Asymmetric Bias in User Guided Segmentations of Subcortical Brain Structures May 2007, UNC/BRIC Radiology 2007 Funding provided by UNC Neurodevelopmental.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Unbiased Longitudinal Processing of Structural MRI in FreeSurfer Martin Reuter
Advertisements

Navigation-related structural change in the hippocampi of taxi drivers
Treatment Planning of HIFU: Rigid Registration of MRI to Ultrasound Kidney Images Tara Yates 1, Penny Probert Smith 1, J. Alison Noble 1, Tom Leslie 2,
Quality Control of Diffusion Weighted Images
The BRAINs Orientation
LING 111 Teaching Demo By Tenghui Zhu Introduction to Edge Detection Image Segmentation.
These improvements are in the context of automatic segmentations which are among the best found in the literature, exceeding agreement between experts.
Assessing Early Brain Development in Neonates by Segmentation of High-Resolution 3T MRI 1,2 G Gerig, 2 M Prastawa, 3 W Lin, 1 John Gilmore Departments.
Age and treatment related local hippocampal changes in schizophrenia explained by a novel shape analysis method 1,2 G Gerig, 3 K Muller, 3 E Kistner, 3.
Medical Image Display Bradley Hemminger School of Information and Library Science Department of Radiology, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
Sponsor: Prof. Sidney Spector Computational anatomy to assess growth pattern of early brain development in healthy and disease populations Guido Gerig.
Level-Set Evolution with Region Competition: Automatic 3-D Segmentation of Brain Tumors 1 Sean Ho, 2 Elizabeth Bullitt, and 1;3 Guido Gerig 1 Department.
September 27, / 18 Automatic Segmentation of Neonatal Brain MRI Marcel Prastawa 1, John Gilmore 2, Weili Lin 3, Guido Gerig 1,2 University.
Preliminary Results Longitudinal Change Conclusions Acknowledgements The most striking result of the longitudinal growth analysis between 2 and 4 years.
12-Apr CSCE790T Medical Image Processing University of South Carolina Department of Computer Science 3D Active Shape Models Integrating Robust Edge.
Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) is becoming a routine technique to study white matter properties and alterations of fiber integrity due to pathology. The.
Caudate Shape Discrimination in Schizophrenia Using Template-free Non-parametric Tests Y. Sampath K. Vetsa 1, Martin Styner 1, Stephen M. Pizer 1, Jeffrey.
Computer-Aided Diagnosis and Display Lab Department of Radiology, Chapel Hill UNC Julien Jomier, Erwann Rault, and Stephen R. Aylward Computer.
Li Wang, Yaozong Gao, Feng Shi, Gang Li, Dinggang Shen
Desiree Abdurrachim Morphometric analysis of the hippocampus in R6/1 HD mouse model Internship August – October 2007 Desiree Abdurrachim Supervisor: Leigh.
Li Wang1, Feng Shi1, Gang Li1, Weili Lin1, John H
Ultrasound Visualization Pipeline A Survey
-1- Pujol S et al. National Alliance for Medical Image Computing 3D Visualization of FreeSurfer Data Sonia Pujol, Ph.D. Silas Mann, B.Sc. Randy Gollub,
Vascular Attributes and Malignant Brain Tumors MICCAI November 2003 CONCLUSIONS References: [1] Aylward S, Bullitt E (2002) Initialization, noise, singularities.
Automatic Brain Segmentation in Rhesus Monkeys February 2006, SPIE Medical Imaging 2006 Funding provided by UNC Neurodevelopmental Disorders Research Center.
Framework for the Statistical Shape Analysis of Brain Structures using SPHARM-PDM M. Styner, I. Oguz, S. Xu, C. Brechbuehler, D. Pantazis, J. Levitt, M.
Quantitative Brain Structure Analysis on MR Images
DTU Medical Visionday May 27, 2009 Generative models for automated brain MRI segmentation Koen Van Leemput Athinoula A. Martinos Center for Biomedical.
Segmentation of Subcortical Sructures in MR Images VPA.
Panel Discussion Part I Methodology Ideas from adult MR brain segmentation are used in neonatal MR brain segmentation. However, additional challenges.
Sparse Shape Representation using the Laplace-Beltrami Eigenfunctions and Its Application to Modeling Subcortical Structures Xuejiao Chen.
-1- National Alliance for Medical Image Computing University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill Neuro Image Research and Analysis Lab Cedric Mathieu, Clement.
 Participants Right-handed, community-dwelling individuals; 16 younger adults (19-28 years; 8 female); 16 older adults (60-82 years; 8 female). Participants.
A longitudinal study of brain development in autism Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Neurodevelopmental Disorders Research Center &
DTI Quality Control Assessment via Error Estimation From Monte Carlo Simulations February 2013, SPIE Medical Imaging 2013 MC Simulation for Error-based.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing A longitudinal study of brain development in autism Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Neurodevelopmental.
A longitudinal study of brain development in autism Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Neurodevelopmental Disorders Research Center &
Statistical Group Differences in Anatomical Shape Analysis using Hotelling T 2 metric February 2006, SPIE Medical Imaging 2006 Funding provided by UNC.
AdvisorStudent Dr. Jia Li Shaojun Liu Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering, Oakland University Automatic 3D Image Segmentation of Internal Lung Structures.
Ventricular shape of monozygotic twins discordant for schizophrenia reflects vulnerability 2 M Styner, 1,2 G Gerig, 3 DW Jones, 3 DR Weinberger, 1 JA Lieberman.
Lateralized change of ventricular shape in monozygotic twins discordant for schizophrenia 2 M Styner, 1,2 G Gerig, 3 DW Jones, 3 DR Weinberger, 1 JA Lieberman.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing NAMIC UNC Site Update Site PI: Martin Styner UNC Site NAMIC folks: C Vachet, G Roger,
Automatic pipeline for quantitative brain tissue segmentation and parcellation: Experience with a large longitudinal schizophrenia MRI study 1,2 G Gerig,
References [1] Coupé et al., An optimized blockwise nonlocal means denoising filter for 3-D magnetic resonance images. IEEE TMI, 27(4):425–441, 2008.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing A longitudinal study of brain development in autism Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Neurodevelopmental.
-1- National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Slicer3 Training Tutorial ARCTIC (v1.2) (Automatic Regional Cortical ThICkness) ‏ University of North.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing A longitudinal study of brain development in autism Heather Cody Hazlett, PhD Neurodevelopmental.
Statistical Shape Analysis of Multi-object Complexes June 2007, CVPR 2007 Funding provided by NIH NIBIB grant P01EB and NIH Conte Center MH
Corpus Callosum Probabilistic Subdivision based on Inter-Hemispheric Connectivity May 2005, UNC Radiology Symposium Original brain images for the corpus.
The UNIVERSITY of NORTH CAROLINA at CHAPEL HILL FVGWAS: Fast Voxelwise Genome Wide Association Analysis of Large-scale Imaging Genetic Data Tutorial: pipeline,
Department of Psychiatry, Department of Computer Science, 3 Carolina Institute for Developmental Disabilities 1 Department of Psychiatry, 2 Department.
National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Volumetric Studies.
Date of download: 5/28/2016 Copyright © 2016 SPIE. All rights reserved. Block diagram representation of the manual segmentation procedure. Figure Legend:
Age and treatment related local hippocampal changes in schizophrenia explained by a novel shape analysis method 1,2 G Gerig, 2 M Styner, 3 E Kistner, 3.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Analysis and Results of Brockton VA study: Controls vs Schizophrenics Personality Disorder Martin.
Dr. Temple Grandin: A Neuroimaging Case Study Jason R. Cooperrider 1,2, Temple Grandin 5, Erin D. Bigler 2,6, Jeffrey S. Anderson 1,3, Nicholas Lange 7,
Segmentation of Single-Figure Objects by Deformable M-reps
Corpus Callosum Probabilistic Subdivision based on Inter-Hemispheric Connectivity Martin Styner1,2, Ipek Oguz1, Rachel Gimpel Smith2, Carissa Cascio2,
Registration of Pathological Images
A longitudinal study of brain development in autism
D Nain1, M Styner3, M Niethammer4, J J Levitt4,
Moo K. Chung1,3, Kim M. Dalton3, Richard J. Davidson2,3
Subjects and image data
3D Visualization of FreeSurfer Data
Whole Brain Segmentation
Fall 2018, COMP 562 Poster Session
MultiModality Registration using Hilbert-Schmidt Estimators
Figure 1 Evolution of MRI findings during interleukin (IL)–7 therapy
Presentation transcript:

Asymmetric Bias in User Guided Segmentations of Subcortical Brain Structures May 2007, UNC/BRIC Radiology 2007 Funding provided by UNC Neurodevelopmental Disorders Research Center HD 03110, the NIH Conte Center MH064065, and NIH RO1 MH61696 and NIMH MH We would like to thank Dale Purves, Duke University, and Donald Mershon, North Carolina State University, for insightful discussions about the origin of this bias. Segmentation Methods Summary: We show evidence of a previously unknown strong left-right asymmetric segmentation bias. This bias fundamentally influences left-right asymmetry analyses. Our work suggests that existing studies of hemispheric asymmetry need to be interpreted in a new, skeptical light. Neuroimaging for Brainmorphometry Pathology Structural segmentations from MRI images use varying degree of user guidance Asymmetric bias for left and right hemispheric structures? Yes, shown in relatively small scale study How to avoid this bias? Introduction Martin Styner, Rachel Gimpel Smith, Mike Graves, Matt Mosconi, Sarah Peterson, Scott White, Mohammed El-Sayed, Heather Cody Hazlett Department of Computer Science and Psychiatry, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Mansoura University, Mansoura Egypt Fig. 1. Left: Subcortical brain structures of interest in a 3D rendering. Right: Snapshot of ITK-SNAP segmentation software employed in all segmentations but of the hippocampus. Fig 2. Results of the segmentation study: Left:Relative asymmetry analysis, Middle: Relative difference histogram orig - mirrored, Right: P-values and comments. Conclusions Varying degree of user interaction –Hippocampus: Landmark placement, landmark constrained fluid registration, ICC= 0.99 –Lateral ventricle: Active curve evolution (ITK-SNAP) on CSF tissue probability, ICC =0.99 –Caudate: Active curve evolution (ITK-SNAP) with manual post- processing in anterior-inferior border, ICC = 0.96 –Amygdala, putamen, globus pallidus: manual segmentation, ICC = 0.83, 0.93, 0.89 Protocols online: Hippocampus: five trained raters, Adult (5) + Pediatric (5) datasets Other structures: single rater, Pediatric (10) datasets Segmentation of original data Segmentation of left-right mirrored data –Re-mirroring for analysis, left segmented as on right hemisphere Randomized order of presentation 1.Relative asymmetry :  V asym = ( V L - V R ) / (( V L + V R ) / 2) 2.Relative difference original vs mirrored :  V diff =(V orig - V mirr )/((V orig + V mirr )/2) No bias =>  Vdiff should have 0 mean Evidence of a strong left-right asymmetric segmentation bias is novel and unknown to the imaging community Bias fundamentally influences any left-right asymmetry analyses. Less surprising to the visual perception community and its likely cause is differences in perception of oppositely curved 3D structures. Segmentation methods need to be adapted, e.g. applied only to one of the hemispheres and its left-right mirrored image Study Design Putamen Amygdala Hippocampus Caudate Lateral Ventricle GP Histogram  Vasym: p=0.12  Vdiff:  =3.4%, p=0.05 Variable segmentation Limited evidence for bias  Vasym: p=0.53;  Vdiff:  =-3%, p= Variable segmentation Clear evidence for bias  Vasym: p=0.13;  Vdiff:  =3.2%, p< Variable segmentation Clear evidence for bias  Vasym: p=0.42;  Vdiff:  =1.3%, p= Stable segmentation Clear evidence for bias  Vasym: p=0.18;  Vdiff:  =0.0%, p=0.991 Stable segmentation No evidence for bias  Vasym: p<  Vdiff: p< Stable segmentation Clear evidence for bias Asymmetry inversion! Hippocampus Caudate Ventricles Pallidus Putamen Amygdala Results Structural segmentations of caudate, putamen, globus pallidus, amygdala and hippocampus showed a highly significant asymmetric bias When considerable manual outlining or landmark placement. Only lateral ventricle segmentation shows no asymmetric bias due to the high degree of automation and a high intensity contrast on boundary.