Explore the key ideas of the cosmological argument. (8 marks)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Cosmological Argument
Advertisements

Cosmological Argument What is it?. Cosmological Argument The simple starting point is that we know the universe exists (a posteriori) The simple starting.
“… if (the best philosophy) doesn ’ t seem peculiar you haven ’ t understood it ” Edward Craig.
Taylor - argument for God from contingency & necessity ~ slide 1 Richard Taylor’s argument for God from contingency & necessity 1. Basic datum - the very.
The Cosmological Argument
The Cosmological Argument. Aquinas’s Cosmological Argument Cosmological Argument is ‘a posteriori’ Attempts to prove the existence of God There are three.
The Cosmological Argument St. Thomas Aquinas ( AD) Italian priest, philosopher.
The Cosmological Argument. Also known as ‘The First Cause Argument’ Unlike the Ontological Argument, it derives the conclusion from a posteriori premise.
The Cosmological Argument The idea that there is a first cause behind the existence of the universe.
The Cosmological argument
Cosmological arguments from causation Michael Lacewing
The Cosmological Argument.
 The cosmological argument is, as it’s name sugessts (from the greek cosmos, meaning ‘universe’ or ‘world’). An a posteriori argument for the existence.
The Cosmological Argument. This is an a posteriori argument There are many versions of it It is based on observation and understanding of the universe.
The Cosmological and Teleological Arguments for God.
History of Philosophy Lecture 12 Thomas Aquinas
Fredrick Copleston, a professor of history and philosophy, was a supporter of the Cosmological argument and reformulated the argument with particular focus.
The Cosmological Argument (Causation or ‘first cause’ theory)
The Cosmological Argument ► Aquinas presents the argument in three “ways” but the argument is a single one. ► First – All things are moved by something.
1225 – 1274 (Aquinas notes created by Kevin Vallier) Dominican monk, born to Italian nobility. Worked ~150 years after Anselm. Student of Albert the Great.
Aquinas’ Proofs The five ways.
PROVING THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
1.Everything which begins to exist has a cause. 2.The Universe exists so it must have a cause. 3.You cannot have infinite regress (i.e. An infinite number.
The Cosmological Argument for God’s Existence or how come we all exist? Is there a rational basis for belief in God?
Anselm’s “1st” ontological argument Something than which nothing greater can be thought of cannot exist only as an idea in the mind because, in addition.
Cosmological Argument The Basics. Science can offer us explanations of things that are within the universe, but does the universe as a whole have an explanation?
The Cosmological Argument Science can offer us explanations of things that are within the universe, but does the universe as a whole have an explanation?
St. Thomas AquinasSt. Thomas Aquinas  CE  Naples, Italy  Benedictine then Dominican monk  Primary Works:  Summa contra Gentiles  Summa.
The Cosmological argument attempts to infer the existence of God from the existence of the cosmos (universe) or from the phenomena within it. The claim.
Taylor - argument for God from contingency & necessity ~ slide 1 Richard Taylor’s argument for God from contingency & necessity 1. Begins with story of.
Chapter 1: The cosmological argument AQA Religious Studies: Philosophy of Religion AS Level © Nelson Thornes Ltd 2008 Revision.
Thomas Aquinas and the Existence of God * The Five Ways (or Proofs) of St. Thomas Aquinas. * We can come to know God through reason. * Consistent with.
Lesson Objective: Lesson Outcomes: Lesson Objective: Lesson Outcomes: Mr M Banner 2016 Grade 12 th May 2016 Starter: What does Cosmology mean to you? Title:
Lesson Aim To recall and explore other forms of the Cosmological Argument.
Aquinas’ Proofs The five ways. Thomas Aquinas ( ) Joined Dominican order against the wishes of his family; led peripatetic existence thereafter.
Introduction to Philosophy
The Cosmological Argument
The Cosmological Argument for God’s Existence
Starter: Mix-Pair-Share
Cosmological arguments from contingency
Arguments based on observation Arguments based on reason
c) Strengths and weaknesses of Cosmological Arguments:
Cosmological Argument
Cosmological Argument
The Cosmological Argument
The Cosmological Argument
THE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT.
Explore the use of inductive reasoning in the cosmological argument
Is Religion Reasonable?
Explore key ideas in the ontological argument. (8 marks)
THE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT.
Aquinas’ three ways Learning Objective
The Cosmological argument
Explore the use of a’priori reasoning in the ontological argument
1 A The Cosmological Argument Kalam Argument
The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument
The Cosmological Argument
The Origin Of The Universe The Cosmological Argument
Or Can you?.
Or Can you?.
INTRODUCTION Page 20 This extract is the transcript of a radio debate between Frederick Copleston (a theist) and Bertrand Russell (an agnostic). Bertrand.
THE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT.
Clarify and explain the key ideas. A’priori Deductive
Philosophy of Religion Arguments for the existence of God
Science can offer us explanations of things that are within the universe, but does the universe as a whole have an explanation? Think, pair, share.
Assess the weaknesses of the cosmological argument. (12 marks)
Assess the strengths of the cosmological argument. (12 marks)
Responses to Aquinas Peter Vardy sees Aquinas’s third way (from contingency and necessity) as the most important. The world is made of contingent things.
Strengths and Weaknesses of Cosmological Argument
‘Assess the credibility of the cosmological argument’ (12 marks)
Presentation transcript:

Explore the key ideas of the cosmological argument. (8 marks) A’posteriori The key crux Family of arguments Motion – everything moved by something else Need for first mover Cause – everything caused by something else Need for a first cause Stretch and Challenge Swinburne and cause Contingent beings cannot come from nothing Need for a necessary being If we can prove God created the universe, we can prove that God exists.

Explore the key ideas of the Cosmological Argument. 8 marks The Cosmological Argument is an a’posteriori argument meaning that it is based on empirical experience and observation. The key crux of the argument is that existence of the universe stands in need of explanation, and the only adequate explanation of its existence is that it was created by God. The cosmological argument is a type or family of arguments rather than a single one, but all the variants are based on the seemingly unobjectionable observation that everything that exists is caused by something else. A significant contributor to the argument was Aquinas and his first ‘Three Ways’ of demonstrating the existence of God form part of the argument. Aquinas’ first ‘Way’ was motion, he observed that everything in the universe is in motion and that something can only be in motion if it is first moved by something else that is already moving. Aquinas then took this further and concluded that to avoid an infinite regress, there must be a ‘first mover’, something that does not require to be moved by something else, and he believed this to be God. His second ‘Way’ was cause, he observed that everything that exists has a cause, nothing can be its own cause and therefore must be caused by something else. Again, he developed this further and concluded that to avoid an infinite regress, there must be a first cause, something uncaused by something else and Aquinas believed this to be God Stretch and challenge - This idea of cause was later further developed by Swinburne who distinguished between different types of cause: inanimate and intentional. Intentional causation is personal and motivated by belief and purpose-this thinking helps theists understand the world in relation to humans. Swinburne believed that God created the world for a purpose and the purpose was to sustain human life. Aquinas’ third ‘Way’ was contingency and necessity. Aquinas observed that everything in the universe is contingent and that contingent beings cannot come from nothing. This led him to conclude that there must be something outside of it all, a necessary being that does not rely on anything else for its existence, that starts the whole thing off and he argued that this was God. Aquinas’ Three Ways aim to show if we can prove that God created the universe then we can prove that he does in fact exist.