X-rays in the COSMOS A picture of large scale structures Nico Cappelluti Nico Cappelluti MPE-Garching MPE-Garching In collaboration with: XMM-COSMOS team:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Challenges for the Standard Cosmology Tom Shanks Durham University.
Advertisements

Low-frequency radio maps for the REXCESS cluster sample S.R. Heidenreich, University of Southampton In collaboration with J.H. Croston, University of Southampton;
The evolution of SMBH from Hard X-ray surveys Andrea Comastri (INAF – Osservatorio di Bologna – Italy) The XRB as a tracer of SMBH mass density Hard X-ray.
Clusters, Galaxies and the COSMOS J Berian James (IfA Edinburgh), John Peacock, Alexis Finoguenov, Henry Joy McCracken & Gigi Guzzo for the COSMOS collaboration.
COSMOS Kyoto meeting May 2005 Obscured AGN in the COSMOS field Andrea Comastri (INAF – Bologna) on behalf of the XMM-COSMOS team.
Extragalatic Surveys, Cambridge MA, Nov 6-8, 2006 Vincenzo Mainieri G. Hasinger, N. Cappelluti, M. Brusa, F. Civano, A. Comastri, M. Elvis, A. Finoguenov,
Swift/BAT Hard X-ray Survey Preliminary results in Markwardt et al ' energy coded color.
Probing the X-ray Universe: Analysis of faint sources with XMM-Newton G. Hasinger, X. Barcons, J. Bergeron, H. Brunner, A. C. Fabian, A. Finoguenov, H.
Weak-Lensing selected, X-ray confirmed Clusters and the AGN closest to them Dara Norman NOAO/CTIO 2006 November 6-8 Boston Collaborators: Deep Lens Survey.
Anton Koekemoer AAS 207, Washington DC, 10 January Using COSMOS to Probe the High-Redshift AGN Population Anton Koekemoer (Space Telescope Science.
Growth of Structure Measurement from a Large Cluster Survey using Chandra and XMM-Newton John R. Peterson (Purdue), J. Garrett Jernigan (SSL, Berkeley),
AGN and Quasar Clustering at z= : Results from the DEEP2 + AEGIS Surveys Alison Coil Hubble Fellow University of Arizona Chandra Science Workshop.
I. Balestra, P.T., S. Ettori, P. Rosati, S. Borgani, V. Mainieri, M. Viola, C. Norman Galaxies and Structures through Cosmic Times - Venice, March 2006.
Boston, November 2006 Extragalactic X-ray surveys Paolo Tozzi Spectral analysis of X-ray sources in the CDFS.
November, CXC Extragalactic Surveys workshop Obscured AGN in the COSMOS field: the multiwavelength challenge Marcella Brusa (MPE) Collaborators:
The spatial clustering of X-ray selected AGN R. Gilli Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF) Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna On behalf of the CDFS.
Günther Hasinger, MPE Garching & TUM Galaxies and Structures through Cosmic Times, Venice, March 30, 2006 AGN Evolution.
Dark Matter and Galaxy Formation (Section 3: Galaxy Data vs. Simulations) Joel R. Primack 2009, eprint arXiv: Presented by: Michael Solway.
X-ray Source-Galaxy Angular Cross-Correlation function in the COSMOS Field Takamitsu Miyaji, Richard E. Griffiths (Carnegie Mellon Univ.) COSMOS XMM-Newton.
High Redshift Galaxies (Ever Increasing Numbers).
Clustering of QSOs and X-ray AGN at z=1 Alison Coil Hubble Fellow University of Arizona October 2007 Collaborators: Jeff Newman, Joe Hennawi, Marc Davis,
Tahoe, Sep Calibrating Photometric Redshifts beyond Spectroscopic Limits Jeffrey Newman Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
March, Galaxies and structure through cosmic time Venice 2006 The AGN content of the COSMOS: the XMM-Newton view Marcella Brusa (MPE) on behalf.
The XMM-Newton hard band wide angle Survey Nicoletta Carangelo and Silvano Molendi (IASF-MI(CNR)) Epic Consortium Meeting Palazzo Steri, Palermo,
Masami Ouchi (Space Telescope Science Institute) for the SXDS Collaboration Cosmic Web Made of 515 Galaxies at z=5.7 Kona 2005 Ouchi et al ApJ, 620,
The spatial clustering of X-ray selected AGN at z~1 R. Gilli Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF) Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna and the XMM-COSMOS.
Environmental Properties of a Sample of Starburst Galaxies Selected from the 2dFGRS Matt Owers (UNSW) Warrick Couch (UNSW) Chris Blake (UBC) Michael Pracy.
X-ray Surveys with Space Observatory Khyung Hee University Kim MinBae Park Jisook.
17 may 04leonidas moustakas STScI 1 High redshift (z~4) galaxies & clustering Lexi Moustakas STScI.
Introduction to the X-ray background Chandra Deep Field-North data Source Redshifts Diversity of X-ray selected sources Constraints on AGN evolution AGNs.
Cosmological studies with Weak Lensing Peak statistics Zuhui Fan Dept. of Astronomy, Peking University.
Obscured AGN and XRB models Andrea Comastri (INAF-OABologna-Italy) Roberto Gilli (INAF-OABologna-Italy) F. Fiore (INAF-OARoma-Italy) G. Hasinger (MPE-Garching-
The clustering of galaxies detected by neutral hydrogen emission Sean Passmoor Prof. Catherine Cress Image courtesy of NRAO/AUI and Fabian Walter, Max.
The Extremely Red Objects in the CLASH Fields The Extremely Red Galaxies in CLASH Fields Xinwen Shu (CEA, Saclay and USTC) CLASH 2013 Team meeting – September.
PHY306 1 Modern cosmology 4: The cosmic microwave background Expectations Experiments: from COBE to Planck  COBE  ground-based experiments  WMAP  Planck.
The Evolution of AGN Obscuration
The Evolution of AGN Obscuration
Revealing X-ray obscured Quasars in SWIRE sources with extreme MIR/O Giorgio Lanzuisi Fabrizio Fiore Enrico Piconcelli Chiara Feruglio Cristian Vignali.
AGN deep multiwavelength surveys: the case of the Chandra Deep Field South Fabrizio Fiore Simonetta Puccetti, Giorgio Lanzuisi.
Lockman Hole (XMM PV) PN CCD (MPE Garching) MOS1 CCD (Leicester U) PN CCD (MPE Garching) MOS1 CCD (Leicester U) PV Observations ksec.
Compton-thick AGN in the CDFN I. Georgantopoulos NOA A. Akylas NOA A. Georgakakis NOA M. Rovilos MPE M. Rowan-Robinson Imperial College.
Zheng Dept. of Astronomy, Ohio State University David Weinberg (Advisor, Ohio State) Andreas Berlind (NYU) Josh Frieman (Chicago) Jeremy Tinker (Ohio State)
Zheng I N S T I T U T E for ADVANCED STUDY Cosmology and Structure Formation KIAS Sep. 21, 2006.
HST Workshop Bologna Jan 31, 2008 Heavily obscured SMBH at high redshift Andrea Comastri INAF - OABologna C. Vignali, R. Gilli, K. Iwasawa, F. Civano,
The Chandra survey of the COSMOS field Fabrizio Fiore & the C-COSMOS team Particular thanks to T. Aldcroft, M. Brusa, N. Cappelluti, F. Civano, A. Comastri,
Andrii Elyiv and XMM-LSS collaboration The correlation function analysis of AGN in the XMM-LSS survey.
EROSITA + group meeting, Ringberg, February 2008 z>3 QSOs in XMM-COSMOS: lessons for eROSITA Marcella Brusa (MPE) with help from: A. Comastri M. Salvato,
Granada - X-ray Universe 2008 X-ray selected z>3 QSOs in the XMM-COSMOS field Marcella Brusa (MPE) The XMM-COSMOS and COSMOS teams.. and in particular:
High-z AGN Candidates in COSMOS Anton Koekemoer (STScI) + F. Civano, M. Elvis, V. Mainieri, J. Trump, E. Treister, T. Murayama, T. Nagao, Y. Oyama, Y.
ENVIRONMENTALPROPERTIES ENVIRONMENTAL PROPERTIES OF z~[1-3] AGN AND OF z~[1-3] AGN AND STARFORMING GALAXIES: STARFORMING GALAXIES: THE Spitzer VIEW ON.
Robust identification of distant Compton-thick AGNs IR AGN Optical AGN Need for deep optical-mid-IR spectroscopy: multiple lines of evidence for intrinsic.
The History of Active Galaxies A.Barger, P. Capak, L. Cowie, RFM, A. Steffen, and Y. Yang Active Galaxies (AKA quasars, Seyfert galaxies etc) are radiating.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
The XMM Distant Cluster Project: Survey limits and Pilot Survey Georg Lamer A. Schwope, V. Hambaryan, M. Godolt (AIP) H. Böhringer, R. Fassbender, P. Schücker,
A synthesis model for AGN evolution: unveiling SMBH growth with (past and future) X- ray surveys Ringberg Meeting, 2/2008 Andrea Merloni Max-Planck Institut.
Evolution of Absorption in AGN Günther Hasinger NGC 3079 Sy2 + SB Gal HST & Chandra Ringberg HE Meeting February,
Study of Proto-clusters by Cosmological Simulation Tamon SUWA, Asao HABE (Hokkaido Univ.) Kohji YOSHIKAWA (Tokyo Univ.)
New XMM-Newton deep Survey in the Lockman Hole Vincenzo Mainieri MPE Workshop on AGN Surveys, Puebla, June 23- July 11, 2003 Guenther Hasinger Hans Boehringer.
Why is the BAT survey for AGN Important? All previous AGN surveys were biased- –Most AGN are ‘obscured’ in the UV/optical –IR properties show wide scatter.
Galaxy Evolution and WFMOS
LoCuSS: An XMM survey of X-ray groups being accreted by massive clusters Chris Haines (INAF - OA Brera, Milano) Alexis Finoguenov (Helsinki,
Cosmological constraints from tSZ-X cross-correlation
Clustering properties and environment of AGN
The Space Density of Compton Thick AGN
Andrea Comastri (INAF- Oss. Astr. Bologna)
Risolvere il Background X al suo picco
Exdended sources in ECDF-S
Black Holes in the Deepest Extragalactic X-ray Surveys
Cluster Cosmology in Deep Fields
Shaji Vattakunnel - University of Trieste
Presentation transcript:

X-rays in the COSMOS A picture of large scale structures Nico Cappelluti Nico Cappelluti MPE-Garching MPE-Garching In collaboration with: XMM-COSMOS team: Hasinger, Böhringer, Brusa, Comastri, Fiore, Gilli, Brunner, Civano, Elvis, Finoguenov, Guzzo, Griffiths, Mainieri, Miyaji, Scoville, Silverman, Vignali, Zamorani+CCOSMOS members

HST ACS PI: N. Scoville Cosmos Survey 2 deg 2

1900 PL source >150 Groups All AGN with z XMM-Newton 55 Fields: 1.5 Ms PI: G. Hasinger

XMM+Chandra COSMOS The inner part of the field has been covered by 1.8 Ms Chandra observation (the largest guest observer Chandra project, P.I. M.Elvis). The inner part of the field has been covered by 1.8 Ms Chandra observation (the largest guest observer Chandra project, P.I. M.Elvis). Another ~1000 faint sources not seen by XMM-Newton. Another ~1000 faint sources not seen by XMM-Newton. Central area of 200 ks average depth. Central area of 200 ks average depth. High precision positioning --> better identification of XMM-COSMOS AGN (see Brusa). High precision positioning --> better identification of XMM-COSMOS AGN (see Brusa).

Better detection of compact diffuse sources (see Alexis). Better detection of compact diffuse sources (see Alexis). Better detection of AGN in Cluster Better detection of AGN in Cluster Excellent export of MPE ML-detection Excellent export of MPE ML-detection

Source population Type I source cluster at soft colors Type I source cluster at soft colors Emission line and absorption line galaxies occupy the region of absorbed sources Emission line and absorption line galaxies occupy the region of absorbed sources 2% sources Compton Thick candidates (Pink AGN) 2% sources Compton Thick candidates (Pink AGN) HR1=(MED-SOFT)/(MED+SOFT)‏ HR2=(HARD-MED)/(HARD+MED)‏

LogN-logS XMM-COSMOS Large area + depth = Low Sample (Cosmic) Variance  Tight constraints to the logN- logS parameters  Argument in favor of obscured sources as main component of the XRB  X-ray source catalogue soon public

Angular correlation function Fit range arcmin Fit model: γ=1.8 fixed; θ o ~2”-4” Limber’s equation: We obtain r 0 =9-10 Mpc in the three energy bands It is a measure of the mean angular source overdensity field Courtesy T. Miyajii

Imaging Large scale structures ACF does not say where the clustering takes place. ACF does not say where the clustering takes place. One can compute a spatially resolved ACF. One can compute a spatially resolved ACF. WARNING!! The significance of the structures has to be evaluated WARNING!! The significance of the structures has to be evaluated

Cluster-AGN Cross-Correlation in the NEP Survey Is an elegant way to determine the average profile of AGN around clusters using the 2 point correlation function formalism First detection of z-space clustering of AGN around galaxy clusters >3σ. Limitations: Low statistics, broad PSF, low sensitivity

CCF in XMM-z COSMOS 98 clusters 650 AGN Measurement in real-space clustering significant at r>0.4 Mpc r 0 ~8 Mpc Hamana et al DM ACF COSMOS No Evidence for an enhanced AGN evolution in clusters as claimed by Eastmann+07 Need widest field to eventually detect an evolution (i.e. eROSITA)‏ ξ gg (r) = b 2 ξ mm (r)‏

AGN Galaxies Sanchez+05 WORK IN PROGRESS CLUSTER-GALAXIES CCF (B. James & J. Peacock) Direct measurement of effects of the environment on AGN activity Decrease of AGN activity in Clusters -b AGN (z=0.38)=2.04±0.42 -Lower bias  Lower probability of forming an AGN in clusters Systematic effect?

CCF as f(Lx)‏ Not enough data to observe a dependence of clustering on Lx Red Log(Lx)>43 Black Log(Lx)<43

Convert  (r,z) to  8,AGN (z): the rms fluctuation in the 8h -1 Mpc sphere. Comparison on the common ground. Comparison with  8 D(z) mass distribution from the linear theory with WMAP  8 =0.74. Bias parameter of the X-ray AGN distribution b AGN (z)=  8,AGN (z) /  8 D(z)‏ Bias vs Dark Matter Halo mass from Sheth et al Density fluctuations and bias l Log(M/M ☼ )= 14 Log(M/M ☼ )=13 Courtesy T. Miyaji Log(M/M ☼ )= 14 Log(M/M ☼ )= 13

Still to do.... Insert Chandra positioning Insert Chandra positioning Use all the sources with a z (~2000)‏ Use all the sources with a z (~2000)‏ Cross correlation as f(Richness) using zCOSMOS groups Cross correlation as f(Richness) using zCOSMOS groups Impact of AGN overdensity to ICM.... Contribution to non thermal emission in Clusters? Impact of AGN overdensity to ICM.... Contribution to non thermal emission in Clusters?

CONCLUSIONS XMM-COSMOS provides an unbiased sample of AGN XMM-COSMOS provides an unbiased sample of AGN Source content consistent with the current picture of the XRB Source content consistent with the current picture of the XRB AGN are physically clustered around galaxy clusters AGN are physically clustered around galaxy clusters AGN at high-z are highly biased tracers of the Large Scale structure. AGN at high-z are highly biased tracers of the Large Scale structure. AGN, according to the their bias trace, DM halos of AGN, according to the their bias trace, DM halos of Log(M/M ☼ ) ~13 Though denser than in the field, is AGN activity less likely in very high density environments? Though denser than in the field, is AGN activity less likely in very high density environments? eROSITA do it better! eROSITA do it better!

Log(M/M ☼ )= 14 Log(M/M ☼ )= 13 2dF QSOs Environment and evolution Low-L AGN (COSMOS, X-ray deep surveys): Number density peaks at z=0.5-1 Triggered by minor mergers? within a group of galaxies, Log(M)13-14 Waiting for the massive halos (groups) to form, the number density peaks later in the history of the universe. High-L AGN (optical): High-L AGN (optical): Peak at z=2-3, Triggered by merging? of low mass DM halos LogM=12 (galaxy scale) in a smaller universe with higher chance of merging.