Method Design 2 prime type (MS vs. Pain) x 3 age of object (New vs. 20 years vs. 100 years) Participants N = 288 Mturk workers - 174 males, age: M = 33.85.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The E-Chug: A Randomized, Controlled Study of a Web-Based Binge Drinking Intervention with College Freshman John Steiner, M.P.H., W. Gill Woodall, Ph.
Advertisements

Cross Cultural Research
The Effect of Mortality Salience on Attitudes Toward Women Meredith Cotton Stephanie Goss Hanover College.
Samantha Nicholas & Khrys Nugent Hanover College
Results PASAT Mood Manipulation PANAS Outcomes. Results of the ANCOVA with PANAS as the dependent variable revealed a significant main effect for mood.
Figure 1. A Trial in the Old-Unpleasant IAT Task
Terror management theory (TMT; Solomon, Greenberg, & Pyszczynski, 1991) Human beings are explicitly aware of the inevitability of death Human beings are.
Culture and psychological knowledge: A Recap
The Effects of Empathy & Social Exclusion PURPOSE AND BACKGROUND Individuals’ willingness to engage in prosocial behavior is a popular topic in social.
The Effects of Extrinsic Motivation and Subsequent Absence on Test Taking Performance Kimala Bennet, Aja Crockett, Sophia Hsu, Lisa Poulin, Dina Zelyony.
Developing and validating a stress appraisal measure for minority adolescents Journal of Adolescence 28 (2005) 547–557 Impact Factor: A.A. Rowley.
Discussion  The results suggest that prosocially oriented videogames have at least a short-term priming effect for prosocial thoughts, feelings, and attributed.
Survey Research & Understanding Statistics
The 2004 Presidential Election and Terror Management Theory York College, CUNY Department of Psychology Admissions Open House November 11, 2004.
Maria Cristina Matteucci, Dina Guglielmi
Negative Urgency, Distress Tolerance and Problematic Alcohol Use Abstract Purpose: This study aimed to explore the relations among Negative Urgency, Distress.
Chapter 8 Experimental Research
Fear and Mortality-Salience increase Volunteering Elise Murray, Kellen Mrkva, Travis Pruitt, Emily Conron, Elizabeth Peterson, Darcia Narvaez Methods Study.
RESULTS CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES As hypothesized and observed in some of our previous work, significant LPS-induced learning decrements were noted, including.
Terror Management and Acculturation: The Effects of Mortality Salience on Acculturation Attitudes toward Culturally Close and Culturally Distant Immigrant.
Mortality Salience Amplifies Moral Appraisal The School of Natural and Behavioral Sciences UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH SYMPOSIUM APRIL 19, 2012 – FORT LEWIS.
Theory ( TMT ) Adapted from: Russ Webster Kansas State University Manhattan, Kansas Terror Management.
History of self research Festinger’s social comparison theory (1957) Mini-theory criticism More recent: cultural, TMT.
Testosterone, Attachment and the green-eyed monster Nicola J. Fussell & Angela C. Rowe School of Experimental Psychology, University of Bristol, UK. Are.
Pavlovian, Observational and Instructed Fear Learning: Emotional Responses to Unmasked and Masked Stimuli Andreas Olsson, Kristen Stedenfeld & Elizabeth.
Individual Preferences for Uncertainty: An Ironically Pleasurable Stimulus Bankert, M., VanNess, K., Hord, E., Pena, S., Keith, V., Urecki, C., & Buchholz,
Instrument One instructional (INS) slide and three masking (MSK) slides provided directions for 4 test slides that each contained 3 lists of 3 color words.
Introduction Method Implications Educational training programs regarding self-injury have potential to improve professionals’ attitudes towards and comfort.
Self-serving Bias
Mental Contrasting Establishes Associations between the Reality and Means to Overcome it Henrik Singmann 1, Andreas Kappes 1 & Gabriele Oettingen 1,2 1.
Jenefer Husman Arizona State University Jenefer Husman Arizona State University When learning seems (un)important: Future Time Perspective and post-secondary.
Training Phase Results The RT difference between gain and loss was numerically larger for the second half of the trials than the first half, as predicted,
Diana Bast Supervisor: Prof. Barnes-Holmes
The effects of working memory load on negative priming in an N-back task Ewald Neumann Brain-Inspired Cognitive Systems (BICS) July, 2010.
Acknowledgments We thank Dr. Yu, Dr. Bateman, and Professor Szabo for allowing us to conduct this study during their class time. We especially thank the.
Terror Management Theory
INTRODUCTION HYPOTHESES MEASURES RESULTS Correspondence to: at the 27 th Association for Psychological Science Conference,
Abstract Research with youth faces particular challenges, including potential confusion about researchers’ intentions and vulnerabilities related to power.
Chapter Two Methods in the Study of Personality. Gathering Information About Personality Informal Sources of Information: Observations of Self—Introspection,
Experimental Psychology PSY 433 Chapter 5 Research Reports.
Ease of Retrieval Effects on Estimates of Predicted Alcohol Use Joshua A. Hicks University of Missouri-Columbia and the Midwest Alcoholism Research Center.
Self-Awareness Identity and Meaning. The “SELF” is Central to Social Psychology Thoughts Feelings Behavior.
Method Results and discussion Fig. 1. Percentages of offered sums saved in high- and low-level construal conditions. Fig. 2. The amount of money ascribed.
Project VIABLE - Direct Behavior Rating: Evaluating Behaviors with Positive and Negative Definitions Rose Jaffery 1, Albee T. Ongusco 3, Amy M. Briesch.
Learning by example: Exposure to others’ success improves people’s expectations about interracial contact Participants Participants were 60 (39 Females,
Satisfaction, Guaranteed: My Perceptions of You Are More Predictive of Negotiation Satisfaction Than Your Actions Devin E. Howington and Sara D. Hodges.
Participants and Procedure 1,447 participants representing 64 countries (mostly India and the United States) completed a cross-sectional survey via Amazon’s.
Methods Participants. Participants (N = 72) were predominantly female (n = 54), Caucasian (85.5%) and (SD = 3.41) years of age. Materials and Procedure.
Anthropological explorations of manhood have found that both men and women share a view of the precariousness of manhood compared to womanhood (e.g., Gilmore,
University of Texas at El Paso
Is Social Exclusion a Moral Issue?
Discussion & Conclusion
Sarah L. Adams & Christopher D. B. Burt
Eleni-Ilianna Mavropoulou & Kenneth E
Kimron Shapiro & Frances Garrad-Cole The University of Wales, Bangor
Exploratory Factor Analysis Participants, Procedures, & Measures
Roommate Closeness Development and Pathological Personality Traits
The self.
Seeking the Shield of Faith: The Influence of Defensive Theology on the Development of Religious Fundamentalism Following Mortality Salience Brian Lammert,
Experimental Research Designs
Bowden, Shores, & Mathias (2006): Failure to Replicate or Just Failure to Notice. Does Effort Still Account for More Variance in Neuropsychological Test.
Alison Burros, Nathan Herdener, & Mei-Ching Lien
The effects of MORTALITY SALIENCE ON SELF-REPORTED Health practices
Jacob A. Jardel Cameron University Dr. Jenel T. Cavazos
Jacob Jardel, Cameron University
Henrik Singmann1, Andreas Kappes1 & Gabriele Oettingen1,2
Spatial Distance Affects Implicit Impressions of Others
Charles N. Elliott, Paul A. Story
Thinking of Safety Through a Different Lens
Cross-National Comparisons of Monetary Donations to
Presentation transcript:

Method Design 2 prime type (MS vs. Pain) x 3 age of object (New vs. 20 years vs. 100 years) Participants N = 288 Mturk workers males, age: M = years, SD = years Procedure After providing informed consent, participants completed various premeasures in order to bolster the cover story and for data exploration, followed by the tasks in the order below. Mortality salience (MS) Participants responded to open-ended questions about death or pain according to random assignment (Rosenblatt, 1989). For example: “Please briefly describe the emotions that the thought of your own death arouses in you.” Distractor task Participants then completed the 60-item positive and negative affect schedule and read a short neutral story to provide the necessary delay to allow participant engagement in culture- oriented buffers (Greenberg et al., 2000). Object value task Participants were shown 6 objects (pen, watch, chair, umbrella, mug, and a journal) that were either new, 20 years old, or 100 years old depending on random assignment and then responded to the following questions: “How much would you pay for this item?” (WTP; open ended) “How much do you want to own this item?” (1 = not at all, 7 = very much so) “How valuable do you think this item is?” (1 = not at all valuable, 7 = extremely valuable) Painting task Similar to Eidelman et al. (2010; study 3), participants were shown a relatively unknown painting with a purported age varying according to condition. This was presented in counterbalanced order with the object value task, but results mirrored that of the WTP item and is not mentioned further. Antique value/Demographics Lastly, participants were asked about basic demographics and how much they value antiques generally. Valuing the Longevity of Objects to Escape Death Introduction Longevity bias Also known as the longer-is-better effect (LIB), longevity bias refers people more positively evaluating things the longer they have existed (Eidelman, Pattershall, & Crandall, 2010). For example, when university requirements, acupuncture, abstract art, a tree, or chocolate are presented as existing for longer periods of time (e.g. 73 years vs 3 years), they are more positively evaluated. Researchers explain that these findings are a result of heuristic processing that associates longevity with goodness. Terror management theory Terror management theory (TMT; Greenberg, Pyszczynski, & Solomon, 1986) is derived from the woks of cultural anthropologist Ernest Becker (1973). The theory posits that humans are disposed toward self-preservation but with he knowledge of unavoidable mortality contend with potentially paralyzing anxiety. Humans manage this potential anxiety by investing in an enduring cultural conception of reality and striving to meet the values prescribed by this view of the world. By engaging in this process one can hope to transcend death through either literal or symbolic means. Current Study The present research was an investigation into the possibility that the longevity of older objects is viewed as having a quality of permanence or robustness against decay and destruction, and therefore valued as a symbol of death transcendence. If so, then reminders of death (mortality salience; MS) should exacerbate the longevity bias and result in an even greater preference for older objects. Results Composite scores for two dependent variables were calculated by adding the evaluations of all 6 objects together for the WTP measure (α =.58) and the other two items (α =.84) forming an index of object valuation. The item assessing general antique valuation was not affected by the manipulations (ps >.76), and subsequently applied as a covariate, though primary effects remained significant after removal as well. 2 x 3 ANCOVA on WTP composite measure Main effect of age F(2, 281) = 8.47, p <.001; participants were willing to pay more for the 100 yr old objects than the 20 yr old (p <.001) and new (p <.01) objects, which were not different form each other (p =.40). All other main and interactive effects were non-significant (ps >.17). 2 x 3 ANCOVA on object valuation composite Main effect of age F(2, 281) = 9.56, p <.001; 100 yr old objects were valued higher than 20 yr old (p =.001) and new (p <.001) objects, which were not different from each other (p =.40). Interaction between prime type and age F(2, 281) = 4.87, p =.01; those in the MS condition valued 20 yr old objects more than new objects (p =.04), and 100 yr old objects more than both 20 yr old (p <.01) and new objects (p <.001). MS x Age on Object Valuation Reminders of mortality (vs. pain) resulted in a marginal lesser valuation of objects that were new, t(96)= -1.89, p =.06, no difference for 20 yr old items, t(95)= 1.15, p =.25, but greater valuation of 100 yr old objects, t(91)= 2.38, p =.02 Discussion The LIB effect was replicated in part from participants indicating a greater WTP for and assigning more value to older objects than newer objects generally. Also, mortality reminders enhanced the valuation of older objects, implicating an existential motivation for the preference of older objects – perhaps due to the symbolic death transcendence related to the perceived permanence of objects that have stood the test of time. Limitations Although promising, limitations and alternative explanations have not been ruled out by this single study. Specifically, the lack of an interaction on the WTP item suggests there might be undiscovered differences related to existential security which might account for the effect on object valuation failing to cross over into financial expenditure. Additionally, given LIB is a heuristic, it may be that MS boosted this effect due to an increased reliance on heuristic processing generally, instead of increasing the value of older objects for their qualities associated with death-transcendence. Conclusion Despite these limitations, these findings and conceptual inferences open doors to a unique understanding of consumer decisions and the existential appeal of aged objects in particular. It is interesting to note that companies regularly display the phrase “Established ####” – perhaps utilizing the deep-rooted knowledge of inevitable mortality that exacerbates the desire to obtain objects which convey a tenacity against death and decay. References Becker, E. (1973). The denial of death. New York: Free Press. Eidelman, S., Pattershall, J., & Crandall, C. S. (2010). Longer is better. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 46, Greenberg, J., Arndt, J., Simon, L., Pyszczynski, T., & Solomon, S. (2000). Proximal and distal defenses in response to reminders of one's mortality: Evidence of a temporal sequence. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 26, Greenberg, J., Pyszczynski, T., & Solomon, S. (1986). The causes and consequences of a need for self- esteem: a terror management theory. In R. F. Baumeister (Ed.), Public self and private self (pp ). New York: Springer-Verlag. Rosenblatt, A., Greenberg, J., Solomon, S., Pyszczynski, T., & Lyon, D. (1989). Evidence for terror management theory I: The effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who violate or uphold cultural values. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57, Society for Personality and Social Psychology Conference. January 28, San Diego, California, USA. Contact: Michael Bultmann, Department of Psychological Sciences, 304 Psychology Building, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO 65211, Michael Bultmann 1, Simon McCabe 2, Melissa Spina 1, & Jamie Arndt 1 1 University of Missouri-Columbia; 2 University of Stirling Age in years