Performance Measurement and Rural Primary Care: A scoping review

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Copyright © Healthcare Quality Quest, Proposed standards for a national clinical audit — How we got involved and what we have learned.
Advertisements

Appraisal of Literature. Task 4 The task requires that you:  Obtain a piece of literature from a journal, book or internet source. The literature should.
Authors and affiliation Research, University of Sheffield, 3 East Midlands Ambulance Service Study flow Conclusion In addition to measures relating to.
The material was supported by an educational grant from Ferring How to Write a Scientific Article Nikolaos P. Polyzos M.D. PhD.
1 Teaching Cultural Competency: A Review of the Literature Sunita Mutha MD 1,2, Carol Allen MA 1, Cynthia Salinas MD 3, Arnab Mukherjea MPH 4 1 The Network.
Accessing Sources Of Evidence For Practice Introduction To Databases Karen Smith Department of Health Sciences University of York.
Background Information : Projected prevalence of arthritis is expected to increase from 2.9 million to 6.5 million Canadians, a rise of 124% (Badley.
O Type 2 diabetes has traditionally been managed as a single chronic disease state but it can commonly exist with co-morbidities such as depression. o.
The PAN-Care Project Development and testing of a comprehensive care planning service to enable patients with end stage pancreatic cancer die at home Department.
Effects of Pediatric Asthma Education on Hospitalizations and Emergency Department Visits: A Meta-Analysis June 3, 2007 Janet M. Coffman, PhD, Michael.
General Presentation Guidelines The object is to interest and inform, not to entertain. Time: Too hurried a pace will not allow your audience to digest.
Systematic Reviews.
Background Information Audience Response Systems (ARS) are a technology used in classrooms that consist of an input device controlled by the learner, a.
How to write a scientific article Nikolaos P. Polyzos M.D. PhD.
Review Characteristics This review protocol was prospectively registered with BEME (see flow diagram). Total number of participants involved in the included.
Drug & Poison Control center
How to Read a Journal Article. Basics Always question: – Does this apply to my clinical practice? – Will this change how I treat patients? – How could.
Paper Writing and Abstract Writing Prof. Peih-ying Lu School of Medicine Kaohsiung Medical University.
Depression Screening in Primary Care and Impact on Suicide Prevention Anne-Marie T. Mann, BSN, RN, DNP Candidate Diane Kay Boyle, PhD, RN, FAAN.
Effects of Alcohol on U.S. Adolescent Sleep Patterns: A Systematic Review Nancy Carballo, MSIV Shahrzad Bazargan-Hejazi, PhD 2015 DIDARP 10 th Annual Drug.
LITERATURE REVIEW OF DECISION MODELS FOR DISEASES WITH SHORT-TERM FLUCTUATIONS/EPISODES: The Case of COPD Dr. Orpah Nasimiyu Wavomba
RTI International is a trade name of Research Triangle Institute The Costs of SBI: Findings from the literature Presented by Jeremy Bray, Gary.
A1 & A2 The aim: (separate) Critique a Qualitative study on “Telemonitoring of blood glucose and blood pressure in type 2 diabetes.” Critique a Quantitative.
Contact: Patrick Phillips,
Data Mining for Expertise: Using Scopus to Create Lists of Experts for U.S. Department of Education Discretionary Grant Programs Good afternoon, my name.
Patient Medical Home Attribute: Commitment
Martin-Misener, R. , Wong, S. , Johnston, S. , Burge, F. , Scott, C
Discussion & Conclusion
Effects of Case Management on Frequent
The Effects of Physical Exercise on the Executive Functions of Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: An Integrative Review of Literature.
A Systematic Review of Discourse’s Outcomes
Works in progress The needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans* people (LGBT) who are affected by dementia: A comprehensive scoping review. Joanna Semlyen,
Do Adoptees Have Lower Self Esteem?
The Essentia Institute of Rural Health (EIRH) is
Patient Centered Medical Home
Patient Registries and Health Outcomes in Diabetes: A Retrospective Study Nipa Shah, MD1; Fern Webb, PhD1; Liane Hannah, BSH1; Carmen Smotherman, MS2;
Interprofessional Online Learning for Primary Health Care:
45 Nursing: A Concept-Based Approach to Learning
iHEA Boston 2017 Congress, Boston Massachusetts, USA 8-11 July 2017
Jessica A. Lanerie, MD1 and Teresa K. Duryea, MD2
Supplementary Table 1. PRISMA checklist
Recommendations for Schools
Distraction Techniques during pediatric medical procedures
EPAs as a Tool for Resident Evaluation
An Evidence Based Project : Title of Your Project Goes Here
Lifestyle factors in the development of diabetes among African immigrants in the UK: A systematic review Alloh T. Folashade Faculty of Health and Social.
Primary health care performance measurement initiatives across three Canadian provinces Martin-Misener, R., Johnston, S., Burge, F., Blackman, S., Scott,
VSAC and Quality Measures
Conceptual Framework: Roy’s Adaptation Model
Health Strategies Group
The efficacy of using CAD for detection of
Systematic Approaches to Literature Reviewing
PubMed Review.
Dr. Glen E. Randall Dr. Michelle Howard McMaster University
Is performing a scoping review useful after recent Cochrane review?
Denmark Leads the Way In IT and Patient-Centered Primary Care 2006: An Example of High Performance Highest public satisfaction with health system among.
Therapeutic writing for eating disorders: A systematic review
What existing research and data can tell us
IMPACT OF PHARMACIST DELIVERED CARE IN THE COMMUNITY PHARMACY SETTING
Example of Information Extracted from an Article
Google Scholar: 8,554 publications Systematic search:
Use of real-time videoconferencing to deliver physiotherapy services:
Implementation of a Quality Practice Model in the Emergency Department
Surgical re-excision versus observation for histologically dysplastic nevi: a systematic review of associated clinical outcomes K.T. Vuong1, J. Walker2,
Nursing and Allied Health Database (ProQuest)
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
TRIFOLD AREA – THIS GUIDE WILL BE REMOVED BEFORE PRINTING – TRIFOLD AREA – THIS GUIDE WILL BE REMOVED BEFORE PRINTING – TRIFOLD AREA – THIS GUIDE WILL.
NHS Long Term Plan: Rapid Diagnostic Centres (RDC) The SWAG Approach
The Effects of Debriefing Following Medical Error
Presentation transcript:

Performance Measurement and Rural Primary Care: A scoping review Murphy, P., Burge, F., Wong, S.T. Contact: patrick.murphy@dal.ca. Background Efforts to improve primary care (PC) rely on measuring and reporting performance to support decision-making. Comprehensive performance measurement systems need to account for diverse stakeholder groups, including rural residents and health care providers. The purpose of this study is to establish the features of PC that should be measured and reported in a rural versus a non-rural context. Methods A literature search was conducted via: PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, grey literature (e.g. Google), and hand searching relevant journals. Inclusion criteria for articles: Compares rural with non-rural aspects of primary care Written in the English language Published between 2003 and 2017 Discusses practice characteristics, physician scope of practice or practice patterns, and/or patient patterns of health care use Pertains to one of four pillars of quality PC as defined by the CFPC’s Patient’s Medical Home model (Fig. 1): accessibility, continuity, comprehensiveness, or electronic health records. These pillars were chosen as they focused the scope of the project and emerged as key elements during the initial literature search. Exclusion criteria for articles: Inverse of inclusion criteria Focuses on specific patient populations, health concerns or health outcomes, and/or patient/physician preferences or experiences with primary care Results Twenty-six studies were identified for analysis for this scoping review (See Fig. 2). Key findings are summarized in Table 1. Access: physicians in rural communities divide their time between hospital and clinic-based practice. Comprehensiveness: increasing rurality is associated with an increase in PC providers’ scope of practice. EMR use: practice size as well as level of rurality, can predict functionality and adoption of EMR systems. Continuity: Rurality is associated with a lower reported level of continuity. Conclusions The 26 identified studies describe differences between rural and non-rural PC that should be considered in the design of performance measurement systems. Further research in this area needs to be conducted e.g. implications on other PMH pillars, patient and provider perspectives, and equivalent definitions of rurality. Acknowledgements Richard Payzant Ward Travel Fund This work is funded by: Figure 1. Patient’s Medical Home Pillars Figure 2. Flow diagram of included articles Patient Centred-Care Personal Family Physician Team-Based Care Timely-Access Comprehensive Care Continuity of Care Electronic Medical Records Education, Training and Research Evaluation and CQI Internal and External Supports Studies identified through database searching (n=7,413) Studies identified through grey literature search and hand-search of remaining studies’ references (n=5) Studies excluded based on title/abstract screening (n=7,341)  Studies assessed for eligibility (n=79) Studies excluded after full- text review (n=53) Studies included in final scoping review (n=26) 4 key pillars emerged during the initial search and were used to focus the scope Table 1. Key findings Select Aspects of PHC Considerations for Performance Measurement in a Rural Context Access There was a marked increase in the use of specialist services among urban residents and a greater likelihood of receiving care from allied health professionals, nursing, and community health centres among rural residents. A greater number of rural residents than urban described receiving care from an emergency department (ED). Most patients attending rural EDs or urgent care centres have primary care providers, but among urban patients attending an ED, this finding is reversed (i.e. urban patients in the ED are less likely to have a primary care provider). The most urban and most rural residents were the least likely to have a primary care provider. Comprehensiveness Increasing rurality is associated with an increase in primary care physicians’ scope of practice; geography is the main driver behind an individual physician’s scope of practice. EMR use Rural-urban differences in EMR use were explained away by adjusting for practice size and type, and rates of use were roughly similar. Continuity Practice factors associated with lower reported patient continuity included rural setting, a higher number of physicians in the practice, employing nurses as part of the practice staff, weekend appointments, and 24 hours or less per week of on-call services. MEASURING AND IMPROVING THE PERFORMANCE OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE IN CANADA