Community participation and vertebrate pest control Alison Greenaway and Bruce Warburton Landcare Research.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Leveraging inter-sectoral action to address the social determinants of health: view from the health system Lucy Gilson University of Cape Town; London.

Advertisements

OECD World Forum Statistics, Knowledge and Policy, Palermo, November

WCDR Thematic Panel Governance: Institutional and Policy Frameworks for Risk Reduction Annotated Outline UNDP – UNV – ProVention Consortium – UN-Habitat.

Toward a Vision for a National System of Natural and Environmental Resource Indicators.

Health impact assessment explained

Accountable governance Danielle Morley Freshwater Action Network.

Intervention planning Using strategies and tactics.

Maria do Rosário Partidário, SEA for strategic assessment SEA for strategic assessment - the critical factors approach Maria do Rosário Partidário IST-

ICT Work Programme NCP Infoday 23 June Maria Geronymaki DG INFSO.H.2 ICT for Government & Public Services Objective.

(The Global Programme of Research On Climate Change Vulnerability, Impacts and Adaptation) Adaptation Knowledge Day V: Climate Change Adaptation Gaps BONN,

Lorelei L. Hanson Gloria A. Filax Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences ALBERTA CLIMATE DIALOGUE (ABCD) PROJECT - CONNECTING TO ARBRI.

Assessing Progress For Sustainable Development

Gender Training Workshop

Raising Your Voice for Children: An Advocacy Training Davida McDonald Director, State Policy NAEYC.

Control of Small Mammal Pests Bruce Warburton, Graham Nugent, Phil Cowan, Penny Fisher.

Towards a Human Dimensions Research Agenda for Parks and Protected Areas R.J. Payne & Norm McIntyre School of Outdoor Recreation, Parks & Tourism Lakehead.

Welcome to The Expert Community Forum 19 November 2007.

Vanessa Liston (TCD) Clodagh Harris (UCC) Mark O’Toole (Kilkenny County Council)

Science & Technology Department University of Peloponnese Socrates Comenius 1 School partnerships Selection 2005 Bari October 2005 Project Activities.

Developing Capacity on Water Integrity WATER INTEGRITY NETWORK Delft 31st May 2013 Francoise Nicole Ndoume Regional Coordinator Water Integrity Network,

Control of Small Mammal Pests and Strategic Technologies for Multi-Species Pest Control.

Ihia.org.uk Health impact assessment: appraising potential consequences of policies and interventions Alex Scott-Samuel IMPACT International Health Impact.

Driver and Levers of Change A Local Government Perspective George Tarvit Sustainable Scotland Network.

Pathways through Participation: investing in research leading to action Véronique Jochum (NCVO) Diane Warburton (Involve) 7 December 2010, SRA annual conference.

Strengthening the quality of research for policy engagement in the African context – achievements and aspirations Tebogo B. Seleka Botswana Institute for.

Techniques in Civic Engagement Presented by Bill Rizzo Local Government Specialist UW-Extension Local Government Center

Collaborative sustainability assessment for significant land use planning and development undertakings Dr Caroline Raphael Bachelor of Science (Honours)

Local Government Programming In-service October 22 & 23, 2014 Deliberative Governance: Civil Discourse and Public Engagement Presented by Bill Rizzo Professor.

GUIDELINES “TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE URBAN DEVELOPMENT” Nairobi, January, 2005.

Environmental and technology ethics Uncertainty, risk and precaution.

Housing Issues for the MAA Carole Hudson – St Helens MBC Cath Green – Liverpool City Council 8 Liverpool City Region MAA:

Citizens’ contributions to the public agenda on animal cloning: project manager Ida-Elisabeth Andersen Structure of the presentation: 1.What is the Danish.

Canada/US Experiences in Public Involvement Learning from our Neighbours C2D2 Presentation Miriam Wyman and Sandra Zagon Collaboration Practitioners Network.

Between Potential and Reality: negotiating participatory visual processes towards community emergence Jacqueline Shaw, Graham Jeffery and Kerrie Schaefer.

Adaptation knowledge needs and response under the UNFCCC process Adaptation Knowledge Day V Session 1: Knowledge Gaps Bonn, Germany 09 June 2014 Rojina.

Klik om het opmaakprofiel van de modelondertitel te bewerken First Project Steering Group Meeting 4-6 April, Bucharest,2011 Dr. Haroon Saad Director LUDEN(QeC-ERAN)

Improving care for people with intellectual disabilities across the life span The ACI Intellectual Disability Network: Maxine Andersson Agency for Clinical.

Professor Philip Lowe Newcastle University Director of UK Research Councils’ Rural Economy and Land Use Programme Researching Environment - Society Relations.

Governance for Sustainable Development: As if it Mattered? Dr. Ann Dale, Trudeau Fellow Canada Research Chair in Sustainable Community Development Royal.

Stakeholder analysis for project design Ingvild Oia, Programme Specialist,UNDP Photo by: Konomiho/flickr.

Support the spread of “good practice” in generating, managing, analysing and communicating spatial information Introduction to PGIS Practice By: Giacomo.

Managed by AEA Technology plc and funded by DIUS 1.

The Relu Programme and Animal and Plant Disease Management.

Introducing the Administrative Data Research Network Tanvi Desai.

Information Systems for Water, Land & Ecosystems Towards evidence-based decision making for sustainable agricultural intensification Ecosystem Health –

Fuelling Social Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Higher Education.

Prioritising Weeds for Biocontrol ( ) Translating Weeds Research into Action on the Ground ( )

Citizen participation in public policy making Novum Forum Perspectives of Active Citizenship Ivo Hartman November 2009.

John England Deputy Director Social Services, Leeds City Council Barcelona 2 – 3 February 2006 Hearing on Immigration and Integration: Co-operation between.

1 Civic Engagement through Public Deliberation Renée A. Daugherty Oklahoma Partnership for Public Deliberation.

Measuring Community Benefits ‘ What we measure is literally a sign of what we value as a society’ (Audit Commission, 2001) Emma Kyng/ Will Swan.

Introduction to the training course Economic Analysis of Invasive Species.

Health Impact Assessment HIA Forum 28 th October 2008 Teresa Lavin Public Health Development Officer

12 June 2015 Commission’s Invasive Alien Species Working Group.

Participatory Framework Knowledge, skills and dispositions to create and sustain change are distributed across groups, settings and levels of the system.

Are multiple-capture traps always better than single-capture ones? Bruce Warburton and Andrew Gormley Landcare Research.

Marco Martuzzi World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe Health Impact Assessment as part of SEA.

Artec new media literacy Frank Boyd arts technology centre BBC future development

Group A: Impacts on Organisms, Communities and Landscapes Q5: How This Topic can Potentially Connect With Other Topics in Chapter Outline Chapter 3: Impacts.

The Deliberative Democracy Consortium The big picture: Two impacts of the Internet 1.Empowering individual citizens (web, – wrapped up in other.

Implementation Science: Finding Common Ground and Perspectives Laura Reichenbach, Evidence Project, Population Council International Conference on Family.

Using Twitter to Share What Keeps You Well: Virtual Asset Mapping Nancy Greig and Lesley Roome, Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland ( the ALLIANCE)

What is Public Deliberation? Deliberation is an approach to politics in which citizens, not just experts or politicians, are deeply involved in public.

Citizen Participation and Sustainable Development Graham Smith School of Social Sciences University of Southampton.

13 th May 2008 Michael Jackson Research Senior Specialist, NERIP

The Value of HIA for EH Professionals

1st Regional Consultation in Trieste (IT) March 2014

Maximizing the value and the impact of health research in Europe

RCA Workshop on RCARO Future Strategies July 2007

Presentation transcript:

Community participation and vertebrate pest control Alison Greenaway and Bruce Warburton Landcare Research

MSI Strategic Technologies for MSPC Programme Objectives Obj 1: Reducing the costs of aerial and ground- based control Obj 2: Reducing the adverse impacts of aerial and ground-based control (welfare, residues, non-targets) Obj 3: Reducing community opposition to pest programmes (increasing community participation in pest programmes)

Objective 3 Community participation in pest programmes improved Key Questions: Can the mismatch between public concerns and current scientific consensus over methods used for possum control be effectively addressed through improved community dialogue? (Alison Greenaway, Bob Frame, Helen Fitt, Bruce Warburton, Phil Cowan), Can ecological games (model visualisation) provide an effective medium for informing community participants of the economic and ecological consequences of their choices? (Pen Holland) Partners & collaborators Clare Veltman, Harry Broad, Michelle Crowell (DOC) John Deal, Nick Hancox (AHB)

Science and the public Why do people have different views of the same problem? Why do we do science? Graham Nugent

Issue Complexity 1080, or aerial application, or all toxins Deer hunters: animal welfare, non-target species Fur harvesters: absence of possums but blame 1080 Chemophobes, water, air, soil

Ecological Complexity Control strategies – thresholds Individual vs population effects

Behaviour complexity Skeptics:If you provide facts to counter their position they will often change Denialists: Facts dont change their beliefs

Denialists 1.Allege there is a conspiracy. 2.Use fake experts to support your story. 3.Cherry-pick the evidence. 4.Carry on trotting out supportive evidence even after it has been discredited. 5.Create impossible standards for your opponents. Existing evidence is not good enough and demand more. 6.If your opponent comes up with evidence you have demanded, move the goalposts.

Consultation

Appreciative Inquiry Change Lab using the U-Process Charette Citizens' Juries Consensus Conference Deliberative Method Future Search Graphic Facilitation Open Agenda Conferences Open House Open Space Technology Participatory Appraisal Roadshows Sustained Dialogue World Cafe A central government perspective

How do we start? Two case studies: Trace changes in comprehension/opposition and levels of discourse around planning Create visibility of project through social media WherePossible places? WhoPossible communities? WhatDecision(s) to get involved with? HowTechniques to use?

Possible Places Waipoua: Little 1080 use but by-kill a concern Wanganui: Possum fur/employment/anti Karamea/Kumara: Strong anti-1080 lobby Coromandel: Strong anti-1080 lobby

Possible community What is a community ? Scale? Participants?

Possible constraints Decision makers have accountabilities: Legal Budgetary Methodological Time

Media to Connect Social media tools: Facebook Online deliberation space Online discussion space (Forums) Computer gaming (Pen Holland) Wekapedia of information ?????

Issues 1.How far could/would agencies move in sharing decision making? 2.What are the agency-specific pathways of decision making and their risk profiles? 3.What is the cost/benefit of participation versus not doing it? 4.How will results be linked with policy/practices