Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Assessing Outcomes After Theyre Gone – Measuring Preparedness and Quality in Practice Presented by: Mary Pat Wohlford-Wessels, Ph.D. Vice President for.
Advertisements

Residents as Teachers: Strategies for Improving Peer Based Education in a Community Based Residency Program Bernard Birnbaum, MD Kim Marvel, PhD Kristen.
Te4Q Educational Project Review Project Title: Designing a Patient Safety/Quality Improvement Curriculum for Graduate Medical Education Participant Names:
Edward P. Sloan, MD, MPH, FACEP Conducting Successful Emergency Medicine Research: Compelling Grant Writing.
Emergency Department Thoracotomy: A Hybrid Simulation With A Clinical Outcome.
Thomas H. Gallagher, MD University of Washington.
Stop the Blame Game: Restructuring M&M to Focus on QI and Teach Patient Safety Molly Horstman, MD Diana Stewart, MD, MBA Barbara Trautner, MD, PhD Michael.
Clinical Teaching Tricks and Tips Julie Story Byerley, MD, MPH.
1 Teaching a statistical program in emergency medicine research rotations: Command- driven or click-driven? Muhammad Waseem, MD Research Director Emergency.
Observing Learning Helen Bacon and Jan Ridgway Inclusion Support Services.
Comparison: Traditional vs. Outcome Project Evaluative Processes Craig McClure, MD Educational Outcomes Service Group University of Arizona December 2004.
Developing A Competency-based Curriculum B. Joyce, Ph.D.
Hollis Day, MD, MS Susan Meyer, PhD.  Four domains for effective practice outlined in the Interprofessional Education Collaborative’s “Core Competencies.
Debriefing in Medical Simulation Manu Madhok, MD, MPH Emergency Department Children’s Hospital and Clinics of Minnesota.
Quality Indicators & Safety Initiative: Group 4, Part 3 Kristin DeJonge Ferris Stat University MSN Program.
Core Competency Assessment in Emergency Medicine from Design to Implementation Christian Arbelaez, MD, MPH Assistant Residency Director Harvard Affiliated.
ACGME OUTCOME PROJECT : THE PROGRAM COORDINATOR’S ROLE Jim Kerwin, MD University of Arizona.
Continuity Clinics as Medical Home Hawaii Dyson Initiative Louise Iwaishi, MD March 5, 2005 Hawaii Dyson Initiative.
The Teaching Physician: How to Become a More Effective Medical Educator The Teaching Center UNC Department of Pediatrics The Teaching Center.
A Novel Quality Improvement Curriculum is Associated with Increased Housestaff Engagement and Improved Clinical Outcomes Elliot B. Tapper, Anjala Tess,
DISCUSSION INTRODUCTION Baseline knowledge, skills, and attitudes in quality improvement and patient safety (QIPS) among Year 1 students Rohit Saha, Ryan.
Simulation-Based Assessment Emily M. Hayden, MD, MHPE Associate Director for Curricular Integration Gilbert Program in Medical Simulation Harvard Medical.
© 2007 Thomson Delmar Learning. All Rights Reserved. Planning for Developmentally Appropriate Curriculum Chapter 3.
Development of Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) for Public Health and Preventive Medicine (PHPM) PHPC CPD Event - May 24, 2015 Kieran Moore MD,
Pediatric Hospital Medicine for Medical Students Julia K. Simmons, MD.
Assessment of Emergency Medicine Residents’ Bedside Communication Skills: A Survey of Emergency Department Patients Amanda Keller York College of PA Biology.
IN-SITU, MULTIDISCIPLINARY, SIMULATION-BASED Trauma Team TRAINING IMPROVES THE EARLY CARE OF TRAUMA PATIENTS Susan Steinemann, MD, FACS Benjamin Berg,
Curriculum Report Card Implementation Presentations
Outcomes Methods RRC-Internal Medicine Educational Innovations Project: Clinical Quality Improvement and Patient Safety- Deliverables to Healthcare from.
Developing an Assessment System B. Joyce, PhD 2006.
Linda A Headrick, MD, MS, FACP February 26, 2013.
AN INNOVATIVE & INTEGRATED TESTING FORMAT COMBINING ANATOMY, PRIMARY CARE SKILLS, AND OMM IN A SIMULATED PATIENT ENCOUNTER Gail Dudley, DO, Francine Anderson,
Facilitate Group Learning
ESSENTIAL SKILLS FOR TEACHING MEDICAL STUDENTS AND RESIDENTS BYRON CROUSE, MD AND STUART HANNAH, MD.
Assessing Learners The Teaching Center Department of Pediatrics UNC School of Medicine The Teaching Center.
Transitional Care Curriculum for Medical Interns Linda DeCherrie, MD Mount Sinai School of Medicine Department of Geriatrics and Palliative Medicine Department.
 Secure resident safety  Assess the resident, provide medical and/or psychosocial treatment as necessary  Examine the resident’s injury and/or psychosocial.
Educational Outcomes Service Group: Overview of Year One Lynne Tomasa, PhD May 15, 2003.
Are We There Yet: Optimal Duration for Direct Supervision of Surgical Interns Joseph M. Galante, MD, Jonathan Pierce, MD, Soman Sen, MD, Ahmed Mahmoud,
Evaluating Resident Transitions of Care in the Emergency Department Nicole Zadzilka MD, Deborah Pierce DO, MS, and Gina Domingo MD Albert Einstein Medical.
Using Simulated Encounters with Standardized Patients to Teach and Evaluate Difficult Discussions Rebecca Stetzer, MD Kathleen M Young, PhD, MPH Albany.
The use of OSCE to assess Patient Care, Professionalism and Interpersonal Communication Milestones in EM residents Miriam Kulkarni, MD, Harsh Sule, MD,
SIM-EHR (Simulated EHR): A Virtual Case-based Educational Tool S9. Medical Student Education Conference Society of Teachers of Family Medicine February.
Introduction Results Curricular Design Patient Safety Leadership WalkRounds™ were first introduced at Partners Healthcare in Engage frontline staff.
Objectives Methods Introduction Results Conclusions To measure the self-reported competency of all EM residents with Level 1 milestones as they enter residency.
Curriculum Development part 1 Design SummerCourse IV Academic Year 2005 – 2006 Tuesday, July 12, :15 am Linda Z. Nieman, Ph.D.
Methods Introduction Results Conclusions Figures Quick Hits - Structured On-Shift Teaching Designed for the Busy Academic Emergency Center It can be difficult.
A Bridge to Safety: A Curriculum for Creating a Safety State of Mind Dr Cindy Gleit Dr Lindsey Konor Dr Steven Livingston Christopher Reed.
Scott Renshaw, MD Department of Family Medicine Third Year Clerkship.
Use of Simulation-Based Surgical Education and Training Within the Context of the Core Competencies, Milestones, Patient Safety, and the New ACGME Accreditation.
Navigating the Proposal Process Keys to Successful Submission.
Introduction References Objectives Conclusions Results Faculty provision of performance feedback is critical for residents to improve their clinical skills.
Learning Objectives Case Presentation Teaching Points For Case Case Presentation (Cont.) Increase comfort in placing weight based orders for medications.
Introduction Methods Purpose Results Conclusions Figures/Graphs Resident- As- Debriefer Curriculum: A Novel Approach to the Senior Resident Teaching Role.
Preparing to Teach Quality Improvement and Patient Safety
May 2017 Kathy Zoppi PhD MPH Jafreen Sadeque MD Stephanie Nader LCSW
Evaluation and management (E/M) Services
PeArLS (Personally Arranged Learning Session)
Jonathan dela Cruz, M.D., Jason A Kegg, M.D.
Interprofessional Asthma Education: Development of a Comprehensive Asthma Rotation in a Pediatric Residency Carolyn C Robinson 4/30/2014 xxx00.#####.ppt.
National Trends in Emergency Medicine Residency ECG Curriculum and Interpretation Practices Céline Pascheles, MD, Leslie Bilello MD, Jenna Singleton MD,
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
Creation of a Milestone-Driven Simulation Based Resuscitation Course
Using an ‘Oral Board’ exam to assess for EPA 10 in
Does a single diversity training day make a lasting impression?
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
Disclosure training Adverse patient events
Embedding SBIRT (Screening, Brief Intervention and Referral to Treatment) into Health Professional Trainees’ Curriculum Hartman, Cheri W. 1; Hartman, David.
The Simulation-Based Medical Education of a Medical Center in Barcelona Juan Martín Salgado.
When the Swiss cheese aligns - Making a clinical error
Presentation transcript:

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Abstract Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital-based and residency-based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case-based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Background: Error disclosure is a critical skill for an emergency medicine resident’s professional development. When an error occurs, critical steps in addressing the error include: acknowledging to the patient that an error occurred, discussing the clinical relevance of the error, addressing systems-based issues that allowed the error to occur, taking steps to prevent future errors, and apologizing by the provider to those involved. Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure and to create changes to the curriculum if necessary. Curricular Design: Our current curriculum includes hospital-based and residency-based activities. Residents attend a mandatory medical center presentation on error disclosure; residency based small group discussions and individualized clinical experiences. We assessed the ability of our residents to apply the principle learned to a cased-based scenario that included multiple errors (omission and commission). Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in standard error disclosure. We compiled the results to evaluate areas for curricular improvement. 32 residents completed the assessment. 100% of residents acknowledged the error of commission (32/32), 34% of the residents did not recognize the error of omission (11/32). 31% did not explain the relevance of the error to the patient (10/32). 50% of the residents did not explain why the system allowed for the error (16/32). 15% did not describe how future errors would be prevented and 15% did not complete the critical step of apology (5/32). This data emphasized that our current curriculum requires improvement. In addition, residents have knowledge gaps in error disclosure, particularly in identifying and managing errors of omission and explaining why errors occur. Future goals will be to augment the medical center curriculum with an EM focused case-based discussion of error disclosure principles. Cases will focus on language that support discussion of systems-based errors with patients. The value and need for apology will be emphasized. Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Future goal: to augment curriculum with EM focused case-based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems-based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Introduction Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital based and residency based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Goal in future to augment curriculum with EM focused case based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents There are several vital actions required to address a medical error Notify the patient that an error occurred Discuss the relevance of the error Address systems-based issues that allowed the error to occur Understand steps to prevent future errors Apologize to the patient and others involved Our resident curriculum includes hospital-based and residency- based activities to teach these actions Hospital based Mandatory medical center presentation Residency based Small-group discussions Individualized clinical experiences Our objective was to assess our current curriculum and to create changes to the curriculum if necessary

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Methods Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital based and residency based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Goal in future to augment curriculum with EM focused case based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize We created a written case based scenario Using a predetermined checklist, residents were graded on ability to recognize the error of commission, omission, explain the relevance of the error, explain why the system allowed the error, describe future prevention, and apologize to the patients Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement The Case You are working in the ED on a busy shift and managing multiple patients You suspect John Smith in room 3 has a PE so you order a CT Chest Angiogram and then see some other patients An hour later you realize that you mistakenly ordered the CT on Ms. Robinson in room 2. When you call the CT Tech to cancel the order she tells you that Ms. Robinson unfortunately just completed the scan. What do you do next? Explain the steps you need to take to try and make this right and prevent it from happening again. Now write a follow up note about the incident as if you were writing it in the patient’s chart

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital based and residency based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Goal in future to augment curriculum with EM focused case based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Results Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital based and residency based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Goal in future to augment curriculum with EM focused case based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize 32 residents total 100% recognized the error of commission (32/32) 34% did not recognize the error of omission (11/32) 31% did not explain the relevance of the error to the patient (10/32) 50% did not explain why the system allowed for the error (16/32) 15% did not describe how future errors will be prevented (5/32) 15% did not apologize to the patient (5/32)

Abstract Conclusions Methods Introduction Results Figures/Graphs Error disclosure is a critical skill for emergency medicine residents to develop There are multiple critical steps required to address the error correctly We assessed our residents ability to disclose medical errors Our results indicate that residents were weakest in explaining why errors occur and identifying errors of omission. Improvement can be focused on language that supports discussion of systems based errors with patients Future Goals Assessing the Effectiveness of our Current Curriculum in Educating Residents in Medical Error Disclosure Our current curriculum includes hospital based and residency based activities to teach the principles of error disclosure Educational Objectives: To assess our current curriculum in error disclosure To create changes to the curriculum if necessary Residents were observed in a case based scenario that included multiple errors of omission and commission Their answers were evaluated against a predetermined checklist of key principles in error disclosure Results were compiled to evaluate areas for improvement Our current curriculum requires improvement Resident knowledge gaps are largest in errors of omission and explaining why they occur Goal in future to augment curriculum with EM focused case based discussions and using language with patients that support discussion of systems based errors Flavia Nobay MD, Linda Spillane MD, Julie Pasternack MD and Joseph Pereira DO University of Rochester Medical Center 100% recognized the error of commission 34% did not recognize the error of omission 31% did not explain the relevance of the error 50% did not explain why the system allowed the error 15% did not describe future error prevention 15% did not apologize Develop a curriculum that includes didactic and small group discussion which focus on the principles of error disclosure Develop case-based scenarios that exemplify the errors of commission and omission Work with Patient Safety and Quality Improvement representatives to discuss systems based errors and disclosure of these errors Work in team-based simulations to practice the art of accountability and apology