needed was the truth" Exploring the information needs of people with CRPS. Sharon Grieve 1,2, Jo Adams 2, Candida McCabe 1,3. 1 Royal National.
ESTABLISHED 1875 – 125 YEARS OF EXCELLENCE Developing Reflexivity in Students: an essential component for clinical reasoning and decision making Dr Marie.
Personal Budgets and the carer - service user relationship: developing the knowledge base about carers and personalisation Carers Federation and De Montfort.
NHS Croydon Claire Godfrey AD Adult Strategic Commissioning.
Involving acute hospital inpatients in the evaluation of an occupational therapy service Cathy Robertson Senior occupational therapist Wirral Hospital.
Exploration of Physiotherapists’ Motivations to Embark upon Taught Master's Level Study Peter Glover MSc BSc (Hons) & Dr Cathy Bulley PhD BSc (Hons)
This Outcome report is based on data from clients who completed a Pain Management Programme at the RealHealth Treatment Centre in Coventry between May.
Effects of Age and Satisfaction on Acceptance of High-Technology Occupational Therapy Post Stroke Elizabeth Widicus, OTS and Dorothy Farrar Edwards, PhD.
Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Research Jenny Tancock, Clinical Librarian, FGH Alison Harry, R+D Co-ordinator,
Qualitative data can be seen as ‘of limited use’ because it is difficult to analyze This is why it is often converted into quantitative data using content.
Enhancing the student’s experience of interprofessional learning in practice Dr Milika Matiti, Senior Lecturer, University of Lincoln, UK Richard Pitt,
Enablers & barriers to increasing physical activity in those using mental health services LYNN SPEED, MENTAL HEALTH PHYSIOTHERAPIST SHIRLEY HAMILTON, SENIOR.
Are Patients Admitted to the Virtual Ward Satisfied with the Intervention of the Community Matron in their Care Pathway? Geraldine Rodgers Dr. Maria Ponto.
This Outcome report is based on data from patients who completed a Pain Management Programme at the RealHealth Treatment Centre in Coventry between November.
International Conference on Enhancement and Innovation in Higher Education Crowne Plaza Hotel, Glasgow 9-11 June 2015 Evaluation of a peer tutoring scheme.
The Research Process Interpretivist Positivist
Influencing the Research Agenda Findings from an independent evaluation of a Cancer Network Consumer Research Panel Cindy Cooper, Julia Moore, Rosemary.
The influence of ‘significant others’ on persistent back pain and work participation: a qualitative study of illness perceptions Serena McCluskey 1, Joanna.
Problem-based learning in a traditional curriculum
The patient journey after stroke: what services do patients in Lothian access and what are their experiences – a qualitative exploration. Introduction:
What is a research proposal? Plan to test hypothesis using research Write research Proposal (plan) Carry out research Apply for grant/ethics Clinical.
Individuals with Lower Literacy Levels: Accessing and Navigating Healthcare Herbert, H. 1, Adams, J. 1, Lowe, W. 1, Leuddeke, J Faculty of Health.
The Tellus Survey - an overview Alison Thompson: Analysis and Research Division DCSF Conference: The Use of Evidence in Policy Development and Delivery,
Jill Rutland My Background Public Health Library Service to Public Health Professionals Need to reach out to ‘frontline’ staff Interested to know.
But I Know it Worked: Unpacking Teachers’ Perceptions about the Effects of Literacy Strategies on Students Kelly Feighan and Debra Coffey Research for.
This Outcome Report is based on data from patients who completed a Functional Restoration Programme (FRP) at the RealHealth Treatment Centre in Coventry.
Stroke patient and carer experiences of Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) as provided through a Lothian drop foot clinic – a qualitative exploration.
Service users at the heart of service evaluation USER FOCUSED MONITORING.
Results Student Engagement : Students generally found logbooks easy to use and practical in the hospital setting. Purpose : There appeared to be a perceived.
Mentoring in Dentistry - Background The Continuum Tutor/Mentor Career Advice PDP Problems Trainer & Trainee Appraisal Career Advice PDP Problems Trainer.
Multiple Sclerosis Functional Electrical Stimulation Service Evaluation Jenny Thain - MS Clinical Specialist Physiotherapist Background People diagnosed.
This Outcome Report is based on data from patients who completed a Functional Restoration Programme (FRP) at the RealHealth Treatment Centre in Coventry.
Background Outcomes / Results Qualitative methodology was used to collect data about parent and professional views of the current services.
RESULTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS RESEARCH DESIGN & METHODS Integration of New Technology into Clinical Practice for Stroke Rehabilitation Jocelyn Wack, OTS and.
Collaborative Working: Speech and Language Therapy and the Stroke Association RCSLT Conference September 2012.
Audit of ‘This is me’ and ‘Forget me not’ on wards Semi structured Interviews with volunteer relatives Observation of care Undertaken over a 24 hour period.
P.Johnson, Research & Development Manager M.Thomson, Research Practitioner.
Template produced at the Graphics Support Workshop, Media Centre Background There is no evidence to suggest that people with dementia experience any less.
BEING INVOLVED ….WHAT IT MEANS TO PEOPLE AFFECTED BY CANCER Carolyn Morris Sussex Cancer Network Partnership Group.
3 rd International Nursing & Midwifery Conference National University of Ireland, Galway April 4 th & 5 th 2011.
An insight into the NHS Health Check Programme in Birmingham NHS Health Check National Learning Network 14 th Workshop - London 17 th July 2012.
The establishment of a new Lothian Functional Electrical Stimulation Clinic – an evaluation and exploration 1Jane Shiels; 1Katie Wilkie; 2Lisa Salisbury.
F EASIBILITY C ASE S TUDY ON THE USE OF D YNAMIC E LASTOMERIC F ABRIC O RTHOSES IN CMT​ Sarah Brown ​ Paediatric Neuromuscular Physiotherapist ​ Royal.
Introduction Ms. Binns.  Distinguish between qualitative and quantitative data  Explain strengths and limitations of a qualitative approach to research.
Evaluation of Social Prescribing in City and Hackney Dr Marcello Bertotti (Senior Research Fellow), Caroline Frostick (Research Fellow) Institute for Health.
upper limb after stroke: a consensus development study
Results Background Objectives Methods Conclusions
Growing Well, Low Sizergh Farm, Low Sizergh, Kendal, Cumbria, LA8 8AE         
DATA COLLECTION METHODS IN NURSING RESEARCH
Factors facilitating academic success: a student perspective
This is a presentation template which can be used and adapted to communicate key introductory messages and stimulate discussion about the personalisation.
Eimear C. Morrissey1, Liam G. Glynn2, Monica Casey2, Jane C
Researching Recovery – User Involvement in Data Analysis
NHS Education for Scotland Effective Practitioner Funded Project Implementing Caseload Supervision in a Nurse-Led Community Service.
The impact of transition to adulthood on health and wellbeing in young people with learning disabilities: a qualitative study Ms Genevieve Young-Southward1,
National Service Framework (NSF) for Older People & Dignity in Care
Barriers to implementing COPD guidelines for non-medical prescribers: a qualitative interview study Alison Paterson1, Anne Kinnear1, Marion Bennie2, Moira.
The Lived Experience of MS related impaired sensation in the feet.
Paediatric Disability Information & Advice Services in Rural Malawi
Nicola Braid ECCF Cohort 2014
Qualitative and Quantitative Data
INNOVATIVE, INTERPROFESSIONAL SIMULATION
National 5 PE Command Words.
Chartered Society of Physiotherapy
Foster Carer Retention Project Michelle Galbraith Project Manager
NHS Education for Scotland Effective Practitioner Funded Project Implementing Caseload Supervision in a Nurse-Led Community Service.
Focus Group Methodology
STAND- Support Through Art and Networking in Diabetes A psychotherapeutic group for adolescent patients and their parents Helen O’Byrne 14th June 2019.
Dr Amanda Miller, Dr Joan Livesley and Dr Angela Darvill
Presentation transcript:

Patient and carers’ experiences of Ankle Foot Orthosis (AFO) and Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) for the correction of dropped foot after stroke. 1 Katie Wilkie; 1 Jane Shiels; 2 Lisa Salisbury; 3 Cathy Bulley; 2 Dr Stephen Smith; 1 Caroline McGuire 1Physiotherapy Department, Astley Ainslie Hospital, Edinburgh; 2 Edinburgh University, Edinburgh; 3 Physiotherapy Subject Area, Queen Margaret University, Edinburgh. Background Approximately 20% of stroke patients present with dropped foot. The present conventional treatment for the correction of dropped foot is an Ankle Foot Orthosis. An alternative strategy to correct or minimize dropped foot is Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES). FES uses electrical stimulation to elicit functional movement in muscles paralysed due to central nervous system lesions e.g. lifting the dropped foot during walking. Following an initial service audit and review of an FES pilot clinic, a funding proposal was submitted to Lothian Health for the provision of a permanent FES service. The data submitted with this proposal was quantitative in nature. Recognising the value and importance of service users feedback, anecdotal comments had additionally been gathered. Aim To further explore service users views in a more scientific manner, a qualitative project was undertaken. The aim of this project was to gain insight into patient and carer perceptions of the clinic and FES. This project provided a wealth of rich data on patients’ and carers’ experiences, not only of FES and the clinic, but also on the use of AFO in stroke. Methods and Analysis A qualitative study was undertaken using semi-structured interviews on 10 carers and 13 patients. Participants were identified from the Lothian FES service using purposive sampling. Interviews were carried out by independent researcher. Participant verification and cross checking of themes was used to ensure rigour. Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis was used as a framework for thematic analysis of the transcripts.. Results A number of positive and negative themes were identified in relation to each treatment modality by both patients and carers. In general, several disadvantages were expressed in relation to AFO. This included discomfort, restricted movement and poorer quality of experience. Some participants did report greater faith in the reliability of the AFO. (See patient and carer quotes) The convenience and efficacy of FES led to increased function and quality of life for many of the patients and carers namely in relation to participation, stamina, confidence, independence and mood. Some specific drawbacks were highlighted in relation to FES, including equipment failure, set up issues and skin irritation. (See patient and carer quotes) Conclusions and Implications  Patients and carers identified benefits in the application of both modalities for the correction of dropped foot following stroke. Overall they felt that FES improved function and quality of life beyond that achieved when using an AFO.  These robust results enhance the evidence base for the use of FES in stroke and have informed the strategic development of an optimum FES service in Lothian. FES Experiences - Patient and Carer QuotesAFO Experiences - Patient and Carer Quotes Quality of Life “I just used to sit and look through the window, smoke, watch telly. And when I got this [FES] it made a hell of a difference, I could walk.” (Patient) “But the foot stimulator yes it has given him an awful lot of confidence and independence. That’s the best thing that ever happened.” (Carer) Efficacy and Function “Well it was 100% improvement compared with the splint.” (Carer) “The difference between using FES and not using it is something like probably 15 or 20% improvements to the walking.” (Patient) Negatives “I wear the splint because I’m safer with that …. that’s why I use it on holiday. It’s to try and retain your independence and the FES with the best will in the world doesn’t give you that amount of confidence because it can break down.” (Patient) “But the one thing that I did find after using the pads I had terrible rashes and the skin started to break out.” (Patient) Reliability “I think whether mechanically it did any good in terms of improving the strength in my ankle. It gave me a significant increase in my confidence in my ankle which is, well to me even more valuable.” (Patient) Discomfort and Restriction of Movement “With a splint on your foot’s always at the same angle….. which gets very uncomfortable.” (Patient) “ It stopped the movement, any movement in the ankle. It restricted a lot of movement which that [FES] doesn’t do.” (Carer) Poorer Quality of Experience “He had two different sized shoes because the splint took up a lot of space in the shoe, so they had to make special shoes so that he could wear the splint.” (Carer) “So I think I lasted three days with all these splints and I said to the physiotherapist, this is’nae for me….. they were a symbol of being disabled.” (Patient)