Revenue and cost recognition Filmed Entertainment Revenue and cost recognition
Agenda Revenue recognition Ultimate revenues Cost amortization Participations and residual expense Other expenses Impaired films and TV shows Development cost write downs Tax incentives/credits
Recap – Life cycle of a film or TV show
Current release windows of a film Licensing and Merchandising Free TV (network & syndicated) Pay TV PPV/VOD Home Entertainment (DVD, Blu-ray) Digital Media Theatrical 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 27 30 33 36 (months)
TV show markets Network Digital Media Cable Home entertainment Syndicated TV New media
Revenue recognition
Revenue recognition Guidance: ASC 926 (SOP 00-2) and ASC 605 (SAB 104, FAS 48) Five revenue recognition criteria, as defined in ASC 926: Persuasive evidence of sale or licensing agreement with customer Film or TV show completed and available for delivery (not necessarily physical delivery) License period has begun and customer can begin exploitation, exhibition or sale Fee is fixed or determinable Collection of fee reasonably assured If an entity does not meet any one of the preceding conditions, the entity should defer recognizing revenue until all of the conditions are met
Revenue recognition - theatrical Revenues recognized over the exhibition period If MG or advance received before exhibition date, defer and recognize in accordance with ASC 926 Settlement rates and “film rentals” International markets
Revenue recognition – home entertainment Revenue not recognized until “street date” All criteria of ASC 926 must be met Shipping considerations (FOB shipping point / destination) Reserves (contra-revenue) must be recorded and inventory must be adjusted
Revenue – home entertainment – reserves Returns reserves (must have ability to estimate) New release Catalog Inventory adjustment component Price protection Slotting fees Charge backs Co-op advertising
Revenue recognition – PPV / VOD All criteria of ASC 926 must be met Recognized as subscribers access (buy) film from cable / satellite company May require reporting from provider for revenue recognition (estimable license fee)
Revenue recognition – Pay TV All criteria of ASC 926 must be met Recognized as film becomes available Output deals – contain terms, including revenue (generally based on box office) Allocation of license fee – multiple windows
Revenue recognition – Free TV All criteria of ASC 926 must be met Generally recognized when film is available to the network Terms included in agreement – output or “one off” May require allocation to multiple windows
Revenue recognition – Licensing & merchandising All criteria of ASC 926 must be met Usually subject to advances and/or MGs MG generally recognized when film is available in the theatrical market Overages/royalties based on statements from licensee Cash vs. accrual basis
Revenue recognition – TV shows Same criteria as for films License fee on a per-episode basis Revenue generally recognized as each episode is delivered License fees paid over more than one year must be discounted
Revenue recognition – other considerations Cross collateralization If cannot allocate, recognized on an “earn out” basis
Ultimate revenues
Ultimate revenues - Film Markets include revenues from: Theatrical (U.S. and Non-U.S.) PPV / VOD SVOD Home entertainment Pay TV Free TV (network & syndication) Includes revenue estimates up to 10 yrs from initial theatrical release Should not include revenues from unproven territories or markets Discounting not allowed except in certain situations
Ultimate revenues – Episodic TV Markets include revenues from: TV license fees Home entertainment SVOD Includes revenue estimates up to the later of: 10 yrs from date of delivery of first episode or, If still in production, 5 yrs from date of delivery of most recent episode Include estimates of secondary market sales only if company can demonstrate history of success
Cost amortization
Cost amortization basics Individual film forecast (IFF) method, as stipulated in ASC 926 (SOP 00-2) Cost amortization is based on estimated gross margin for the life of the film Estimated gross margin may change throughout life, which may affect cost amortization in period change occurs
Amortization calculation Year 1 Year 2 Yr. 1 revenues Ultimate revenues Ultimate costs Costs to amortize Ult costs to go Yr. 2 revenues Ult revs to go Costs to amortize
Amortization calc – Example – Yr 1 Yr. 1 Ultimate Revenues (total) $ 60 Ultimate Costs (total) 40 Ultimate Gross margin 20 Actual Revenues: 20 Yr. 1 revenues Ultimate revenues Ultimate costs Costs to amortize 20 60 40 13
Recording amortization – Year 1 Cost of revenues (Amortization expense) $13 Capitalized film costs (Accumulated amort) $13 Record Year 1 amortization expense
Amortization calc – Example – Yr 2 Yr 1 Yr 2 (to go) Ultimate Revenues (total) $ 60 $ 40 Ultimate Costs (total) 40 27 Ultimate Gross margin 20 13 Actual Revenues: 20 15 Actual Costs Amortized: 13 ? Ult costs to go Yr. 2 revenues Ult revs to go Costs to amortize 15 40 27 10
Recording amortization – Year 2 Cost of revenues (Amortization expense) $10 Capitalized film costs (Accumulated amort) $10 Record Year 2 amortization expense
Amortization calc – Example – Yr 2 (revised ultimate) Yr. 1 Ult Yr. 2 Ult Yr. 2 (to go) (revised) (revised) Ultimate Revenues 60 55 35 Ultimate Costs 40 40 27 Ultimate Gr. margin 20 15 8 Actual revenues: 20 15 Actual costs amortized 13 ? Ult costs to go Yr. 2 revenues Ult revs to go Costs to amortize 15 35 27 12
Recording amortization – Year 2 (revised ultimate) Cost of revenues (Amortization expense) $12 Capitalized film costs (Accumulated amort) $12 Record Year 2 amortization expense – revised ultimate
Case Study part 2
Participations
Participations – overview Contingent compensation for creative talent (actors, writers, directors, producers) Expensed using IFF method (based on ultimates) Amounts paid, if any, are based on contractually agreed-upon formulas and cash received (not revenue recognized) Formulas vary depending on star power of talent (gross deal vs net deal)
Participations – overview Agreements typically include: Revenues to be included (music, merch, etc) Percentages to be used (2.5% of net profits) Producer’s recoupment of direct and indirect production costs Producer’s recoupment of exploitation costs Reporting periods and payment terms Audit rights
Participations – common terms Gross receipts Distribution fees Production costs and production interest P&A, marketing and distribution costs (exploitation costs) Adjusted gross receipts Net receipts Break even (first, second, rolling) Bonuses and deferments
Sample participation calculation
Participation calculation example
Participations – Example – Yr 1 Yr. 1 Ultimate Revenues (total) $ 567,500 Ultimate Participation Costs 30,200 Actual Revenues: 362,000 Yr. 1 revenues Ultimate revenues Costs to amortize Ultimate costs 362 567.5 30.2 19.3
Recording participations Costs of revenues (Participation exp) $19.3 Accrued participations $19.3 Record Year 1 participation expense and related liability
Residuals
Residuals – Overview Additional compensation for “ancillary” markets (DVD, pay TV, cable, network TV, etc) Residuals based on percentage of gross revenues received by a distributor from ancillary markets Residuals for TV shows based on original salary paid during the production and are not paid on the initial airing of the show (only on “re-runs”) Union or “guild” specific Payments made to individuals or to the guilds on behalf of members
Residuals – Overview Guilds in TV and film: Screen Actors Guild (SAG*) – represents motion picture actors American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (AFTRA*) – represents television actors and radio personalities Directors Guild of America (DGA) – represents directors Writers Guild of America (WGA) – represents writers American Federation of Musicians (AFM) – represents musicians International Alliance of Theater and Stage Employees (IATSE) – represents production crew and administrative staff * SAG and AFTRA recently merged
Residual rates – Motion pictures
Residual rates – TV shows
Residuals – Overview Pro-ration for filming outside the U.S. Some states are “right-to-work” states (non-union) SAG/AFTRA applies no matter where actor works Range from 12.5% - 20% of revenues generated in ancillary markets Fringe benefits (payroll tax, pension, health & welfare benefits) can add another 25% surcharge to residual payments
Residuals – Guild audits Guilds conduct periodic audits of film and TV producers Specialized firms do most audits Industry-wide litigation regarding various practices employed by film producers when calculating residuals Percentage of home entertainment revenues subject to residual payments Allocation of minimum guarantees
Residuals calculation
Residuals – Example – Yr 1 Yr. 1 Ultimate Revenues (total) $ 567,500 Ultimate Residuals Costs 11,800 Actual Revenues: 362,000 Yr. 1 revenues Ultimate revenues Ultimate costs Costs to amortize 362 567.5 11.8 7.5
Recording residuals Costs of revenues (Residuals expense) $ 7.5 Accrued residuals $ 7.5 Record Year 1 residuals expense and related liability
Other expenses
Other expenses DVD inventory Manufacturing costs Obsolescence reserves (don’t forget about units added back as part of returns reserve calculation) Prints – capitalize and amortize vs. expense Advertising – ASC 720-35 (SOP 93-7) Expense as incurred or Upon first airing
Ultimate costs
Ultimate costs – Film and episodic TV Estimated total costs directly associated with generation of ultimate revenues Production (or acquisition) costs Negative costs Capitalized overhead Capitalized interest Participations and residuals Other considerations
Tax incentives and Credits
Tax incentives and credits Offered by various cities, states and countries to entice filming in their locale Treated as a reduction to film costs Timing of recording
Impaired films and TV Shows
Impaired film / TV show costs Pre-release write down Impairment after release of film Certain events or changes in circumstances may indicate company should assess whether product is impaired (fair value less than unamortized film costs): Film performance Costs in excess of budget Delays in completion or release schedules Insufficient funding or resources to complete film and market it effectively
Impaired film / TV show costs If there is indication product is impaired, must determine fair value of film and write off amount by which unamortized capitalized costs exceed fair value If film already released, calculate and record IFF amortization first, then calculate impairment Discounted cash flow analysis
Development cost write downs
Development cost write downs Presumption that if a film has not been set for production within 3 years of first capitalized cost, it will be disposed of Write off required (assumes fair value of $0) What about films with a longer production period (e.g. CG animation)?
Case Study Part 3